
Patients would rather see a GP than pharmacists and nurses, study finds
The review of 33 existing studies, from the University of Southampton, also found patients often like to choose a specific doctor to maintain continuity of care.
Trust and confidence decreased when patients wanted to see a GP but were directed to a nurse or other health worker instead, it added.
The study noted people also wanted easier ways to book GP appointments, clearer phone options, shorter recorded messages, and simple online routes with quick responses.
It comes after the Government published its 10-year health plan which intends to massively increase use of the NHS App, as well as recruit more GPs.
An improved app will give patients more control over booking, moving and cancelling appointments, as well as quicker access to medics and other forms of care.
The new study, published in the British Journal of General Practice, suggested confidence and trust scores appeared to be lower when people wanted a face-to-face appointment and received a call instead.
The public also wanted clear details on the roles of different NHS workers, it found.
Lead author Helen Atherton, professor of primary care research, said: 'Patients want a deeper connection with their doctor's practice, better communication, and the choice to see the right professional in the best way for them.
'The NHS needs to better understand what people want so it can shape its services to work for patients.
'Ignoring these fundamental needs will only exacerbate the issues it currently faces.'
Writing in the journal, Prof Atherton and colleagues added: 'Patients wanted a nearby practice, with clean waiting rooms, easy appointment booking using simple systems and with short waiting times, and to be kept informed about the process.'
In particular, researchers found that, for medication reviews and long-term conditions, patients preferred seeing someone they were familiar with.
The research also suggested that, where a patient's condition was worsening, 69.5% of patients reported preferring to consult a GP than a pharmacist and 42.7% strongly agreed or agreed that they would prefer to consult with a GP rather than a pharmacist.
Professor Kamila Hawthorne, chair of the Royal College of GPs, said: 'It's really encouraging to see how much patients value the care, and continuity of care, their GP provides – there are some things that only a GP can do for their patients, but it's also important that patients don't feel somehow short-changed if they're offered an appointment with another member of our highly-skilled multi-disciplinary team.
'Not all patients need to see a GP. Procedures such as blood tests, routine management of non-complex long-term conditions, the monitoring of repeat prescriptions, or assessment of a painful joint, for example, can be carried out by some of the various other members of the team who now work in general practice, such as nursing staff, mental health professionals, clinical pharmacists and physiotherapists.
'This also alleviates workload on GPs, allowing us to spend time with those patients with complex health needs who really do need our expert medical attention.
'However, we know that even when working as part of multi-disciplinary teams, patients often struggle to access their GP when they need to – and we share their frustrations.
'This is due to decades of under-funding of general practice and poor workforce planning, which has meant patient need for our care has escalated in recent years, while GP numbers have sadly not risen in step.
'We need thousands more GPs, and the recently published 10-Year health plan commits to providing these.
'We're now looking ahead to the revised long-term workforce plan, due later this year, to see how the Government plans to recruit more GPs and keep more GPs in the profession for longer – but also address some of the nonsensical issues GPs are reporting that they can't find appropriate employment upon qualification.'
Henry Gregg, chief executive of the National Pharmacy Association, said: 'It's not surprising that people want to see a GP when they go to a GP surgery but all our research and experience shows that people are very happy to visit a pharmacy if they can access treatment or advice quickly without having to wait to see a GP.
'Pharmacists are highly trained medical professionals who offer first-class care for a range of ailments quickly and conveniently and will send patients to a GP or hospital if needs be.
'Increasingly people will be able to pop into a community pharmacy and see a highly qualitied pharmacist for things like screening, check-ups, HRT, weight management or ongoing care without lengthy waits, freeing their NHS colleagues in hospitals and GPs to do more and offering patients the choice and convenience we all want to see.'
Royal College of Nursing chief nursing officer, Lynn Woolsey, said: 'Nursing staff are an integral part of any general practice delivering a range of services to patients.
'They lead public health clinics, run screening and vaccination programmes, support patients in the management of chronic disease and can diagnose and prescribe.'

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Daily Mirror
Nick Knowles' new wife Katie undergoes major surgery for painful conditions
TV star Nick Knowles and Katie Dadzie tied-the-knot in a ceremony in Essex on 7 June - and now Katie has revealed she has undergone major surgery just weeks after their happy day Nick Knowles's wife, Katie Dadzie, has revealed she underwent a hysterectomy, just weeks after they tied the knot, as she confronted her personal health battles. Katie, 35, and TV star Nick, 62, married last month in an intimate ceremony in Essex after dating for four years. But just weeks later, Katie underwent major surgery after suffering with Polycystic Ovary Syndrome (PCOS), endometriosis and adenomyosis. The Boa Boa lingerie founder, who has two children from a previous relationship, has now shared details of her health journey, bringing attention to the conditions she battled. The NHS says PCOS is "a common condition that affects how a woman's ovaries work", while they describe endometriosis as a condition where "cells similar to those in the lining of the womb (uterus) grow in other parts of the body. It can have a big impact on your life, but there are treatments that can help". The NHS states adenomyosis is "a condition where the lining of the womb (uterus) starts growing into the muscle in the wall of the womb. There are treatments that can help with any symptoms." Taking to Instagram on Friday, Katie shared video clips showing herself in hospital, wearing a hospital gown, and laying in a hospital bed. The footage showed various bandages on her abdomen, where surgeon entered her body to remove her uterus. In a candid and personal statement alongside the video clips, Katie shared her story, writing: "I'm 35 and I've just had a hysterectomy." Giving more detail, she continued: "I've lived with pcos, endometriosis and adenomyosis since Moses wore short pants. "And no, it wasn't 'just a bad period.' It was constant hospital trips. Multiple laparoscopies. Bleeding through clothes. Vomiting from the pain. Being curled up in bed, missing out on life." Sharing more painful symptoms of her condition, she wrote: "It was extreme bloating that made me look pregnant. It was migraines, stabbing pains in my legs, butt and stomach. It was chronic fatigue. It was hiding in loos, crying over another ruined day. It was my daughters terrified of getting their periods in case they end up like mummy. Years of misdiagnosis & being fobbed off. Told to take painkillers. That it was 'normal.' It wasn't." Katie went on to explain the emotional toll her condition took on her, sharing: "I've cried on bathroom floors. I've bled through clothes in public. I've had 3 surgeries. I've tried every pill, every patch, every hormone tweak. I've been put on a medical menopause just to get through uni. And still… the pain came." She added: "Today I looked through my phone and realised I hardly have any photos of myself like this. Because I don't recognise the woman I am when I'm in pain. Because I don't want to remember the days where I was too sore, too tired, too bloated." Katie, who has two daughters from a previous relationship, then addressed the fact her decision to undergo surgery would mean she could not carry any more children, and explained: "I didn't want more children, my girls are everything. But that doesn't mean this is easy. Because the choice has been taken from me. And that grief is real. It feels like something in me has changed, apart form being sans uterus." Her searingly honest account continued: "Right now, I'm in lots of pain. Im bloated. I'm exhausted. I'm hot. I'm forgetful. I'm hot (see how that works on multiple levels). I feel raw and less like myself. Less like a woman, if I'm being really honest. View this post on Instagram A post shared by Katie Knowles (@katieaknowles) "But this was a decision I made to take my life back. To stop surviving and start living again, & have days that aren't defined by pain. This is hopefully the beginning of healing. The beginning of self-love, scars, stitches and all." She concluded by writing: "And please, if you've made it this far, I ask gently: This is something deeply personal. If you're tempted to leave a judgmental or flippant comment, I'm asking you to just scroll on. There is a real person behind this post." Katie's post was met with a wall of support - with many congratulating her for speaking up and sharing details of an important issue. EastEnders star Rita Simons was among those to comment on the post - and shared details of her own experience. The TV star wrote: "Been there, done it and got the scars! And it's hands down the best thing I ever did!!! If you need anything tell the hubby to give you my a journey but it's so good the other side of it." Katie has a nine-year-old daughter named Savannah, and a six-year-old girl called Alex. While DIY SOS presenter Nick has four children from three different relationships - sharing daughter Tuesday and eldest son Charlie with ex-wife, Gillian Knowles, son TJ with dancer Paula Beckett, and another son named Eddie.


STV News
an hour ago
- STV News
Nearly 2m waiting over four hours since A&E target last hit
Almost two million people have waited more than four hours in A&E since the last time the Scottish Government's target was hit, figures show. The Government aims for 95% of people each week to be seen and subsequently admitted, transferred or discharged within four hours in the country's emergency departments. But that figure has not been hit since the week of July 12 2020, in the early months of the Covid-19 pandemic, when the number of people going to hospital plummeted. According to analysis by the Scottish Lib Dems, since the target was last hit, 1,921,053 people waited four hours or more. Elsewhere, 237,623 people waited more than 12 hours during that period and 588,480 people waited longer than eight hours. First Minister John Swinney has pinpointed the NHS improvement as key for his Government, announcing this week an £85 million investment in Hospital at Home provision in an attempt to keep people out of hospitals and reduce delayed discharge, as well as placing frailty teams in A&E units to divert elderly patients to other services and free up emergency care. Lib Dem MP Wendy Chamberlain said: 'Under this SNP government, A&E has been mired in crisis for years. 'Staff are stuck working under pressure-cooker conditions and patients are stuck having to wait hours for vital care. 'We are now on our fourth different Health Secretary since this SNP government last met the A&E waiting time target. 'Jeane Freeman, Humza Yousaf and Michael Matheson have all come and gone without making a dent and it looks as if Neil Gray will go the same way.' She added: 'Alongside efforts to alleviate the pressure on A&E and ambulance staff, we need to invest in care services to get people out of hospital and free up space. 'That's why Scottish Liberal Democrats fought for more money for social care in the budget and back a new UK-wide minimum wage for care workers that is £2 higher.' Scottish Tory public health spokesman Brian Whittle said: 'Under the SNP, millions of patients have suffered because they can't meet their own targets. 'Real lives are being lost to delays that could and should have been avoided. 'Dedicated frontline staff are working tirelessly for their patients, but they're had the carpet pulled from under them by successive nationalist health secretaries. 'The SNP still don't have a credible plan to fix this crisis. This is a national scandal.' Scottish Labour's deputy leader Jackie Baillie said: 'These stark figures lay bare the human cost of SNP incompetence. 'Scots have lost their lives as a result of these dangerously long waits and many more have suffered in agony for hours on end. 'Year after year, an array of different SNP health secretaries and first ministers have all promised to fix the crisis in our NHS, but they have all failed. 'If the SNP was capable of fixing this mess it would have done it by now – our NHS needs a new direction and a new government with Scottish Labour.' The Scottish Government has been contacted for comment. Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country


Daily Mirror
2 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
'My dad went in for a simple op - and was still in hospital 46 days later'
Stanford 'Sonny' Francis was admitted for an emergency pacemaker - and was still in hospital 6 weeks later. This Windrush hero is one of 30,000 patients who stay 21 days over their discharge-ready-date every year - half a million beds the government plans to get back On May 12 this year, Stanford Francis' daughter Coleen saw her dad wasn't well. She contacted his GP who called in for a home visit and rang 999. It took seven and a half hours before an ambulance arrived for Stanford – known as Sonny – and then he was stuck in the ambulance for two hours outside A&E at Queen's Medical Centre, Nottingham. After the paramedic intervened, the 89-year-old was taken straight to resus, and was then admitted to Nottingham City Hospital's cardiac unit to have a lifesaving pacemaker fitted. "Dad was meant to be discharged the day after the procedure," Coleen says. "But he was in hospital for over five weeks because a care package couldn't be agreed. If I hadn't fought for him, he would still be in there now." Sonny, who has dementia and is partially sighted, only finally came home from hospital on June 26 – 46 days after being admitted, and 44 days after he was medically fit enough to leave hospital. Despite not having cancer, he spent almost four weeks of his stay in a cancer ward. A proud member of the Windrush generation who helped build this country, Coleen says his prolonged stay led to his condition deteriorating. "His dementia has got worse since being at hospital," she says. "He now often thinks he is living back in Jamaica." In the hospital, Sonny thought he was at home and became frightened there were strangers in his house, waving his stick at the nurses. His family say on one occasion a security guard was used to get him back to bed. "He then got moved onto a cancer ward because they needed the bed on the ward," Coleen says. "One night he got so fed up, he took himself to an empty room and slept in there for four nights." Sonny is one of 30,000 patients which the NHS says stay 21 days over their discharge-ready-date every year. It's a crisis that not only harms patients but has serious knock-on effects across the NHS. In some trusts, a staggering 1 in 4 bed days are lost due to delayed discharges – adding up to around half a million bed days annually. Think-Tank the Nuffield Trust says this is "one of the biggest challenges the NHS is facing". Solving this situation is at the heart of the Labour government's new Urgent & Emergency Care Plan 2025/26, which aims to target delay discharges bringing the half a million bed days back into use for patients waiting for hospital treatment. The government says it is investing £450 million in getting patients discharged on time. We first met Sonny when he took part in the 'Colour of Love' project in Nottingham in 2019, capturing the experiences of people who were in mixed race relationships in Nottinghamshire during the 1940's-1970's. "As soon as I stepped off the boat I started working," Sonny told us then. "I was offered three jobs." In Jamaica, Sonny had been a tailor, but in Nottingham he took a job laying kerbs on the Clifton Housing Estate. He married his English wife Christine on Christmas Eve 1957, despite the disapproval of some of her family. A year later he did National Service with the British Army, delivered the mail at Chilwell Army Base and then went on to work at the B&B Foundry run by J. Barber & E. Brockway for over two decades making bollards and litter bins. Sonny and Christine went on to have six children, 22 grandchildren and 29 great grandchildren. Christine died 31 years ago, and Sonny was diagnosed with dementia in early 2024. He lives alone and has four carers a day. "Dad didn't understand that he was in hospital," Coleen says. "He often referred to staff as Duppy – the Jamaican term for ghost. There were safety concerns as he would wander off in the ward. Some days I cooked dinner and took it to the hospital for him because the staff would take his dinner away before he had eaten. He was often left to go to the toilet himself. The nurses never understood his accent. The system is not set up to look after black people with dementia. "The whole system is so bad. While he was in hospital, dad deteriorated, he became confused, his legs were swollen, he had ulcers on them, which I had to tell the nurses to dress." Coleen says the five-week discharge delay was due to a lack of internal communication at the hospital and NHS Continuing Healthcare – and failures by social services to provide the right care package for her dad. They just kept saying he needed to go into a care home, but dad was adamant he didn't want to," she says. "He just needed night support as he already has day carers, and we live five minutes away." Age UK's Caroline Abrahams says unnecessary hospital stays cause their own problems. "The longer older people are in hospital, the higher the risk of losing muscle strength, delirium, pressure sores and infection, undermining their chances of a good recovery. For many older people, this will often mean that even when they are eventually discharged, within days or weeks they can find themselves back in hospital." She adds that delayed discharges "play a significant part in the ongoing scandal of corridor care, leaving older people stuck on trolleys for 12 hours, and often much longer". A spokesperson from Nottingham and Nottinghamshire Integrated Care System said: "Health and care colleagues work together to support people to be discharged from hospital as quickly as possible as soon as they are medically fit. Sometimes it can take time to get the right care in place to help someone return home. On these occasions, an interim care placement will be offered, such as a temporary care home placement. If the patient or family do not wish to take this option, this can lead to an extended stay in hospital. We will always work with patients and their families to meet their needs in the best way possible." A Department of Health and Social Care spokesperson said: "We recognise how distressing this experience must have been for Mr Francis and his family. No-one should have to stay in hospital longer than necessary, and we are working hard to better link up the NHS and social care to get people out and closer to home more quickly. Shifting care out of hospitals and into the community is a core part of our 10 Year Health Plan as we rebuild our health and care system." The experience has left Sonny's family feeling confused and angry. "Dad never went to the doctors, never needed hospital care, worked hard his whole life to now be treated like this," Coleen says. Sonny is now safely home, but without his daughter to advocate for him she believes he might still be there. "Had I not fought, I believe dad would still be in the hospital now," she says. "And that would be costing far more in hospital than his home care package."