‘Eminent Jews' Review: Pushing the Boundaries
The title 'Eminent Jews' naturally evokes 'Eminent Victorians,' Lytton Strachey's takedown of Victorian culture through crushing biographical essays on Cardinal Manning, Florence Nightingale, Thomas Arnold and Charles George Gordon. Unlike the Strachey volume, David Denby's 'Eminent Jews' has been written not to crush but to celebrate Mel Brooks, Betty Friedan, Norman Mailer and Leonard Bernstein.
The celebration does not come off. Mr. Denby hopes his book will exhibit 'a composite picture of the ideology and practice of postwar Jewish cultural achievement.' Yet even though Mr. Denby is himself Jewish, his 'Eminent Jews' could as easily be read as promoting antisemitic stereotypes—the book's cover features the prominent, or as I think of them the chosen, noses of its four subjects—emphasizing as it does Jews who specialized in vulgarity (Mel Brooks), intractable leftism (Betty Friedan), relentless self-promotion (Norman Mailer) and flamboyant egotism (Leonard Bernstein). Not, any of this, likely to bring much pleasure in the offices of the Anti-Defamation League.
All four of Mr. Denby's subjects were ostjuden, or Eastern European Jews, and thus Ashkenazi. Eastern European Jews, who came to the U.S. in profusion in the last two decades of the 19th and the first two decades of the 20th centuries, were once viewed in contrast to the more determinedly assimilationist German Jews, whom the Eastern European Jews called yekkes—Yiddish for jackets—denoting the formality of the German Jews in never removing their suit jackets. A joke of the time asked, 'What is the difference between a yekke and a virgin? The answer: A yekke remains a yekke.'
Mr. Denby devotes roughly 80 pages to each of his four subjects. He begins with Mel Brooks, whose specialty was to go up to the line of bad taste—and cross it. For Mr. Denby, Mr. Brooks 'was a more complicated Jewish clown than the world was ready to acknowledge' and 'a significant figure in Jewish history.' At one point he compares Mr. Brooks to Franz Kafka. Informed of the comparison, one imagines Kafka, not a man given to mirth, would have enjoyed a hardy, falling-off-the-couch laugh.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
5 hours ago
- New York Post
Dave Portnoy target of antisemitic comment during Barstool Sports pizza review
Barstool Sports founder Dave Portnoy was on the receiving end of an antisemitic comment as he filmed a pizza review in Toronto. Portnoy, doing a review at Terrazza for his ever-famous 'One Bite' reviews that was posted Monday, was outside the shop with a box containing a pizza pie as someone off camera went by and yelled 'F–k the Jews' toward Portnoy. 'See, there we go, there we go,' Portnoy, who is Jewish, said after the person made the comment. Advertisement A few young fans of the Bartsool Sports head standing behind him then started to laugh, which led Portnoy to reprimand them. 'What are you guys f–king laughing about?' he said as he turned toward the fans, who then became quiet. 'Exactly. So here we go, one bite everybody knows the rules. We won't let that get … what is that Toronto hospitality there? Advertisement 'That's terrible, terrible ' said Bill the Greek, who was with Portnoy for the video in Canada. This incident comes about a month after a server at a Barstool Sports bar in Philadelphia allegedly carried out a sign during a bottle service that read 'f–k the Jews.' Dave Portnoy heard the comment during a pizza review in Toronto. One Bite Pizza Reviews/YouTube Two servers were fired and two Temple University students were suspended after the incident at Barstool Sansom. Advertisement 'We are saddened, embarrassed, and frustrated by the deplorable actions of a customer and misguided staff,' Barstool Samson Street said in a post after the incident. 'Who the f—k would do that sign in my f—king bar? You think I'm just gonna sit here? I'm gonna make it my f—king mission to put you in lights. My f—king mission,' Portnoy said in the immediate aftermath of the sign going viral. 'What I'm saying is, I'm getting the names, I'm trying to be a little responsible, I'm trying to keep it together, but I'm on it,' he said. 'But I'm on it. I'm f—king on it.' Portnoy chided the fans for laughing after the comments. One Bite Pizza Reviews/YouTube Advertisement Portnoy then offered two customers a trip to Auschwitz in Poland to better educate themselves, but he then took away the offer to at least one of the people, as Portnoy said the person denied responsibility for what happened after the Temple student allegedly posted the sign on social media. 'His trip to Poland has been revoked,' Portnoy said in a post on X. 'Whatever ramifications come his way he 100% earned.' 'I'm like trying to make this a teachable moment, throw a lifeline to a kid, and he's like, 'Well, I already got suspended from Temple' because you got a 'f–k the Jews' sign at a bar and posted it on social media,'' Portnoy added.
Eater
8 hours ago
- Eater
What to Eat and Drink for Pride 2025 in Seattle
Pride this year is a celebration and an act of political resistance against a resurgent anti-LGBTQ brand of right-wing politics. In Seattle, as usual, the largest event will be the official Seattle Pride Parade, which will bring more than a quarter-million people downtown to march on June 29. But the whole month of June will be filled with Pride events, like neighborhood Pride festivals, meetups, and even a 'Pride Pet Vaccine Clinic' where LGBTQ pet owners pay only what they can. Pride in Seattle is not particularly focused on food and drink, but anytime anyone is celebrating, they're likely eating and drinking, too. What follows is a list of food- and drink-focused Pride events in Seattle — either Pride-themed menu items, or Pride events taking place at restaurants and bars. If you want to celebrate Pride by eating at a LBGTQ-owned establishment, the Seattle Times has a good list. We'll update this article as we hear about new events or specials, so if you are reading this and know of something that should be on the list, please email us at seattle@ Pride brunches On any given weekend there are drag brunches all over Seattle — here's our guide to the best ones — but during Pride, a lot more pop up. On June 8, the Fairmount Olympic Hotel is hosting the 'Big O-lympic Drag Brunch and Show,' which runs from 10 a.m. to 1 p.m. and includes a 360-degree photo booth, a DJ, and performances from 'Seattle's top queens, hosted by a soon-to-be-announced icon.' A $90 ticket (plus tax) gets you food and a glass of sparkling wine; a portion of proceeds go to Seattle Pride. For more info and to book tickets go here. The day of the Pride Parade, June 29, there's an official drag brunch at the Hilton Motif, also downtown, which is fundraising for the Pride Impact Fund. The brunch starts at 10:30 a.m. and there's a host of events including a drag show, pop-up market, and a 'refreshment retreat' after the parade. Tickets are $87.21. Also on parade day, the gay-owned businesses El Suenito Brewing and Frelard Tamales — which share a space near the waterfront on the Ballard-Fremont border — are throwing their own drag brunch, featuring Drag Race star Geneva Karr. The event starts at noon and runs until 1:30 p.m.; tickets to this 18-plus event start at $30, with group and VIP packages also available. Other events On Friday, June 6, the Capitol Hill location of upscale ping-pong parlor chain SPIN is throwing a Pride event from 8 to 11 p.m. It'll feature 'Drag Pong Battles' pitting drag queens against 'SPIN pros' in 'high-energy paddle duels,' according to a press release. There will also be a photo booth, 'Sing-Along Pong,' complimentary rainbow Jell-O shots, and a special cocktail whose sales will benefit the Trevor Project. Tickets are $10. On June 14, the popular Ballard brewery Reuben's is hosting a no-cover 'Pridefest' that will feature rainbow flights of beer, a 'danceable DJ soundtrack,' and limited-edition merch. Sales of the Pride-themed Crikey IPA cans will benefit Seattle Pride. The Greater Seattle Business Association — a LGBTQ-allied chamber of commerce — is throwing a luncheon and pop-up market on Wednesday, June 18, from 10:30 a.m. to 1:30 p.m. (the meal starts at noon). This is much less raucous than the Pride brunches above; the featured guests are Washington State Supreme Court Justice Mary Yu and Washington State Senate Majority Leader Jamie Pedersen. Tickets are $65. Finally, local charcuterie maker Boards by Erica is hosting a charcuterie-making workshop at Capitol Hill brewery Outer Planet from 7 to 8:30 p.m. on June 27. Tickets are $60.54 and include the materials for your charcuterie boards, plus a flight of beers to accompany the cheese and meat. Sign up for our newsletter.
Yahoo
8 hours ago
- Yahoo
Luke's Lost The Force: Mark Hamill's Trump Attacks Turn Jedi Legacy Into Political Grudge
Actor Mark Hamill, best known for portraying Luke Skywalker in the Star Wars saga, ignited a social media firestorm this week after unleashing a string of politically charged comments targeting President Donald Trump. In an interview published by the Los Angeles Times, Hamill, 73, titled 'Mark Hamill starred in the ultimate battle of good and evil. Now he just wants to make America normal again,' the piece explored Hamill's evolving career, his personal struggles after the January 2025 Malibu wildfires, and his outspoken criticism of Trump during the former President's second term. Shared on X by the LA Times, the post quickly ignited a firestorm of backlash, with users excoriating Hamill as a 'whack job liberal' and implicitly mocking the outlet as a far-left mouthpiece. The interview veered from promoting his latest film to railing against Trump's second term in office, likening the President to a fictional Sith Lord and framing himself as part of 'the Resistance.' The remarks—delivered with signature sarcasm and wrapped in Star Wars metaphors—drew swift criticism from audiences across the political spectrum, with many accusing the veteran actor of using his platform to peddle partisan vitriol. Proof this guy is full of SITH. — Mark Hamill (@ 2025-05-04T19:44:09.954Z 'Proof this guy is full of SITH,' Hamill wrote on Bluesky, mocking an AI-generated image of Trump holding a red lightsaber, the iconic weapon of Star Wars villains. He has also referred to his political opponents as fascists and openly mocked Trump supporters online. While Hamill's fans praised his outspokenness, critics blasted the LA Times for platforming what they described as a divisive political tirade disguised as entertainment journalism. 'The has become nothing more than a far-left megaphone,' one commenter wrote. 'This isn't reporting. It's partisan propaganda dressed up in a puff piece.' Others questioned why a legacy media outlet would run a glowing feature that offered little scrutiny of Hamill's increasingly aggressive rhetoric. Hamill, who also described himself as a supporter of 'MANA — Make America Normal Again,' admitted he obsessively tracks his follower count and spends hours muting dissenting voices on social media. He acknowledged that his political commentary often overshadows his acting, saying, 'I didn't want to talk about politics — I know when I talk about it, that's the headline,' before launching into yet another attack on Trump. Critics say the actor's efforts to align himself with anti-Trump resistance movements reflect the broader trend of celebrity activism encroaching into political discourse without real-world accountability. 'You're an actor, not a policymaker,' one user replied to a viral clip of the LA Times interview. 'Stick to playing pretend.' Even some longtime Star Wars fans expressed disappointment, lamenting the politicization of a character originally meant to represent universal themes of good versus evil. Hamill's latest film, The Life of Chuck, is based on a Stephen King novella. The actor plays a small but emotional role as a dying grandfather. But for many, the off-screen theatrics have distracted from any on-screen nuance. 'Hollywood can't help itself,' another social media user posted. 'They'd rather alienate half the country than keep politics out of movies and interviews.' For many Americans, the episode is just another reminder that the line between fiction and politics has all but disappeared in today's media landscape.
