I was the last person to see man who suffered 'worst death imaginable' - this is why I couldn't save him
John Jones died after becoming trapped for more than 24 hours in the Nutty Putty Cave in Utah in 2009 after he and his friends decided to explore it.
The 26-year-old medical student, who considered himself a keen and experienced explorer, was described to have 'essentially crawled into his own grave' upon his death more than 15 years ago.
After setting out to explore the extremely tight 'Birth Canal' area of the cave, John, who stood at 6ft tall, took a wrong turn and mistakenly entered a tiny passageway head-first which measured just 10 inches by 18 inches and became stuck.
Trapped in the crevice and unable to turn or move backwards, the 26-year-old father endured '27 hours of claustrophobic hell' while his brother Josh could only watch on helplessly.
Cave explorer and YouTuber Brandon Kowallis was the last person to see John alive and despite his tireless efforts to save him, he explained how the rescue mission was impossible from the start.
Brandon has spoken about the doomed ordeal in a blog post, recalling the mission on November 25, 2009 at Nutty Putty.
By the time he joined, rescuers had already been working to save John for several hours, but he was 'quickly going downhill'.
Having been stuck upside down for several hours, the blood in his body that normally flowed to his feet had instead rushed to his head.
He was starting to have trouble breathing and his heart was beating twice as fast in order to counteract the gravity to push the continuous flow of blood out of his brain.
'He was in and out of consciousness and had started talking about seeing angels and demons around him', the cave explorer explained.
Brandon was asked to crawl down the impossibly tight shaft to check on John, along with fellow rescuer Debbie. What he found haunts him to this day.
Brandon could hear a gurgling breath - an indication that fluid was building up in John's lungs, and his legs were twitching violently.
'It looked very bleak. I wondered if it was even possible to get him beyond this point', Brandon said.
The rescuer studied the rigging that had been set up by other emergency workers and John's position, trying to find hope. But the reality was cruel.
'It looked like he could only be lifted another foot or two in his current position because of where the webbing was anchored around his knees. After a foot or two his feet would hit the ceiling. And then once he reached the ceiling, there was no way to tilt him to a horizontal position', Brandon explained.
'And then once he reached the ceiling, there was no way to tilt him to a horizontal position. He would have to do it himself, but he was now unconscious.
'And even if we could get him into a horizontal position, he would then have to maneuver the most difficult sections of the passage he was trapped in.
'If he were conscious and had his full strength there was a minute chance he could possibly do it. But even if that was the case it looked grim'.
The only remaining solution was to use a jackhammer to widen the narrow tunnel - a desperate, brutal option that could have left John with shattered bones.
'He would be cut up very badly and probably end up with several broken bones, but if nothing else would work, that seemed like the best option.'
Brandon spent hours chipping and hammering away at the rocks, but even that proved difficult.
'My estimate was anywhere from three to seven days to get back to where John was'.
During this time, a radio was brought down so that John's family could speak to him.
'I think it was his father, mother, and wife who spoke to him, telling him that they loved him and were praying for him and that his father had given him a blessing.
'His wife mentioned a feeling of peace, that everything would be OK. She talked to him about 5 to 10 minutes before I told her that we needed to get back to working at getting him out', Brandon said.
Rescuers had to think of their next step, but just before midnight struck, Brandon was asked to check John's vitals, and noticed how his body was close to the temperature of the rocky walls of the cave.
He reported his findings to a paramedic who was able to get down to John.
'John Edward Jones was pronounced dead at 11:52, I believe it was.'
John's death was put down as cardiac arrest and suffocation.
Although John's wife Emily insisted that her husband's body be recovered, it was soon decided that it was too dangerous to recover it.
To prevent a future accident the entrance to the passage was collapsed with controlled explosives and filled with concrete.
The entrance to the cave was turned into a makeshift memorial for the family with a plaque also installed in memory of John.
John left behind his wife Emily and their baby daughter Lizzie.
Emily was also expecting their second child at the time of the accident. A baby boy was born the following year who she named after his father.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
20 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Lake mysteriously vanishes and leaves confused kids playing in the dry sand
A popular lake in Minnesota has completely disappeared due to a maintenance mistake, leaving disappointed visitors to play in dry sand. Lake Alice has vanished from William O'Brien State Park and all that remains of the once sprawling body of water is a creek running through the empty lake bed and swarms of dead fish. The lake was completely drained due to 'a mechanical failure of the water control structure' that came after officials attempted to control increasing water levels. A malfunctioning valve led to a 'significant drawdown' of the water level on the lake, officials say. 'Due to heavy precipitation last month, water levels on Lake Alice were steadily increasing,' said a statement from officials. When water levels became 'high enough that water was flowing over the dike between the lake and the St Croix River', Minnesota Department of Natural Resources staff opened the water control structure's valve to release excess water from Lake Alice, but they couldn't close the valve. Park-goers say they've never seen anything like it. 'This is crazy. I've been camping here for years, and I've never ever seen it like this. It's kind of sad, actually,' Rose Wolfson, a Minnesotan, told KSTP. However this time around, the Wolfson's trip to Lake Alice was a flop - the confused children used their water toys to play in the dry sand and they certainly didn't get a chance to swim. 'They're [kids] having fun. They're disappointed they couldn't swim, but they're making the best of it,' Wolfson said. 'I'd like to see a lake again so that they could swim.' Another park visitor said, 'I feel badly for the fish population.' Lake Alice is known for great fishing, with various species that include bluegill, black crappie, largemouth bass, northern pike, walleye, yellow perch and bullhead. The lake usually spreads over 26 acres and is nine feet deep. Wayne Boerner, of Minnesota DNR, said the fish population will take a massive hit, but that other species will benefit from that. 'A bad day for one animal is a good day for another,' Boerner said. 'This morning you saw a few hawks going around. They are using this as basically somewhere to feed. You also have turtles down there. They're feeding on some of the dead fish.' 'They're [kids] having fun. They're disappointed they couldn't swim, but they're making the best of it,' a local said Lake Alice hasn't always existed. It was once just a stream, until the DNR installed a dike and water control system in 1961, turning it into a lake. 'We are seeing what is underneath Lake Alice right now from pre-1961,' Boerner said. 'We always want to do proactive measures for a lot of our infrastructure. In some cases, we don't have the money to do it certain times, or it gets delayed.' 'This was an accident through failed infrastructure,' he explained. The DNR said it could take at least a month to get the water back in Lake Alice. Luckily, the William O'Brien State Park sits on the St. Croix River, another great option for visitors looking for fishing, boating and paddling.
Daily Mail
5 hours ago
- Daily Mail
American reveals the British supermarket staples that would 'unsettle' people in the US
An American woman living in the UK has sparked fury among Brits on social media after she shared four products commonly found in supermarkets that would unsettle people back home in the States. Paige Wester, who moved from the US to Newcastle in 2024 with her British partner and their two young sons, regularly posts lighthearted videos about her UK culture shocks to her 56,000 followers on TikTok. But her latest post, filmed during a routine shop at Tesco Express, didn't go down quite so smoothly with British viewers. In the video, the mother-of-two walks through the aisles, highlighting a selection of British foods that would 'send Americans into a coma'. The content creator reached for a bottle of HP Sauce - a type of brown sauce - before launching a scathing attack on the condiment. She said: 'I need someone to tell me what brown sauce is and why doesn't it have a name. It's so bad that it's just named after a colour. This is definitely a staple in British households... but you know what? To each their own.' She moved on to the frozen aisle, where she was left scratching her head at the abundance of peas on display. Paige said: 'British people absolutely love their peas... but why on earth are there so many types? And the fact you go and mush them and say they're edible is a disgrace.' Next, the mother questioned why Brits were so fond of squash, and accused the nation of prioritising it over water, as she added: 'Americans might be fat, but someone tell me why British people won't drink water - they have to have juice.' Paige also took aim at the 'unsanitary' open baskets shoppers can pick pastries and loaves of fresh bread from, and admitted the idea of the baked goods being in 'direct contact with everyone's germs' leaves her 'repulsed.' Despite being left baffled by various offerings at the supermarket, she revealed she was blown away by the stark difference in trolleys in the US and UK. The mother hailed British trolleys as the 'best invention to come out of England,' due to their 360 degree rotating wheels, and urged American manufacturers to 'take notes.' Over 2500 viewers shared their thoughts in the comments - with many Brits left furious by Paige's takes on beloved UK staples. Regarding squash, one person wrote, 'Wait til you find out what you're meant to put in the juice,' while another said, 'It's not juice, it's squash. It's a staple. Could be worse, we could be drinking mountain dew and koolaid.' Another, defending HP sauce, said: 'I don't even like brown sauce but coming after that when your cheese comes out a squirty bottle is mad One person, who hails from the States, agreed: 'I'm an American and I love brown sauce. It's like A1 but better.' Over 2500 viewers shared their thoughts in the comments - with many Brits left furious by Paige's takes on beloved UK staples In terms of peas, one viewer defended: 'Peas are to us what guns are to you. We don't need em but having them is our constitutional right!' Another wrote: 'If you're amazed by the peas, wait until you see the different types of ham.' Regarding baked goods, one wrote: 'How is the bakery unsanitary? according to UK health and safety they are permitted to be out for up to 4 hours and they are not high risk as they don't have moisture or protein.' Finally, one viewer concluded: 'What would send me in a coma in the USA is all the additives and corn syrup added into the food and drink and how processed it is.'
Telegraph
12 hours ago
- Telegraph
The forgotten story of the world's deadliest plane crash
Tragedy generally hits hardest close to home, where the places and locations in question can trigger grief and trauma long after the initial event has slipped queasily into the past. Which might explain why the collective British memory does not easily recall the deadliest plane crash of all time: a catastrophe that took place more than 8,000 miles away, on the other side of the planet, but claimed 520 lives. It did so an exact 40 years ago today, on August 12 1985, on a wild mountainside, 60 miles north-west of Tokyo. The fate of Flight 123 is certainly not forgotten in Japan, where the scarring is still visible (there will be commemorations at the crash site today, as there are every year). True, its loss of life did not match the 583 victims of the Tenerife Air Disaster of March 27 1977, where two Boeing 747s collided on the runway on the largest of the Canary Islands. Nor does it equate to the unique circumstances of the two Boeing 767s flown into the twin towers of the World Trade Center on September 11 2001. But Flight 123 holds its own dark position in the annals of aviation – as the deadliest crash involving a single aircraft. A ticking time bomb Perhaps inevitably, with a fatality count of such awful weight, that aircraft was also a 747 – specifically a 747 SR-46, toiling away for Japan Airlines (JAL). 'SR' stands for 'short range', with the plane part of the boom in domestic flights in the Land of the Rising Sun that took hold in the early 1970s. Demand was so high that, in 1972, JAL placed an order with Boeing for a bespoke version of the 'Jumbo Jet' – one adapted for maximum passenger capacity, but with strengthened body structure and landing gear able to cope with the regular take-offs and landings (and considerable stress) inherent in short-haul flying. So it was that the 747 SR-46 emerged from Boeing's Seattle plant with space for 498 travellers; a figure that would rise to 550 after further modification. It made its first commercial flight, for JAL, on October 7 1973. JA8119 – to use its registration number – arrived in the JAL fleet in 1974, and promptly became a workhorse. By the time of its demise in 1985, it had chalked up 25,000 hours of flying, and 18,800 flights; the majority of them quick trips back and forth between Tokyo and Japan's other major cities. Flight 123 – a scheduled service from Haneda Airport in the capital to Itami Airport in Osaka, which should have taken one hour – was the fifth of six short hops it was due to make that day. However, the cause of the disaster was not rooted in that summer afternoon in the mid-1980s. It had been planted seven years earlier – and with a grim symmetry, on the same route. On June 2 1978, JA8119 was damaged by a heavy touch-down at Itami. The landing was so jarring that the 747's tail hit the runway (a 'tailstrike') – so forcefully that this caused cracking in the rear bulkhead, a vital component of any plane's pressurisation system. The breakage was repaired, swiftly but – it would transpire – insufficiently. JA8119 had 8,830 hours on its log at the time of the strike, and would fly on, without much further incident, for 16,170 more. Yet deep within its fuselage, a clock was ticking. The death toll from the crash was tragically inflated by unfortunate timing: August 12 1985 fell within Obon season – a celebration of ancestral spirits, effectively Japan's 'Day of the Dead', which moves around the calendar, but generally sees the Japanese travel home in great numbers to spend time with loved ones. So it was that JA8119 was full of families for its early-evening departure. The records indicate that, of the 524 passengers and crew on board, 502 were Japanese. They included one notable celebrity – the 43-year-old singer and actor, Kyu Sakamoto. 32 unthinkable minutes JA8119 took off from Haneda at 6.12pm, a little behind schedule. For the next 12 minutes, it proceeded as normal. But at 6.24pm, as the 747 SR-46 crossed the coastal waters of Sagami Bay, 50 miles south-west of Tokyo, the decade-old patch-up job on its rear bulkhead finally failed. The plane suffered an explosive decompression which brought down the ceiling at the back of the economy cabin, severed all four hydraulic lines and knocked out the vertical stabiliser. At a stroke, the jet was all but uncontrollable. At the opposite end of the aircraft, Captain Masami Takahama – a 49-year-old pilot of significant experience – remained calm. A distress call was put out; an emergency plan to turn Flight 123 around and return to Haneda was discussed. But it soon became clear that JA8119 was incapable of nuanced manoeuvre. Cockpit recordings suggest its crew was already beginning to suffer from hypoxia, a lack of oxygen in the decompressing jet leading to slow answers and an audible difficulty in comprehending instructions. In the 21 minutes which followed the explosion, JA8119 flew erratically, lurching and rolling, gaining and losing altitude – and, crucially, swerving north, so that it was back over land. Its final 11 minutes were a desperate struggle. By 6.45pm, the jet was descending rapidly, had plunged to 13,500ft (4,100m), and was veering towards high mountains. At 6.46pm, Takahama was heard to utter the weary words: 'This may be hopeless.' At 6.49pm, there was a brief stall, at 9,000ft (2,700m). And while this was corrected, seven minutes later, at 6.56pm, JA8119 clipped a ridge on 1,979m Mount Takamagahara in Japan's central Gunma Prefecture. The collision dislodged the end third of the right wing, and two of the four engines. Now conclusively disabled, the 747 flipped onto its back, struck a second ridge, and exploded. The impact was so violent that it registered on the seismometer at the Shin-Etsu Earthquake Observatory, 100 miles away. It is impossible to say how many people were still alive in the immediate aftermath of the crash, because the rescue mission was as poorly executed as the repair work that had led to the disaster. It was still daytime when JA8119 went into the mountain, but as the light faded, a Japanese military helicopter did a cursory scan of the site, and reported no obvious signs of life. With night imminent, and the terrain challenging, paramedics did not attempt to reach the wreckage until the following morning. Interviewed in her hospital bed, Yumi Ochiai, an off-duty flight attendant who was one of just four survivors – all female; all of whom had been sitting on the left hand side of the cabin, between rows 54 and 60 – remembered seeing lights and listening to the noise of rotor blades after waking up in the charred remains of the plane. She expected help to arrive, she said, but the only sounds she heard for the next few hours were the cries of the injured and dying. The fallout The government response was rather more clear-eyed. The official inquiry, which released its findings on June 19 1987, placed the blame on the inadequate repair in 1978. By that point, JAL president Yasumoto Takagi had already lost his job; he tendered his resignation on August 24 1985, less than a fortnight after the crash. Sadly, the catastrophe claimed two further victims as its aftershocks reverberated around Japan. Two JAL employees – maintenance manager Hiroo Tominaga, and engineer Susumu Tajima, who had inspected JA8119 after the tailstrike incident, and had declared it airworthy – took their own lives, buckling beneath the psychological burden of the disaster. Forty years on, the crash site is home to a memorial; two unadorned stone triangles, set against the slope. The relatives of the dead gather there every August 12, perhaps taking small consolation from Mount Takamagahara's place in Japanese folklore as a parallel to Greece's Mount Olympus; a heavenly home of the gods. There are more tangible echoes as well. Not least the Safety Promotion Center, a museum attached to Haneda Airport, which examines the causes of the disaster, and the lessons to be learnt from it. Among its artefacts are fragments of the plane, and farewell letters written by its passengers in the 32 unthinkable minutes when they were probably aware that they were going to die. JAL has recovered to be Japan's second biggest airline, but suffered an inevitable decline in the wake of Flight 123; passenger numbers fell by a third in the next year, as a wary public avoided the brand. Nonetheless, not everyone affected by the crash was put off flying. Captain Takahama's daughter Yoko became a flight attendant, working for JAL.
