Simon Harris ‘did all he could' on child scoliosis case, Donohoe says
Simon Harris has faced calls to resign over unmet pledges around child spinal surgery waiting lists made several years ago.
Advertisement
It comes amid heightened scrutiny on the matter after the death of nine-year-old Harvey Morrison, who suffered from scoliosis, on July 29th.
His parents, Gillian Sherratt and Stephen Morrison, learned last August that Harvey had been removed from Children Health Ireland's (CHI) scoliosis waiting list without their knowledge.
After they publicly raised their son's case, Harvey, from Clondalkin, received spinal surgery last December after waiting for years.
By then, his spinal curve had reached the point where it could not be fully corrected.
Advertisement
While he spent years on a waiting list, his spinal curve caused his rib cage to twist around his lungs and heart, severely restricting his breathing.
While health minister in 2017, Mr Harris pledged that no child would wait more than four months for scoliosis treatment.
Opposition politicians have joined Harvey's mother and father in calling for the Fine Gael leader's resignation, further criticising Mr Harris for failing to meet his parents.
Asked if he stood by his party leader on Wednesday, Finance Minister Paschal Donohoe said Mr Harris has a commitment to supporting families dealing with scoliosis.
Advertisement
'Minister Harris, as minister and then as taoiseach and Tánaiste, when he became aware of the needs of the particular family in question here, did all he could in terms of engaging with the Department of Health, in terms of engaging with the HSE, and I'm very conscious that we have a family who have lost a loved one who are grieving at the moment, and we have to respect that and allow them to make the points that they believe are important.
'But alongside that, Simon and the Government have placed huge focus on how we support young children with scoliosis.
'We always want to do more. We always want to make more progress. But additional resources, additional clinical support and operating theatres have all been made available to focus in on supporting those children.'
He added: 'Those who are waiting for care have seen a reduction in how long they're waiting.
Advertisement
'We're seeing a reduction in the number of people on the waiting list.
'But we know we need to do more, and we will always continue to prioritise this as a vital health issue.'
Pressed on whether Mr Harris should be accountable for failures to meet the commitment to cut waiting lists to four months, and resign, Mr Donohoe said: 'We're all accountable through the appearances that we make in front of the Dáil, the questions we deal with in relation to matters of health or any aspect of public policy.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
2 hours ago
- The Guardian
Sally Rooney could be arrested under Terrorism Act after pledging royalties to Palestine Action
Irish novelist Sally Rooney could be arrested under the Terrorism Act after saying she intends to use proceeds from her work to support Palestine Action, which was proscribed as a terrorist organisation in the UK last month, a legal expert has warned. Earlier, No 10 said that supporting the group was an offence under the act, after Rooney had made her pledge. Royalties from Rooney's books, including Normal People and Conversations with Friends, and BBC adaptations of them would be used to support Palestine Action, she wrote in the Irish Times over the weekend. The legal expert also said that the bestselling writer could face prosecution if she were to express her views at, for example, a UK book festival, underscoring the proscription's 'gross disproportionality'. While the prime minister's spokesperson would not respond to the author's comments specifically, they said that there was 'a difference between showing support for a proscribed organisation, which is an offence under the Terrorism Act, and legitimate protest in support of a cause', according to the Press Association. Asked what message No 10 would give to people considering donating money to Palestine Action, the spokesperson said: 'Support for a proscribed organisation is an offence under the Terrorism Act and obviously the police will, as they have set out, implement the law as you'd expect.' More than 700 people have been arrested under the Terrorism Act in relation to the group since it was proscribed in early July, many of whom were detained at a peaceful protest on 9 August in Parliament Square, London. 'My books, at least for now, are still published in Britain, and are widely available in bookshops and even supermarkets,' wrote Rooney on Saturday. 'In recent years the UK's state broadcaster has also televised two fine adaptations of my novels, and therefore regularly pays me residual fees. I want to be clear that I intend to use these proceeds of my work, as well as my public platform generally, to go on supporting Palestine Action and direct action against genocide in whatever way I can.' Palestine Action was proscribed as a terrorist organisation after activists broke into an RAF base in Oxfordshire and spray painted two planes. They 'knew, of course, that their actions were illegal,' Rooney wrote in the Guardian in June. 'From the suffragettes to the gay rights movement to the anti-apartheid struggle, genuine political resistance has always involved intentional law-breaking.' In her Irish Times article last weekend, Rooney said that she 'would happily publish this statement in a UK newspaper – but that would now be illegal'. Rooney's books also include Beautiful World, Where Are You and, most recently, Intermezzo. Lawyer and writer Sadakat Kadri said: 'Receiving money with the intention of using it to support terrorism is an offence under section 15 of the 2000 act.. That means Rooney could be arrested without a warrant as a 'terrorist'.' He added that 'the absurdities don't end there', and said the decision of the home secretary, Yvette Cooper, to bracket Palestine Action with groups such as Islamic State meant the BBC would also be criminally liable if it continued to pay royalties to Rooney. in view of her stated intentions. 'Authoritarian governments routinely threaten writers and intimidate broadcasters, but I find it quite extraordinary that Labour under Keir Starmer has now chosen to go down the same path.' Asked whether Rooney could face legal repercussions if she, for example, spoke at a book festival in the UK, Kadri said that 'there's certainly a risk she'd fall foul' of the law. If Rooney expressed 'her views in terms of condemning the war crimes being committed in Gaza, an arguable case for prosecution could be made out'. 'Saying that isn't for one moment an attempt to justify the statute,' said Kadri, which he described as 'a shameful attack' on free speech. 'It's just a particularly stark illustration of the measure's gross disproportionality.' Mike Schwarz, head of the public inquiry team at the legal firm Hodge Jones & Allen, said that 'anyone providing money which might, in the state's eyes, fund 'terrorism' and, separately, anyone supporting an organisation proscribed under terrorism legislation runs a very real risk of serious police interest and prosecution for grave offences in the UK. This seems particularly the case in the current febrile political climate surrounding Palestine Action.'
BBC News
4 hours ago
- BBC News
Ballymena councillor Lawrie Philpott resigns from DUP
A Democratic Unionist Party (DUP) councillor has resigned from the party, saying he wanted to focus "entirely on the needs and concerns of local people" without being influenced by party Philpott was elected as a representative for Ballymena on Mid and East Antrim Borough Council in will now serve as an independent - bringing the number of independent representatives on the council to is the second councillor to leave the DUP on Mid and East Antrim Council since the start of the current term, following David Clarke's departure in January 2024. No influence from 'political agenda' On Monday, Philpott said he had now "left party politics behind to put people first"."This decision has not been an easy one, but I believe it is the right one," he said."My priority has always been - and will always remain - to represent and serve the people of Ballymena to the best of my ability."By stepping away from party politics, I can focus entirely on the needs and concerns of local people, without being influenced by any wider political agenda."Philpott said he was committed to working with other colleagues "regardless of political affiliation" to achieve the best for Ballymena."I will continue to work hard for the people of Ballymena, listening to concerns and doing my best to get things done," he added.A DUP spokesperson said the party had received Philpott's resignation and wished him well.
BreakingNews.ie
7 hours ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Tony Holohan cites ‘duty as father' after ruling out presidential bid
Dr Tony Holohan has cited concerns over the potential impact on his friends and family as he ruled himself out of contention for the role of president. The former chief medical officer, who held a key role in steering the country's response to Covid-19, said he believed he did have a 'pathway' to securing a nomination to run. Advertisement However, Dr Holohan said he had a responsibility and a duty to think of his family who he said may have been exposed to what he described as unfair criticism due to his past professional life. On Monday, he told RTÉ's News At One that he had 'kicked the tyres fully' when considering whether to proceed with seeking a nomination. 'I entertained the possibility that this might be something that was worth thinking about for me, and I decided that I should give it careful and due consideration.' He added, 'It was a balanced consideration across a lot of different criteria. Advertisement 'Among those that weighed heavily on me were some of my own personal experiences and the family experiences we've had.' As a high-profile role decision-maker during Covid-19, Dr Holohan was a figurehead for critics of the pandemic response, with his family home targeted by protests. He has also been criticised for his handling of the CervicalCheck scandal, which centred around women not being informed about audits of their previous smear tests. 'I had a role that was a prominent one. Advertisement 'You don't get to have a prominent role in public life without having people who will have a variety of different opinions on that and find ways of making those opinions known. 'Sometimes that strayed into areas that, for me, would have been unacceptable. 'I've had protests outside my house during the course of Covid that weighed heavily on my children. 'You'll be aware that over the course of Covid, my wife was ill and died. Advertisement 'I've had people put comments on social media that they're glad and using much more colourful language than that.' Presidential candidate Catherine Connolly (Brian Lawless/PA) Dr Holohan also recalled a moment he felt 'fearful' while he was alone and confronted in a park, adding there were 'upsetting' moments for his children and neighbours when people demonstrated outside his home. He said the consideration for his family was just one of several factors in his decision to step away from the process. 'I have confidence in my own ability to explain and to defend issues that I've been involved in the past during my professional role. Advertisement 'But other people in my family don't have that capacity, they don't have the insights, they don't have the experience. 'They hear the self same criticism, some of which is balanced and fair, much of it is not, and it has a bearing on them and I have a duty and a responsibility as a father, as a husband, as a family member to think not just of my own interests, but those of my family in a balanced way.' Former minister for social protection Heather Humphreys (Brian Lawless/PA) Elsewhere in the race, momentum is gathering behind former Fine Gael deputy leader Heather Humphreys as the party's potential candidate for Áras an Uachtaráin. It comes after Mairead McGuinness withdrew from the race on health grounds weeks after securing the party's backing. Party MEP Sean Kelly is also considering whether he will enter the contest to be Fine Gael's next candidate. Fine Gael will consider its option through a meeting of its executive council. Meanwhile, independent TD Catherine Connolly has secured the backing of Labour, the Social Democrats, People Before Profit and a range of other independents. Fianna Fáil and Sinn Féin have yet to decide if they will field a candidate. Nutriband entrepreneur Gareth Sheridan, mixed martial arts fighter Conor McGregor, and Riverdance star Michael Flatley are among other hopefuls seeking a nomination. A presidential election is expected towards the end of October, as it must take place in the 60 days before the term of Michael D Higgins ends on November 11th. To be eligible to run, a candidate must be an Irish citizen who is 35 or older. They must be nominated either by at least 20 members of the Oireachtas or by at least four local authorities. Former or retiring presidents can nominate themselves.
