Indonesia's Silvermen Beg To Make Ends Meet
On a rainy day in Indonesia's capital Jakarta, three men coated in metallic paint known as the "manusia silver", or silvermen, brave the elements at an intersection near a mall to ask drivers for change.
It is an arresting act that comes with health risks, one some young Indonesians feel is necessary to make ends meet as the cost of living worsens and jobs dwindle after the Covid pandemic.
"I'm ashamed to earn money like this. I want to find a real, more dignified job," said Ari Munandar, 25.
"But the embarrassment disappears when you remember that your daughter and your wife are at home."
Barefoot, dressed only in shorts and daubed head to toe by the irritating paint, Ari, his brother Keris and their friend Riyan Ahmad Fazriyansah each take a lane in the road.
When the cars come to a stop they strike robotic poses in front of the drivers.
"Good afternoon, have a nice drive," says Ari.
The poses have little meaning other than to attract cash.
"I do them because one day I saw a friend earn more by doing them," he said, moving between cars, holding out a bucket for donations.
On a good day they can pocket up to 200,000 rupiah ($12), but typically earn around 120,000.
That's much less than Jakarta's monthly minimum wage of five million rupiah and barely enough to cover daily expenses.
"I'm not going to eat lunch, just drink and smoke," said Ari.
Every penny counts in a country where prices have risen steadily in recent years.
A kilogram (two pounds) of rice, the archipelago's main staple, jumped by 27 percent between 2015 and 2025, according to statistics agency data.
And behind the paint, the friends are clearly undernourished.
None are taller than 172 centimetres (five feet eight inches) nor weigh more than 55 kilograms.
A lack of employment opportunity is the main cause of young men and women taking to the streets, they say.
"Since I was made redundant in 2019 I've been begging," said Ari.
"Before that, I worked cleaning toilets."
According to government data, the number of people living below the poverty line in metropolitan Jakarta -- a megalopolis of 11 million people -- was up from 362,000 in 2019 to 449,000 as of September 2024.
"Many young people with few qualifications between the ages of 20 and 40 have found themselves unemployed," said Bhima Yudistira, executive director of the Center of Economic and Law Studies.
"Even though there is no national count, there has been a huge rise in begging in Jakarta after the pandemic of 2021."
After five hours at the intersection, the group returns home by hitchhiking a ride from a tuk-tuk.
The three pile into the back, counting their meagre earnings and lighting a cigarette to share.
Once dropped off, they walk by a polluted river and across a railway line to their Jakarta slum.
Far from the capital's high-rises, children play near the tracks to the rhythm of the trains as Ari makes his way back to remove the silver.
The paint, similar to that used for screen-printing on fabric, is not easy to remove.
Squatting in front of a well and buckets filled with water, he splashes his body before scrubbing fiercely, his one-year-old daughter Arisya watching.
"At first the paint burned and I had a blister on my neck, but now it only stings my eyes," he said.
The shower reveals a new, younger man.
Once dry, he heads home to play with Arisya.
"As soon as I'm here I forget all the fatigue and the hardship," he says, smiling.
"But I hope she never does what I do."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Local Germany
13 hours ago
- Local Germany
Record number of complaints received by Germany's Anti-Discrimination Agency
Germany's Anti-Discrimination Agency published it's latest annual report on Tuesday, and the results made for grim reading. In 2024, the agency received 11,405 complaints about discrimination -- the highest number ever recorded, and a six percent rise compared to previous year. In 2019, the year before the Covid pandemic, the number of complaints received was 4,247. At 43 percent, the majority of complaints were about racist discrimination, followed by discrimination based on disability (27 percent) and gender (24 percent). Announcing the publication of the report, Ferda Ataman, the Independent Federal Commissioner for Anti-Discrimination, drew a clear line between the rise in the number of cases and the creeping normalisation of racist and discriminatory discourse. 'Discrimination is a growing problem in Germany,' warned the commissioner. 'With the rising number of votes for a party of the extreme right, it seems that more and more people feel encouraged to make racist comments in public.' Ataman added that the true number of cases – rather than the number of cases reported – is likely to be far higher, because 'most of those affected keep discrimination to themselves.' German protections are 'the weakest in Europe' According to Ataman, Germany's General Equal Treatment Act (AGG) is 'one of the weakest anti-discrimination laws in Europe.' Discrimination on the basis of nationality, for example, is not protected directly under Germany's General Equal Treatment Act (AGG). However, it can be considered indirect racial discrimination in some cases. Advertisement In 2024, around 2,350 complaints about discrimination involved incidents that were not covered by the current law. READ ALSO: Levels of racism and discrimination in Germany revealed in new survey Room for improvement The report identifies three areas for immediate action, including an urgent need for nationality to be included in the AGG as a ground for discrimination -- noting that the present loophole may have the unintended effect of encouraging anti-Semitic and anti-Roma discrimination. The commissioners also want to see the AGG extended to apply to government agencies. Currently, the authors suggest, citizens are inadequately protected against discrimination in government offices, in interactions with the police, in court, and in public schools and universities. In 2024, 25 percent of complaints received by the Anti-Discrimination Agency were connected with government agencies. Passers-by walk across a street in Munich's Haidhausen district in the early hours of the morning. Photo: picture alliance/dpa | Peter Kneffel Finally, the commissioners are calling for greater accessibility and protection against digital discrimination, amid concerns that AI systems and algorithms can disadvantage older people and people with disabilities. Discrimination at work and in everyday life One in three complaints received by the Anti-Discrimination Agency is related to incidents that occur during job searches, job interviews, at work, or when leaving employment. The report focusses particularly on experiences of workplace discrimination based on gender and suggests that women are frequently affected by poor pay, lack of career opportunities, and sexual harassment. 'Gender-based discrimination is still deeply rooted in our society—and it is on the rise again,' said Commissioner Ataman. The report also makes clear that acts of discrimination can take place anywhere, at any time. Twenty-two percent of cases reported involved everyday activities such as flat hunting, visiting restaurants, or shopping, for example. Advertisement In one instance, described by Commissioner Ataman, a Muslim woman in Nuremberg was turned away from a doctor's practice with the words, 'We don't want people like you here.' In another case, a Mahmoud Z. applied for an apartment under the name Stefan H. According to the report, Mahmoud had already been turned down for more than 20 apartments, often without even being invited to a viewing. Mahmoud conducted his 'test' on the advice of the Anti-Discrimination Agency, to see whether his name was a contributory factor in his lack of success. Sure enough, 'Stefan' was invited to view an apartment that 'Mahmoud' had been told was no longer available. If there is a silver-lining to be found, it's that the apparent year-on-year rise in discrimination complaints may reflect an increase in the number of people who are aware of their rights, and have the courage to try and enforce them. If you have experienced discrimination in Germany, the Federal Anti-Discrimination Agency provides free, confidential counselling in a variety of languages. READ ALSO: What to do if you experience racism in Germany
DW
5 days ago
- DW
Single in Indonesia: stigma and emancipation – DW – 05/31/2025
Whether single, looking for a partner or divorced – what happens when young Indonesians decide to look for love their way? In Indonesia, marriage is still the social norm. Those who don't conform, stand out and must often field many uncomfortable questions. Treading the fine line between familial pressure, religious duty and growing self-confidence, Indonesian singles are now seeking love in new ways. Whether divorced, separated or simply without a partner: what does it feel like to push back against society's expectations? And in this largely traditional country, how is it possible not just to find love, but also self-fulfilment?
Int'l Business Times
07-05-2025
- Int'l Business Times
Indonesia's Silvermen Beg To Make Ends Meet
On a rainy day in Indonesia's capital Jakarta, three men coated in metallic paint known as the "manusia silver", or silvermen, brave the elements at an intersection near a mall to ask drivers for change. It is an arresting act that comes with health risks, one some young Indonesians feel is necessary to make ends meet as the cost of living worsens and jobs dwindle after the Covid pandemic. "I'm ashamed to earn money like this. I want to find a real, more dignified job," said Ari Munandar, 25. "But the embarrassment disappears when you remember that your daughter and your wife are at home." Barefoot, dressed only in shorts and daubed head to toe by the irritating paint, Ari, his brother Keris and their friend Riyan Ahmad Fazriyansah each take a lane in the road. When the cars come to a stop they strike robotic poses in front of the drivers. "Good afternoon, have a nice drive," says Ari. The poses have little meaning other than to attract cash. "I do them because one day I saw a friend earn more by doing them," he said, moving between cars, holding out a bucket for donations. On a good day they can pocket up to 200,000 rupiah ($12), but typically earn around 120,000. That's much less than Jakarta's monthly minimum wage of five million rupiah and barely enough to cover daily expenses. "I'm not going to eat lunch, just drink and smoke," said Ari. Every penny counts in a country where prices have risen steadily in recent years. A kilogram (two pounds) of rice, the archipelago's main staple, jumped by 27 percent between 2015 and 2025, according to statistics agency data. And behind the paint, the friends are clearly undernourished. None are taller than 172 centimetres (five feet eight inches) nor weigh more than 55 kilograms. A lack of employment opportunity is the main cause of young men and women taking to the streets, they say. "Since I was made redundant in 2019 I've been begging," said Ari. "Before that, I worked cleaning toilets." According to government data, the number of people living below the poverty line in metropolitan Jakarta -- a megalopolis of 11 million people -- was up from 362,000 in 2019 to 449,000 as of September 2024. "Many young people with few qualifications between the ages of 20 and 40 have found themselves unemployed," said Bhima Yudistira, executive director of the Center of Economic and Law Studies. "Even though there is no national count, there has been a huge rise in begging in Jakarta after the pandemic of 2021." After five hours at the intersection, the group returns home by hitchhiking a ride from a tuk-tuk. The three pile into the back, counting their meagre earnings and lighting a cigarette to share. Once dropped off, they walk by a polluted river and across a railway line to their Jakarta slum. Far from the capital's high-rises, children play near the tracks to the rhythm of the trains as Ari makes his way back to remove the silver. The paint, similar to that used for screen-printing on fabric, is not easy to remove. Squatting in front of a well and buckets filled with water, he splashes his body before scrubbing fiercely, his one-year-old daughter Arisya watching. "At first the paint burned and I had a blister on my neck, but now it only stings my eyes," he said. The shower reveals a new, younger man. Once dry, he heads home to play with Arisya. "As soon as I'm here I forget all the fatigue and the hardship," he says, smiling. "But I hope she never does what I do."
