Keelings fruit company fails in bid for private hearing of whistleblower allegations
At the Workplace Relations Commission on Wednesday an adjudicator told the firm's representatives that the prospect of 'certain people being named' in connection with the case was not reason enough to justify hearing the matter out of the public eye.
Keelings Logistics Solutions had sought a private hearing into claims by the worker, former warehouseman Rudolph Csikos, which were called on Wednesday at the employment tribunal.
He has alleged breaches of the Minimum Notice and Terms of Employment Act 1973, the Unfair Dismissals Act 1977, the Organisation of Working Time Act 1997 and the Protected Disclosures Act 2014 against the company.
READ MORE
At the hearing, adjudicator Brian Dalton noted the application by the company's representative, Emily Maverley of the Irish Business and Employers' Confederation (Ibec), for a hearing 'in private'.
'That's quite unusual, because this case is about the administration of justice,' he said. 'I do have the power to have a hearing in private, but I have to have very good reasons for it,' he said.
'Certain wrongs, certain people being named – that in itself is not a reason,' he added.
'In the administration of justice, the whole process is tested, and ultimately I will make a ruling. You can't make an allegation of defamation in the administration of justice. It's up to me to decide,' he said. He added that the law required 'exceptional' circumstances for a private hearing.
Mr Dalton said he was only aware of the basis for the application for a private hearing at a 'high level' and said there was 'no point' discussing the detail any further with a member of the press in the room.
'I'm going to ask the press to leave temporarily,' he said.
The matter proceeded for around 25 minutes behind closed doors before Mr Dalton reopened the hearing to the public.
'An application was made for the hearing to be heard in private, and it was turned down,' he said.
After a short adjournment, Mr Dalton quoted a section of the Workplace Relations Act, as amended, to the parties.
He said the legislation required a hearing 'in public, unless the adjudicating officer… determines that due to the existence of special circumstances, the proceedings or part thereof should be conducted otherwise than in public'.
'In other words, most of this case will be heard in public,' Mr Dalton said.
The adjudicator gave May 27th as the date for a further hearing and adjourned the matter shortly after that.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Surviving Miami Showband members remember their bandmates on 50th anniversary of atrocity
Surviving members of the Miami Showband travelled north and south of the Border on Thursday, commemorating their former bandmates who paid the 'ultimate price' during the Troubles. Thursday marked 50 years since lead singer Fran O'Toole, guitarist Tony Geraghty and trumpeter Brian McCoy were murdered by loyalist paramilitaries on July 31, 1975, after the band was stopped at a bogus checkpoint outside Newry, Co Down. [ Miami Showband massacre 50 years on: 'The trauma lasts for ever' – Stephen Travers ] The fake army patrol attempted to hide a bomb on the band's tour bus before the device exploded prematurely, killing two of the would-be bombers. Their accomplices then opened fire on the band. On Thursday, beginning at the site of the attack on Buskhill Road, Ray Miller, Des Lee, Stephen Travers and their former road manager Brian Maguire then travelled to Newry, Dundalk and finally Dublin on Thursday. READ MORE Speaking at the site of the Miami Showband memorial on Parnell Square, Dublin, Mr Maguire (76) said: 'It never leaves you. 'Today has probably been the hardest day I've had in 50 years.' Miami Showband's Tony Geraghty, Fran O'Toole, Ray Millar, Des McAlea, Brain McCory and Stephen Travers. Photograph courtesy of Stephen Travers He said that on the night he had left the venue before the band, which was a rare occurrence. 'If I had been 20 seconds behind the boys, I'd have been stopped and shot as well. It never goes out of your memory. It's always a part of you,' he said. About 80 people congregated at the memorial on Parnell Square and heard how the band members sought to bring enjoyment to those north and south of the Border, but ended up paying the 'ultimate price'. Mr Travers said that for any victims of the Troubles '50 years is only like 50 seconds, because it's ever-present'. His abiding memory of that day, he said, was the 'cursing and anger' among those who had carried out the attack 'because it had all gone wrong for them'. He recalled rolling over on his back after the attack and staring at the moon after the men had left. 'Eventually, I started to crawl around through the bodies of my friends, and body parts of the unfortunate men who blew themselves up,' he said. Noting he had spent Thursday 'talking about the slaughter of three musicians', Mr Travers said: 'Every time I turn on the television at night time I see the slaughter of 60,000 people in Gaza. The genocide must stop. How can we possibly lament three musicians and our lost lives and not be just as vocal in lamenting theirs.' Mr Travers said the futility of violence and the failure of violence were 'something politicians should get their head around'. He said he was proud to have been a member of the band, saying: 'I ask myself why are we commemorating the Miami Showband. And the reason I came up with is because it's now much more than a band. 'Every single man and woman that ever stood on a stage north of the Border during those terrible times was a hero, every one of them, because they brought people together. 'And that's the legacy of the Miami Showband: wherever we played, people flocked together, whether they were Catholic, Protestant, unionist, nationalist, they came together. 'Sectarianism was left outside the door and people came into the ballrooms and saw each other as human beings and danced with each other. Sometimes, they fell in love.'
Irish Times
5 hours ago
- Irish Times
The Irish Times view on infrastructure provision: report is a sad indictment of the system
The report published by the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform this week on accelerating the provision of infrastructure in Ireland must lead to change. And pushing this through is a key task for Ministers. However, reading it also leads to some reflection on the scale of the opportunity Ireland has missed in recent years. During a time of plenty in the public finances, the scale of which may never be repeated, Ireland has not made the most of the available resources. The previous government took its eye off the ball. Major projects were not progressing, caught in a diplomatic and legal quagmire. Yet little was done and the result is now clear; a housing crisis and creaking infrastructure in areas like water and energy which threaten the policy response to this, as well as undermining the confidence of business investors. A host of problems identified in the report have been clearly evident for years: overly-complicated regulation, often with little purpose; decisions left to the courts due to judicial reviews; and an administrative system stuck in a pattern of risk aversion. The number of judicial reviews of planning decisions continues to rise, up 20 per cent this year on 2024. Many of these are on environmental grounds, but the report finds 'little evidence' that they are leading to better outcomes. The threat of legal review is also found to be driving an overly-cautious approach among regulatory bodies. The report might also have taken a closer look at the role of the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform itself. After all, it is the body responsible for the spending of State money and this goes beyond a requirement to watch the pennies. READ MORE This report, completed by the new infrastructure division in the department, is now to be forwarded to a special Accelerating Infrastructure Taskforce, a mix of private sector expertise and the key players from the public sector, chaired by Sean O'Driscoll, former chairman and chief executive of the Glen Dimplex Group. An action plan and recommended policy changes are to follow. There is clearly much to be done. The Government will hope that the new Planning Act can help, including by tightening the rules on judicial reviews. But a sweep of Ireland's regulatory practices is also needed. The planning application for Uisce Éireann's big project taking water from the Shannon to serve the Midlands and Dublin regions will likely extend to more than 30,000 pages. Proper oversight of such a major project is essential, but this scale of paperwork serves no useful purpose. Senior ministers, presenting the revised National Development Plan, made great play of talking about reforming delivery. They made no reference to the fact that they had all been in government when these problems were hiding in plain sight.
Irish Times
6 hours ago
- Irish Times
‘We are heartbroken': Gardaí conclude search related to missing Fiona Sinnott in Wexford
Gardaí have concluded a search of a parcel of land in south Wexford as part of the Fiona Sinnott murder investigation. The operation in Killinick took place from Thursday morning, close to where Ms Sinnott went missing. Ms Sinnott, the mother of an infant daughter, lived at Ballyhitt, Broadway, at the time of her disappearance and was last seen socialising in Butler's pub on February 8th, 1998 with friends. Gardaí have confirmed that the search and excavation finished on Thursday afternoon without success. READ MORE Family members met with Garda representatives at approximately 4pm and said they were 'devastated' that there had been no breakthrough after 27 years. Her family is appealing to anyone with knowledge relating to her disappearance to contact the Gardaí. Fiona's sister, Diane said: 'We, as a family, are heartbroken but we will not give up. The Gardaí are also devastated that this latest search did not bring up anything. They are as devastated as we are. The Gardaí say they will not give up and they will continue to try and locate Fiona. We, as a family, will also not give up. We move on. Perhaps the next search will bring a conclusion,' she added. The parcel of land close to the village was sealed off on Thursday morning, with heavy machinery and drones used to carry out a full technical and forensic examination of the site. This has been one of the longest running investigations in Wexford, with gardaí collating thousands of documents, reports, along with interviews as they try to bring closure for the family. Gardaí upgraded their investigation to murder, carrying out a significant amount of enquiries and interviews into the circumstances surrounding her disappearance. During the course of the investigation and searches carried out over different intervals, Wexford Gardaí also interviewed six people in relation to the investigation all of whom were released without charge. The last confirmed sighting of Fiona Sinnot was when the 19-year-old left the pub. A motorist said they saw a man and a woman on the road near Kisha Cross, a short distance from the pub, at around midnight. There were also two males in their late teens or early 20s close by. None of these four people have ever come forward, and gardaí said they are 'anxious to trace them or anyone who was in the vicinity who did not, or could not, come forward at the time'. A renewed appeal for witnesses was made in February 2023, on the 25th anniversary of Ms Sinnott's disappearance. Gardaí on Thursday said a search operation on open ground was set to begin at a location in Co Wexford. The area will be subject to excavation, technical and forensic examinations over the coming days. Road closures will be in place, and diversions will be in operation, the force said. Gardaí continue to appeal to anyone with any information who has not spoken to the force to come forward. Any person who may have previously felt they could not provide gardaí with all the information they had is urged to contact Wexford Garda station on 053 9165200, the Garda Confidential Line on 1800 666 111 or any Garda station.
