Alleged childcare predator continued working despite being stood down after alleged 'uncomfortable' incident
David William James, 26, allegedly abused children at Outside School Hours Care (OSHC) facilities across Sydney between April 2021 and May 2024.
Police allege James photographed or filmed ten victims aged five to six while working at six out-of-school-hours (OOSH) care centres in the city's north and CBD.
James' identity had been kept secret for the past nine months until a suppression order was lifted in Downing Centre Local Court on Thursday.
He was employed as a casual worker through staffing agency Randstad Education and worked at 58 OOSH centres.
One of his colleagues reported feeling 'uncomfortable' after witnessing an alleged interaction between him and a child at Mowbray Public School's Primary OSCare, in Lane Cove North, in June 2024.
Parent company for Mowbray Public School's Primary OSCare, Junior Adventures Group (JAG), confirmed NSW Police and the Office of the Children's Guardian were notified of the alleged incident, which is separate to the police investigation.
James was stood down from Mowbray Public School's Primary OSCare and he was subsequently banned from working at JAG centres. But the ban did not affect his Working with Children Check (WWCC) and he continued working for Randstad.
A JAG spokeswoman said James was let go because of staff members' 'concerns'.
'The individual was stood down after concerns were raised about a separate incident that is not part of the current police investigation,' she told the Sydney Morning Herald.
'When the concerns were raised, JAG immediately took action, notifying NSW Police and the NSW Office of the Children's Guardian.'
A WWCC is only affected if there is a sustained finding made under the Reportable Conduct Scheme, the Office of the Children's Guardian states.
However, reporting inappropriate conduct does not always result in a person being barred from working with children.
In some instances, the Office of the Children's Guardian can put an interim bar on an individual's working with children, however this was not done in James' case.
Parents from Lane Cove West Public School, where James once worked, were shocked to find he retained his employment despite the complaints against him.
One parent claimed the WWCC was 'obviously not comprehensive enough', while another labelled the situation a 'travesty' and an 'abomination'.
It was revealed last month, before James' name could be published, that 1,200 letters were to parents and carers who may have crossed paths with him (pictured)
Randstad Education has also released a statement in light of the allegations.
'We are deeply disturbed by the allegations, and we extend our deepest sympathies to the children and families impacted by the alleged offending,' they said.
'Screening of workers, including for the accused, is conducted in accordance with best practice in Child Safe recruitment principles.'
Last month, 1,200 letters were sent to parents and carers whose children may have come into contact with James.
The letters were sent as part of a process led by NSW Police and the AFP under the Joint Child Protection Response Program.
Investigators asked parents and carers who received the letter to read it carefully, including instructions for contacting a hotline with any relevant concerns.
'Based on information currently available, investigators believe the alleged behaviour of the man involves a very small number of children, however, the parents and carers of any child who may have had contact with the man have received a letter,' the AFP said in a statement.
On Thursday, AFP acting Assistant Commissioner Brett James said the investigation was launched after child abuse material was detected on the dark web in June 2024.
The 26-year-old attended Knox Grammar at Wahroonga (pictured) until 2017 and worked part-time at 58 child care facilities between 2018 and 2024
He said police had examined 142,000 files on the alleged paedophile's devices which amounted to 18.9GB of material.
Daily Mail understands that police will allege James filmed boys using the toilet and pleasured himself while in a classroom in front of children.
He attended the prestigious private school Knox Grammar until 2017 and was a probationary police constable between December 2021 and September 2022.
He failed to finish his probation period and resigned from the NSW Police Force in May 2023 after a stint working in a civilian capacity.
NSW Police confirmed James was rejected by the force because he had failed to disclose his part-time childcare employment.
'During his employment, the man failed to seek the required approval to engage in secondary employment, and as such, police were unaware of his concurrent role in the childcare sector,' a police spokesperson said.
'We acknowledge the seriousness of the allegations and condemn any behaviour that places our community's most vulnerable members at risk.'
James was initially charged last September with refusing to grant Australian Federal Police access to his phone and was arrested again a month later when he was charged with further offences.
He has been charged with nine counts of aggravated use of a child to make child abuse material, one count of using a child to make abuse material, two counts of possessing abuse material and one count of refusing officers access to his phone.
James has been refused bail since October and will next face court on August 21.
Full list of places where alleged abuser David James worked
Artarmon Before and After School Care: Willoughby City Council - June 2019
Bales Park OOSH Services - December 2018
Beacon Hill Vacation Care: Northern Beaches Council - December 2018
Camp Australia: Artarmon - February - December 2022
Camp Australia: St Andrews Cathedral - June 2018
Camp Australia: St Luke's Grammar School - April 2018
Chatswood ASC & VC: Willoughby City Council - November 2018
Cromer Vacation Care: Northern Beaches Council - January 2020
Cubby House: Artarmon - June to August 2019
Forestville Vacation Care: Northern Beaches Council - July 2018 to April 2022
The Girls & Boys Brigade: Surry Hills - November 2020
Gowrie NSW Erskineville Outside of School Hours Care - June 2018 to February 2019
Gowrie NSW: North Sydney Community VC - April 2023
Helping Hands: Bourke Street - March 2019 to April 2024
Helping Hands: Lane Cove West - April 2018 to September 2024
Helping Hands: North Ryde - May 2018 to August 2023
Helping Hands: St Ives Park Public School - December 2023 to May 2024
Helping Hands: Willoughby Public School - April 2018 to December 2022
Hornsby South Before and After School Care - May 2018
Jigsaw: Anzac Park Public School - May 2018
KGV OSHC: City of Sydney - November 2018 to April 2022
KidsCo Australia: Virtual Holiday Program - July to August 2021
Knox Grammar High School - March 2018 to July 2020
Knox Grammar School OSHClub - May 2024
Manly Vale VC: Northern Beaches Council - April 2019 to July 2022
North Shore Coaching College - July 2023 to September 2024
OSHClub: Barker College - May 2018 to May 2024
OSHClub: Beaumont Road - May 2018 to April 2023
OSHClub: Fort Street - May 2018
OSHClub: Highfields - April to November 2018
OSHClub: Hornsby South - August 2018 to July 2023
OSHClub: Knox Grammar Preparatory - May 2018 to February 2020
OSHClub: Newington Lindfield - February 2020
OSHClub: Smalls Road - February 2022 to August 2023
Our Lady of Good Counsel OSHC: Forestville - August 2018 to March 2019
Our Lady of the Rosary OSHC: Waitara - October 2018
Primary OSHCare: Chatswood - September 2019 to March 2020
Primary OSHCare: Forestville - February 2021
Primary OSHCare: Frenchs Forest - September 2022
Primary OSHCare: Killarney Heights - January 2023
Primary OSHCare: Mowbray - March 2020 to May 2024
Primary OSHCare: St Ives - July 2021 to January 2024
Primary OSHCare: St Ives North - February to March 2024
Pyrmont OSHC: City of Sydney - October 2018 to July 2022
SCECS: OSHC Rose Bay - January to May 2023
St Kieran's OSHC: Manly Vale - May 2018 to February 2019
St Martin's Davidson OSHC - September 2018
St Mary's OOSH: Erskineville - December 2020
Stanmore OSHC Service: Inner West Council - July to August 2018
TeamKids: ANZAC Park Public School - February 2021 to June 2023
TheirCare: Ravenswood School for Girls - May 2023
TheirCare: St Andrew's Cathedral School - December 2020
Ultimo OSHC: City of Sydney - July 2018 to September 2024
Uniting OSHC: Brookvale - July 2023
West Lindfield Getaway Vacation Care: Ku-ring-gai Municipal Council - April 2018
Willoughby Kids House - July 2023
YMCA Bankstown City - July 2018
YMCA NSW: Lycée Condorcet - July to August 2023
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
11 minutes ago
- BBC News
Reckoning for Australia's childcare sector after onslaught of abuse cases
Twice a week, Ben Bradshaw drops his young son off at a Sydney childcare centre before heading off to thousands of parents and carers across Australia, the 40-year-old had always been confident that the staff have his child's best interests at in recent months, that trust in the childcare system has been "eroded", the father-of-two says, after several high-profile cases of alleged sexual and physical abuse at centres across Australia."It's that old adage of cockroaches - if you see one in your house, there's 10 that you don't see. These are the ones that get caught. It's more scary the ones that you can't see," he tells the the past few weeks, 2,000 children in Victoria have been urged to undergo infectious disease testing after a childcare worker was charged with the mass sexual abuse of babies; police have named a Sydney man who worked for 60 after-school-care providers and is accused of taking "explicit" images of children under his supervision; a Queensland woman has faced court over allegations she tortured a one-year-old boy; and another two workers in Sydney have been charged after a toddler was left covered in comes as the nation is still reeling from the crimes of childcare worker Ashley Paul Griffith - dubbed "one of Australia's worst paedophiles" - who was late last year sentenced to life in prison for raping and sexually abusing almost 70 series of allegations have sparked panic and fear among parents, child safety advocates have demanded action to fix what they call a dangerously incompetent system, and politicians have promised reform to keep Australia's most vulnerable safe."Some childcare centres are still safe, but the current childcare system is definitely not working to protect children or prioritise their safety," says Hetty Johnston, a leading child protection advocate. "It fails at every step." Rapid growth, greater risks In recent years, there has been a nationwide push to give more children access to early childhood education and care, which research indicates has many positive long-term of dollars have been poured into the sector from federal and state governments, including funding to guarantee three days of childcare for low and middle-income families. Such measures have prompted rapid growth in the sector, with a rush of new centres opening which has deepened a shortage of qualified growth has led to "significant vulnerabilities", says Prof Leah Bromfield, director of the Australian Centre for Child Protection."Whenever you grow something really quickly, that comes with risks," she says, listing off a lack of regulation and monitoring, limited training for managers, and the disparate and casual nature of the workforce."You put all that together and you've created a weak system from the perspective of a predatory perpetrator… a system where it's easier to infiltrate."In the wake of the Melbourne child sexual abuse case where Joshua Dale Brown was charged with 70 counts of abuse against eight babies, the federal government gave itself greater powers to strip funding from providers that breach quality and safety Education Minister Jason Clare said the measure was not designed to "shut down centres" but rather increase pressure for them to "raise standards".But Mr Bradshaw wants more. He says taking away funding from a centre "doesn't stop the crime, it just punishes it"."You have to do things that are proactive in nature." Knee-jerk reactions The spate of alleged crimes have sparked a heated national conversation about how to better protect kids. Limiting the role of men in childcare is one of the most controversial was a public call to ban men from certain tasks such as changing nappies and taking children to the toilet – though some warned this could place extra pressure on female staff."It's not about banning male educators, but about providing families with agency and informed choice," says Louise Edmonds, an advocate for child sex abuse case prompted G8 Education – who owned the centre where he worked - to introduce so-called "intimate care waivers", giving parents and carers the opportunity to choose who carried out private and sensitive duties. It also pledged to install CCTV at all of its centres. Ms Johnston - who founded child protection group Bravehearts - says these are natural responses, but cautioned that, though "men are definitely a higher risk", women do abuse children too and offenders can do so in all kinds of settings."They are opportunistic… when others don't pay attention, when they are distracted, complacent, disinterested or too trusting, they create 'opportunities' for offenders."Other practical measures centres could adopt to improve child safety include having two educators with direct line of sight of children at all times and getting rid of blind spots in centres - replacing solid doors with glass panes, eliminating windowless walls, and putting more mirrors up to create "incidental supervision"."It's all about reducing opportunities for predators to isolate or conceal in nooks and crannies," Ms Johnston says. Hiding in plain sight But massive system reform is also long overdue, experts 2017, more than 400 recommendations emerged from a years-long royal commission into child sex abuse in institutional settings – like churches, schools and childcare - but critics say progress has stalled on some of the most significant of those outstanding recommendations, to be discussed by the country's attorneys-general at a meeting this month, is to overhaul Australia's checks on those who work with each state and territory complete what is essentially a police check required for those who work alongside children, but they don't share the information with each other. Advocates have called for a nationalised system, but some say the checks themselves don't go far enough."It's inconsistent, relies too heavily on prior convictions," Ms Edmonds instance, many say, the system should capture red flags such as formal complaints, workplace warnings, police intelligence, and people identified as alleged abusers in confidential applications to the national redress scheme set up after the royal a broader net is important, experts argue, as child abuse allegations can be difficult to stand up in court. Often the witnesses are young children, who are either non-verbal or have limited vocabulary, may struggle with memory, and often have a lack of situational understanding."Catching someone red-handed and being able to prove it beyond reasonable doubt is almost impossible," Ms Johnston says. That's why Prof Bromfield is among those calling for a national registration scheme for the childcare sector – like those that exist for doctors or teachers. It would require workers to prove their qualifications, could provide a detailed work history, and would bind them all by a code of argue the system could also capture many of the things the working- with-children checks currently do not."Often in child sexual abuse cases, when you look back, you see lots and lots of red flags," Prof Bromfield says."There might be a pattern, but [at the moment] we just don't see that because they are moving between states or between sectors or between providers."Mr Bradshaw says having access to more information about staff would help parents like him make informed is a necessity for his family, he explains, as he works full-time and his wife, a high school teacher, works four days a often, there's little detail about the childcare centre's staff "beyond the pictures on the wall" of the teachers and educators, so parents often have to assess a provider "based on vibes"."It's a bit of a blackbox and you're bound because you need to have your kids in childcare so you can pay for living in a big city."That's where greater education for parents is needed too, Prof Bromfield says, so they know what questions to ask and, in the worst-case scenarios, how to spot signs of grooming include enquiring about a provider's child safety policies, asking about its staff turnover, and assessing the physical spaces for any visibility issues. There also needs to be better, more regular training for managers in the sector on how to prevent and identify problematic behaviour or patterns, experts Prof Bromfield - who was part of the team which conducted the royal commission into child sex abuse – these are conversations she has been having for over a she is hopeful the current crisis will shock Australia into taking greater action."Perhaps one of the things that will happen is there will be greater political will to prioritise safety for children," Prof Bromfield says."The big lesson is that we can never rest on our laurels when it comes to children's safety."Perpetrators just keep getting smarter, working around the systems we've got. We can't forget the lessons of the past… and we can't assume that this is a problem that's gone away."
The Guardian
5 hours ago
- The Guardian
‘No clear explanation': businesses reliant on Meta struggle in the wake of wrongful suspensions
This time of the year is typically the busy booking season for Sam Enticknap, a makeup artist based in Margaret River, Western Australia. But the phone has stopped ringing since her Instagram account, which had 48,000 followers, was suspended without notice by Meta three weeks ago. 'I received a horrible email saying a reference to child sexual exploitation content, which obviously was quite traumatic to see,' she said. 'Saying my Instagram accounts have been disabled with just no clear explanation.' Enticknap estimates that, as a result of her account being wrongly suspended, she has lost 80% of the bookings she otherwise would have leading into the busy wedding season in Margaret River. Sign up: AU Breaking News email 'A lot of people come through Instagram, they find hashtags and they find word of mouth, and obviously through other businesses that always tag us,' she said. Enticknap said it made her realise how reliant she was on Meta for business. She said she lost two Instagram accounts and a Facebook account as a result of the permanent suspension, and said attempts to contact the company to have the ban appealed had resulted in a 'dead end'. She said she was not alone, citing another Western Australian business – which sells artificial flowers – which had been suspended from Meta platforms and received the same reference to child sexual exploitation. 'My friend who has another successful makeup business, she went down the week after me, but she's managed to get her account back,' Enticknap said. Incorrect account suspensions on social media platforms are not a new phenomenon. Often when Meta is asked by media about an account, it is later restored. However, something changed in July. A flood of emails were sent to journalists from people all over the world saying that, without warning, their Facebook and Instagram accounts had been suspended. Many were told – erroneously – by Meta that their accounts had been suspended for breaching community standards on child sexual exploitation, abuse and nudity. Users report Meta has typically been unresponsive to their pleas for assistance, often with standardised responses to requests for review, almost all of which have been rejected. There are petitions with tens of thousands of signatures, a subreddit devoted to people who have had their accounts disabled and talk of a class action against Meta over the bans. From around a dozen emails received in the past two weeks, Guardian Australia has reported five accounts – including Enticknap's to Meta, which said it had internally escalated the investigation of those accounts. Media reporting of the plight of businesses struggling as a result of their Instagram ban has led to many of those accounts being restored. But the company claims there has not been an increase in incorrect account suspension, and the volume of users complaining was not indicative of new targeting or over-enforcement. Sign up to Breaking News Australia Get the most important news as it breaks after newsletter promotion 'We take action on accounts that violate our policies, and people can appeal if they think we've made a mistake,' a spokesperson for Meta said. Meta is reliant on a mix of human reports and automation to find and remove accounts in breach of its rules. The company publishes data on how many accounts it removes – and data on how many it subsequently restores – in its quarterly community standards enforcement report. However, the latest report only covers to the end of March, so it can't yet be judged whether the company has had a significant uptick in removed accounts or appeals. For Enticknap, the suspension carries an emotional weight. Her father died this year, and the photos and messages her father uploaded to Facebook cannot be accessed. 'I've tried to message and just say: 'Can I just get my data? Can I just get that? Shut me down, but let me get those pictures back',' she said. 'But nothing. I've not had any reply.'
Daily Mail
6 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Footy boss lashes back at the NRL over an 'unfair' punishment which left one of his club's key members 'struggling'
Ivan Cleary has clapped back at the NRL after the league handed down a heavy punishment to the Penrith Panthers after one of the club's trainers was involved in a controversial incident in Round 22. Trainer Corey Bocking found himself under scrutiny after he appeared to run in front of Gold Coast Titans star Jayden Campbell as the fullback attempted to take a kick for goal. Campbell missed the set shot, with the Panthers rallying late in the match. Nathan Cleary kicked a two-point penalty in the 79th minute to send the game to a golden point tiebreaker Blaize Talagi crossed over the white wash in the 82nd minute to keep the Panthers' eight-match winning streak alive. But the talking point from the match was Bocking's decision to run back in front of Campbell while he was taking a kick. While the Panthers are adamant the incident was an accident, the league handed a proposed five-match ban to Bocking and slapped the club with a prospective $50,000 fine. The severity of the punishment takes into account the Panthers' rap sheet, which includes six other indiscretions involving trainers. Shane Elford was the most recent to cop a fine, with the trainer being slapped with a $10,000 penalty after squirting water on a ball during a clash against North Queensland. Cleary, though, claimed the penalty on Bocking was unfair. 'I think the punishment is pretty heavy,' the four-time premiership-winning coach explained. On Bocking, he added: 'I think his suspension is the biggest of anyone in the NRL this year. I think it's a bit harsh to come and say that his penalty is based on other things. 'He's struggling, has been right from the time it happened. 'We kind of try to temper that with banter, which he takes in good nature. 'But yeah, he's struggling. He cares about his job and understands that he made a mistake and it's become a big deal. 'The last thing he would want is any excess attention, that's his nature. You can see clearly that he was embarrassed and apologised. 'I just think it's harsh and I think it's a little unfair.' Cleary also took responsibility for the trainer's decision to run across the pitch. 'It was clearly a mistake,' Cleary added. 'His job is to stay with the team after the goal has been kicked. 'The only reason why he ran that line is because I changed a sub. If anyone is to blame, it's me - that is the truth.' The Panthers have stated that Bocking was running to the bench to alert the Penrith dugout of a substitution when the incident took place. Penrith will have five days to respond to the breach notice. Speaking on the heavy sanctions, NRL CEO Andrew Abdo explained that it was important for the NRL to take into account other actions of Panthers coaches in recent times in their sanctions. '(Penrith) have an opportunity to respond to the breach notice but it's important to note there have been six separate incidents involving Penrith Panthers trainers since 2021,' Abdo said at the launch of the NRL's Indigenous Round. 'So whilst we treat every incident on its own merits, taking into account the fact there have been several indiscretions by trainers from that club, it was important for us to take the action that we've taken.' Lifeline 13 11 14
