Members of British Jewish body suspended after criticising Israel to launch appeal
Thirty-six elected representatives to the UK's largest Jewish organisation are to appeal against disciplinary action taken against them after they criticised the Israeli government's operations in Gaza, and have said they remain 'deeply concerned' about the war.
The Board of Deputies of British Jews announced on Tuesday that five of the group would be suspended for two years and 31 would be reprimanded for breaching its code of conduct after a two-month investigation.
In a statement released on Thursday, the group said they would appeal after taking legal advice. They 'remain deeply concerned about the remaining hostages, the appalling humanitarian crisis and ongoing war in Gaza and the further deteriorating situation in the West Bank', they said.
The five deputies who gave media interviews about an open letter that was published by the FT in April had received 'the enhanced punishment of effective expulsion from the board' as they were suspended for the remainder of their terms of office, the statement said.
It was 'the biggest mass disciplinary action in the board's history, with over one in 10 elected board members disciplined', it added.
The open letter caused a furore among British Jews amid growing divisions over the war and distress at the suffering of Palestinians in Gaza. It said that 'Israel's soul [was] being ripped out' by military action that renewed in March, and that the signatories could no longer 'turn a blind eye or remain silent' on the issue.
Statements issued by the Board of Deputies since the war began in response to atrocities committed by Hamas on 7 October 2023 have been broadly supportive of the Israeli government's actions.
The board launched an investigation after receiving complaints from other members. It stressed that it welcomed a diversity of opinions, debate and free speech but that its code of conduct required deputies not to misrepresent the position of the board and not to bring the institution into disrepute.
The reprimanded group's statement said they stood 'in solidarity with the 70% of Israelis that consistently say they want an immediate end to the war in Gaza, which is the perceived price for the return of all the hostages'.
Since writing the open letter, a lack of food and aid had 'engineered conditions of scarcity, which has seen hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of Palestinians being killed week after week in the desperate scramble for survival that has been created'. There was 'no justification for the continuing misery and destruction being wrought on Gazan civilians'.
Sign up to First Edition
Our morning email breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters
after newsletter promotion
Harriett Goldenberg, one of those suspended, said: 'So many Jews in the UK agreed with our sadly groundbreaking letter. We were inundated with thanks from those who said we represented them, and that we were their voice. It is tragic that voice is still needed.'
Philip Goldenberg, another suspended deputy, said the board's executive was 'effectively expelling those who spoke inconvenient truth unto power. This is utterly contrary to the Jewish tradition that robust debate is an essential part of a civilised life, and feels more like Putin's Russia.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
13 minutes ago
- The Independent
Government's smoking ban ‘risks breaching post-Brexit deal'
A proposed UK smoking ban, supported by Keir Starmer, risks breaching the post-Brexit Windsor Framework, according to former Tory justice secretary Robert Buckland. The ban, which would make it illegal for anyone born after 2008 to buy tobacco, conflicts with EU law requiring tobacco to remain legal for adults over 18 in Northern Ireland under the Framework. Buckland warns that applying the ban to Northern Ireland would breach EU law, while excluding it would fracture the UK's internal market, leading to a breach of the signed treaty. He urges the Government to pause the Bill and either negotiate an exemption for Northern Ireland or remove it from the Bill's scope to avoid a legal and constitutional crisis. Despite these warnings, the Government believes the measures drafted in the Bill are consistent with its obligations under the Windsor Framework.
The Guardian
25 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Friday briefing: How years of siege, war and blockade led to the unravelling of Gaza's economy
Good morning. While much of the world's attention has been focused on Israel's conflict with Iran, the humanitarian catastrophe in Gaza has worsened by the day. Since March, when Israel broke a ceasefire agreement and imposed a total blockade, very little food or medicine has been allowed in. Though the blockade was partially lifted on 19 May, only a trickle of desperately needed aid has made it through – and yesterday Israel closed the most direct route. Israeli forces have killed hundreds of Palestinians who are trying to access it, in what aid workers are now calling a 'death trap'. Israel is fighting allegations of genocide in Gaza, where it has killed more than 55,000 people. Truly to understand the scale of the catastrophe in Gaza, it's necessary to place it in historical context. This isn't just a crisis born in 2023: it's the culmination of nearly two decades of siege. For today's newsletter, I spoke to British-Palestinian economist Zayne Abudaka, senior fellow at the Institute for Social and Economic Progress in Ramallah, about how Gaza's years of economic strangulation has shaped the current crisis. That's after the headlines. Middle East crisis | Iran's supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, has threatened to respond to any future US attack by striking American military bases in the Middle East. Welfare | Keir Starmer has offered Labour MPs 'massive concessions' on his controversial welfare bill in a move that has won over key rebels and is likely to have saved the prime minister from a damaging Commons defeat. The changes will reportedly cost the government several billion pounds over the next few years but will shore up the prime minister's precarious authority. UK weather | An amber heat health alert has been issued by the UK Health Security Agency for much of England because of predicted temperatures above 30C over the weekend. UK news | Two police officers who were involved in the strip-search of a black teenager at her school have been found to have committed gross misconduct. The search was 'disproportionate, inappropriate and unnecessary' and made the girl feel degraded and humiliated. Health | Scientists have developed a test to identify women with an increased risk of miscarriage, which could pave the way for new treatments to prevent pregnancy loss. The blockade of Gaza was imposed after Hamas took over in 2007 and Israel declared that it was now a 'hostile territory'. With the support of Egypt, Israel sealed Gaza by land, sea and air, devastating its economy, driving unemployment to record levels and leaving the population dependent on aid to survive. Though it may seem impossibly distant now, life before 2007 was very different, even though Israeli forces were still occupying Gaza. 'A lot of people talk about those times as better: there was more money, and a better economy,' Zayne Abudaka said. According to UN Trade and Development, real GDP per capita in Gaza dropped by more than 27% between 2006 and 2022. Here's how that happened – and how it shaped the current catastrophe. What was Gaza like before the blockade? Before the signing of the Oslo Accords in 1993, a Palestinian in Gaza could get in a car and drive to Haifa in Israel without checkpoints or permits. 'Obviously there were no civil rights, there was a lot of oppression, because you had an entire national identity without self-determination,' Abudaka said. 'But in terms of freedom of mobility, access to resources, and opening a business, it was pretty straightforward.' Before the formation of the Palestinian Authority (PA), the economy relied heavily on productive industries like farming, although farmers were, and still are, regularly harassed by Israelis, Abudaka said. Then the PA created a huge raft of public sector jobs. 'So all the people whose kids were going to become farmers, they started telling the children, 'why go through this headache? Why don't you work for the PA?'' The influx of aid, which increased rapidly until 2013, further empowered the PA to absorb workers from different sectors. 'The things that the Oslo accords had introduced, including the division of the different areas, lack of access to borders and to energy generation created a situation whereby the only jobs that were increasing were public sector and international NGO jobs,' Abduka said. 'And all the productive jobs like industry and agriculture started dying down.' He points to a stark statistic: in 1996, more than 20% of the Palestinian territories' GDP came from industry. Today, it hovers around 10%. When the second intifada erupted in 2000, the deaths of thousands of Palestinians and Israelis were accompanied by an intensifying Israeli occupation and the destruction of key infrastructure. 'We lost 30 to 40% of our GDP in a single year,' Abudaka said. 'Cities were under siege, curfews were imposed, you couldn't leave your house. It was a dramatic escalation in violence. People were left feeling desperate.' What has been the impact of the siege? After Israel imposed its blockade, trade and investment collapsed. 'Unfortunately the PA did not direct its finances to investing in the economic productive base,' Abudaka said. 'So you have a lack of investment, less jobs, and end up in a situation where two-thirds of young people are unemployed.' The siege imposed restrictions on a list of items that it was claimed that Hamas could use to make weapons and rockets – many of which were essentials for civilian life. It included wedding dresses, baby bottles and nappies, and water and sewage pumps. Agriculture also suffered from the territory's extreme density. Gaza spans just 360 sq km, and its population grew significantly before the war. As a result, traditional farmland quickly became overbuilt. 'In the north of Gaza, there was an area called Sheikh Ijlin, which was known for really good grapes. The area has 300,000 people living in one sq km. If you had walked in that area, you would have seen buildings and grapes side by side.' How did Gaza try to adapt? Gaza's local authorities set out new rules to manage the siege economy. 'You would go on the ministry website and see how many dunams, a unit of area, of every single plant they had. So they managed to say, 'We need this many tomatoes, so we'll do that',' Abudaka said. In some ways, Gaza's strangled economy had the potential to function better than the more prosperous West Bank's. 'The West Bank is not one continuous area,' Abudaka said. 'The PA controls these tiny islands that are surrounded by settlements. Although Gaza was seized, it was one area. So the people living there had control over their resources, which meant that they had services that worked. They had agriculture production despite everything.' But these adapted resources were battered by the wars that followed in 2008, 2012, 2014, 2021, and 2023. After each war came promises of reconstruction, but only a fraction of the aid money that was pledged ever materialised, Abudaka said. Israel wanted reassurances that aid that went in couldn't fund Hamas's military activity, Abudaka said. 'This led to the creation of the Gaza Reconstruction Mechanism, which is a security arrangement where Israeli security checks the goods that enter. It didn't stop Hamas from building tunnels. It did annihilate Gaza's economy.' What does the future hold for those living there? What is now unfolding in Gaza is a process of 'de-development,' Abudaka said. In 2006, about 63% of Palestinians in Gaza relied on aid. Today, almost all of Gaza's 2.3 million inhabitants depend on humanitarian assistance. A smaller, yet still damaging version of this is playing out in the occupied West Bank. Abudaka pointed to the banking system as one example. 'Because we don't have our own currency, we use four, including the Israeli shekel. But we can't deposit physical shekels with the Israeli central bank unless we prove where they came from. So Palestinian banks end up holding piles of cash they can't use. That limits lending, which hurts growth,' he said. Another issue is clearance revenues. 'Because we don't have a customs authority at the border, the Israeli authorities will collect that tax in our place. And then they'll send us the money back, but we have to show them receipts, which is often impossible because we don't control the borders. Then we go to the Israelis and say, 'You owe us 100m.' And they say, 'No … we're keeping the other 50m because you didn't provide all the receipts. On top of that, the Israelis take 3% as a fee.' Now far-right finance minister Bezalel Smotrich is trying to stop the money altogether. 'But this isn't the whole story … He wants the PA to be simply a military force that looks Palestinian, but is actually Israeli. A force that controls Palestinians, but doesn't provide them with services.' This crushing Israeli control over every facet of ordinary life, Abudaka said, is forcing young Palestinians to confront a difficult question. 'You do see a lot of Palestinian young people who are saying, listen, I love my country. I just don't have a future,' he says. 'We have really been steadfast, but this can't go on.' Kirsty Major kicks off a fascinating series on Europe's housing crisis and how it's stoking support for the far right – but, she reports, it doesn't have to be this way. (And do subscribe to our weekly email This Is Europe.) Craille Maguire Gillies, production editor, newsletters Ahead of the Women's Euro 2025 kicking off on Wednesday, the Guardian has compiled these interactive profiles of every one of the 368 women taking part, each written by local journalists from each nation. Charlie Lindlar, acting deputy editor, newsletters I loved this compilation of Guardian readers' favourite films of 2025 so far. I don't typically seek out a new Nic Cage film, but after one reader made a compelling case for The Surfer, I just might check it out. (Thanks Joe in Leeds!) Craille An interesting piece here from Nicole Carpenter on what happens when game developers are falsely accused of using generative AI in their work. 'It's completely unfair that so many people who have honed their craft for years are … being wrongfully accused,' says one. Charlie In her newsletter Culture Study, Anne Helen Petersen has an earnest obit for Mozilla's Pocket, which has joined other web-reading tools in the internet cemetery in the cloud. 'I miss the internet that wanted to be read, not scrolled.' Craille Sign up to First Edition Our morning email breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters after newsletter promotion Football | Manchester City won Group G of the Club World Cup with a dominant performance on Thursday, beating Juventus 5-2 at Camping World Stadium. Erling Haaland's goal in the second half marked the 300th of his career. Cricket | England have fast-tracked Jofra Archer into their squad to face India in the second Test at Edgbaston next week. The 30-year-old fast bowler returns to the Test setup for the first time since February 2021. Football | Cristiano Ronaldo has signed a new two-year deal at Al Nassr, extending his stay with the Saudi Pro League team to June 2027, when the forward will be 42. The Guardian leads with ''Massive concessions' on welfare bill win over key Labour rebels'. The Financial Times has 'Starmer yields to avert Labour 'civil war' over cuts to welfare'. The Daily Mail and the Telegraph both go with 'Starmer caves in to rebels on benefits', while the Times has 'PM pledges protections for disabled to rescue bill'. The Mirror says 'New hope on PIPs', while the Sun goes its own way, reporting 'Killer back stalking Cheryl'. Our critics' roundup of the best things to watch, read, play and listen to right now Music Lorde: Virgin | ★★★★☆ Lorde began her career speaking directly to her fellow teens about stuff that mattered to them – paving the way for Billie Eilish, Olivia Rodrigo et al in the process – and is now continuing to grow up alongside her fans. That's always a tough job, but one Lorde seems more than capable of thanks to writing that remains as skilful and incisive as it did when she was precociously skewering pop's obsession with unattainable lifestyles from an Auckland suburb in 2013. Virgin is powerful, moving, personal but universal – and packed with bangers. Alexis Petridis TVThe Bear | ★★★★☆ Recalibrate your palate: The Bear is not the show it used to be. More than ever, it's a show about family – the traumas they inflict on each other and the power they have to soothe them – and how families extend to friends and colleagues who can be just as beloved and just as maddening. Where once The Bear made pulses pound, now it lets the happy tears flow; the second half of the season is like one long therapy session. Jack Seale Film FI | ★★★★☆ Brad Pitt gets behind the wheel in this outrageously cheesy but extravagantly shot Formula One melodrama. Along with a lot of enjoyable hokum about the old guy mentoring the rookie hothead, F1 the Movie gives you the corporate sheen, real-life race footage with Brad as the star in an unreasonably priced car, the tech fetish of the cars themselves (almost making you forget how amazingly ugly they are), and the bizarre occult spectacle of motor racing. Peter Bradshaw Games Death Stranding 2 | ★★★★★ This latest offering from Hideo Kojima has the atmosphere and narrative delivery of arthouse cinema. It's light of touch in its storytelling but exhaustive in its gameplay systems, and the tension between the two makes it compelling. Of the many things the game is trying to say, the message that comes to the fore is: you are never truly alone. Global disasters, big tech, even death itself – these things might abstract the way we connect to one another, but they can't sever the connection altogether. Not bad for a game about delivering boxes. Phil Iwaniuk 'It'll push disabled people into poverty': Labour's controversial welfare bill Guardian columnist Frances Ryan on the reality of being disabled in the UK and the impact of the government's proposed cuts. A bit of good news to remind you that the world's not all bad Waymap, a new app-based navigation technology designed to assist blind, partially sighted, and disabled people, has been installed at Lord's cricket ground in London. Lord's is the first sports stadium in the world to use such a personal GPS system. England visually impaired cricketer Moshfique Ahmed was among the first to test the app at Lord's. Using his cane and following the app's voice directions, he was able to move independently around the ground. Although he encountered a few misdirections, these issues were attributed to the app still learning his walking style. Ahmed expressed hope that this technology could significantly improve accessibility for visually impaired sports fans, 'I know so many people who are into sports but don't go. This would push the door completely open for them.' Sign up here for a weekly roundup of The Upside, sent to you every Sunday And finally, the Guardian's puzzles are here to keep you entertained throughout the day. Until tomorrow. Quick crossword Cryptic crossword Wordiply
The Independent
35 minutes ago
- The Independent
Ukraine-Russia war latest: New prisoner swap agreed in Istanbul includes return of ‘heroes of Mariupol'
North Korea's deployment to Ukraine will be 'significant battlefield inflection' – ISW North Korea's deployment of its troops to Ukrainian territory will represent 'significant battlefield inflection', the Institute for the Study of War. 'The North Korean and Russian military commands authorising the deployment of North Korean forces to Ukrainian territory would mark a significant battlefield inflection that may improve Russian forces' ability to sustain simultaneous offensive operations in multiple directions, which the Russian military has traditionally struggled to conduct,' the US-based think tank said in its latest assessment. According to the South Korean intelligence, North Korea may deploy an unspecified number of additional North Korean forces to Russia to fight against Ukraine as early as July or August 2025 and that North Korea continues to arm Russia with artillery ammunition and missiles. Arpan Rai27 June 2025 06:33 Britain must 'actively prepare' for a war on home soil, major government review warns The UK must prepare for the possibility of a ' wartime scenario' on home soil, a major new government review has National Security Strategy, published on Tuesday, has issued the grim warning as events in the Middle East and Russia's war with Ukraine continue to add to international instability. It comes just 48 hours after Iran threatened to target UK bases following the US attack on its nuclear facilities, before a ceasefire was announced last night. The strategy also recommends that UK citizens undergo 'national resilience exercises' in preparation for attacks at home. UK must 'actively prepare' for a war on home soil, major government review warns The new National Security Strategy has been published with a grim warning as international turmoil in the Middle East and Ukraine continues Arpan Rai27 June 2025 06:29 EU leaders seek a big boost in Ukraine military support but make little progress on Russia sanctions European Union leaders called for even greater efforts to help meet Ukraine's pressing military needs, and expressed support for the country's quest to join their ranks. The talks, however, made little headway with new sanctions against Russia, slowing EU's key agenda for months now. At a summit in Brussels yesterday, the leaders said it was important to deliver more "air defense and anti-drone systems, and large-caliber ammunition, to help Ukraine, as it exercises its inherent right to self-defence, to protect its citizens and territory against Russia's intensified daily attacks." They also underlined the need to help support Ukraine's defence industry, which can make weapons and ammunition more quickly and cheaply than its European counterparts. Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelenskyy took part in the meeting via videolink. The leaders said the bloc "remains steadfast in its support for Ukraine's path towards EU membership." That message comes a day after Nato leaders refrained from putting a reference to Ukraine's hopes of joining the military organisation in their summit statement, due in large part to US resistance. Arpan Rai27 June 2025 05:58 Zelensky welcomes home fresh batch of Ukrainian prisoners of war Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelensky welcomed home a new batch of the country's soldiers taken captive by Russia as the two sides exchanged more prisoners of war yesterday. 'We are continuing the exchanges, another stage has taken place. Today, warriors of the Armed Forces, the National Guard, and the State Border Guard Service are returning home. Most of them had been in captivity since 2022,' he said in a post on X. 'We are doing everything possible to find each person, to verify the information on every name. We must bring all our people home,' he said, just days after he said Russia had sent some of its own dead soldiers to Ukraine in a swap of fallen soldiers. He also shared an emotional video of the Ukrainian soldiers reuniting with their loved ones upon return to the country at an undisclosed location. The returned soldiers are seen draped in Ukrainian flags, hugging and crying their loved ones, calling their family members, drinking a beverage and smoking. Arpan Rai27 June 2025 05:43 Chinese reporter injured in Ukrainian drone attack on Kursk, Russia says A Ukrainian drone attack on Russia's Kursk region on the border with Ukraine injured a war correspondent from the Chinese news outlet Phoenix TV, Russian authorities said late last night, "A Ukrainian drone today struck the village of Korenevo in the Korenevsky district," acting governor of the Kursk region, Alexander Khinshtein, said on Telegram. "A 63-year-old correspondent, Lu Yuguang, who went to the border area on his own, was injured." Mr Khinshtein said in a later post that the journalist had skin cuts to his head and after treatment, refused hospitalisation. Russia's foreign ministry called on the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights and other international organisations to "promptly respond and give a proper assessment" of the incident. "The targeted attack.... indicates the intention of the Kyiv regime to silence and de facto destroy representatives of any media that seek to convey objective information," Maria Zakharova, the foreign ministry's spokesperson, said in a Telegram post. According to Russia's state and official media outlets, Lu has been reporting on the war since its early days. Russia launched the war with a full-scale invasion on Ukraine in February 2022. Lu told Russia's state news agencies that he was feeling fine. "Western journalists are not visible at all (in Kursk)," Lu said in a video posted by TASS on social media, with his head in bandages, "We, Chinese journalists, want to convey what happened in the Kursk region." Russia has also urged for an intervention from the United Nations on the incident. Arpan Rai27 June 2025 05:32 North Korea could send troops to Russia for summer offensive, says South Korea North Korea may send more troops to Russia to fight against Ukraine this summer, South Korean lawmakers have claimed citing the country's intelligence agency. The National Intelligence Service (NIS) believes Russia may be readying to mount a large-scale assault against Ukraine in July or August, South Korean member of parliament Lee Seong-kweun told reporters. This assessment is based on new round-up of troops by the North Korean military, and the visit of a top Russian presidential security official. Pyongyang is likely to receive technical advice on satellite launches and missile guidance systems in return, the briefing said according to Mr Lee. Russia and North Korea have said their cooperation is based on a treaty signed by Vladimir Putin and North Korean supreme leader Kim Jong Un, which includes a mutual defence pact. Arpan Rai27 June 2025 05:07 Russia and Ukraine carry out new round of prisoner swaps Russia and Ukraine completed another round of prisoner exchanges, officials in both countries said yesterday, part of an agreement struck in Istanbul recently between the two sides. Both sides exchanged the same number of prisoners, but there was no word on how many soldiers were involved, Russian state RIA news agency said. Ukraine's coordination headquarters for the treatment of prisoners of war said majority of the prsioners had been captive and in Russian custody for more than three years. The swap included injured soldiers and those with health complaints. The youngest is 24 and the oldest is 62, it said, adding that more exchanges are expected soon. Many of them were taken prisoner in the Ukrainian city Mariupol, which fell to Russian forces after a lengthy siege in 2022. 27 June 2025 04:20 Kremlin says no progress towards next Russia-Ukraine peace talks The Kremlin has said there was no progress yet towards setting a date for the next round of peace talks with Ukraine, Interfax news agency reported yesterday. Kremlin spokesperson Dmitry Peskov said Russia was in favour of continued US mediation effort, another news agency, Tass, reported. Resuming negotiations after a gap of more than three years, Russia and Ukraine held face-to-face talks in Istanbul on 16 May and 2 June that led to a series of prisoner exchanges and the return of the bodies of dead soldiers. But they have made no progress towards a ceasefire which Ukraine, with Western backing, has been pressing for. Arpan Rai27 June 2025 04:05 Trump would join peace talks between Putin and Zelensky, says Erdogan Turkish president Recep Tayyip Erdogan has said that Donald Trump told him he would attend potential peace talks between the leaders of Ukraine and Russia in Turkey. But it all depends on if Russian president Vladimir Putin also agreed to take part, Mr Erdogan said. On his return flight from a Nato summit at The Hague, where he met Mr Trump for the first time since the latter returned to office, Mr Erdogan said he told the US president Ankara aims to bring the Russian and Ukrainian leaders together in Turkey for peace talks. "He (Trump) said, 'if Russian president Vladimir Putin comes to Istanbul or Ankara for a solution, then I will also come," Mr Erdogan told reporters, according to his office. "We will hold the necessary contacts and God willing realise this meeting as soon as possible." Arpan Rai27 June 2025 04:03 The myriad countries arming Russia and Ukraine – and the billions it costs Donald Trump has suggested that the US could send more Patriot missile systems to Ukraine, and has not ruled out providing the war-torn country with a new military support package. Speaking at the Nato summit in the Netherlands on Wednesday, the president said 'we'll see what happens' when asked whether Washington would add to the $8 billion pledged by Nato allies. "They do want to have the anti-missile missiles, OK, as they call them, the Patriots," the US president said. "And we're going to see if we can make some available. We need them, too. We're supplying them to Israel, and they're very effective, 100 per cent effective. Hard to believe how effective. They do want that more than any other thing.' Here, The Independent takes a look at what weapons the US and other countries have been sending to Ukraine and Russia as the war show no signs of ending soon. The myriad countries arming Russia and Ukraine – and the billions it costs Arpan Rai27 June 2025 03:59
