This Photo Of "The Ultimate Tuna Melt" Has The Internet Seriously Divided, And It's Very Obvious Why
I will personally never forget (or forgive) Senator Mark Warner's atrocious take on one of my favorite sandwiches.
Warm tinned fish with mayo and melted cheese will probably always be a controversial sandwich choice, but a recent post by Cook's Illustrated just reopened the decades-long debate with what they deem to be "the ultimate tuna melt."
View this photo on Instagram
The recipe for "Diner-Style Sheet-Pan Tuna Melts" comes from America's Test Kitchen (the parent publication of Cook's Illustrated) and calls for an entire head of iceberg lettuce that's "cut into 1-inch-thick slabs" and divided amongst four sandwiches. Let's just say commenters were a little skeptical about this approach.
And, hey, I'll defend some crunchy iceberg on a sandwich or burger any day, but this? The roof of my mouth hurts just looking at it.
More importantly: WHERE IS THE TUNA?! Respectfully, this is a lettuce sandwich.
Some people are even calling it a "recession indicator."
Chef and cookbook author J. Kenji López-Alt even shared his own troll-y version of the now-infamous iceberg (tuna) melt with the caption, "How'd I do, @cooksillustrated?" But he did admit that the original sandwich "looks really good."
View this photo on Instagram
He's not the only one who thinks so. Chrissy Teigen also commented on the original post, saying that it "LOOKS BOMB." Okay, Chrissy.
But over on the r/FoodieSnark subreddit, people were convinced the sandwich was rage bait. "I'm an iceberg girlie but this is ridiculous and a textural nightmare," the OP wrote.
A few internet sleuths figured the recipe was likely inspired by Palace Diner, a small counter restaurant in Maine known for serving a thick slab of lettuce on their tuna melts, which receive rave reviews.
Commenters seemed to notice the similarity, too. One former Palace Diner employee pointed out the big differences, though: the original has both less lettuce and more tuna. A "gigantic ice cream scoop of tuna," to be exact.
Anywho, I sure won't be adding a 1-inch lettuce slab to my tuna melts anytime soon because, as one commenter points out, we've endured enough.
Would you try this sandwich? Let us know in the comments!
No shade to the "ultimate," but if a classic tuna melt is more your style, download the free Tasty app to save and cook our recipe (plus 7,500+ others!) — no subscription required.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Chicago Tribune
2 days ago
- Chicago Tribune
Hundreds attend Unplugged Festival in Lake Zurich sans phones; ‘Wouldn't it be great … to connect on a personal level?'
Despite ominous skies and a little rain, more than 400 people attended the fifth edition of the Unplugged Festival at Paulus Park in Lake Zurich on Sunday. The event continued to build upon its original theme of disconnecting from the cell phone and, instead, connecting with the community at large. The other purpose was live demonstrations and interactive displays from local businesses, along with outreach programs available in the area. Nearly 50 organizations were represented, as families were urged to bring a picnic lunch and explore new hobbies, make crafts or just relax. 'The festival was created by Alexis Alt in 2020, and she was only 11 years old at the time,' Lake Zurich Mayor Tom Poynton said. 'It was a response to people's reliance on technology during COVID. It's grown into a significant community event. 'She did a lot of the groundwork, and proves that you can make a success of your passion at any age,' he said. Alt is a former Miss Lake Zurich, and the teenager hit on the idea at a summer camp. 'I went to a device-free summer camp,' she said. 'It was liberating, and fun just to talk with people. Afterwards, I saw how many people were literally attached to their phones, and thought, 'Wouldn't it be great just for everyone to connect on a personal level?'' COVID derailed the first attempt to stage the event in 2019, and oddly, rain played a part by washing out the following year's event. The Foglia YMCA in Lake Zurich stepped in, and allowed the event to be held on its premises. It has been located at Paulus Park ever since. 'Yes, we helped stage the inaugural event, and have watched it grow over the years,' said Carrie Landmeier, Foglia's senior director of customer experience. 'It's great exposure for us in presenting what we have to offer. If it translates into memberships and people getting healthy, that's a great thing.' Alt, now 16, is dedicated to community service including groups like the SOUL Harbour Ranch Animal Therapy Program and the Lake Zurich Leos Club. She is also the current Miss Ela Township. She said setting up the festival always brings something new to her attention, as well as the community. 'Lake Zurich has a dance studio,' she said. 'I didn't even know the stuff was here. The big impacts are that businesses have free advertising and free trials. The other is people connect to the businesses, businesses connect to the community, and the community connects to others in the community.' Alt said that her parents helped out making legal arrangements such as insurance, permits and items only an adult has the authority to do. 'She has done a fantastic job, both this year and in past years, with this community-focused event,' said Marisa Boynton, the special events recreation supervisor for the village's parks office. 'We're excited to have such wonderful external partners like Unplugged Fest to choose our property to host their amazing event.' Jennifer Ashley, a visitor to the event, said, 'I wasn't even aware of a lot of these businesses being in town. I love crafts and painting, so this fuels my hobbies and interests. It was a metaphysical event with the little bit of rain, and no phones.'
Indianapolis Star
18-07-2025
- Indianapolis Star
Explore Indianapolis with the WNBA Allstars Hoop Pass
Intern Sam Habashy and Alt forms digital producer Madyson Crane explore the many Indianapolis locations on the WNBA Allstars Hoop Pass. Madyson Crane
Yahoo
16-06-2025
- Yahoo
How to Eat Like a Chef at T-Mobile Park? Try One of Everything — Especially the Teriyaki!
Eating at T-Mobile Park these days is as much Cracker Jack as it is Dungeness crab pizza. In this Q&A, Seattle chef and award-winning food writer J. Kenji López-Alt maps a game plan to bring local flavor to every inning, including with his very own Seattle-style teriyaki pop-up. BELLEVUE, Wash., June 16, 2025--(BUSINESS WIRE)--J. Kenji López-Alt is wearing a "I <3 Teriyaki" T-shirt underneath a Seattle Mariners jersey with his last name on the back. As the acclaimed chef and best-selling cookbook author takes the pitcher's mound at T-Mobile Park, two thoughts cross his mind. "My primary goal is not to embarrass myself in front of my kids," he says, jokingly. "And then my secondary goal is being completely okay with embarrassing myself in front of my kids. I figured there was a 50/50 chance that I'd get it somewhere near the plate." Turns out, he had nothing to worry about. The ball sailed right over, landing into the waiting glove of Mariners third base coach Kristopher Negrón. Cheers from the crowd naturally followed. Of course, there was also plenty of excitement for the heat López-Alt brought to the park that night as a culinary pro. The main point of the chef's MLB debut: his Teriyaki Night pop-up. As is often the case with López-Alt's endeavors, the event was a hit, with tickets selling out well ahead of time and the evening ending with many a satisfied baseball — and teriyaki — fan. To anyone familiar with his work, his stats and bona fides in the food world are packed. His popular books include The Food Lab, one of two to win a prestigious James Beard Foundation award. He's a regular in both print and video for the New York Times, and has some 809,000 Instagram followers and over 134,000 followers on TikTok. And, of course, he is the creator and host of Kenji's Cooking Show on YouTube, where he has nearly 1.7 million YouTube subscribers — and where he recently posted a video about his favorite foods at T-Mobile Park, serving as a walk-up to his Teriyaki Night event. Here he reveals his secret sauce (somewhat literally) for the perfect teriyaki plate, the real importance behind throwing the first pitch and eating anything and everything at T-Mobile Park. Your sold-out Teriyaki Night pop-up at T-Mobile Park was huge success. How does teriyaki fit into the world of Seattle baseball? I grew up in New York, and in New York, pizza is the big democratizer, the one that everybody eats and the one that everybody enjoys and the one that you can get. It's like every neighborhood has their local pizza spot and they're all a little different, but they're all New York pizzas. So when I moved to Seattle five years ago, I found that teriyaki is the Seattle equivalent. It's a dish that was created and is still mostly cooked by immigrants. It's inexpensive and filling. Every neighborhood has its own spot. And it is really unique to Seattle: Chicken teriyaki was invented here by a Japanese American immigrant in 1976, Toshi Kasahara, and it's since gone on to sort of take over the entire area. There are over a hundred teriyaki shops in and around the Seattle area. I've been following the Mariners since I moved here in 2020, and I love going to games. They reached out to me and asked if I'd be interested in talking to them about teriyaki, because, despite the wide range of food options available at T-Mobile Park, they'd never done teriyaki. It felt like it was time to add it to the menu. It's a hometown dish for the hometown team. What does your Major League twist on the local dish look like? Of course, rice and chicken teriyaki with sauce. People could get hot sauce if they wanted to make it spicy for themselves, but it's not spicy by default. And then a little salad of pickles, daikon and carrots, which is not the traditional accompaniment to teriyaki. Traditionally teriyaki in Seattle would come with either a cabbage salad or an iceberg salad that's served cold. But because we serve teriyaki hot and ready to go, it didn't make sense to include warm wilted iceberg. So we went with a pickled carrot and daikon salad instead. I think it goes really nicely with the teriyaki. It's tangy, a little bit sweet, crunchy. A nice contrast to the chicken. What's the strategy that you would recommend for people coming to see a Mariners game and wanting to try out some great local food? I mean, there are so many choices and a lot of them are really amazing. I have two little kids, and so usually when I go to a game, it's with a couple of other parents and all their kids, and we'll divide and conquer. We'll each take a little different section and pick up a few different things and then bring it all back to our seats, and then we'll all just share everything. You recently posted a video where you pretty much ate your way through T-Mobile Park. What are some foods that people can get at T-Mobile Park that you think really represent Seattle cuisine? T-Mobile Park offers a lot of foods that are just a mesh of various cultures and cuisines. It is, I think, actually quite a good cross section of the immigrant community in Seattle and the types of food that have developed here and have taken root here. There's a very big Japanese influence in Seattle cuisine, so curry katsu from Tamari Bar, the teriyaki, obviously. Moto Pizza has Detroit-style pizza, but it's got some very personal twists as far as the toppings and the presentation goes. You can't really get it anywhere else. And it's wonderful. People waited online for it for months when it was just a small shop, and now you can get it at the ballpark and it's just as good. I also would say getting garlic fries from Ivar's. I think most cities that have a garlic-growing region near them have their own version of garlic fries, but that feels like a real T-Mobile Park staple. I think it's amazing the quality of sushi and poke that you can get there from Sushi Nakagawa. I never would've imagined when I was a kid that one day I'd go to a baseball game and get really good sushi. Seattle has a very strong seafood culture, and so that's represented in the ballpark as well. It's not just peanuts and Cracker Jack and hot dogs. There's a lot of local representation. How was throwing the first pitch on Teriyaki Night? I thought about it sort of the way I think about cooking a meal, which is that not everything you cook is going to work out. But the important thing to remember is that when you're cooking for your friends and family, the food is only the consolation prize. The more important part is that you're showing this expression of hospitality and generosity, and you're getting your friends or your family around a table so that you can all hang out and enjoy each other's company. And so I thought about throwing out the first pitch the same way. It's like, who really cares if the ball goes over the plate or not? As long as everyone is there having a good time, then that's the more important part. What's next on your plate for teriyaki and the city of Seattle? I'm going to continue going around Seattle and trying all the teriyaki I can and sort of celebrating it as much as I can, as a way to get to know my new city. I think the best way to get to know a place is to eat its food. We have had thoughts of a long-term project, having a teriyaki festival of some kind or having made-to-order teriyaki at T-Mobile Park. Right now, the teriyaki that you get is from the hot and ready to go walk-off kiosks, but having it cooked to order so that you get a more true teriyaki experience top to bottom would be really nice. So that's something I'd be interested in helping them develop at the park. But for now I'm just thrilled to be part of this and to be part of the pride of my adopted hometown. I've been working on a teriyaki recipe for a long time and refining it now that I'm in Seattle and have a new perspective on specifically what Seattle teriyaki is. So I'm planning on releasing both a recipe and a video showing people how they can make Seattle style teriyaki at home sometime this summer. Finally, the Mariners have started off the season doing really well. What are your predictions, are we going to see a teriyaki pop-up in October? Hopefully we're going to go all the way! For more information on Magenta Status benefits at T-Mobile Park, including information about Post Malone's concert on June 26, visit Follow the T-Mobile Newsroom on X and Instagram to catch the latest company updates. About T-Mobile T-Mobile US, Inc. (NASDAQ: TMUS) is America's supercharged Un-carrier, delivering an advanced 4G LTE and transformative nationwide 5G network that will offer reliable connectivity for all. T-Mobile's customers benefit from its unmatched combination of value and quality, unwavering obsession with offering them the best possible service experience and undisputable drive for disruption that creates competition and innovation in wireless and beyond. Based in Bellevue, Wash., T-Mobile provides services through its subsidiaries and operates its flagship brands, T-Mobile, Metro by T-Mobile and Mint Mobile. For more information please visit: View source version on Contacts Media ContactT-Mobile US, Inc. Media RelationsMediaRelations@ Investor Relations ContactT-Mobile US, Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
