WA news LIVE: Man convicted over Cassius Turvey's death appeals sentence
Pinned post from 9.40am
Man convicted of Cassius Turvey's killing appeals sentence, says he should never have been found guilty
By
Mitchell Forth, one of the men who was convicted of being involved in the killing of Swan View schoolboy Cassius Turvey, will appeal his sentence.
Forth, 27, was acquitted of murder by a Supreme Court of WA jury in May, but found guilty of the lesser charge of manslaughter and sentenced to 12 years in prison over the 15-year-old's death in 2022.
He received a nine-year sentence for the manslaughter and a total of three years for other assaults and stealings that occurred in the days before.
Cassius was killed after being chased across a vacant reserve in the east Perth suburb of Middle Swan by local thugs Brodie Palmer and Jack Brearley.
It was Brearley, Chief Justice Peter Quinlan found, who delivered the fatal blows to Cassius' head with the metal handle of a shopping trolley.
Cassius died in hospital from those injuries 10 days later.
The trio, as well as Brearley's then-girlfriend Aleesha Gilmore, were charged with his murder but pleaded not guilty, and the matter was taken to a 12-week trial earlier this year.
Loading
Gilmore was eventually acquitted of any involvement in Cassius' death but found guilty of other offences in the days before.
Brearley and Palmer were sentenced to life in prison.
In documents lodged with the WA Court of Appeal this week, Forth's legal team have stated they will appeal against his conviction and his sentence.
'The verdict of guilty on which the conviction is based should be set aside because having regard to the evidence it is unreasonable or cannot be supported,' it read.
A second document stated that his sentence of nine years solely for the manslaughter charge was 'manifestly excessive given his personal circumstances and the circumstances of his offending'.
Throughout the trial, Forth maintained that he was not part of the group that chased Cassius and other indigenous teens across the reserve, but prosecutors said he could still be convicted of murder or manslaughter because he was with them at the time.
9.39am
Across Australia and around the world
Here's what is making headlines elsewhere today:
The federal government has lifted its longstanding de facto ban on US beef, addressing one of the key trade complaints that President Donald Trump used to justify his tariffs on Australia while starting a fight with the Nationals.
The Albanese government will march forward with its legislative agenda after introducing two key draft laws on Wednesday. Labor is hoping the passage of its bills will be expedited with support from the Coalition, which also appears receptive to its student debt reduction bill. In the first question time of the 48th parliament on Wednesday, the government and opposition exchanged blows on topics ranging from housing affordability to climate change policy and superannuation tax reform.
Former prime minister Scott Morrison has warned the United States Congress that Australians are at risk of 'going to sleep' on the security threat posed by China, and warned the US and its allies that they must be prepared to wear economic pain to stand up to Beijing. He later told reporters that Australians' level of awareness of the security threat posed by China had clearly diminished significantly over the past three years.
Countries besieged by the effects of climate change can legally pursue their neighbours for reparations if they fail to uphold their obligations to curb emissions, a top court has found. The historic advisory ruling was handed down by the International Court of Justice and paves the way for massive compensation claims in a case brought by a group of law students from Vanuatu.
9.38am
Today's weather
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Advertiser
11 hours ago
- The Advertiser
Wrongly convicted Folbigg 'failed again' by $2m offer
A $2 million compensation offer to a woman who spent two decades in prison after being wrongfully convicted of killing her children has been described as woefully inadequate and a slap in the face. Kathleen Folbigg was jailed over the deaths of her four children before being freed in June 2023 after new scientific evidence cast reasonable doubt over her convictions. NSW Attorney-General Michael Daley said he decided to make an ex gratia payment to the 58-year-old, more than a year after a compensation claim was submitted to the government. "The decision follows thorough and extensive consideration of the materials and issues raised in Ms Folbigg's application and provided by her legal representatives," Mr Daley said on Thursday. "The decision has been communicated to Ms Folbigg via her legal representatives." Ms Folbigg requested details of the payment, including the amount, were not publicly shared, government officials said. Ms Folbigg's solicitor Rhanee Rego said she had been offered $2 million. "The sum offered is a moral affront - woefully inadequate and ethically indefensible," Ms Rego said in a statement. "The system has failed Kathleen Folbigg once again." Greens MP Sue Higginson described the offer as "an absolute slap in the face". "And a failure of the NSW premier to uphold the principles of fairness and justice," Ms Higginson told reporters. "Kathleen Folbigg was imprisoned for 20 years, accused wrongly of the murder of her own children. "She has suffered. She has now been released. She is owed compensation that rights the wrong of this state." Nationals MP Wes Fang said the offer was made the same day upper house members pushed for an inquiry into the payment. "I believe this payment was only offered to her as a way of closing down this inquiry," he told reporters. Unlike court-run compensation claims with a series of precedents, ex gratia payments are one-off matters and are expected to be a decision of state cabinet. Ms Folbigg joins Lindy Chamberlain as rare Australians long jailed but later acquitted and offered compensation. Ms Chamberlain and her former husband Michael were awarded an ex gratia payment of $1.3 million in 1992 for their prosecution in the Northern Territory over the death of baby daughter Azaria. West Australian man Scott Austic in May received $1.3 million on top of an earlier payment of $250,000 after serving nearly 13 years for murdering his pregnant secret lover. He had sought $8.5 million after being acquitted in 2020 on appeal. Both payments were ex gratia, unlike David Eastman who was awarded $7 million in damages by the ACT Supreme Court in 2019. Ms Folbigg was convicted of three counts of murder and one count of manslaughter following the deaths of her children between 1989 and 1999. She appealed successfully against her convictions after scientific discoveries in genetics and cardiology cast doubt on her guilt following two inquiries into her verdicts. In 2024, Ms Rego told AAP the compensation claim included a lengthy statement explaining her 24-year experience with the matter, submissions detailing errors by agents of government and an expert report assessing loss suffered by the former prisoner. Ms Folbigg had previously sought a meeting with Premier Chris Minns, but he refused on the grounds she was in the middle of negotiations with the attorney-general. A $2 million compensation offer to a woman who spent two decades in prison after being wrongfully convicted of killing her children has been described as woefully inadequate and a slap in the face. Kathleen Folbigg was jailed over the deaths of her four children before being freed in June 2023 after new scientific evidence cast reasonable doubt over her convictions. NSW Attorney-General Michael Daley said he decided to make an ex gratia payment to the 58-year-old, more than a year after a compensation claim was submitted to the government. "The decision follows thorough and extensive consideration of the materials and issues raised in Ms Folbigg's application and provided by her legal representatives," Mr Daley said on Thursday. "The decision has been communicated to Ms Folbigg via her legal representatives." Ms Folbigg requested details of the payment, including the amount, were not publicly shared, government officials said. Ms Folbigg's solicitor Rhanee Rego said she had been offered $2 million. "The sum offered is a moral affront - woefully inadequate and ethically indefensible," Ms Rego said in a statement. "The system has failed Kathleen Folbigg once again." Greens MP Sue Higginson described the offer as "an absolute slap in the face". "And a failure of the NSW premier to uphold the principles of fairness and justice," Ms Higginson told reporters. "Kathleen Folbigg was imprisoned for 20 years, accused wrongly of the murder of her own children. "She has suffered. She has now been released. She is owed compensation that rights the wrong of this state." Nationals MP Wes Fang said the offer was made the same day upper house members pushed for an inquiry into the payment. "I believe this payment was only offered to her as a way of closing down this inquiry," he told reporters. Unlike court-run compensation claims with a series of precedents, ex gratia payments are one-off matters and are expected to be a decision of state cabinet. Ms Folbigg joins Lindy Chamberlain as rare Australians long jailed but later acquitted and offered compensation. Ms Chamberlain and her former husband Michael were awarded an ex gratia payment of $1.3 million in 1992 for their prosecution in the Northern Territory over the death of baby daughter Azaria. West Australian man Scott Austic in May received $1.3 million on top of an earlier payment of $250,000 after serving nearly 13 years for murdering his pregnant secret lover. He had sought $8.5 million after being acquitted in 2020 on appeal. Both payments were ex gratia, unlike David Eastman who was awarded $7 million in damages by the ACT Supreme Court in 2019. Ms Folbigg was convicted of three counts of murder and one count of manslaughter following the deaths of her children between 1989 and 1999. She appealed successfully against her convictions after scientific discoveries in genetics and cardiology cast doubt on her guilt following two inquiries into her verdicts. In 2024, Ms Rego told AAP the compensation claim included a lengthy statement explaining her 24-year experience with the matter, submissions detailing errors by agents of government and an expert report assessing loss suffered by the former prisoner. Ms Folbigg had previously sought a meeting with Premier Chris Minns, but he refused on the grounds she was in the middle of negotiations with the attorney-general. A $2 million compensation offer to a woman who spent two decades in prison after being wrongfully convicted of killing her children has been described as woefully inadequate and a slap in the face. Kathleen Folbigg was jailed over the deaths of her four children before being freed in June 2023 after new scientific evidence cast reasonable doubt over her convictions. NSW Attorney-General Michael Daley said he decided to make an ex gratia payment to the 58-year-old, more than a year after a compensation claim was submitted to the government. "The decision follows thorough and extensive consideration of the materials and issues raised in Ms Folbigg's application and provided by her legal representatives," Mr Daley said on Thursday. "The decision has been communicated to Ms Folbigg via her legal representatives." Ms Folbigg requested details of the payment, including the amount, were not publicly shared, government officials said. Ms Folbigg's solicitor Rhanee Rego said she had been offered $2 million. "The sum offered is a moral affront - woefully inadequate and ethically indefensible," Ms Rego said in a statement. "The system has failed Kathleen Folbigg once again." Greens MP Sue Higginson described the offer as "an absolute slap in the face". "And a failure of the NSW premier to uphold the principles of fairness and justice," Ms Higginson told reporters. "Kathleen Folbigg was imprisoned for 20 years, accused wrongly of the murder of her own children. "She has suffered. She has now been released. She is owed compensation that rights the wrong of this state." Nationals MP Wes Fang said the offer was made the same day upper house members pushed for an inquiry into the payment. "I believe this payment was only offered to her as a way of closing down this inquiry," he told reporters. Unlike court-run compensation claims with a series of precedents, ex gratia payments are one-off matters and are expected to be a decision of state cabinet. Ms Folbigg joins Lindy Chamberlain as rare Australians long jailed but later acquitted and offered compensation. Ms Chamberlain and her former husband Michael were awarded an ex gratia payment of $1.3 million in 1992 for their prosecution in the Northern Territory over the death of baby daughter Azaria. West Australian man Scott Austic in May received $1.3 million on top of an earlier payment of $250,000 after serving nearly 13 years for murdering his pregnant secret lover. He had sought $8.5 million after being acquitted in 2020 on appeal. Both payments were ex gratia, unlike David Eastman who was awarded $7 million in damages by the ACT Supreme Court in 2019. Ms Folbigg was convicted of three counts of murder and one count of manslaughter following the deaths of her children between 1989 and 1999. She appealed successfully against her convictions after scientific discoveries in genetics and cardiology cast doubt on her guilt following two inquiries into her verdicts. In 2024, Ms Rego told AAP the compensation claim included a lengthy statement explaining her 24-year experience with the matter, submissions detailing errors by agents of government and an expert report assessing loss suffered by the former prisoner. Ms Folbigg had previously sought a meeting with Premier Chris Minns, but he refused on the grounds she was in the middle of negotiations with the attorney-general. A $2 million compensation offer to a woman who spent two decades in prison after being wrongfully convicted of killing her children has been described as woefully inadequate and a slap in the face. Kathleen Folbigg was jailed over the deaths of her four children before being freed in June 2023 after new scientific evidence cast reasonable doubt over her convictions. NSW Attorney-General Michael Daley said he decided to make an ex gratia payment to the 58-year-old, more than a year after a compensation claim was submitted to the government. "The decision follows thorough and extensive consideration of the materials and issues raised in Ms Folbigg's application and provided by her legal representatives," Mr Daley said on Thursday. "The decision has been communicated to Ms Folbigg via her legal representatives." Ms Folbigg requested details of the payment, including the amount, were not publicly shared, government officials said. Ms Folbigg's solicitor Rhanee Rego said she had been offered $2 million. "The sum offered is a moral affront - woefully inadequate and ethically indefensible," Ms Rego said in a statement. "The system has failed Kathleen Folbigg once again." Greens MP Sue Higginson described the offer as "an absolute slap in the face". "And a failure of the NSW premier to uphold the principles of fairness and justice," Ms Higginson told reporters. "Kathleen Folbigg was imprisoned for 20 years, accused wrongly of the murder of her own children. "She has suffered. She has now been released. She is owed compensation that rights the wrong of this state." Nationals MP Wes Fang said the offer was made the same day upper house members pushed for an inquiry into the payment. "I believe this payment was only offered to her as a way of closing down this inquiry," he told reporters. Unlike court-run compensation claims with a series of precedents, ex gratia payments are one-off matters and are expected to be a decision of state cabinet. Ms Folbigg joins Lindy Chamberlain as rare Australians long jailed but later acquitted and offered compensation. Ms Chamberlain and her former husband Michael were awarded an ex gratia payment of $1.3 million in 1992 for their prosecution in the Northern Territory over the death of baby daughter Azaria. West Australian man Scott Austic in May received $1.3 million on top of an earlier payment of $250,000 after serving nearly 13 years for murdering his pregnant secret lover. He had sought $8.5 million after being acquitted in 2020 on appeal. Both payments were ex gratia, unlike David Eastman who was awarded $7 million in damages by the ACT Supreme Court in 2019. Ms Folbigg was convicted of three counts of murder and one count of manslaughter following the deaths of her children between 1989 and 1999. She appealed successfully against her convictions after scientific discoveries in genetics and cardiology cast doubt on her guilt following two inquiries into her verdicts. In 2024, Ms Rego told AAP the compensation claim included a lengthy statement explaining her 24-year experience with the matter, submissions detailing errors by agents of government and an expert report assessing loss suffered by the former prisoner. Ms Folbigg had previously sought a meeting with Premier Chris Minns, but he refused on the grounds she was in the middle of negotiations with the attorney-general.
Sky News AU
a day ago
- Sky News AU
Controversial Sheikh Dadoun spotted at Sydney Harbour Bridge protest
Sky News host Sharri Markson says Sheikh Dadoun was among those in the crowd during the pro-Palestine demonstrations on the Harbour Bridge over the weekend. NSW Police have launched a series of investigations into the Sydney Harbour Bridge protesters over death chants, waving terrorist flags, and displaying Hamas and Nazi symbols. 'That is the protest that Albanese and others have praised – it's just appalling,' Ms Markson said.
News.com.au
a day ago
- News.com.au
Employment Minister Amanda Rishworth urged to release ‘secret report' following unlawful JobSeeker cancellations
The Albanese government has been urged to release a 'secret report' into an automated system responsible for the cancellation of more than 900 Jobseeker payments. The Commonwealth watchdog found the Department of Employment and Workplace Relations (DEWR) and Services Australia unlawfully cancelled 946 Jobseeker payments between April 2022 and July 2024 through automated systems, leading to potentially 'catastrophic' consequences for vulnerable Australians. Additionally, it took DEWR secretary Natalie James 10 months between April 2022 to September 2023 to pause the automated cancellations after it was raised by external legal advisers. Following initial revelations in December, Deloitte was paid $439,142 to undertake an assurance review into the Targeted Compliance Framework, the system which cancels, suspends or reduces social security payments if jobseekers are found to not have undertaken their mutual obligations. While it was completed in June this year, the report has yet to be made public, despite attempts made by Greens senator Penny Allman-Payne to have the review released to the Senate. However Senator Allman-Payne's order to secure the documents by August 5 (Tuesday), were also delayed with the DEWR citing the need for 'additional time to consider the request'. Despite this details of the Deloitte Review shared by Commonwealth Ombudsman Iain Anderson on Wednesday gave a scathing assessment of the system, criticising the TCF as 'increasingly unstable,' and volatile. Mr Anderson said the review determined 'assurance could not be provided regarding the integrity, effectiveness, or appropriateness of decisions produced by the TCF IT system in its current form' and the 'current practices risk generating unlawful outcomes'. As a result, the 'latent design flaws' had resulted in 'confirmed adverse impacts on job seekers arising'. While it was completed in June this year, the report has yet to be made public, despite attempts made by Greens senator Penny Allman-Payne to have the review released to the Senate. In a letter to Senator Allman-Payne request, Employment Minister Amanda Rishworth said DEWR needed 'additional time' to 'consider the request'. Senator Allman-Payne criticised Ms Rishworth for withholding the report. 'This secret report has been sitting on Labor's desk for over a month, and with each day that passes, more welfare recipients lose access to payments that keep food on the table,' she told NewsWire. 'Labor are dragging their feet on this problem just as the Coalition did on robodebt. Apparently they've learned nothing.' The Greens spokeswoman for social services joined in calls made by welfare advocates to pause suspensions, in addition to cancellations and payment reductions amid investigations into the unlawful processes. 'We're calling on Minister Rishworth to release this report now, to stop the suspension of welfare payments today, and work towards the end of mutual obligations,' Senator Allman-Payne said. 'If Labor won't stop payment suspensions today, then people already living below the poverty line will go hungry tomorrow.' Australian Council of Social Service chief executive Cassandra Goldie has made repeated requests for the government to publicly publish the report, and reiterated her demands. 'Release the Deloitte Report. Release the legal advice that confirmed (the unlawful cancellations),' she said. 'Hundreds of thousands of people were brutally affected by the automation of the system, data matching, (and) the use of big technology by smart guys in suits 'I want to be very clear. What we're talking about is hell on earth that has been unleashed on people.' Asked whether the Deloitte Review should be publicly released, Mr Anderson said it was a 'matter for the Senate, the Minister and the department,' however he said he believed the details shared in his report were 'in the public interest'. 'While noting that the Deloitte review has not been publicly released, I formed the opinion that it was in the public interest to disclose in my report the matters I did about the Deloitte review,' he said. While Ms Rishworth did not directly respond to questions on when and if the Deloitte report would be published, she welcomed Mr Anderson's report and said she expected the recommendations to be 'implemented in a timely manner'. 'The report reinforces that when legislative changes are made, it is essential the processes and systems that agencies employ to deliver services reflect the legislation,' she said. 'The government understands the importance of ensuring government systems operate effectively, particularly when interacting with vulnerable people.'
