$1.7 million approved for wrongfully convicted Broward man sentenced to 400 years in prison
Sidney Holmes, now 59, can't get the 34 years he spent behind bars back, but he can live the rest of his days knowing that his name has been cleared.
'This a gesture that recognizes Mr. Holmes was wronged and that we, in the State of Florida and in the justice system, will help him and compensate him,' said State Attorney Harold Pryor, whose Conviction Review Unit identified Holmes' case and conducted the investigation that determined he was an innocent man.
Holmes was 22 years old when he was accused of taking part in a Father's Day 1988 robbery at the One Stop store in the 2500 block of Northwest Sixth Street, in an unincorporated area west of Fort Lauderdale. The getaway driver was described by a witness as 'short and heavyset.' Holmes was a lanky 6 feet and 183 pounds.
He also said he was at a family gathering at the time of the robbery. It didn't matter: A jury convicted him the following April, and the prosecutor, calling Holmes a habitual offender, sought a prison term of 825 years. Circuit Judge Mel Grossman, finding that sentence too harsh, ordered Holmes behind bars for 400 years.
Exonerated Broward man seeks $1.7 million from state after serving decades of 400-year sentence
'The reason for my recommendation and an exceedingly high number of years is to ensure that he won't be released from prison while he's breathing,' the original prosecutor said at Holmes' sentencing hearing.
The conviction review unit became aware of Holmes' case in 2020 and convinced a judge to release him in 2023. 'It's surreal,' Holmes said when he walked out of jail after spending more than half his life behind bars. 'I never would give up hope. I knew this day was going to come sooner or later, and today is the day.'
Because of his prior criminal record, Holmes was not legally entitled to payment under the state's law on compensating victims of wrongful incarceration. A claims bill filed by state Rep. Michael Gottlieb and state Sen. Jason Pizzo was passed earlier this year and signed Tuesday by the governor.
Holmes will receive $1,722,000 along with 120 hours of college or career center tuition and fees.
'Since his release from prison, Mr. Holmes has obtained full-time employment,' the State Attorney's Office announced in a news release. 'He has also visited our office and participated in training sessions by talking to our prosecutors about his experience and how to try to avoid wrongful convictions in the future.'
Rafael Olmeda can be reached at rolmeda@sunsentinel.com or 954-356-4457. Follow him on Threads.net/@rafael.olmeda.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
9 hours ago
- Yahoo
Kilmar Abrego Garcia's attorneys move to dismiss criminal case
Kilmar Abrego Garcia's attorneys accused federal prosecutors on Tuesday of "vindictive and selective prosecution" in a motion seeking to dismiss the criminal charges against him. Abrego Garcia could be released from Tennessee criminal custody on Friday, when U.S. Magistrate Judge Barbara Holmes's temporary stay is set to expire. This comes after a separate judge ruled last month that Abrego Garcia must be returned to Maryland if he is released. In the 25-page filing, Abrego Garcia's attorneys argued that the government charged him "because he refused to acquiesce in the government's violation of his due process rights." MORE: Justice Department investigating 2022 Abrego Garcia traffic stop: Sources "Kilmar Abrego Garcia has been singled out by the United States government," his attorneys said. The Salvadoran native was deported in March to El Salvador's CECOT mega-prison -- despite a 2019 court order barring his deportation due to fear of persecution -- after the Trump administration claimed he was a member of the criminal gang MS-13, which he denies. He was brought back to the U.S. in May to face charges in Tennessee of allegedly transporting undocumented migrants. In the filing on Tuesday, the attorneys said that Abrego Garcia was "sent on his way without so much as a traffic ticket" after the Tennessee Highway Patrol stopped their client in 2022. "Yet three years later, unrelatedly, the government picked Mr. Abrego up off the street—along with others with similar immigration status—as part of a shock-and-awe immigration enforcement push," they said. MORE: Timeline: Wrongful deportation of Kilmar Abrego Garcia to El Salvador After Abrego Garcia's wrongful removal, the attorneys said the government "responded not with contrition, or with any effort to fix its mistake, but with defiance." "A group of the most senior officials in the United States sought vengeance: they began a public campaign to punish Mr. Abrego for daring to fight back, culminating in the criminal investigation that led to the charges in this case," they said. Abrego Garcia's attorneys said in their filing the government is using the criminal case to punish their client for "successfully fighting his unlawful removal." "That is a constitutional violation of the most basic sort," they said. "The indictment must be dismissed."
Yahoo
20 hours ago
- Yahoo
Amid criticism of Probation boss Juanita Holmes, department issues memos on media contact, USB drives
NEW YORK — Probation Commissioner Juanita Holmes moved last week to underscore policies aimed at controlling the flow of information amid criticism of her tenure stemming from a July 28 Council hearing and from within the agency, the Daily News has learned. Holmes' aide Antonio Pullano sent an email Friday to Probation employees reminding them of a policy they are not to speak with reporters, a copy of that document shows. A second written order went out midweek barring the use of thumb drives in the office, which can be used to make copies of agency documents. Earlier last week, a sign appeared at the entrance to the cubicles of the Human Resources division at Probation headquarters on the 18th floor of 33 Beaver St. 'Authorized personnel only,' the sign reads, a photo obtained by The News shows. The memos come after The News revealed Thursday that Holmes sidelined her Chief Information Officer Razwan Mirza while at the same time hiring her niece, Demmi Slaughter, for a role in the department. The agency said she was hired as a 'certified IT administrator' but an inboarding document obtained by The News shows her listed as 'Assistant Commissioner of Information Technology.' The News also obtained internal agency statistics which showed rearrests of probationers had spiked 19% during Holmes tenure. Holmes had twice claimed in the hearing that rearrests were down, then tried to blame her predecessor Ana Bermudez for supposedly manipulating statistics. The number of rearrests are key indicator for an agency that is supposed to be preventing probationers from reoffending. The moves took place after The News sent detailed inquiries to Probation and the City Hall press office Aug. 11 about Mirza and Slaughter and the internal statistics showing the increase in rearrests. The News also previously reported that the city Comptoller barred Probation from self-registering certain contracts after finding the agency sidestepped procurement rules in the taxpayer-funded purchase of Holmes' $87,000 SUV. Probation spokeswoman Regina Graham defended the media email, saying 'This is a longtime city policy and has existed across several mayoral administrations and DOP Commissioners.' 'Across every single city agency, anyone must get approval and clearance by senior supervision and the Deputy Mayor for Communications to speak to members of the public or the press in your official capacity as a city employee,' she said in a statement. 'This longstanding policy does not exist to protect any commissioner or mayor — it exists to ensure that New Yorkers receive accurate, clear information from their city government.' Rendy Desamours, a spokesman for the City Council, said, 'The questionable data provided to the Council and staffing turmoil within the Department point to severe leadership challenges that are undermining its mission and the efforts of rank-and-file agency staff. 'These issues have real consequences for New Yorkers' public safety and the stability of our communities. They cannot be swept under the rug – City Hall and DOP leadership must advance meaningful solutions that reduce high caseloads, restore confidence, and ensure clients are being effectively supported.' The Council statement built upon a call last week by Council Member Sandy Nurse for an outside audit of Probation. Graham said Holmes 'would welcome any outside entity to conduct an agency audit,' adding that Probation was in an 'antiquated state' prior to Holmes arrival. 'Since instituting critical changes, Commissioner Holmes has received positive feedback from dozens of staff members, who welcome these innovative shifts and her leadership,' she wrote. Pullano's email on the media said, 'This is a reminder that DOP policy prevents speaking to or sharing information with the media without approval from the communication team and/or the commissioner,' the one-paragraph memo reads. The thumb drive ban was issued two days earlier. 'Effective immediately, the use of USB drives and other removable media devices is strictly prohibited on all DOP computers, laptops, tablets and networks,' the thumb drive edict stated. 'These devices present a high security risk and can expose and compromise systems data.' The missive added, 'All USB and removable media ports will be blocked to prevent unauthorized use.' Graham explained that thumb drives 'present (a) high security risk' and said 'There is no acceptable reason to share confidential information,' though Graham did not specify what confidential information had been shared. The 'authorized personnel only' signs at Human Resources appeared first last week. Probation's HR department has had significant turnover under Holmes, and questions have been raised about the hiring of friends and relatives to posts with the agency. The department said that because 'amongst the 23 floors in the building, three of the floors are occupied by DOP staff … it must be indicative that these DOP specific floors have signage noting for 'Authorized Personnel Only.''
USA Today
5 days ago
- USA Today
Boxer Gervonta Davis will not face domestic violence charges
Boxer Gervonta Davis will not face misdemeanor charges for battery-domestic violence because the alleged victim, Davis' former girlfriend, and the alleged witness, the woman's mother, failed to cooperate, according to the Miami State's Attorney Office. Davis, 30, was arrested July 11 and the charge stemmed from an alleged incident with his former girlfriend, who is the mother of his two children, on Father's Day, June 15, in Doral, Florida. "This case was dropped as the victim is declining to prosecute per her … attorney," Ed Griffith, Public Information Officer for the Miami State's Attorney Office, told USA TODAY Sports by email. "Her sentiments were directly confirmed by the Assistant State Attorney handling the prosecution. "The witness to the incident, who is the victim's mother, also failed to cooperate and failed, after being subpoenaed for a prefile conference on Thursday (Aug. 7). Followed up attempts to contact the witness via phone were unsuccessful. The incident itself was not observed by the police officer who had been called to the scene eliminating him as a possible witness to what had transpired." With the dropping of the criminal charge, the $10,000 bond required as a part of the pretrial release was dismissed, according to Griffith.
