Corporal Manu Anthony Smith sentenced over intimate recording of woman without consent
Photo:
Pool / Stuff / Kai Schwoerer
A soldier has been sentenced to two months detention in a military jail for
making an intimate visual recording of a woman without her consent.
Corporal Manu Anthony Smith made the recording while having sex with his now-former girlfriend in 2020.
The sentencing followed a three-day court martial at Burnham Military Camp.
The 41-year-old has also been ordered to pay $2000 in compensation to the woman.
Smith will remain in the army, but will be on a formal written warning for the next year.
On Wednesday, a three-person military panel found Smith guilty of taking the images of the woman during sexual activity between August and December 2020.
Two other charges against Smith were
dropped on the second day of the hearing.
Before the verdict was reached, the woman who was filmed by Smith told the court martial she felt ashamed and embarrassed about the recording.
Smith's commanding officer told the court he was a diligent and enthusiastic soldier and had been decorated for his service in Afghanistan's Bamiyan province.
His sisters spoke of his mana and dedication to the armed forces.
During his summing up on Wednesday morning, Judge Gilbert said the case was one of law not of morals. He said the panel must not let beliefs about the way Smith or the complainants were living their lives colour deliberations.
In a court martial, all three members of a military panel must agree unanimously on a verdict. The panel deliberated for less than two hours before returning the guilty verdict.
Judge Gilbert said neither party disputed Smith made the video.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
33 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Toddler found in suitcase in bus luggage compartment, woman charged
File photo. Photo: RNZ / Angus Dreaver A young girl has been found in a suitcase in a bus luggage compartment, and a woman has been charged with ill-treatment of a child. Detective Inspector Simon Harrison said police were called at 12.50pm on Sunday, after a passenger asked for access to the luggage compartment during a planned stop in Kaiwaka. "The driver became concerned when he noticed the bag moving. When the driver opened the suitcase, they discovered the two-year-old girl," he said. Harrison said the little girl was reported to be "very hot", but otherwise unharmed. She has been taken to hospital in a "minor" condition for an extensive medical assessment. A 27-year-old woman was arrested and has been charged with ill-treatment/neglect of a child. She is due to appear in the North Shore District Court on Monday. "We would like to acknowledge and commend the bus driver, who noticed something wasn't right and took immediate action, preventing what could have been a far worse outcome," Harrison said. "Police enquiries into this incident are ongoing and further charges cannot be ruled out. Oranga Tamariki has also been notified." An Intercity spokesperson said the company was aware of an incident involving a passenger on one of its services earlier on Sunday. "Police were called to respond, and they are now investigating the matter. No one was harmed during the incident and the service has resumed. As this is now an active police investigation, we are unable to comment further." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
Prominent figure with name supression set to reappear in court
Photo: RNZ / Dan Cook A prominent New Zealander is set to reappear in court on Monday. RNZ earlier revealed a prominent New Zealander had been arrested . After being made aware of the man's arrest, RNZ approached the Wellington District Court to see if there were any suppression orders and when he would be appearing in court. In response, a registrar said the man faced eight charges, all of which are category three offences meaning the offence is punishable by imprisonment for life, or imprisonment for two years or more. However, an application had been granted prohibiting media from being able to report the man's name, identifying particulars as well as the nature of the charges he faced before his first appearance. The man appeared in the Wellington District Court via audio visual link on 3 July. Media opposed the suppression orders. However, the defendant's lawyers asked for the orders to continue on an interim basis until their next appearance. Judge David Laurenson agreed to continue the orders. The man was remanded on bail without plea until his next appearance on Monday. Under the Criminal Procedure Act a court may make an order forbidding publication of the name of a person who is charged with an offence if the court is satisfied publication would be likely to result in eight different outcomes including causing extreme hardship and creating a real risk of prejudice to a fair trial. The fact a defendant is well known does not, of itself, mean that publication of his or her name will result in extreme hardship. At first appearance a defendant only needs to advance an "arguable case" that one of the eight grounds applies. The only section in the Criminal Procedure Act that permits suppression of the charges is section 199C, which permits suppression of "trial-related information" where the court is satisfied publication of that information is likely to create a real risk of prejudice to a fair trial. Trial-related information includes "any other specific information in relation to any trial". Where an interim order is made under section 199C it only lasts until the defendant's next court appearance. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
10 hours ago
- RNZ News
Nine penguins found dead in Golden Bay over past fortnight
Nine penguin have been found dead in Golden Bay over the past fortnight or so. File picture. Photo: 123RF The Department of Conservation is warning dog owners to keep their pets under control, after nine little penguins were found dead in Golden Bay over a nearly two-week period. On Wednesday, three kororā were found dead on Pakawau Beach in Golden Bay and were believed to have been killed by a dog. The dead birds have been sent to Massey University for a necropsy and DNA testing, which would confirm if a dog was to blame. The bodies of six others were found on nearby Parapara beach over the 12 days prior, all of them killed by a dog. DOC acting Golden Bay operations manager Shane Butland reminded owners to keep dogs on leads during the day and contained at night, if there were penguins in the area. "Kororā are the world's smallest penguin, about 25cm long when fully grown. They have a conservation status of 'At Risk - Declining'. "Threats include dog attacks, predation from introduced predators and being hit by vehicles, and they are easily disturbed by people." Golden Bay ward councillor Celia Butler said the situation was not unprecedented. "There is a problem ongoing with penguins being killed by dogs, and part of the problem is that dogs are very, very attracted to the smell of penguins and they are nesting at the moment." Butler said, under council rules, dogs should be under control at all times, which meant they should not be able to roam at night. "This can be a particular threat to penguins. When people allow dogs to roam at night, they are breaking the bylaw, but it's very difficult to know whose dog it is." Kororā are fully protected by the Wildlife Act, and harming or killing them is illegal. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
