Federal judge alleges 'willful and bad faith refusal' to comply in Abrego Garcia deportation case
U.S. District Judge Paula Xinis – who was nominated to the bench by former President Barack Obama – accused the Trump administration of obstructing the legal process and refusing to provide information about the steps they have taken, if any, to free Abrego Garcia from Salvadorian custody and return him to the United States.
"For weeks, Defendants have sought refuge behind vague and unsubstantiated assertions of privilege, using them as a shield to obstruct discovery and evade compliance with this Court's orders," Xinis wrote in an eight-page order Tuesday. "Defendants have known, at least since last week, that this Court requires specific legal and factual showings to support any claim of privilege. Yet they have continued to rely on boilerplate assertions. That ends now."
4 More Dems Travel To El Salvador To Push For Abrego Garcia's Return To Us
"If Defendants want to preserve their privilege claims, they must support them with the required detail. Otherwise, they will lose the protections they failed to properly invoke," the judge added.
She gave the administration until 6 p.m. Wednesday to provide those details.
Read On The Fox News App
President Donald Trump on Tuesday posted a photo to TRUTH Social of himself in the Oval Office holding up a photo of the gang-affiliated tattoos etched on Abrego Garcia's knuckles.
"This is the man, Kilmar Abrego Garcia, that the Courts are trying to save from being deported?" Trump wrote. "He was supposed to be, according to the Judge and the Democrats, a wonderful father from Maryland, but then they noticed he had "MS-13" tattooed onto his knuckles (and lots of really bad stories about his past!). This is the gang that is, perhaps, the worst of them all. What is wrong with our Country?"
The Trump administration deported Abrego Garcia, 29, to El Salvador in what it described in court filings as an "administrative error," and has since said that it is up to El Salvador whether Abrego Garcia returns to the U.S.
Deported Illegal Alien And Suspected Ms-13 Gang Member Transferred From Notorious El Salvadoran Mega-prison
The U.S. Supreme Court ordered the Trump administration nearly two weeks ago to facilitate Abrego Garcia's return to the U.S., so that court proceedings could continue, rejecting the White House's claim that it couldn't retrieve him.
Trump administration officials have pushed back, arguing that it is up to El Salvador — though the president of El Salvador has also said he lacks the power to return Abrego Garcia. The administration has also argued that information about any steps it has taken or could take to return Abrego Garcia is protected by attorney-client privilege laws, state secret laws, general "government privilege" or other secrecy rules.
But Xinis said those claims, without any facts to back them up, reflected a "willful and bad faith refusal to comply with discovery obligations."
A three-judge panel on the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals scolded the administration last week, saying its claim that it can't do anything to free Abrego Garcia "should be shocking."
The Justice Department unveiled documents last week detailing domestic violence allegations that Abrego Garcia's wife, Jennifer Vasquez, included in a court filing in 2021. Vasquez alleged in the filing that Abrego Garcia beat her and that she had documentation of the bruises he left on her. Additionally, a 2022 Homeland Security Investigations report obtained by Fox News claims that Abrego Garcia was suspected of partaking in labor and human trafficking. The report said a Tennessee Highway Patrol trooper pulled Abrego Garcia over in 2022 after swerving. The patrol officer found eight other individuals in the car with Abrego Garcia, who had just begun driving three days prior.
The officer originally believed the incident qualified as a human trafficking case because no luggage was found in the car, but the officer ultimately only wrote up Abrego Garcia for driving with an expired license.
Fox News' Paul Steinhauser, Diana Stancy, David Spunt, Rachel Wolf, Greg Norman and the Associated Press contributed to this report. Original article source: Federal judge alleges 'willful and bad faith refusal' to comply in Abrego Garcia deportation case
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Wall Street Journal
11 minutes ago
- Wall Street Journal
Federal Reserve Governor Adriana Kugler to Resign
Federal Reserve Gov. Adriana Kugler plans to resign from her post Aug. 8, she wrote Friday in a letter to President Trump. Kugler's term as a governor was set to expire early next year. The vacant board seat opens a slot for Trump to nominate an eventual successor to Fed Chair Jerome Powell to join the Fed's board, should he choose an external candidate to succeed Powell. That person could then be nominated to succeed Powell as Fed chair after Powell's chair term expires in May.
The Hill
12 minutes ago
- The Hill
Putin blames frustration in peace talks on ‘inflated expectations'
Russia's President Vladimir Putin on Friday said peace talks with Ukraine have been stalled due to 'inflated expectations' as leaders continue to urge the Kremlin to shift course. 'All disappointments come from inflated expectations,' Putin told reporters on Friday, according to The New York Times. 'In order to solve the issue in a peaceful way, we need deep conversations, not in public, but in the silence of a negotiating process,' he added. One of the most vocal critics of Russia's repeated airstrikes has been President Trump, who promised to end the conflict in Ukraine within 24 hours if elected to the presidency. As his administration surpasses its six-month mark, negotiators have been unable to make headway as a past temporary ceasefire agreement fell through. After Trump issued a a 50-day timeline for Russia to agree to a peace deal in mid-July, he shrunk the deadline on Monday and said he wanted to see progress in 10 to 12 days. Trump is threatening to impose strict tariffs on the Kremlin and their trading partners, including India and China, if headway isn't made. 'I gave him to a lesser number, because I think I already know the answer what's going to happen,' Trump said on Monday while standing beside British Prime Minister Keir Starmer in Scotland. But Russia's leaders have brushed aside the president's ultimatum. 'Trump issued a theatrical ultimatum to the Kremlin. The world shuddered, expecting the consequences,' Dmitry Medvedev, deputy chair of the Security Council of the Russian Federation, wrote in a mid-July post on the social platform X. 'Belligerent Europe was disappointed. Russia didn't care,' added Medvedev, who also previously served as president and prime minister of Russia. In a Monday post on X, Medvedev continued the battle. 'Trump's playing the ultimatum game with Russia: 50 days or 10…' he wrote. 'He should remember 2 things: 1. Russia isn't Israel or even Iran. 2. Each new ultimatum is a threat and a step towards war,' Medvedev wrote. 'Not between Russia and Ukraine, but with his own country. Don't go down the Sleepy Joe road!' Trump hit back on Friday urging the leader to ' watch his words.' 'I don't care what India does with Russia. They can take their dead economies down together, for all I care. We have done very little business with India, their Tariffs are too high, among the highest in the World,' Trump wrote on Truth Social. 'Likewise, Russia and the USA do almost no business together. Let's keep it that way, and tell Medvedev, the failed former President of Russia, who thinks he's still President, to watch his words. He's entering very dangerous territory!' the president added.
The Hill
12 minutes ago
- The Hill
85 percent of parents worry about tariffs affecting back-to-school cost: Survey
Tariff concerns are affecting parents as they begin back-to-school shopping early to avoid the higher costs they believe are coming for school supplies, according to a Wednesday survey from U.S. News. Sixty percent of parents already began back-to-school shopping as 62 percent expect to pay more this year than last year, according to the survey. Eighty-five percent of parents said they were concerned about rising prices due to tariffs when thinking about back-to-school shopping. The survey found that 57 percent of Americans are cutting back on back-to-school shopping due to concerns of rising prices, with the top categories targeted for drawbacks including clothes and shoes, accessories and technology. Thirteen percent of parents expect to pay more than $500 per child in back-to-school costs this year, almost double the amount that felt the same in 2024. Concerns about how tariffs will affect prices come as President Trump aims to implemen t new tariffs on Aug. 7, which has caused markets to fall around the world. While the president has discussed frameworks for deals with some countries, others such as Canada face a 35 percent tariff. The president delayed a similar tariff on Mexico. 'The complexities of a Deal with Mexico are somewhat different than other Nations because of both the problems, and assets, of the Border,' Trump posted Thursday on Truth Social. 'We have agreed to extend, for a 90 Day period, the exact same Deal as we had for the last short period of time.'
