HS2 has suffered ‘significant cost' from legal challenges by public bodies
The Cabinet minister noted that in 'almost all cases', the courts have found in favour of the high-speed rail scheme between London and Birmingham.
HS2 Ltd was given the power to construct the railway when the High Speed Rail (London – West Midlands) Act received royal assent in February 2017.
The most recent of the nine legal challenges the project has faced from other public bodies since then was launched by North Warwickshire Borough Council in relation to the extension of the under-construction Bromford Tunnel.
In May, the High Court rejected the council's bid for a judicial review.
Since royal assent was obtained, there have also been 25 appeals relating to the HS2 planning regime.
In a six-monthly written update to Parliament on HS2, Ms Alexander acknowledged it is 'right there are checks and balances embedded in our legal and planning systems', but expressed concern these are being used to 'frustrate the delivery of consented projects'.
She wrote: 'The delivery of HS2 has continued during this period to be the subject of both legal and planning challenges, which have added significant cost, uncertainty and potential for delay.'
She added: 'The Government continues to monitor this issue closely and will consider further interventions where appropriate, alongside its wider work on planning reform.'
Ms Alexander also announced that she has lifted safeguarding on the majority of land protected for HS2's former Phase 2b eastern leg between Birmingham and Leeds, which was cancelled in November 2021.
Safeguarding is used to stop land from being developed in a way that would conflict with future schemes.
More than 550 properties were acquired by HS2 Ltd ahead of the planned construction of Phase 2b's eastern section.
Removing safeguarding means the process of selling them can begin.
Former owners of property within the safeguarding zone, which was acquired by HS2 Ltd will be given the opportunity to buy it back at the current market value.
HS2 has suffered repeated delays and soaring costs.
Ms Alexander announced last month there was 'no route' to meet the target date of having HS2 services running by 2033.
In her update to Parliament, the Secretary of State said her department is working with HS2 Ltd chief executive Mark Wild to 'reset' the project, with the aim of providing an 'updated delivery baseline and funding envelope in 2026'.
She went on: 'Until this work is completed, this Government is not in a position to say with confidence how much HS2 will cost or when it will be delivered.
'That is a deeply unsatisfactory position, but it is necessary to complete the hard work we have embarked upon.'
HS2 was originally planned to run between London and Birmingham, then on to Manchester and Leeds, but the project was severely curtailed by the Conservatives in power because of spiralling costs.
The first phase was initially scheduled to open by the end of 2026, but this was later pushed back to between 2029 and 2033.
In 2013, HS2 was estimated to cost £37.5 billion (at 2009 prices) for the entire planned network, including the now-scrapped extensions from Birmingham.
In June last year, HS2 Ltd assessed the cost for the line between London and Birmingham would be up to £66 billion.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South Wales Argus
7 minutes ago
- South Wales Argus
Archbishop Rowan Williams extension link to house sales
Funding for the extension of Archbishop Rowan Williams Church in Wales Primary School, which has been close to capacity for at least the past two years, is linked to money promised to Monmouthshire County Council by housing developers. The councillor in charge of education, Labour's Laura Wright, said a timeframe for when a planned classroom extension for the Portskewett school can be built is dependant on the housing developments. She said the council has invoiced the developers for 'some of' the money it is owed under a Section 106 legal agreement which governs payments for community benefits linked to planning permissions. It has requested the cash as Cllr Wright said the 'relevant number of houses have either been sold or occupied'. She said: 'However the amount isn't immediately sufficient to develop a classroom extension as envisioned as being needed. When the remaining funds are received from the developer it will be feasible to undertake the work. 'A timeframe for this is as yet undefined and will be dependent on how quickly the houses can be built and sold. This approach isn't unusual in the circumstances but I appreciate it is probably frustrating. We do remain committed to the development and extension of Archbishop Rowan Williams Church in Wales Primary.' Conservative councillor for Portskewett, Lisa Dymock, said all connected with the school were 'eagerly awaiting clarity on the promised funding especially given the pressures on space and rising pupil numbers.' Two years ago there was a row between the Conservatives and the ruling Labour group over a decision to allocate more than £400,000 paid to the council, from earlier housing developments, to a primary school in Caldicot rather than Archbishop Rowan Williams. At the time Cllr Dymock, and the Conservatives, claimed some of the cash should have gone to the Portskewett school which was just four places short of its 210 pupil capacity. But the council cabinet said the money wouldn't have covered the work required at the school but its expansion could be funded from an expected £1.1m due from the other local housing developments.
Metro
7 minutes ago
- Metro
I've heard enough words – I want Government action on Israel-Palestine
Every day when I turn on the TV or open social media, I am haunted by a new horrific tragedy from Gaza. We all want the suffering to stop, and the question is, what can the UK government do to go further and faster in ending this war? Last week, Israel hit Gaza's only Catholic church, killing three people sheltering there. A parish priest was also injured, among many others. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said his country 'deeply regrets' the 'stray ammunition'. Days prior, 10 Palestinians – including six children – were killed in an Israeli air strike at a water collection point. The Israeli military called it a 'technical error'. But when so-called mistakes equals the killing of innocent people, surely we need to stop Israel from making them. There have been so many reports of desperate Palestinians killed while seeking aid. In a period of almost seven weeks, the UN recorded earlier this month that 875 people were killed in Gaza while trying to access food. Are all of these 'mistakes' or 'errors' too? In my opinion, they are deliberate actions to demonise, starve, and kill citizens. When I watched a mother cradling her newborn, who had to have their leg amputated before they even took their first step, my heart broke. Where is our humanity? And when I watched an interview with an Israeli soldier talking about suicide and suffering from PTSD because of what he had done, we need to ask ourselves, what is being created by this war? I have consistently condemned Hamas and called for the release of the hostages, who have suffered so much from this horrifying ordeal. I also helped secure the release of a constituent's mum taken hostage by constantly lobbying the government to get her home. The Government has done everything with regards to saying the words. It has called the situation 'intolerable', called out Israel's actions, and called for a ceasefire. But words are not enough. It's now time to ask: Are we scared of doing something? I am urging my government to take meaningful action – to go further and faster. I want to see the immediate recognition of the State of Palestine. To have a two state solution, we need two states. On top of that, we need support for the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees (UNRWA), which provides aid and relief to refugees in the region but has been subject to defunding and political attacks. We must continue to demand the immediate and unconditional release of the hostages, whom Hamas continues to cruelly detain. I have also made two new demands. Amnesty International reports that over 4,000 Palestinians are being held in Israel without charge or trial, which they say violates international law – that must end. And finally, I am calling for an end to all arms sales to Israel. The Government suspended around 30 arms export licences to Israel, from a total of approximately 350. However, it has been reported that UK firms have exported thousands of military items, including munitions, to Israel despite those suspensions. There is also the ongoing concern of whether the UK has continued to sell F-35 parts indirectly to Israel as part of the global supply chain, in potential breach of the arms export suspensions. I was disappointed that the Foreign Secretary didn't confirm action on this in his statement yesterday, and I urge him to think again. Ultimately, we need an immediate ceasefire. I will continue to call for one and vote for one at every opportunity. That ceasefire must last and be fully respected by both sides. To ensure that happens, any violation must be condemned and be met with further sanctions – including a full boycott on goods from illegal settlements in the West Bank. Until then, it's time to act. If you knew that your neighbour was starving another group of people, would you still call them your friend? Would you still support them? We need to be honest about the situation. Because I feel like I am being gaslighted. Think back to March when Israel killed 15 emergency workers in Gaza. First, they claimed that troops opened fire because the convoy approached suspiciously. But then a video found on the mobile phone of one of those killed showed that the vehicle had their lights on and emergency signals flashing. The bodies of the 15 dead workers were then buried in sand to protect them from wild animals and the vehicles were moved and buried to clear the road, an official claimed. If it wasn't for the phone footage being discovered, the excuses would have kept coming. The ethnic cleansing of Gaza is happening before our eyes. I want peace and I know that is a hard thing to imagine right now. But I'm not alone. My constituents write to me every single day asking what we will do to stop that death and destruction. Frankly, I feel ashamed, embarrassed, and sad that my many actions and words cannot stop what's happening. More Trending The ICJ ruled last year that there was a plausible risk of genocide in Gaza, and in April, sought more information from Israel on the accusation. When you think about the many genocides that have taken place throughout history, I am sure there were some people in positions of power who could have said and done something — and regretted it for the rest of their lives. How will the history books reflect this moment in time? It's time for real action. And for the UK to fully play its role in the movement towards peace. Do you have a story you'd like to share? Get in touch by emailing Share your views in the comments below. MORE: Ozzy Osbourne predicted his epitaph would be about bats – this one isn't MORE: The Great British Sewing Bee is back – but I miss Kiell Smith-Bynoe MORE: Jess Carter proves there's no room for error as a Black player
Western Telegraph
10 minutes ago
- Western Telegraph
Record number of police officers sacked amid drop in force numbers
Latest Home Office data reveals 426 officers were dismissed or had their contracts terminated in the 12 months to March. This is up 17% year on year from the previous record of 365 and more than double the number fired at the start of the decade, when 164 officers were dismissed in 2019/20. The latest 12-month period also saw 4,806 officers voluntarily leaving policing: the second-highest number since records began in 2006 and down slightly from the peak of 5,151 in 2023/24. The figures come as ministers have sought to tighten rules on standards to improve confidence in policing, while they have also faced warnings from forces that funding falls short to keep its existing workforce. A total of 146,442 full-time equivalent (FTE) police officers were in post at the end of March 2025, down almost 1% from 147,745 at the same point last year, which was the highest in modern times. Last month, plans for an average 2.3% rise in police spending per year faced backlash from police leaders, who warned a projected £1.2 billion shortfall will continue to grow and leave forces facing further cuts. Acting national chairwoman of the Police Federation, Tiff Lynch, had said: 'We will lose 10,000 experienced officers a year to resignation by the end of this spending review period, driven out by poor pay and unacceptable working conditions.' Chairman of the National Police Chiefs' Council Gavin Stephens added that the amount 'falls far short' of what is needed to fund Government plans and to maintain the existing workforce. Ministers have committed to recruiting 13,000 more neighbourhood policing officers by 2029, with 3,000 extra recruits to be in post by April 2026. Reacting to the figures, the Conservatives said the falling police numbers were a 'devastating blow' to neighbourhoods dealing with rising crime and anti-social behaviour. The figures cover the last three months of the former Conservative government, and the first nine months of Labour in power. Shadow home secretary Chris Philp said: 'Labour has let down policing and has let down the public. 'We need police to catch criminals, respond to 999 calls, investigate crime and patrol our streets. 'Labour has massively increased our taxes, squandered the money, and now they're reducing police numbers. The public are less safe as a result of Labour's incompetence.' The Home Office has been contacted for comment.
