I tried the most popular peanut butter brands, and the best one is a classic
When I mentioned to friends that I would be testing this pantry staple, they were all quick to offer opinions. (It turns out everyone thinks they know the best store-bought peanut butter!) They also had lots of questions: Would I try creamy peanut butter? Crunchy? Organic? Salted? Because there are so many options, I stuck with creamy only (both conventional and organic) from peanut butter brands that are available in supermarkets across the country. I tasted them by the spoonful without jelly or bread to interfere with the flavor and mouthfeel.
As a culinary school grad who has worked in restaurants and written about food and cooking, I can appreciate the difference between old-school creamy peanut butter and the organic, all-natural version. I bought options across the spectrum from most processed to least, and the one that creamed the competition? Well, let's just say the brand is synonymous with peanut butter.
To narrow down the pool, I stuck with smooth peanut butter, ranging from processed to natural. When it came to tasting, I decided the best approach was to be a purist: Just open the jar, breathe in the aroma and dig in with a spoon. No bread, no jelly, no celery sticks.
Jif Creamy Peanut Butter: As close to Skippy as you can get, Jif is a strong runner-up. It's creamy and rich, but the flavor isn't quite as craveable. It contains the same hydrogenated vegetable oil as most other conventional/processed peanut butter and has the same thick and spreadable texture you expect. It was yummy!
Peter Pan Creamy Peanut Butter: This was my first encounter with Peter Pan, but I know the brand has a cult following. Peter Pan has been around since 1920, at first under a different name but then coined "Peter Pan" as a nod to the character and the play. Like the other processed peanut butter, it spreads beautifully and feels lighter, but the intense sweetness was off-puting to me.
Justin's Classic Creamy Peanut Butter: I was so disappointed in Justin's, having tried and enjoyed the brand's almond and cashew butters. This was the worst-tasting natural peanut butter with little flavor to speak of and a hint of bitterness, plus grit. This peanut butter contained peanuts and palm oil.
365 by Whole Foods Market Unsweetened Creamy Peanut Butter: Made from only peanuts and salt, this was the least thick and creamy of the all-natural bunch. It's almost drippy in texture. The flavor was nutty enough and had a good kick of salt, but it's not winning medals.
Good & Gather Organic Peanut Butter: Another organic and all-natural option, Target's house brand spread contains only dry roasted peanuts. When shopping, I didn't realize that this is unsalted, which gave it a real disadvantage. The texture was smoother than others, though.
Skippy Natural Creamy Peanut Butter: This alternate version of the classic Skippy is okay. Like some "natural" peanut butter, it has added palm oil, which keeps the oil and solids from separating and needing to be stirred. For my money, and if I'm going to submit to the sheer heaven that is processed peanut butter, I prefer the original Skippy.
Teddie All Natural Smooth Peanut Butter: This natural option contains only peanuts and salt and is thicker than some of the others. It has an earthy, authentic peanut flavor that would likely make a good addition to dips or sauces.
Now that you know which spread to buy, here's how to take your PB (or PB&J) sandwiches to the next level.
Got some sticky questions? We've got answers!
As far as snacking goes, peanut butter pairs perfectly with crunchy raw veggie sticks (celery, carrots and jicama all work) and sliced apples or banana. It's also delightful on top of rice cakes or as a dip for pretzels.
We recently tested a variety of nut butter to come up with a list of the healthiest nut butter, which included two tasty peanut butter options — Big Spoon Roasters Peanut Crunchy Peanut Butter and One Trick Pony SIlky Smooth Peanut Butter.
Some dogs absolutely love peanut butter as a treat, but dogs don't benefit from the added salt and sugar that humans may enjoy, so choose a peanut butter that's all-natural and unsalted, like Teddie All-Natural Unsalted Smooth Peanut Butter.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
Top-prize Take 5 ticket worth over $17K sold in Cheektowaga
BUFFALO, N.Y. (WIVB) — A top-prize Take 5 lottery ticket worth over $17,000 was recently sold in Cheektowaga, the New York Lottery announced. The winning ticket for Friday evening's drawing is worth $17,380.50 and was sold at the J&M Convenient Food Shop at 2365 Williams St. Take 5 drawings are televised twice daily at 2:30 p.m. and 10:30 p.m. To see the winning numbers, click here. Latest Local News Along 4 The Hike: Eighteen Mile Creek Top-prize Take 5 ticket worth over $17K sold in Cheektowaga 'He did not deserve this': Family of Rochester missing man killed, found in Cattaraugus Co. fights fort justice Community works together to reopen East Side staple from 1949 Chief of Narcotics admits to reckless driving after multiple crashes last April Katie Skoog joined the News 4 team in April 2024. She is a graduate from the University at Buffalo. You can view more of her work here. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
3 days ago
- Yahoo
The Wacky Vintage Spread Only '70s Kids Remember
We may receive a commission on purchases made from links. If you grew up in the 1970s, you'll definitely remember this one -- a nutty, neon-hued spread that looked like peanut butter but acted more like a sugar rush in a jar. Koogle was Kraft's short-lived answer to boring brown lunchbox fillers, and it made no apologies for what it was: candy-fied chaos on toast. Introduced in 1974, the spread came in four over-the-top flavors -- chocolate, vanilla, cinnamon, and banana -- all housed in cheerful jars with a wide-mouthed grin and the wide-eyed gaze of its chaotic mascot. Think Nutella if it took a detour through Saturday morning cartoons. Packaged food was booming, and while Kraft helped change the landscape for packaged food through more lasting staples, Koogle was more of a chaotic detour. It hit shelves just in time for back-to-school season, and Kraft made sure the commercials stuck -- literally. In one ad, a child gleefully declares the spread "doesn't make my mouth stick together," a sly jab at traditional peanut butter's glue-like reputation. The branding was loud, the flavors were louder, and the target audience was crystal clear: hyper kids with a sweet tooth and no palate for plain peanuts. Today, most people under 50 have never even heard of it, but Koogle still has a cult following. And yes, there is even a Koogle-themed T-shirt being sold on Amazon. Read more: 17 Discontinued Sodas We Aren't Getting Back From Lunchboxes To Memory Lane Koogle didn't last long. Despite Kraft's marketing push, the spread began disappearing from shelves just two years after launch. By 1976, it was already slipping out of rotation in the U.S., and by 1978, it was basically gone. Canada held on a little longer -- but not by much. The likely culprit? Koogle was a niche product trying to ride the wave of a trend that fizzled. Still, nostalgia runs deep -- especially when it comes to old school snacks. Koogle might've vanished from grocery store aisles, but it's alive and well in the memories of people who grew up with its candy-sweet flavors and offbeat charm. There's even a Facebook group called Bring Back Koogle Peanut Butter, where former fans trade memories, photos, and the occasional wishful rumor. "I was a teenager in the 1970s and loved Koogle. I used to eat it right out of the jar," one member wrote. Another recalled, "I remember Koogle quite well as a kid of the seventies. I'd love to see it back and I'm sure that it would be well received." And then there's the mascot: the Koogle Nut -- a red, wobbly-eyed fever dream of a puppet that looked like a jar of peanut butter crossed with a Muppet who missed rehearsal. He didn't speak. He jiggled, he spun, he danced -- and if nothing else, he made sure Koogle stuck in your head, even if it didn't stick around. Hungry for more? Sign up for the free Daily Meal newsletter for delicious recipes, cooking tips, kitchen hacks, and more, delivered straight to your inbox. Read the original article on The Daily Meal. Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
02-08-2025
- Yahoo
The 1-Ingredient Upgrade for Unforgettable Cucumber Sandwiches
I've been rapturously eating this sandwich every summer since Takeaways • Pair peanut butter—especially the crunchy variety—with cucumbers. It's an unusual but delicious upgrade that elevates the simplest cucumber sandwich into something memorable. • The creamy, nutty richness of peanut butter pairs beautifully with the fresh, watery crunch of cucumber, creating a contrast classic spreads like cream cheese can't match. • You can build it as a sandwich using whole‑grain bread or, for a low‑carb version, dip cucumber spears directly into peanut your pantry, at this very moment, sits the key ingredient to transforming an ordinary cucumber sandwich from a watery, forgettable snack to a sandwich that'll blow your mind. Exactly in what way it'll blow your mind is up for debate, but it's worth trying just for the experience—and it might just become your new summer go-to. This take on a cucumber sandwich exists somewhat in the shadowy fringes of sandwich subculture. You won't see it on deli menus or tea party platters, but I'm a diehard fan, and I know I'm not the only one. Though the combo may sound oddball, it's a match made in heaven. If you know, you know. The Cucumber Sandwich Upgrade You'll Never Forget It's peanut butter. Yes, that's it. The sandwich soul mate of cucumber slices is peanut butter, a spread usually relegated to other, less dynamic if beloved sandwiches (ahem, PB&J). When Simply Recipes reader Bill Hunsinger wrote to us in response to a previous cucumber sandwich article we published, I sat up and took notice. 'If you want the absolute best-tasting cucumber sandwich you'll ever taste, make a peanut butter and cucumber sandwich,' he said. ' I learned this from my father, who I believe either learned it from his parents during the depression of the 1930s or when he was in the Air Force during World War II, which at that time was called the Army Air Corp.' Well! I've been rapturously eating peanut butter and cucumber sandwiches every summer since 2013 or so, and I've rarely encountered others with the same habit. It was great to talk shop. Bill went on to explain how he makes his take on his father's sandwich. How To Make a Peanut Butter and Cucumber Sandwich Two slices of the best whole-grain bread you can find One healthy helping of peanut butter, crunchy or creamy, your choice Enough cucumber slices (as thick as you want them) to cover the bread slice, usually four or six Put the two slices together, take a bite and enjoy "If you're not into a sandwich or you're watching your carbs closely, forget the bread and cut a cucumber into spears and then drag through the peanut butter still in the jar. Regardless of how you enjoy this combination, you'll find peanut butter (especially crunchy, my favorite) and cucumber is an unbeatable flavor that will make you wonder why you never tried this before. I learned this recipe 63 years ago, and I love it as much today as I did back in 1961." Bill mentioned the reaction he's received over the years when he's related this sandwich to others. 'It's usually the same face most people get when trying to describe biting into a lemon.' Who Even Eats This Sandwich? Besides me, Bill, and his dad, who else covets peanut butter and cucumber sandwiches? There are precedents: Think of fresh spring rolls with peanut dipping sauce or Indonesian gado-gago. The richness of the peanut butter sets alight the juicy crunch of cucumber in a way that spreads like Boursin or cream cheese just can't. Also, peanut butter is inexpensive, non-perishable, and needs no softening. It's always ready to be turned into a delightful sandwich. Its substantial body and nutritional density make a cucumber sandwich a meal that sticks with you. A 2013 story on NPR initially tipped me off on the cucumber-peanut butter combo. The sandwich mentioned in that story was far more elaborate, a pile of fresh garden vegetables (tomato, onion, cucumber) with cheese and a finishing slick of peanut butter. Like Bill's sandwich, it employs whole-grain bread. NPR listeners voted the recipe the winner of the 'Taste of Summer' competition that year; its down-home ingenuity must have struck a chord. Over the years, I pared down my take on it to just peanut butter, tomato, and cucumber. I only eat it this way if the tomatoes are big, fat, homegrown ones, and it's the messiest thing ever (I like thick, even layers of crunchy natural peanut butter on both slices of bread). You have to assemble the sandwich and eat it immediately, preferably over the sink with paper towels nearby. Usually, I toast the bread lightly so it holds up to the juicy vegetables better. Whole-grain bread is a common thread with this otherwise malleable sandwich. I asked Bill what he likes. 'I love Arnold's Whole Grains Healthy Multi-Grain,' he wrote back. 'It has an earthy, natural flavor without tasting like I just shoved my face into a pile of dirt and yet it's subtle enough so that it doesn't take away from the flavor created when cucumber and peanut butter combine on my taste buds.' If you've made it this far, you probably have your own personal history with peanut butter and cucumber sandwiches. If so, I'd love to know more, so and let us know how you make yours and where you first came across it. Many thanks to Bill for reminding us about this oldie but goodie of a summer sandwich combo. Read the original article on SIMPLYRECIPES
