Nunes defamation lawsuit over Rachel Maddow comment dismissed
U.S. District Judge Kevin Castel ruled this week that Nunes failed to prove Maddow and her team at the network acted with actual malice during a discussion about a package Nunes received addressed to him from Andrii Derkach, a Ukrainian legislator with ties to Russian officials and intelligence services, while he was the ranking member of the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence.
'The Court concludes that no reasonable jury could find that NBCU made the statement with constitutionally-defined actual malice,' Castel wrote.
MSNBC is owned by NBC Universal as part of the Comcast corporate umbrella.
Nunes, a longtime ally of President Trump, sued Maddow in 2021 alleging she and the network 'harbor an institutional hostility, hatred, extreme bias, spite and ill-will' toward the Republican.
The suit specifically took issue with statements made by Maddow during her show on March 18 of that year, during which she suggested that Nunes refused to turn over a package he had reportedly received from the suspected Russian agent to the FBI.
Castel in 2022 ruled Nunes' case could proceed, writing his attorneys had 'plausibly allege[d] actual malice' but did not make a determination about the merits of the former congressman's claim against the network.
Maddow has for years attacked Trump, who has blasted Comcast over NBC News coverage of his administration and suggested critics such as Maddow be taken off the air.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
25 minutes ago
- New York Post
Rift emerges between allies Russia and Iran over $1.75B weapons deal, Putin's lack of support for Tehran
A rift is reportedly emerging between allies Russia and Iran, after Tehran feels it's gotten shortchanged in strongman Vladimir Putin's war against Ukraine. Moscow inked a $1.75 billion weapons deal with the Islamic Republic in 2023 — called at the time 'a covert partnership' — to get the designs to domestically produce Iran's infamous Shahed drones, which it had been importing since launching its full-scale invasion on Ukraine a year earlier. 4 Putin inked a deal with Iran in 2023 to get the designs for its Shahed drones. MIKHAIL METZEL/SPUTNIK/KREMLIN POOL/EPA/Shutterstock But Tehran has been growing increasingly frustrated with the little backing it's received from Russia since, CNN reported, citing a Western intelligence source. The resentment hit a high note during the Islamic Republic's 12-day war with Israel in June, when Tehran was expecting more than just words from its ally. 4 At the start of its invasion of Ukraine in 2022, Russia paid as much as $200,000 for just one of these Iranian drones. NurPhoto via Getty Images Russian officials condemned Israel's attacked as 'unprovoked and unacceptable' and offered to mediate the conflict — but did not provide any military support to Iran, despite the two countries' partnership. Left to fend for itself, the Iranian regime was badly battered and weakened during the conflict. The Jewish state carried out numerous devastating aerial strikes on the Islamic Republic and its nuclear facilities, killing more than 30 Iranian commanders, at least 11 of the regime's top nuclear masterminds and sending the Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei into hiding. 4 The unmanned drones are sometimes refered to as 'kamikaze' drones because they self-destruct after reaching their target. Middle East Images/AFP via Getty Images It showed Russia's 'purely transactional and utilitarian nature,' the intelligence official told the outlet. 'This explicit disengagement demonstrates that Russia never intervenes beyond its immediate interests, even when a partner – here an essential supplier of drones – is attacked,' they said. The Shahed drones — also referred to as kamikaze drones — have since become the cornerstone of Moscow's war machine, when hundreds of are often launched on Ukraine in a single evening. 4 Iran's Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei reportedly feels cheated from his deal with Putin. LEADER OFFICE/AFP via Getty Images To add insult to injury, Putin's men have taken Tehran's designs and developed better, cheaper versions — and failed to make some of its payments to Iran because of the Western sanctions placed on the Kremlin. It is unclear how much Moscow has yet to pay its counterpart toward the deal. Russia has also modernized the drones to make them more lethal and harder to bring down, according to Ukraine, leaving Tehran in the dark about the developments. It's also brought down the cost from $200,000 for one Shahed drone — to just $70,000. Intelligence officials believe as much as 90% of Shahed production is now done inside Russia, and satellite images show the largest drone factory — in Alabuga, 600 miles east of Moscow — is continuing to expand.
Fox News
26 minutes ago
- Fox News
Democratic strategist says party lacks 'moral authority' on Texas redistricting fight
Democrats are fighting tooth and nail to stop Texas lawmakers' plan to redraw the state's congressional map, but critics, including one prominent member of their own party, say they don't exactly hold the moral high ground. Democrat legislators have fled the state to avoid votes on redistricting, which is expected to add more Republican seats to Congress for the Lone Star State. They're getting the rock-star treatment as they visit blue states, where several governors have vowed to gerrymander Republicans out of their own Congressional delegations in retaliation for the Texas effort. However, Democratic strategist Julian Epstein told "Fox News Live" on Saturday that his party is not immune from criticism, as many blue states have already gerrymandered in a way that limits Republican congressional representation. "No, I think they don't have the moral authority, and there's a lot of pearl-clutching going on," he said. Several blue states, including Massachusetts, Connecticut and New Mexico, have no Republicans in their House delegations. And many feature oddly-drawn districts, seemingly crafted to limit GOP representation. "The Democrats don't have clean hands here. You look at states like Massachusetts, New Jersey[…] Illinois, California, and Democrats have effectively gerrymandered Republicans out of existence," Epstein added. Epstein cautioned that the nationwide redistricting battle could create a "race to the bottom," and that leaving Republicans and Democrats in states led by the opposite parties could lead to people feeling left out of the democratic process. Epstein cited New Jersey, in which Trump garnered 46% of the vote in 2024, but Republicans only have three out of the 12 congressional seats. Meanwhile, Texas state Rep. Brian Harrison, a Republican, told Fox News Digital on Saturday that Democrats are guilty of "total hypocrisy and faux outrage." "The dirty little secret is Democrats have no problem whatsoever with states redrawing their congressional maps to maximize partisan political advantage. They're just furious that Republican states are starting to redraw their maps," Harrison said. "It's because Democrat state after Democrat state, for a decade, has been gerrymandering the hell out of their congressional maps," he said. "Massachusetts, Connecticut, Vermont, Rhode Island, Delaware, all of these states have zero. If you're a Republican in those Democrat states, you don't have any voice in Congress," he added. "And [there are] many, many more that have given you just one seat, Oregon, I think Maine and Maryland." In California, a special election is likely to occur in November to counteract the Texas redistricting plan. "We are talking about emergency measures to respond to what's happening in Texas, and we will nullify what happens in Texas," California Gov. Gavin Newsom said on Friday with some Texas state lawmakers. "We'll pick up five seats with the consent of the people. And that's the difference between the approach we're taking and the approach they're taking," Newsom added. "We're doing it on a temporary basis. We're doing it in a fully transparent way and we're doing it by asking the people of the state of California for their consent and support." Harrison explained that Texas's redistricting push has numerous reasons behind it, including the population growth in the Lone Star state since the last census.
Newsweek
an hour ago
- Newsweek
Beto O'Rourke Defiant After Legal Blow in Texas Redistricting Standoff
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. Beto O'Rourke was defiant after a judge temporarily barred him and his political group from helping fund Texas Democratic lawmakers who left their home state to block redrawn congressional maps, which President Donald Trump has backed. The ruling marks a victory for Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, who alleged O'Rourke's group Powered by People engaged in bribery and deceptive fundraising. Paxton "wants to silence me and stop me from leading this organization," O'Rourke, a former Texas congressman who ran unsuccessfully for governor and Senate, wrote on X after the ruling on Friday. "He wants to stop us from fighting Trump's attempt to steal the five congressional seats he needs to hang on to power. But I'm not going anywhere." Newsweek has contacted Paxton's office and O'Rourke through Powered by People for comment via emails sent outside regular business hours. Former U.S. Rep. Beto O'Rourke speaks to attendees during a "Our Fight, Our Future" rally at The Millennium bowling alley on October 02, 2024 in Austin, Texas. Former U.S. Rep. Beto O'Rourke speaks to attendees during a "Our Fight, Our Future" rally at The Millennium bowling alley on October 02, 2024 in Austin, It Matters The Democratic lawmakers who left Texas have denied their Republican colleagues the quorum needed for a vote on the redrawn maps that could net the GOP five additional seats in the 2026 midterm elections. They face thousands of dollars in out-of-state lodging and dining costs. They also face fines of $500 for each day they are absent and these cannot be paid from their office budgets or political contributions under Texas House rules. Those who left have declined to say how long they'll hold out. What To Know Powered by People gave money to the Texas House Democratic Caucus to help cover their up-front costs, a spokesperson for the group told The Associated Press earlier this week. Tarrant County District Judge Megan Fahey, a Republican who was appointed by Texas Governor Greg Abbott in 2019 and has since won reelection, granted Paxton's request for a temporary injunction. "Defendants have and will continue to engage in unlawful fundraising practices and utilization of political funds in a manner that either directly violates or causes Texas Democratic Legislators to violate" state law and House procedures, she wrote in her ruling. Her order bars Powered by People from using political funds to pay for travel, hotel or dining costs for the Texas Democrats who left the state or fundraising on their behalf. Powered by People filed a responding lawsuit against Paxton on Friday, alleging his investigation violates the group's right to association, free speech and equal protection, the Houston Chronicle reported. "The true motivation behind defendant's action thus appears to be an unlawful desire to retaliate against Mr. O'Rourke," it said. What People Are Saying Paxton celebrated the judge's ruling, saying in a statement on Friday: "Today, I stopped his deceptive financial influence scheme that attempted to deceive donors and subvert our constitutional process. They told me to 'come and take it,' so I did.'" O'Rourke responded to Paxton on X, saying: "Actually, you didn't. Still here, still raising and rallying to stop the steal of 5 congressional seats in Texas. Ironic that you'd accuse someone of bribery when you were impeached in Texas for taking bribes from Nate Paul." (Paxton was acquitted of bribery and corruption charges by the Republican-led Texas Senate in 2023 after the GOP-controlled House voted to impeach him). In another post, he wrote: "They want to make examples out of those who fight so that others won't. Paxton is trying to shut down Powered by People, one of the largest voter registration organizations in the country, because our volunteers fight for voting rights and free elections... the kind of work that threatens the hold that Paxton, Trump and Abbott have on power in Texas." What's Next O'Rourke is set to speak at a rally—dubbed "The People vs. The Power Grab"— in Fort Worth on Saturday afternoon. Fahey's order is to remain in effect for two weeks. She has scheduled a hearing for August 19.
