logo
After teal wave of 2022, there was no ‘sophomore surge'. Where to from here for the independents?

After teal wave of 2022, there was no ‘sophomore surge'. Where to from here for the independents?

The Guardian10-05-2025

As Climate 200 founder Simon Holmes à Court sees it, there are no safe seats or silver medals in politics.
The political fundraising body Climate 200 supported 35 community independents – commonly called teals though some shirk that tag – in this year's federal election. Nine have won, while votes are still being counted in other seats where teals are contenders.
In 2019, the independent Zali Steggall famously ousted Tony Abbott from Warringah, joining a crossbench featuring Helen Haines, Andrew Wilkie and Rebekha Sharkie. But it was in 2022 that the teal wave washed through parliament.
Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email
Many have posited that the teal appeal was, at least in part, a response to Scott Morrison's deep unpopularity and his Liberal government's 'women problem'. But Labor and the Greens are not immune.
The vote for independents has gone up from 5.3% in 2022 to more than 7% this year.
In Bean, the independent Jessie Price is a whisker ahead of Labor incumbent David Smith. In Bradfield, a similarly tiny difference puts Liberal candidate Gisele Kapterian just in front of Nicolette Boele. In Kooyong, MP Monique Ryan is battling to hold on against the Liberal candidate Amelia Hamer.
Zoe Daniel initially celebrated winning Goldstein, but Liberal candidate Tim Wilson – who lost it to the independent in 2022 – later claimed victory. The independent Kate Julett gave Labor MP Josh Wilson a fright in Fremantle.
The electoral analyst and blogger Ben Raue says typically there's a 'sophomore surge' with independents, where name recognition sees their vote go up at the second election. 'That largely hasn't happened,' he says, but adds 'they've done reasonably well'.
Thanks to the independents creating a three-way competition in some seats, vote counting is more complicated, he says.
'Even where they don't win they're keeping it interesting,' Raue says.
Raue says climate change was not on the agenda as much this year compared with 2022, which could explain the more subdued support for the teals, who campaign on climate action, gender equity and political integrity.
But he says overall the rise of the independents has been a 'transformation'. 'It used to be all about minor parties. There were a few independents in the parliament, but now it's much more of a wave.'
The polling analyst Kevin Bonham makes the same point about the lack of a sophomore surge, and says there is no 'startling pattern' in the results so far.
'The independent vote is up but that's because there were more of them running in more seats,' he says.
'Let's wait and see where they end up in terms of how many seats they win. I guess the worst possible result would be losing a couple, but it's not a greatly different result to what happened last time.'
Holmes à Court, the son of a billionaire, says the independents are 'here to stay'.
'The fact that so many of the independents kept their seats shows that the movement was not a blip,' he says.
'A record number of independents [have come] within striking distance of a win.
'There's no silver medal in politics, but if there were medals, at least 22 community-selected independents would be walking away with a gold or silver.'
There are other, non-teal independents, of course – such as Dai Le, who looks likely to stay on in Fowler. And there are others who managed respectable primary votes and could pose a future threat.
Sign up to Afternoon Update
Our Australian afternoon update breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters
after newsletter promotion
The onward march of the independents, though, could be hobbled by electoral funding laws that the two major parties joined together to pass in February.
At the time, the Centre for Public Integrity said the speedy passage of the laws – which went through without the scrutiny of a public inquiry – were an 'affront to our democratic process'.
The new rules will cap political donations and election campaign spending, increase transparency around donations and – from the 2028 election – increase the public funding per vote.
The move was pitched as a way to rein in 'big money' such as that deployed by the mining magnate Clive Palmer, who spends tens of millions of dollars on election campaigns. But crossbenchers described it as a 'stitch-up' that would advantage Labor and the Coalition over the independents and minor parties.
The $50,000 cap on the amount a donor can give to a party or individual can be sidestepped using multiple donations to the various sub-groups that the major parties have, and there's a carve out for peak bodies such as unions and business councils.
There's also a spending cap of $800,000 for each candidate, but the independents argue established parties have plentiful access to resources and staff which they don't. And a boost of about $3 to $5 for each vote for candidates who get at least 4% of first-preference votes will advantage incumbents, they say.
Holmes à Court describes the new laws as a 'financial gerrymander' on the income and the expenditure side.
'It will be tougher, because there's now one rule for independents and another rule for the parties,' he says.
But he adds that independent candidates aren't going to walk away, just because they got silver this time.
'We put out a [documentary] earlier this year called No Safe Seat. I think that's the theme of the election,' he says.
'In the 'class of 2022', all seven won formerly safe seats. The difference between losing a couple of seats and gaining a few is plus or minus 1000 votes in half a dozen seats.
'Politics is brutal.'

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Morning Mail: Aukus in doubt as Pentagon reviews pact; Beach Boy Brian Wilson dies, Australia fight back at Lord's
Morning Mail: Aukus in doubt as Pentagon reviews pact; Beach Boy Brian Wilson dies, Australia fight back at Lord's

The Guardian

time25 minutes ago

  • The Guardian

Morning Mail: Aukus in doubt as Pentagon reviews pact; Beach Boy Brian Wilson dies, Australia fight back at Lord's

Morning everyone. The Pentagon dropped a metaphorical bomb this morning, with the news it is launching a review of the Aukus pact, central to Australia's defence policy for the next 50 years, to check whether it is 'America first'. Meanwhile the mayor of Los Angeles has accused the Trump administration of provoking six days of unrest as part of an 'experiment', as other American cities prepare for protests. And the world is mourning the death of Brian Wilson, the creative force behind the Beach Boys. At home, Choice has exposed the shortcomings of some suncreen brands, and research shows we're listening to less homegrown music. Plus: Australia's men's cricket team fought back strongly at Lord's. Tuned out | The international success of acts such as the Kid Laroi and Amyl and the Sniffers (pictured) is not translating into more listens for homegrown talent, new research shows, with only 8% of the top 10,000 artists streamed in Australia in 2024 from these shores. AI push | Australia must 'lean in hard' to the benefits of artificial intelligence or else risk ending up 'on the end of somebody else's supply chain', according to the new industry and science minister, Tim Ayres. Methanol hope | Australian researchers have developed a prototype methanol 'breathalyser' capable of detecting small concentrations of the toxic substance in alcoholic drinks or on someone's breath. Zero sum | The financial cost to reach net zero by 2050 may shape the Coalition's decision on whether to retain or abandon the target, says the new shadow minister, Dan Tehan. Screen test | Some of Australia's most popular sunscreens, including some made by Bondi Sands, Banana Boat and the Cancer Council, are falling short of the level of skin protection on the bottle, a Choice investigation has found. Vale Brian Wilson | Brian Wilson, the Beach Boys musician, songwriter and producer who created some of the greatest pop music ever made, has died aged 82. Wilson was the creative force behind songs such as California Girls, Good Vibrations and God Only Knows. Aukus review | The Pentagon has launched a review of the Aukus submarine and defence agreement to make sure it is aligned with Trump's 'America first' agenda, throwing the $240bn defence pact with Britain and Australia into doubt. Trump 'experiment' | US immigration officials have increased 'enforcement activity' in California's agricultural heartland and the mayor of Los Angeles accused the White House of trying to test federal power as the conflict between the state and Donald Trump's administration intensifies. Follow developments live as other US cities brace for protests. Trump's show of force in LA was years in the making, experts have claimed, while the rightwing media has stepped behind the administration to attack the protesters as 'invaders'. China deal | Donald Trump has endorsed the US-China trade deal struck in London that will ramp up supplies of rare earth minerals and magnets needed for the automotive industry, saying it will take total tariffs on Beijing to 55%. Gaza tragedy | A Palestinian doctor whose husband and nine of her 10 children were killed by an Israeli strike has been evacuated from Gaza, bound for Italy with her only surviving child. The shocking death toll from inaction in prisons Ariel Bogle and Christopher Knaus speak to Reged Ahmad about why warnings about ligature points in prisons are still being ignored and what it will take to stop preventable deaths. Sorry your browser does not support audio - but you can download here and listen $ In today's Grogonomics column, Greg Jericho delivers an impassioned plea that Labor's attempts to change superannuation tax concessions should be just the start of a concerted effort to reduce wealth inequality. With his illuminating graphs, Jericho argues that wealthy people oppose the changes because they're worried the rest of us will realise the system is rigged. When he became involved in setting up an animal sanctuary in the Indonesian jungle, Warren Ellis was a bit concerned he might come across as a 'Bono-like, grandstanding' figure. But the legendary musician need not have worried as a new film about the project reveals his life from Ballarat to sanctuary in Sumatra. Sign up to Morning Mail Our Australian morning briefing breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters after newsletter promotion Cricket | Australia endured a topsy-turvy opening day of the World Test Championship at Lord's after they were skittled for 212 in two-and-a-half sessions before Mitchell Starc helped reduce the Proteas to 43-4 in reply. Football | The expansion of the World Cup means more teams from the Asian section in the US – and, as Australia's dramatic run shows, it has made for a more exciting qualifying competition. Plus, how Jordan qualified for the first time. Rugby union | The British & Irish Lions are confident the veteran tighthead prop Tadhg Furlong will be fit for their Australian tour despite some injury concerns. Investors, lawyers and governance experts say three major issues at Monash IVF require answers from management, the Age reports. A pizza maker in western Sydney can claim to be the best in the world after wining an international competition, the Telegraph reports. The city of Adelaide claims there is more parking than ever, but traders tell the Advertiser they think the council is waging a 'war on cars'. Business | Asic chair Joe Longo gives a speech and Q&A to the American Chamber of Commerce in Sydney at 12pm. Prisons | ABS figures on adult prisoners and community based corrections. Sydney | Speech on 'Trump and the West' at the Lowy Institute by John Hamre of the Centre for Strategic and International Studies. If you would like to receive this Morning Mail update to your email inbox every weekday, sign up here, or finish your day with our Afternoon Update newsletter. You can follow the latest in US politics by signing up for This Week in Trumpland. And finally, here are the Guardian's crosswords to keep you entertained throughout the day. Until tomorrow. Quick crossword Cryptic crossword If you have a story tip or technical issue viewing this newsletter, please reply to this email. If you are a Guardian supporter and need assistance with regards to contributions and/or digital subscriptions, please email

Major blow for Australia just days before Anthony Albanese meets Donald Trump
Major blow for Australia just days before Anthony Albanese meets Donald Trump

Daily Mail​

timean hour ago

  • Daily Mail​

Major blow for Australia just days before Anthony Albanese meets Donald Trump

The Trump administration has launched a review into the AUKUS security deal with Australia and the UK. The review, which was announced overnight on Thursday, will be led by vocal sceptic Elbridge Colby, Under Secretary of Defense for Policy who has called the pact 'crazy'. A defence official told The Daily Telegraph the Pentagon was looking at the deal to ensure 'this initiative of the previous Administration is aligned with the President's America First agenda'. 'As (Defence) Secretary (Pete) Hegseth has made clear, this means ensuring the highest readiness of our service members, that allies step up fully to do their part for collective defence, and that the defence industrial base is meeting our needs. It comes almost two weeks after it was revealed Hegseth urged Australian counterpart Richard Marles to increase military spending. Australia's total defence spend in 2024-25 was about $53.94billion, or 2 per cent of GDP. This is set to increase to 2.33 per cent by 2033-34 - but the US wants the number to be at least 3 per cent. Head of the US Seapower Subcommittee, Congressman Joe Courtney has spoken up to encourage his government not to abandon the pact. 'The new administration certainly has the right to review the trilateral AUKUS mission,' he said. 'But as the recent UK government's defence review determined, this is a defence alliance that is overwhelmingly in the best interest of all three AUKUS nations, as well as the Indo-Pacific region as a whole. 'To abandon AUKUS – which is already well underway – would cause lasting harm to our nation's standing with close allies and certainly be met with great rejoicing in Beijing.' Under the pact, Australia will spend up to $368billion eight nuclear-powered submarines and purchasing more from the United States. It marks the biggest defence investment in Australian history with the annual cost amounting to 0.15 per cent of GDP until the mid-2050s. Prime Minister Anthony Albanese will be attending the G7 Summit next week in Canada, during which he is expected to meet with Donald Trump.

Australia news live: productivity commissioner warns of job cuts coming from AI; aged care provider to close
Australia news live: productivity commissioner warns of job cuts coming from AI; aged care provider to close

The Guardian

timean hour ago

  • The Guardian

Australia news live: productivity commissioner warns of job cuts coming from AI; aged care provider to close

Update: Date: 2025-06-11T20:32:16.000Z Title: Welcome Content: Good morning and welcome to our live news blog. I'm Martin Farrer with the top overnight stories and then it will be Nick Visser to take you through the day. The new industry and science minister, Tim Ayres, warns today that Australia must 'lean in hard' to the benefits of artificial intelligence or else risk ending up 'on the end of somebody else's supply chain'. His comments follow an appearance by Australia's productivity commissioner on 7.30 last night in which she said AI could cost jobs. More coming up. We'll bring you news soon of a big aged care provider which is closing next month. And parties in Tasmania will be gearing up for another election campaign today after the state's governor said she had been left with no choice but to call a poll to resolve the Apple Isle's political crisis. We'll have the latest.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store