High Court rules suspension of Garda who allegedly had inappropriate relationship with woman is lawful
Last March, Donegal-based Garda Keith Harrison brought a High Court challenge against his ongoing suspension.
Harrison brought judicial review proceedings before the High Court seeking orders lifting and quashing his suspension.
The suspension relates to allegations he had an inappropriate relationship with a woman who for a time was his partner.
It is alleged that in 2019, Harrison took a formal statement from a woman who had made a criminal complaint of domestic abuse against her then partner.
Harrison later entered into a relationship with this woman.
While she is not pursuing any criminal complaint against Harrison, An Garda Síochána contend that the relationship was 'inappropriate and contrary to the professional duty of care owed by a member of An Garda Síochána to a person alleged to be a vulnerable victim of a crime'.
An Garda Síochána also cited a 'power dynamic between a person making a complaint of domestic abuse and the Garda to whom that complaint is made'.
The High Court noted that there is 'strong evidence of the applicant having entered into a sexual relationship with the complainant within weeks of the complaint of domestic abuse'.
The woman, who can't be named to respect her privacy, didn't pursue a criminal prosecution against her then partner.
Advertisement
It was argued by Harrison that the fact that there was no criminal prosecution by the woman against her then partner means that she cannot properly be described as a 'vulnerable victim of a crime'.
It was also argued that this 'at the very least reduces the seriousness of the alleged breach of discipline'.
However, the High Court said there are many reasons why a criminal prosecution might not be pursued in the context of alleged domestic abuse and that 'it cannot automatically be inferred that the person making the complaint was not vulnerable'.
Harrison previously stated that he entered into 'a fully consensual' relationship with the woman and noted that the two have a child together.
Harrison was first suspended in March 2021 and his suspension has been extended in a series of three-monthly decisions since.
The High Court today ruled that Harrison's continued suspension is lawful.
Mr. Justice Garrett Simons said that given the 'seriousness of the breaches of discipline alleged, it was reasonable and rational for the Assistant Commissioner to extend this suspension on each of the three-monthly reviews'.
The judge dismissed the application for judicial review.
Harrison was one of several garda members to have appeared before the Disclosures Tribunal, which investigated claims by Garda whistleblowers.
In 2017 and 2018, the tribunal chair Mr Justice Peter Charleton rejected allegations by Harrison and his then-partner.
The allegations included that a woman, who is not the woman at the centre of the High Court legal action, was compelled by gardaí to make a statement against Harrison that led to a Tusla referral and that Harrison was the victim of a five-year intimidation campaign after arresting a fellow officer for drink driving in 2009.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
6 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Fraud offences up by 73% in six months
Overall fraud offences have increased by 73% in the first six months of this year compared to the same period in 2024, according to provisional crime statistics from An Garda Síochána. The garda figures are subject to change, with official statistics published by the Central Statistics Office on a quarterly basis. The statistics show significant increases across most forms of fraud, with the biggest rise recorded in forgery or false instruments, which rose by 200% between January to the end of June 2025 compared to the same time last year. An Garda Síochána said "deception or other" rose by 178%, shopping or online auction fraud was up 166% and money laundering increased by 82%. Reports of "bogus tradesmen" had a 57% increase during this time compared to previous statistics for this period, while fraud relating to accommodation rose by 22% and so-called "account takeover fraud" rose by 18%. However, gardaí said other forms of fraud decreased, including a drop of 88% in reports of counterfeit notes and coins. Instances of phishing, vishing and smishing reduced by 26% - such crimes are usually carried out online, via a phone call or text message. Insurance fraud also dropped by 45%, the figures showed. The second highest rise in crime was in reports of arson, which increased by 20% compared to the first six months of last year. But the report added that other examples of criminal damage, excluding arson, dropped by 14%. An Garda Síochána's provisional report showed a 16% reduction on last year in reports of child sexual abuse material and related offences. But it said that "nationally the number of sexual offences reported has increased" compared to the same time last year. It said there was a 4% rise in reports of rape and a 7% increase in sexual assault that were not aggravated. The provisional figures from gardaí also found an overall reduction of 2% in road traffic collisions up to 30 June this year compared to the same period last year. It said there were "over 22,100 road traffic collisions reported to An Garda Síochána" during this time. But gardaí said instances of people "driving while intoxicated" rose by 8%. In the six months to 30 June 2025, the report said gardaí initiated "over 27,000 arrests", with "over 67,000 criminal charges created". It also said officers made "over 6,500 referrals to the Juvenile Diversion programme in accordance with the Children's Act 2001".
Irish Times
6 hours ago
- Irish Times
Espionage and ‘destructive ideologies' are among main threats to State, says Garda report
The Garda 's national security service has warned about the 'ever present' threat from foreign spies intent on stealing sensitive political information and intellectual property. In a newly published document, the Security and Intelligence branch also raises concerns about the threat of 'destructive ideologies' and the rise of extremism in Ireland. The force 's Annual Security Services Plan offers a rare, though vaguely worded, insight into what it believes are the main threats facing the State. It comes amid efforts by the Government to revamp the State's clandestine security services in the face of increasing foreign threats. Almost uniquely among western countries, the Garda is responsible for both day-to-day policing and State security. READ MORE It says the Garda's secretive Security and Intelligence Service is responsible for State security. One of its key roles is liaising with overseas secret services, while the role of its operational arm, the Special Detective Unit, is 'identifying, investigating and reporting for prosecution' threats to State security, it says. The report says the service will also be required to carry out threat assessments and security operations relating to Ireland's presidency of the EU next year. According to the report, the main threats to the State are 'terrorism, violent political extremism, espionage, sabotage and subversion'. Ireland is a 'potential target of hostile state actors' that are intent on stealing information on 'intellectual property, as well as policies and political information of the State'. The report does not specify which countries are a threat, although senior security officials have previously raised concerns about espionage activities by Russia, China and Iran. In particular, China is believed to regularly attempt to gain access to the intellectual property of technology and pharmaceutical companies here. A Russian expatriates network accused of acting as an extension of the Kremlin's security services has also been active in Ireland , while there is evidence China has been using a Dublin-based overseas Chinese service centre to coerce its citizens living here . In recent years, the Government has taken steps to reduce the number of Russian intelligence agents in Ireland. It has introduced national security legislation preventing Russia from extending its embassy and has refused to issue visas to multiple incoming diplomats. In a sign of the evolving security landscape, the threat from 'subversion', typically a reference to violent Republican groups, is only alluded to once in the document. However, Ireland is 'not immune' from the threats of terrorism and extremism seen in other EU countries, including 'lone wolf' extremists, the report warns. A stabbing attack on a Defence Forces chaplain in Galway last year by a radicalised teenager has been officially designated as Ireland's first Islamic terrorist attack. Another stabbing attack on a Garda, which is currently before the courts, is also been investigated as potential Islamic-inspired terrorism, while there are also concerns about possible attacks from far-right extremists, sources say. 'The proliferation of destructive ideologies poses a direct threat to the values of democratic society, threatens lives and endangers the freedoms and norms that we have become accustomed to in a secure society,' the report warns. 'Interconnected groupings/individuals displaying extremist and terrorist ideologies present a potential threat to the security of the State and our citizens.' The Government has committed to a ring-fenced budget that will allow the security service to expand recruitment of civilians with specialist skills, it says. In a forward to the plan, Garda Commissioner Drew Harris , who retires at the end of August, says Garda capabilities in the areas of national security, counter-intelligence and counter-terrorism 'will continue to be enhanced and partnerships between national and international partners will be developed, maintained and strengthened'.
RTÉ News
6 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Garda provisional figures show 73% rise in fraud
Overall fraud offences have increased by 73% in the first six months of this year compared to the same period in 2024, according to the gardaí's provisional crime statistics. The gardaí's figures are subject to change, with official statistics published by the Central Statistics Office on a quarterly basis. The statistics show significant increases across most forms of fraud, with the biggest rise recorded in forgery or false instruments, which rose by 200% between January to the end of June 2025 compared to the same time last year. An Garda Síochána said "deception or other" rose by 178%, shopping or online auction fraud was up 166% and money laundering increased by 82%. Reports of "bogus tradesman" had a 57% increase during this time compared to previous statistics for this period, while fraud relating to accommodation rose by 22% and so-called "account takeover fraud" rose by 18%. However, gardaí said other forms of fraud decreased, including a drop of 88% in reports of counterfeit notes and coins. Instances of phishing, vishing and smishing reduced by 26% - such crimes are usually carried out online, via a phone call or text message. Insurance fraud, the figures showed, also dropped by 45%. The second highest rise in crime was in reports of arson, which increased by 20% compared to the first six months of last year. But it added that other examples of criminal damage, excluding arson, dropped by 14%. An Garda Síochána's provisional report showed a 16% reduction on last year in reports of child sexual abuse material and related offences. But it said that "nationally the number of sexual offences reported has increased" compared to the same time last year. It said there was a 4% rise in reports of rape and a 7% increase in sexual assault that were not aggravated. The provisional figures from gardaí also found an overall reduction of 2% in road traffic collisions up to 30 June this year compared to the same period last year. It said there were "over 22,100 road traffic collisions reported to An Garda Síochána" during this time. But gardaí said instances of people "driving while intoxicated" rose by 8%. In the six months to 30 June 2025, the report said gardaí initiated "over 27,000 arrests", with "over 67,000 criminal charges created". It also said officers made "over 6,500 referrals to the Juvenile Diversion programme in accordance with the Children's Act 2001".
