Concerns over government spending on outdated driving licence printing machine
Government continues to spend millions repairing and maintaining its only driving licence card printing machine.
Image: SUPPLIED
The Organisation Undoing Tax Abuse (Outa) said it is concerned at how the government continues to spend millions of Rands maintaining its only driving licence card printing machine and the costs to catch up with backlogs.
The organisation said this is concerning because the government has been talking obtaining about a new licence card machine for the past 10 years.
This was after Transport Minister, Barbara Creecy, revealed that the machine had been out of service for 38 days since April 1, resulting in a backlog of 733,000 licence cards.
Creecy disclosed this in response to a written parliamentary question from Rise Mzansi leader, Songezo Zibi.
Zibi asked how many times the machine had broken down in the past three financial years, including since the start of the 2025/26 financial year.
He also wanted to know how much had been spent on repairs during this period and how much overtime had been paid to employees due to lost printing time as a result of the breakdowns.
Creecy revealed that the machine was broken for 26 days in the 2022/23 financial year. In 2023/24 it was broken for 48 days. It was also broken for 17 days in 2024/25.
The department paid R9,267,862 for the repair and maintenance in 2022/23. It paid R1,651,772 in 2023/24, R544,747 in 2024/25, and R624,988 so far, totaling R12,089,370,64.
The department also had to fork out R4.4 million for overtime payments between the 2022/23 and 2024/25 financial years.
Creecy said it takes four people to operate the machine.
She said she has directed that a declaratory order be sought from a competent court on the tender to acquire a new machine, in order to ensure that no further irregular expenditure occurs.
In March, Creecy announced that she had instructed her department to lodge a High Court application for a declaratory order regarding the licence machine tender -awarded to Idemia and Security South Africa.
Her decision was influenced by the findings from the Auditor-General (AG) report, which identified instances of non-compliance with the required procurement procedures.
Outa's chief executive officer, Wayne Duvenage, said the organisation was also concerned by the length of time it takes for the department to get the court to nullify the contract - riddled with irregularities and potential corruption.
'Why does it take so long to get this process done?' he asked.
'Lots of money spent on maintaining and overtime costs to catch up with backlogs. This is very concerning. The government has been talking about a new driving licence card machine for about 10 years now, with multiple tenders awarded and cancelled for the past 5 years and still, we are nowhere near resolving this issue. Incompetence and political interference at its best,' Duvenage said.
Department of Transport spokesperson, Collen Msibi did not respond to a request for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
an hour ago
- The Citizen
Here's how much it cost to repair SA driver's licence card printing machine over three years
The machine was out of service for nearly 130 days. Over the past three and a half years, R12 million has been spent to repair and maintain South Africa's only driver's licence card printing machine, which has suffered frequent breakdowns. This information was disclosed by Transport Minister Barbara Creecy in a written parliamentary reply. Songezo Zibi, leader of Rise Mzansi, quizzed the minister regarding the 26-year-old machine, which had been out of operation for much of this year, resulting in a significant backlog of driver's licence cards. Zibi asked how many times the machine had broken down over the past three financial years, including the current 2025/2026 financial year, and the total cost of those repairs. He also sought details on how much overtime pay had been made to employees due to printing delays, as well as the number of staff required to operate the machine effectively. The machine, which produces around 300 000 cards per month, resumed production in early May. Driver's licence card printing machine repair costs In her response, Creecy revealed that the machine was non-operational for 26 working days during the 2022/2023 financial year, with repair and maintenance costs amounting to R9 267 862.33. In the 2023/2024 financial year, it was down for 48 days, incurring costs of R1 651 772.57. The following year, the machine was out of commission for 17 days, with R544 747.64 spent on repairs. The machine has been out of operation for 38 days in the current financial year, with R624 988.10 spent on repairs and maintenance. ALSO READ: The driver's licence machine is fixed, but another problem remains Over the entire period, the machine was offline for a total of 129 days, with total maintenance costs adding up to R12 089 370.57. Creecy also said overtime payments over the three years amounted to R4.4 million. The overtime breakdown was R1 435 376.79 in 2022/2023, R1 608 102.52 in 2023/2024, and R1 351 473.78 in 2024/2025. No overtime payments have been made so far in the current financial year. She added that four operators are needed to operate the printing machine effectively. As of 15 May, the backlog in driver's licence cards stood at 733 000. Red flags over new machine tender In response to a question about the acquisition of a new machine, Creecy said: 'The minister has directed that a declaratory order be sought from a competent court on the tender to acquire a new machine, in order to ensure that no further irregular expenditure occurs.' In March, Creecy instructed the Department of Transport to seek a High Court declaratory order regarding the tender. This decision followed findings by the Auditor-General that the procurement process for the R898 million contract awarded to the South African subsidiary of French multinational technology company, Idemia, in August 2024 was irregular. The bidding process began in April and concluded in May 2023. According to the Organisation Undoing Tax Abuse (Outa), the Driving Licence Card Account had budgeted just over R486 million for the new machine, while Idemia's bid was reportedly either R762 million or R898 million. Other companies that submitted bids included Ren-Form Corporate Print Media, Nec Xon Systems, Muehlbauer ID Services, and Gemalto Altron Fintech Southern Africa. NOW READ: Why has the questionable driving licence card tender not been overturned?
Eyewitness News
4 hours ago
- Eyewitness News
Consultants bungling municipal audits despite receiving over R1 billion: COGTA committee chair
JOHANNESBURG - Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs committee chairperson, Dr Zweli Mkhize, says consultants are bungling municipal audits despite being paid over R1 billion to ensure the books balance. Mkhize has also noted what he calls a deepening crisis in the local government sector, saying there's a lack of accountability and leadership. He made the remarks while addressing a governance cluster briefing in Parliament on Monday.. Mkhize says the latest audit outcomes show how the financial and governance crisis in the country's municipalities is deepening. He says this has profound consequences for service delivery and public trust. Mkhize says the audits also show that 59% of financial statements submitted for auditing contained material misstatements despite being prepared by private sector consultants. 'This, despite municipalities having spent over R1.4 billion on consultants to prepare these very statements. It is unacceptable that such exorbitant spending yields so little value.' Mkhize says what is even more 'troubling' is that many of these municipalities across the country already have permanent staff tasked with performing this work and have called for the wastage to end.
IOL News
5 hours ago
- IOL News
Reserve Bank probes Nthabeleng Likotsi over alleged false information in bank application
The South African Reserve Bank has launched an investigation into Nthabeleng Likotsi and her bank, YWBN Mutual Bank. Image: IOL / Independent Newspapers The South African Reserve Bank has launched an investigation into Nthabeleng Likotsi and her bank, YWBN Mutual Bank, over claims that she may have provided false or misleading information during the bank's application process. The move follows a major fallout with investment firm AFRIBIZ Financial Services, and could lead to serious legal consequences for Likotsi. At the centre of the controversy is a failed R9 million deal between AFRIBIZ and YWBN. AFRIBIZ says it paid this amount for a 26% stake in the mutual bank. But after the bank allegedly failed to meet key regulatory requirements, the promised shares were not issued. Instead of receiving their 26% shareholding, AFRIBIZ claims it was offered just 2% as part of a "full and final settlement" — an offer the company immediately rejected. 'They sold us shares. We paid. Now we want what we paid for,' said a source close to AFRIBIZ's legal team. 'Returning the money is not good enough. That was never part of the agreement.'The Reserve Bank is now reviewing whether Likotsi or anyone at YWBN knowingly gave misleading or untrue information as part of their application to register the bank. Under the Mutual Banks Act, it is a criminal offence to do so. Legal experts say the situation is serious. Advocate Mandla Tshabalala, a corporate law specialist, explained: 'When someone pays for shares and you offer a refund instead, it sends the message that either the shares don't exist, or you never intended to follow through.'AFRIBIZ has made it clear they are not backing down. They insist that the R9 million payment was labelled as 'non-refundable' and was meant to secure actual shares, not a promise or future negotiation.'This is not just about a disagreement,' said one banking insider. 'It raises questions about trust, transparency, and whether proper processes were followed from the beginning.' This is not the first time YWBN has faced trouble. In 2021, the Companies and Intellectual Property Commission Tribunal ruled that YWBN had failed to follow rules under the Co-operatives Act and ordered the return of funds to investors. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad loading For Likotsi, the situation is especially damaging. Just a few years ago, she made headlines as the first black woman to start a mutual bank in South Africa — a historic and inspiring achievement. But now, that legacy is under threat.'She started on the wrong foot,' said a senior banking executive. 'This was a chance to prove that new leadership could work in the sector. But instead, we're seeing delays and avoidance.' Likotsi, however, has defended her actions. She says YWBN made the offer to AFRIBIZ in good faith, trying to resolve issues that arose after regulatory compliance problems. She insists the door remains open for future collaboration. Still, critics argue the damage has already been done. The Reserve Bank's investigation could take time, but its outcome may have lasting effects not only on Likotsi's future but on the image of mutual banking in South Africa. With AFRIBIZ considering legal action and investor trust shaken, YWBN faces an uphill battle to restore credibility. As the inquiry continues and public scrutiny intensifies, what once seemed like a bold step forward for financial inclusion now hangs in the balance.
