2020 Delhi riots: Court acquits 12 in Hashim Ali murder case
Additional Sessions Judge Pulastya Pramachala of the Karkardooma Courts cleared all allegations against Lokesh Kumar Solanki, Pankaj Sharma, Ankit Chaudhary, Prince, Jatin Sharma, Himanshu Thakur, Vivek Panchal, Rishabh Chaudhary, Sumit Chaudhary, Tinku Arora, Sandeep and Sahil.
'I find that in the name of circumstantial evidence, there are some fragments and pieces of evidence, which fall much short to point out towards any of the accused persons as member of the culprit mob,' the judge said in the order.
According to witness accounts, the accused were seen carrying stones, sticks, swords, iron rods, and shouting slogans such as 'Jai Sri Ram' and 'Har Har Mahadev'. It was further claimed that these men were leading the mob and instructing others by calling out names.
As per the FIR, they were allegedly involved in the murder of nine Muslim men after checking their identities. Public witnesses had reportedly seen the killing of Hashim Ali. The prosecution alleged that the group conspired to 'teach Muslims a lesson' for attacks on Hindus.
They were said to have armed themselves with sticks, swords, firearms and more, and killed several, including Hashim Ali and his brother Aamir Khan. But the court found the evidence lacking in terms of identifying any of the accused as part of the mob that stopped the two brothers.
'In fact, except for PW1, no other witness claimed having seen any incident, which could be connected with incident with Hashim and Amir,' the court noted.
The judge also dismissed the prosecution's claim that WhatsApp messages linked Lokesh and others to the riots. 'However, I find that this plea is just a general presumption without support of substantive evidence. It shall be matter of analysis of other piece of circumstantial evidence, to see if the chain of all circumstances has been connected, to show involvement of Lokesh and others in the incident leading to death of Hashim,' the judge further said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Man duped of 2.96 crorein online stock mkt fraud
Lucknow: A man was duped of over Rs 2.96 crore in an online fraud in Indiranagar. According to an FIR lodged on Saturday, victim Apoorva Rai of Faridi Nagar said he was watching reels on the social media platform Instagram on April 19 when he saw an ad related to stock market analysis training. When he clicked on the ad it took him to a WhatsApp user whose name was written as Tripti Grover ACI. She advised him to invest money in the stock market. On April 24, he was made to download an ACI Century App by sending a link on his WhatsApp from the said number. After this, he logged into the app with his number and created an ID password. Thereafter, he was asked to join a WhatsApp group called ACI Exclusive Guidance Group, which included five members, including him. In this group, screenshots of profit were sent daily and instructions were given for buying and selling QIP stocks, UC stocks and IPOs. They also allotted them an (SME) IPO worth around Rs 1.5 crore. Rai said the cyber fraudsters used to take money in different mule accounts for buying capital-raising tools. After depositing the money in them, they used to send screenshots of transactions. Thereafter, that amount started getting displayed in the app. After this, they used to buy IPO, which later started showing profit on the money invested in that app. When he requested to withdraw 50% of the profit on May 27, the cyber criminals, citing different charges, transferred Rs 2,96,43,437 in 26 transactions from April 25 to July 6 in the name of investment in three govt banks. He said he gave an application to cyber crime police station Lucknow. "I am giving the statement of the accounts from which the money was transferred along with the application," he said. SHO, cyber cell, Brijesh Yadav said that the matter is being probed. Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area.
Time of India
3 hours ago
- Time of India
NU students council poll among demands raised at Gadkari's Janata Darbar
Nagpur: The last election for Nagpur University (NU) student council was held in September 2019 and now demand is being made to conduct a fresh election. The demand was taken up on Sunday at Union Minister Nitin Gadkari's Janata Darbar, where other issues like space for a Muslim kabrastan, salaries for teachers in Naxal-affected border villages, and job reinstatement were also raised. National Students' Union of India (NSUI) district member Abdul Reheman claimed that student representation has weakened and left major issues unresolved at NU in absence of a students' council. "The union has renewed calls to continue with the "carry-on" system. This is about fairness and the future of thousands of students. We will push until the rules are revised and elections are held," Reheman said. He noted that while the student body's tenure is technically one year, the election process itself takes nearly two months, with official notices consuming another 6-8 months. "Gadkari has directed NU core committee member Vishnu Chande to look into the matter," said Rehemen. Some citizens present at the Janata Darbar sought urgent attention to their civic grievances. Farukh Sheikh from Jaripatka said the Muslim graveyard in his locality is full, forcing families to bury loved ones in distant areas. "A graveyard is not just land; it's the final resting place. Denying a place for it in one's own locality is against dignity," he said. Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Learn More - How Watching Videos Can Boost Your Income TheDaddest Undo by Taboola by Taboola Former sanitation worker Vandana Shirshat alleged she was unfairly removed from her job at Nagpur railway station despite reinstatement orders from Gadkari's and chief minister Devendra Fadnavis's offices. "Now, I am selling tea outside the station. I am asking for the right to work with dignity," she said. A teacher from Bhandara appealed against reduced salaries for employees in Naxal-affected border villages, warning it demoralises staff despite lingering security risks. The Al Nushrat Foundation, which supports underprivileged children and families, sought Gadkari's help for an ambulance and computers to provide free Aadhaar, ration, and voter card services. Gadkari advised them to apply under govt schemes. Residents of Ghughus, Chandrapur, demanded completion of the long-delayed flyover near Rajiv Ratan Chowk railway crossing, saying the four-year delay has led to congestion and accidents. Mala Meshram, a local resident, recalled a mother and newborn died at the crossing, underscoring the urgent need for action. Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area.
Economic Times
3 hours ago
- Economic Times
SIR challenge: Domicile verification backlog hits electoral roll revision
Synopsis Bihar's Seemanchal region faces challenges in the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls, particularly in Muslim-dominated Kishanganj, due to a surge in domicile certificate applications. The administration struggles to verify applications amidst concerns about Bangladeshi infiltrators. On an average, Muslim-dominated Kishanganj district receives 30,000 online applications per month seeking issuance of 'Awasiya Praman Patra' (domicile certificate). In July, three lakh voters submitted applications for this certificate, which is one of the 11 documents required by the Election Commission of India (ECI) in the ongoing Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral is a challenge for the Kishanganj administration to verify each application at the ground level to issue permanent residence certificates to genuine citizens within a short time. As per the SIR schedule, the decision on the Enumeration Forms (EFs) received during H2H enumeration and disposal of claims and objections will be completed by September 25, 2025. This is just one of the problems in carrying out a proper SIR in Bihar's sensitive Seemanchal region spanning four districts -- Kishanganj, Araria, Purina and Katihar. Seemanchal region remains in the news for the alleged presence of Bangladeshi there is apparently little cooperation between the ECI and political parties to complete SIR at the ground-level, the administration depends on booth level officers (BLOs) to give a final shape to the electoral rolls. "You can't expect us to fully cooperate after the collection of EFs in SIR's first phase. BLOs distributed EFs and collected it from voters on their own without support from BLAs. So, the process for SIR could not begin on a good note," claimed Abhay Sinha, Purnia district's general secretary of the state's main opposition has a different version on SIR. "We have organised workshops in different areas to train our BLAs on their role in the SIR process. We want our BLAs to develop proper understanding with the BLOs concerned," Manoj Singh, BJP's Purnia district president, said. Although SIR is a commendable step, it is tough to complete in a short time, he first stage was significant because of ECI's intensive search for 'ASD' (absentee, shifted and dead) voters. Most BLOs this reporter met in Kishanganj, Araria and Purnia, admitted they completed the task of distributing and collecting EFs on their own, besides tracing 'ASDs'. At Singhiya Chakandara village in Kishanganj's Kochadhaman assembly constituency, three BLOs -- Prabhakar Ghosh, Mehmood Aalam and Ghulam Taha -- were busy identifying voters who have not submitted SIR documents. "We spent sleepless nights to distribute and collect EFs on our own. Now, we are calling voters to submit the documents," said Ghosh, who is trying to contact the remaining 429 voters (out of 796 at booth number 208) to collect said they had made a special appeal to voters to arrange documents in advance at the time of the collection of EFs. "This is farming season. Farmers are busy planting paddy. They are available only during evening hours," said BLO Mehmood Aalam, who is struggling to collect documents from 3q50 voters (out of a total 796) at booth number middle school, Simalbadi (Kishanganj), two BLOs, Uttam Kumar and Lutfun Nishan, said they collected mobile numbers of all voters during the distribution and collection of EFs. "The phone numbers made our task easy to contact voters for the collection of documents. Although we do not get any support from BLAs, we are in touch with ward members, Anganwadi Sevika, women associated Jeevika, ration dealers and panchayat functionaries to trace voters for submitting SIR documents," Uttam Kumar were given a list of names of Mahadalit voters, issued by Bihar Mahadalit Vikash Nigam. "This list is helpful for Mahadalit voters. This is a recognised document as the family register," BLO Uttam said. So, most Mahadalit voters are apparently not facing the threat of being deleted from the electoral rolls, he Katihar's Bheriya Rahika, this reporter accompanied BLO Shakoor Aalam (booth number 106), who was trying to collect documents, to see at first hand the challenges he faced. He met a voter, Soni Devi at a tea stall, whose father-in-law Ramanand Chauhan's name is in the 2003 electoral roll. She is not ready to bring the required documents from her father's place of Khokhali Bagh (Purnia). "I am desperately looking for available options to ensure her name in the rolls," Aalam said. He said most voters do not possess their own documents. This is a major problem to link them with their parents whose names are in the 2003 rolls. They produce documents like Aadhaar and pan card which are not Maharajpur panchayat of Purnia, Bhukhiya Devi approached BLO Lakshman Singh as her name is not in the draft rolls although she was a voter in the 2003 rolls. The BLO tried to pacify her that an objection has been filed and her name will be in the final rolls. The SIR exercise in Seemanchal shows that there is a need for a proper understanding between political parties and BLOs. What has politically troubled Opposition parties in Bihar is the SIR's timing, which just ahead of the 2025 polls. "This is the right time for opposition parties to highlight political issues to woo voters. This is the time for them to target the NDA government. However, opposition parties are entangled with the SIR issue," a voter in Purnia said. Officers engaged in SIR do not spare time to hearing people's grievances. This is not a good sign for the ruling NDA alliance ahead of the assembly polls.
