City of Tshwane clamps down on illegal land use
Ensuring compliance is 'crucial for maintaining the integrity of the city's development plans and ensuring sustainable growth'. Picture: Supplied
The Tshwane city council has approved the implementation of penalty rates on 713 property owners identified by the administration for illegal land use and failure to take remedial action.
This includes some illegal developments as well as individual properties spread all over the city that are being used for purposes in contravention of the current zoning.
These properties will now be recategorised for rates purposes as 'unpermitted use' and the owners compelled to pay penalty rates.
Ben Espach, director at Rates Watch, previously said the rates for a residential property valued at R1 million amount to R1 016 per month, before applying any rebates. If the same property is classified as non-permitted use, this would increase to R7 628 per month (based on 2023/24 tariffs).
ALSO READ: Tshwane to consider demolishing houses in illegal developments
Missing out on billions in property rates
Republican Conference of Tshwane councillor Lex Middelberg calculated that the cash-strapped metro is missing out on more than R3 billion in property rates by failing to impose penalty rates on around 20 identified illegal developments comprising almost 20 000 'erven'.
The current Tshwane administration has seemingly taken this to heart and has resolved to act.
Executive mayor Dr Nasipho Moya recently appointed a sub-committee to develop a response to the increasing illegal developments.
A report by the sub-committee that Moneyweb has seen, which is expected to serve before council later this month, acknowledges penalty rates as one option, but seems hesitant in this regard.
One of the other options it proposes is to demolish illegal structures, which may affect more than 10 000 houses.
Member of the mayoral committee for economic development and spatial planning Sarah Mabotsa has in the meantime taken action and obtained council approval for imposing penalty rates on 713 non-compliant property owners.
ALSO READ: Kleinfontein is not an illegal township, maintains CEO
Severe implications
'The non-permitted land use activities range from unauthorised commercial activities in residential zones, through to illegal construction and land encroachments,' says Mabotsa in a statement.
'The implications of these violations on the city and its residents are significant, as they can lead to loss of revenue, inability to access critical servitudes, offer unfair land use activity and commercial advantages to transgressors, increase the costs of policing for the city, and can have potential safety and legal liabilities.
'The suburbs where these illegal land use activities have been identified are literally an 'A to Z' – Arcadia to Zwavelpoort – of the City of Tshwane,' she adds.
The areas or farms include Alphenpark, Annlin, Arcadia, Ashlea Gardens, Atteridgeville, Bon Accord, Booysens, Brooklyn, Capital Park, De Onderstepoort, Derdepoort, Die Wilgers, Eersterust, Elandsfontein, Eldoraigne, Ga-Rankuwa, Garsfontein, Haakdoornboom, Hartebeesfontein, Hazelwood, Kameeldrift, Kleinfontein, Kudube, Laudium, Magalieskruin, Montana, Moreleta Park, Olievenhoutbosch, Onderstepoort, Pretoria Central, Pretoria North, Silverton, Sinoville, Soshanguve, Sunnyside, The Reeds, The Willows, Waterkloof, Witfontein and Zwavelpoort.
While several large illegal township developments are included in this list – for example those occurring on one or two large properties at Elandsfontein, Haakdoornboom, Kleinfontein, Kudube, and Onderstepoort – non-permitted land use activities have also been identified several individual smaller properties in Pretoria Central, Pretoria North, Sunnyside, Sinoville, Witfontein and Silverton.
Mabotsa says the 713 properties have a combined municipal value of R1.3 billion, with the average property value being R1.9 million.
She notes that the city's department of economic development and spatial planning receives numerous complaints related to contraventions of zoning, national building regulations and its outdoor advertising by-law.
ALSO READ: Opposition in Tshwane offers 'solution' for Kleinfontein rates problem
Proactive and reactive measures
'The recommendation to implement non-permitted land use rates is one mechanism we use to encourage landowners engaged in non-[compliant] land use activities to correct their actions,' says Mabotsa.
'To identify illegal land use activities, law enforcement officials in Tshwane utilise a combination of proactive and reactive measures.
'Proactive measures include regular inspections and patrolling, as well as satellite imagery to detect unauthorised activities. Reactive measures involve responding to complaints and reports from the public.'
Once an illegal activity is confirmed, contravention notices are served to the owners of the property to rectify the contraventions.
If the contraventions are not rectified, the matter may be referred to the courts for criminal prosecution.
ALSO READ: 'Obvious sore point'- EFF to march to exclusive Afrikaner township Kleinfontein
Land use contraventions, if not corrected, are referred to city's finance department to implement rates and taxes for non-permitted land use.
After the landowner has addressed the illegal activity, the economic development and spatial planning department informs the city's property valuation section so that the finance department can reverse or terminate the tariff for that owner, Mabotsa explains.
'Ensuring more compliant land use activities is crucial for maintaining the integrity of the City of Tshwane's development plans and ensuring sustainable growth,' she adds.
'By implementing the non-permitted land use policies, the city can better manage land use violations, protect its financial interests, and promote a more orderly and compliant, equitable development environment for all its residents.'
ALSO READ: WATCH: 'Apartheid and Kleinfontein can't be mentioned in the same sentence' says Afrikaner community after MK party visit
Preventing chaotic urban sprawl
The economic development and spatial planning department has indicated that the implementation of the non-permitted land use rates and taxes, in terms of the Municipal Property Rates Act and bylaws, is currently by far the most powerful and successful manner used to force the discontinuation of illegal land uses, according to Matsopa.
'Township establishment laws are designed to prevent chaotic urban sprawl and ensure that city infrastructure keeps pace with development.
'For example, when an estate is established legally, the developers contribute to the cost of expanding roads, water, sewage and electricity services. Those costs that are then passed on to property purchasers.'
When a development happens illegally, developer contributions could unfairly be expected to be paid for by all other ratepayers.
ALSO READ: Tshwane municipality issues warning to landlords illegally subdividing apartments
'Illegal developments can also place too much strain on available electricity or other services in an area,' says Mabotsa.
'Legal development processes also protect homeowners and residents. The processes ensure that homes are built on stable land and not in environmentally vulnerable areas.
'In some illegal estates, there has also been no formal subdivision of the land.
'This means that purchasers in illegal estates may not actually own the land that they live on,' she points out.
'From a broader sustainability perspective, allowing illegal developments to flourish risks destroying prime agricultural land or biodiversity hotspots, weakening both food security and ecological resilience.'
This article was republished from Moneyweb. Read the original here.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
4 hours ago
- IOL News
Durban Chamber of Commerce raises alarm over eThekwini Municipality's R1 billion in unspent infrastructure grants
The Durban Chamber of Commerce and Industry NPC has expressed deep concern about the unspent grants earmarked for infrastructure upgrades, amounting to over R1 billion. It stated that with eThekwini Municipality's ongoing service delivery challenges, this not only reflects poor governance within the municipality but also represents significant missed opportunities to create a more enabling environment for businesses to thrive. The Mercury recently reported that there have been concerns that close to a billion rand in grants have not been spent. While the mayor's office expressed general concerns about under-expenditure, it stated that it intends to spend 95% of the grants. The chamber said Durban's water and sanitation system is under severe strain, with much of its infrastructure, such as pipelines and treatment facilities, ageing and deteriorating. 'The growing water demand continues to place additional pressure on the system. Furthermore, poor management of the City's stormwater networks is increasing the City's vulnerability to flooding. These challenges have become a serious concern for businesses, many of which are experiencing operational downtime and have been forced to explore alternative options to sustain their operations,' said the chamber in a statement. It noted that despite these challenges and the urgent need to upgrade deteriorating infrastructure, the capital budget is on a declining trajectory. 'According to the Durban EDGE (2025), National Treasury guidelines indicate that 20% of the total budget should be allocated to capital infrastructure expenditure. However, in our current budget, only 9.95% has been allocated for capital expenditure, which is far below the recommended threshold. 'As organised business, we recognise that infrastructure plays a critical role in sustaining business confidence, fostering rapid economic growth, and investment in Durban,' it said. The statement outlined that the Durban Chamber of Commerce and Industry NPC believes efforts should be focused on: Improving the regulatory framework Regular maintenance, refurbishment, and replacement of critical infrastructure Increasing infrastructure investment through public-private partnerships Reducing non-revenue water 'The Durban Chamber of Commerce and Industry NPC, together with the private sector, is committed to working with the City to address the infrastructure challenges. We have submitted a proposal to the City to address these challenges through a PPP model but have not received any commitment to date,' it said. 'There needs to be accountability and transparency. Failing to spend allocated grants efficiently has the potential to lead to further deterioration of infrastructure, which will have far-reaching implications for our economy. Therefore, we urge eThekwini Municipality to review its bureaucratic systems, fast-track priority infrastructure projects urgently, and actively involve the business sector to ensure that available funding is utilised efficiently and effectively for the benefit of the City and businesses,' it concluded THE MERCURY
eNCA
2 days ago
- eNCA
Patricia de Lille reacts to alleged R100m SA Tourism tender scandal
JOHANNESBURG - The Tourism Department denies allegations of serious tender procurement irregularities. This relates to the hosting of flagship trade event Meeting Africa and Africa's Travel Indaba which happened early this year. The department allegedly awarded a R100 million rand tender to a company that failed to show proof of experience, and which provided false and misleading information in its bid. In a statement by the Department of Tourism it denied these allegations. The department said no tender worth R100 million was awarded. It further emphasised that the countries tourism is commissioned by two independent firms who conduct a probity and forensic review of all tender processes. "Their findings were received, reviewed and informed internal consequence management actions. I have been informed by the South African Tourism that the cost of both audits were less than R1 million."
IOL News
2 days ago
- IOL News
Is South Africa's solar energy growth hindered by outdated regulations?
According to GoSolr paper, regulations are hindering the growth of solar installations in the country. Image: Pexels South Africa's solar energy sector is growing steadily, but not nearly fast enough to keep up with demand or the worsening national energy crisis. This is according to a 14-page GoSolr Light Paper – June 2025, that highlighted findings on solar energy in the country. The paper reported that 137,000 homes in South Africa have already installed solar systems, with 1,000 new installations per month. But instead of being supported and encouraged, solar users are being penalised through high fixed fees, forced time-of-use tariffs, and inconsistent municipal regulations. 'We're still facing an energy crisis — Eskom can't produce all we need. Yet instead of encouraging solar, the system is actively placing hurdles in people's way,' the report warns. One of the key issues raised is the tariff structures imposed by certain municipalities. This is most notable in Johannesburg. While prepaid customers in Joburg pay a fixed monthly fee of R423, solar users on postpaid systems are being forced onto time-of-use billing with fixed fees as high as R1,615 per month, and no real ability to feed power back into the grid. Cape Town allows prepaid solar users to remain on simpler billing plans and offers a feed-in tariff of R1.16/kWh, plus an incentive of R0.29/kWh. The paper outlined how solar installation rules vary across municipalities. It noted that national requirements demand certified electricians and engineer sign-offs, but many municipalities go further, requiring extra application fees, tariff changes, and meter upgrades. 'The result is a complex, fragmented, and expensive process that deters many households and small businesses from going solar,' says GoSolr. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad Loading Even with Eskom waiving solar application fees until March 2026, the paper argues this must become permanent, and be backed by a single national policy framework to simplify compliance. South Africa's Energy Availability Factor (EAF) from Eskom remains low at 57.3%, far below the 70% target — raising fears of worsening load shedding during winter. Yet instead of scaling solar as a relief valve, the country is bogged down by policy gridlock. 'We are over-regulated and underperforming,' the paper states. 'It's time to stop faffing around with regulations and start doing.' GoSolr proposes five urgent actions: Free consumer tariff choice – no forced billing models. Review and reduce import tariffs for solar components. Implement a national solar framework that streamlines installation rules. Scrap excessive registration/compliance costs. Allow all producers — large and small — to feed energy into the grid. The findings were publicised after Eskom strongly rejected false claims circulating online about imminent stage 4 and stage 6 loadshedding from July 6 until July 20. The power utility stated the country's power system remains stable with loadshedding suspended since 10pm on 15 May 2025. "The Winter Outlook, published on 5 May 2025, covering the period ending 31 August 2025, remains valid. It indicates that loadshedding will not be necessary if unplanned outages stay below 13 000MW. If outages rise to 15 000MW, loadshedding would be limited to a maximum of 21 days out of 153 days and restricted to Stage 2. There are no planned outages of this scale. Misinformation causes unnecessary alarm. Stay informed—trust only official Eskom updates on our official platforms," the power utility said. IOL NEWS
