EV vs hybrid war: All clean fuel-run vehicles are equal for the PMO
The Prime Minister's Office (PMO) believes the Centre needs to support all clean-fuel vehicles including hybrids, even as a rift widens in the Indian auto industry over hybrids being put on a par with pure electric vehicles (EVs).
The stand, confirmed by two top government officials, comes after manufacturers of both electric and hybrid vehicles sought the Centre's favour after several state governments proposed incentivizing electric, hybrid and CNG vehicles equally.
'I do not understand why there is so much lobbying. State policies may differ, but the central government has supported both EVs and hybrids in clean mobility schemes. It cannot be that you incentivize one and not the other. The idea is to help all forms and all clean fuels," one of the two officials said on the condition of anonymity.
The incentives for EVs and hybrids are aimed at reducing the country's fuel imports and carbon emissions. "All clean mobility initiatives which contribute to this have been incentivized so far, and will continue to be so," the second official said, also on the condition of anonymity.
Govt support
Mint reported on 6 June, quoting Union heavy industries minister H.D. Kumaraswamy, that the government would continue to support all forms of clean mobility, including hybrid vehicles, which combine the power of a traditional internal combustion engine (ICE) with an electric motor, improving fuel efficiency while cutting down on emissions and fuel usage.
Even in the past, the Centre supported hybrids and EVs alike in various subsidy schemes, including the second iteration of the Faster Adoption and Manufacturing of (Hybrid &) Electric Vehicles in India (FAME India), which ran from 2018-19 to 2023-24.
Also read | ARAI likely to plan division of auto testing agencies allocation
Eventually, support for clean-fuel cars was removed under the PM E-Drive scheme (2023-24 to 2025-26). However, it continues to incentivize pure electric buses and electric and hybrid ambulances. The outlay for incentivising such ambulances is ₹500 crore till the end of FY26.
Nevertheless, the Union government will continue to support policies to promote clean mobility through all possible means, including EVs, hybrid vehicles, as well as vehicles running on compressed natural gas (CNG) and liquified natural gas (LNG), among others, according to the government officials cited above.
The EV vs hybrid war
Mint reported on 24 April that the Delhi government had proposed to grant hybrid cars the same benefits as fully electric ones, raising concern among carmakers that had committed vast amounts to develop battery EVs, skipping hybrid technologies.
The draft of the Delhi Electric Vehicles Policy 2.0 seeks to waive road tax and registration fees on electric cars priced up to ₹20 lakh ex-showroom and extend the benefit to strong hybrid EVs (SHEVs) and plug-in hybrid EVs (PHEVs) with a similar price cap as well.
Also read | More than 6 lakh electric 2, 3-wheelers sold under PM E-Drive scheme since April
An SHEV is typically a car in which an electric motor gives significant assistance to the combustion engine. PHEVs, as the name suggests, come with a charging port for the battery that drives the motor. These vehicles can also run exclusively on the electric motor.
Uttar Pradesh was the first state to waive these charges for hybrid vehicles in July 2024.
CAQM direction
Meanwhile, the Commission for Air Quality Management (CAQM) on 4 June also directed commercial vehicle operators to include 'clean' vehicles, including hybrids, in their fleets to help curb air pollution in the national capital.
Worried about losing market share, EV makers have urged the Union government not to incentivize them on par with EVs. They have argued that parity between incentives for hybrids and pure EVs would push consumers towards hybrids, which are not zero-emission vehicles.
Also read | Tata Motors pushes for e-taxi subsidy after exclusion from PM E-Drive
India's EV market was valued at $54.41 billion in 2025, and the hybrid vehicle market at about $0.53 billion, according to market research company Mordor Intelligence. India's automobile market, the world's third-largest by sales, was valued at $137.06 billion.
Clean-fuel clash
India's major EV makers include Tata Motors Ltd, Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd, Hyundai Motor India Ltd, Kia India Pvt. Ltd, and JSW MG Motor India Ltd. The hybrid carmakers are led by Maruti Suzuki India Pvt. Ltd, Honda Cars India Ltd, and Toyota Kirloskar Motor Pvt. Ltd.
'Tata Motors believes that government incentives should be directed towards promoting zero-emission technologies such as EVs by bridging funding gaps, developing enabling infrastructure, and accelerating innovation to help them reach scale and maturity. Hybrid is an incremental and mature ICE technology, which is commercially viable and faces no funding or adoption barriers that typically warrant government support," said a Tata Motors spokesperson in an emailed statement.
Also read | Subsidies on e-scooters to slide to ₹5,000 per scooter in Oct 2025
The spokesperson added that hybrids use fossil fuels, resulting in PM2.5, CO2, and other tailpipe emissions like any other ICE vehicles. Directing any incentives or subsidies toward them can divert India from its net-zero and energy security objectives.
'Viability gap'
Rahul Bharti, senior executive officer, corporate affairs, Maruti Suzuki, countered the argument, saying that strong hybrid EVs reduce CO2 emissions by 25% to 31% over pure petrol vehicles and increase energy efficiency by 36% to 44%, but they still have a viability gap.
'So, the tax cannot be the same for a strong hybrid and a pure petrol/diesel vehicle. Data shows that wherever SHEVs have been incentivized, the sales of BEVs have not fallen at all; on the contrary, they have gone up. SHEVs will help reduce pure diesel/petrol cars, and that is in the national interest," he added.
Also read | E-buses under PM E-drive to be used now for intercity, tourist travel
While hybrid vehicle sales rose about 12% year-on-year to 365,024 in 2024-25, pure EV sales rose 17% to 1,967,313, showed data from the central government's Vahan portal.
Queries emailed on 5 June to the PMO, on 6 June to Mahindra & Mahindra, Hyundai Motor India, Kia India, JSW MG Motor, Honda Cars, and Toyota Kirloskar Motor, and on 7 June to the heavy industries ministry, remained unanswered until the time of publishing this story.
Experts weigh in
The share of non-conventional fuels has increased to a fifth of total passenger vehicle volumes, as against less than 5% five years ago, said Srikumar Krishnamurthy, senior vice-president and co-group head, corporate ratings, Icra Ltd.
'Specifically, hybrids have seen better acceptance in the last one and a half years as they reduce carbon emissions while managing to achieve good ranges. While hybrids at this stage are a stop-gap solution as EV infrastructure is yet to mature, they are also playing a strategic role in achieving sustainability and with more product launches and better product quality, it has become more popular."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hans India
33 minutes ago
- Hans India
Kashmir's rail revolution is a tribute to govt resolve and grit
On a clear June day, draped in marigold flowers and national pride, the Vande Bharat Express began its maiden journey from Shri Mata Vaishno Devi Katra to Srinagar. Flagged off by Prime Minister Narendra Modi, the moment marked more than just the launch of a high-speed train. It was the culmination of a century-old dream—one forged in steel, vision, and unyielding resolve. The rail unification of Kashmir with the rest of India is that resolve. A train to Kashmir with an ultra-modern travel experience runs on the solid foundation of our engineers. Cutting the travel time short, Vande Bharat trains run twice a day, six times a week from both sides. They are not only bringing in the much-needed push for the local economic development in the valley but are emerging as a boon for tourists from all over. For decades, Kashmir's story has been told through the lens of conflict and remoteness. It's heartening to see it being rewritten in the language of infrastructure – bridges, tunnels, and rail lines threading their way through the mountains. Coming on the eve of the 11 years of Modi's governance at the Centre, the special trains and the connecting link are all set to change the destiny of locals in Kashmir. In its 172-year history of service to the nation, Indian Railways has crossed many important milestones. Generations of dedicated railway men and women have toiled to make connectivity and carriage an everyday reality. But to paraphrase a line from an iconic Indian advertisement: Indian Railways doesn't just build tracks—it also knits the fabric of national unity! From isolation to integration Historically, Kashmir's isolation was more than metaphorical—it was geographic and punishingly real. Tucked high in the Himalayas and routinely cut off by snow for days together, the region remained distant not just in reach but even experience. Roads were often treacherous, air travel limited, and full rail connectivity a mirage. A British-era proposal for a Kashmir rail link remained on the drawing board for decades, hindered by complex geopolitical challenges. After countless rounds of deliberations, feasibility studies, technical evaluations, and consultations with both domestic and international experts, the Udhampur–Srinagar–Baramulla Rail Link (USBRL) was officially sanctioned in 1994. While the northern and southern sections progressed steadily and were effectively completed within a decade, the central stretch—from Katra to Banihal—posed an engineering and security challenge of Himalayan proportions. For years, the rail line lingered as two disconnected segments—like outstretched hands reaching across a chasm of mountains. But that chasm symbolized more than just physical terrain. The final push to complete the USBRL project came when the government declared it a national priority. With a firm resolve and cutting-edge technology working in tandem, the project finally saw light at the end of the tunnel—quite literally. As Railway Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw aptly remarked, this was far more than a transportation initiative; it was a nation-building effort. Where steel defies the sky The USBRL project may well be the most ambitious rail initiative since Independence. The 272-km stretch between Udhampur and Baramulla snakes through 40 tunnels and over 900 bridges. And at the center of it all is the record-breaking Chenab Bridge – the tallest railway bridge in the world, standing 359 meters above the riverbed. This engineering marvel is capable of withstanding wind speeds of up to 260 kmph and tremors of seismic zone-V. Beside it stands the: Anji Khad Bridge, the country's first cable-stayed railway bridge, stretching asymmetrically across a valley, anchored by a single pylon and supported by 96 cables. Tunnels, including the 11-kilometer-long T-80 (Banihal - Qazigund) tunnel through the Pir Panjal range, have been carved through fragile rock with a mix of dynamite and human grit. Physical surveys were done on horseback, while drones and satellite imaging provided aerial support. Workers labored through harsh winters, sudden landslides, and the looming threat of Pak-sponsored terrorist attacks. Today, more than 190 km of tunnels and thousands of tons of steel later, the line stands complete – a feat that combines precision engineering with a certain audacity of vision, linking the valley to the rest of the nation in a way that is profoundly symbolic. A train called hope In many ways, the Vande Bharat Express is not just a train, it is a metaphor. It glides quietly through meadows and valleys, bridging distances both physical and psychological, proclaiming that Kashmir is no longer distant! It has reduced travel time between Srinagar and Katra to just over three hours, down from nearly six. What was once a treacherous road journey through landslide-prone hairpin bends and unpredictable weather, is now a smooth ride through tunnels and bridges that defy belief. It connects not only cities, but lives. Children in far-off villages are now talking about universities in Jammu and Delhi. Local artisans, apple growers, and carpet weavers now see their goods reaching markets beyond the valley – fresher, faster, further. 'Where there were checkpoints and delays. There is now the sound of a train. It feels like we're no longer waiting for the rest of the country to arrive, we are moving with it,' said a young shopkeeper in Srinagar. A new journey unfolds This is not to suggest that one train will solve Kashmir's complex problems. Infrastructure cannot erase history or immediately heal wounds – security concerns will need addressing yet. But it can open doors—both literally and symbolically. And it can lay the groundwork for integration that is economic, social, and, ultimately, emotional. What began as a dream on drawing boards in colonial offices has become a reality on steel rails blending with Himalayan rock. The rail line to Kashmir is the story of a country that refused to be daunted by terrain, terror, or time. From mountain shadows to sunlit stations, a new journey has begun! (The writer is former CEO and Chairman Railway Board)
Hans India
34 minutes ago
- Hans India
MyVoice: Views of our readers 11th June 2025
Handcuffing incident exposes arrogance of US administration The handcuffing incident exposes the arrogance of U. S. administration, epically while dealing with India and its citizens. The hapless Indian student did not commit any treason, but is facing deportation, for which, he need not be handcuffed. I don't know why parents from India want their children to pursue higher studies in the United States, which has ceased to be an 'Eldorado'. In fact, it is gripped with internal strife, rising violence and racial discrimination. USA may be a superpower, but its administration must not ignore the fact that India is an 'emerging superpower'. R J Janardhana Rao, Gudimalkapur road, Hyderabad-28. An in human act The disturbing incident at Newark has expectedly sparked widespread outrage. Handcuffing an Indian student and pinning him to the ground prior to his deportation is as an 'inhuman' act. Unfortunately, such incidents have been occurring with an alarming frequency. The Modi-Trump friendship should have at least ensured a dignified deportation, rather than treating the student like a criminal or a terrorist. It's imperative that the Indian Government uses its good offices to facilitate smooth deportations of students, without subjecting them to a traumatic treatment that may haunt them all through their life. Ganti Venkata Sudhir, Secunderabad Railways should invest in technology upgrade After every train accident, the railway minister and administrators come up with their versions about how and what led to the mishap. Compensation is released to families of victims immediately. I suggest that the railways should invest more on technology upgrade to ensure safety of drivers, passengers and trains. All engines shall have display screens with aural and visual warning generators. The display screens have to indicate the track ahead, gates, signals and the train ahead along with the speed, acceleration and vibration levels. Audio and visual warnings alert at least one of the drivers and they can work out corrective actions. Moreover, drivers shall be provided with both internal and external communication facilities. Using an internal system, they can update passengers and the guard about the actual facts. Gudipati Anirudh, New Bowenpalli, Secunderabad-11 India returns to space India is poised to script a remarkable chapter in its space journey as Group Captain Shubhanshu Shukla leads the Axiom 4 mission to the International Space Station. More than a scientific venture, this launch symbolises India's growing global stature, scientific ambition, and readiness for long-duration human spaceflight. With ISRO's active support and the Indian Air Force's proud endorsement, it marks a historic return to space by an Indian after four decades. The mission's research will not only advance space science but also lay vital groundwork for India's Gaganyaan program. This is a proud moment—where technology, vision, and national aspirations go beyond the sky. Mohammad Asad, Mumbai Axiom -4 Mission Heartiest congratulations to Group Captain Subhanshu Shukla for his space journey, following in the footsteps of Wing Commander Rakesh Sharma, who ventured into space in 1984. The entire nation is proud of you and supports the team in conducting a series of scientific experiments aimed at enhancing knowledge in microgravity, life sciences, and material sciences, in collaboration with scientists from over 30 countries N S K Prasad, Saket Colony, Hyderabad-62 High five on AI The present era can truly be called the age of artificial intelligence (AI), which is making deep inroads into every aspect of our daily lives- from education to healthcare and from business to industry. In this context, it has become essential for individuals from all walks of life-students, professionals, entrepreneurs, and educators-to understand the appropriate and ethical use of AI. However, the reality is that there are now numerous accessible platforms available to learn the fundamentals and practical applications of AI-such as online courses, webinars, e-learning platforms, and various training programs. Importantly, the knowledge of AI is not limited to technologists alone. It has become an essential skill for students from arts, commerce, and science streams, as well as for working professionals and entrepreneurs. The more people understand and responsibly apply AI, the more it can simplify life, save time, and enhance productivity. We the media to give greater importance to spreading awareness about this transformative technology so that the society can stay informed and empowered, while at the same time removing the misconceptions that exist. Jayanthy Subramaniam, Sion East, Mumbai-22
Time of India
37 minutes ago
- Time of India
'Just managing': US tariffs leave Indian shrimp farmers struggling
NEW DELHI: R. Mahadevan, a shrimp farmer in southern India, is considering something no farmer wants to say out loud: stopping production. Having already seen his monthly income shrink in recent years due to rising costs and stagnant demand, he said U.S. President Donald Trump 's planned tariffs on Indian exports may push him to the brink. "Already I am struggling, just somehow managing," said 48-year-old Mahadevan, adding that his income had fallen to below $200 a month from about $350 in 2018. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Elegant New Scooters For Seniors In 2024: The Prices May Surprise You Mobility Scooter | Search Ads Learn More Undo Trump said in early April his government would impose a 26% tariff on all Indian exports, including the thousands of tonnes of shrimp Indian exporters ship to American customers each year. Mahadevan is among the hundreds of thousands of Indian shrimp farmers bracing for the impact of Trump's trade wars and is worried the 26% tariff could make his product too expensive in the U.S. market, the top destination for Indian shrimp. Live Events "If I shut down my farm, the idle ponds and machinery will be ruined, and restarting will become more difficult," said Mahadevan in the town of Karhiripulum in Tamil Nadu state. "But (I have) no other option, I cannot afford to sell my shrimp any cheaper." Indian negotiators won a 90-day pause in the tariff increase, keeping the tariff on exports at 10% until July, while pushing for a broader trade deal with the United States by the end of the year. But for the hundreds of thousands of farmers raising vannamei shrimp - a fast-growing species farmed in small saline ponds along the country's coastal districts - any increase in the cost of sending their product to the United States could put them out of business. There were 120,000 vannamei shrimp farmers in 2021, according to the latest industry estimates. Shrimp accounts for 66% of India's seafood exports and are worth billions of dollars, according to the Ministry of Commerce and Industry. But the people cultivating them tend to be impoverished and rely on loans to set up their small businesses, making them particularly vulnerable to falling prices and global shocks, said the Prawn Farmers Federation of India. While an exporting boom buoyed the shrimp industry at large in 2021, farmers said they did not benefit from the government subsidies made available to the large exporters they buy feed from and sell their shrimps to. Troubled sector India is the world's largest exporter of frozen shrimp, shipping more than 716,000 metric tonnes in the financial year ending in 2024, according to government data. Nearly 60% of India's shrimp exports - $2.9 billion worth - went to the United States in 2024, the data showed. But the industry has been struggling. After peaking in 2021, shrimp exports have declined amid a glut in the world's supply, falling prices and repeated disease outbreaks, according to a report from the Global Shrimp Forum. Indian shrimp farmers have also been grappling with the 7% duty the United States imposed on the sector in 2024 for countervailing and anti-dumping purposes, according to Siddharth Chakravarty, an expert on the fishing sector. With the 7% anti-dumping and countervailing duty, as well as the 10% tariff, India's shrimp exports to the United States already face a 17% duty that could climb as high as 37% if Trump goes ahead with the higher tariff, said a trade analyst who asked not to be named. "(India's shrimp) sector is already reeling from a global oversupply of shrimp, on one hand, and demand stagnation on the other," said Chakravarty. "Now, a higher tariff could push it over the edge." Mahadevan said he earns about a fifth less on a kilo of shrimp than he did three years ago, "whereas all costs - feed, labour, electricity, diesel - have increased too much." "If shrimp prices go down further, my family will suffer surely," said Mahadevan, who has already had to delay his daughter's wedding and a house renovation. The concern is that a steep U.S. tariff could wipe out profits entirely in a fragile industry, said Chakravarty. Shrimp farmers heavily rely on loans to cover their input costs - such as feed, electricity, diesel and land leasing - while output is sensitive to weather, seed quality and disease outbreaks. "With margins near zero, even small changes can be catastrophic. Even a 1% additional tariff is salt in the already raw wound," said V. Balasubramaniam, general secretary of the Prawn Farmers Federation of India. Farmers are now calling on the government for help, demanding interventions to reduce input costs and access to better markets and prices for their shrimps. There appears to be some relief on the way. The administration in Andhra Pradesh, India's top shrimp-producing state, has been subsidising power to shrimp farms since April and is urging the national government to sign a trade pact with the European Union to reduce the sector's reliance on the U.S. market, according to local media. Balasubramaniam said feed manufacturers started offering small discounts to farmers in April after meeting with local officials in Andhra Pradesh but that these were merely "symbolic" given the discounts were much smaller than the fall in shrimp prices. Meanwhile, exporters are rushing to sell about 40,000 tonnes of shrimp from last year's harvest that are in cold storage before the new tariff takes effect, according to a separate local media report. Looking for new markets Chakravarty said the over-dependence on the United States has helped create the crisis shrimp farmers now face. "One market for one product yielded benefits for India's shrimp sector in the beginning. But that boom has ended," he said. Expanding sales of shrimp at home would also help, said Balasubramaniam. That would require the government to invest in a national distribution network, including cold-chain logistics such as refrigerated transportation, he said. "We have been reaching out to the national government to establish a strong domestic market, but so far it has been a piecemeal approach," Balasubramaniam said. India's commerce ministry did not immediately respond to the Thomson Reuters Foundation's request for a comment.
