
Former Clare hurler Niall Gilligan 'lost it' and hit boy, 12, 'multiple times' with stick, court told
Ms Comerford told a jury at Ennis Circuit Court on Monday that Mr Gilligan 'lost control' on October 5, 2023, when he punished the boy for the damage being caused at the time to his Jamaica Inn hostel property in Sixmilebridge.
Ms Comerford was making her closing speech in the case where Mr Gilligan, aged 48 of Rossroe, Kilmurry, Sixmilebridge, denies the assault causing harm with a stick of the boy at the Jamaica Inn hostel, Sixmilebridge on October 5, 2023.
Defence closing speech
In his own closing speech, counsel for Mr Gilligan, Patrick Whyms BL said in no way is Mr Gilligan trying to suggest that he was entitled to punish the boy as was suggested and said that the injuries sustained by the boy 'are clearly regrettable'.
Mr Whyms said that on the evening at the Jamaica Inn hostel, Mr Gilligan 'didn't know that he was dealing with a child and did not create this situation'. He said that Mr Gilligan "was at the end of his tether" by the vandalism being done to a vacant property he was trying to sell.
Putting forward the defence of reasonable force against the charge of assault causing harm, Mr Whyms said that Mr Gilligan was at the Jamaica Inn hostel on the night of October 5 'in the dark and believed that he was under siege'.
He said: 'Believing himself under threat and needing to protect himself and his property, Niall Gilligan needs to make an instant decision and so we are here."
Mr Whyms, instructed by solicitor, Daragh Hassett, said: 'And Mr Gilligan, a family man who has young children and no previous convictions gives a clear story which hasn't changed and an entirely credible, fulsome account of what happened."
'Did Niall Gilligan use such force as was reasonable in the circumstances as he believed them to be and if he did then no offence was committed.'
In his prepared statement at Shannon Garda Station in February 2024 on the alleged assault, Mr Whyms said that Mr Gilligan 'has given a perfectly plausible account in an otherwise impeccably accurate description of what occurred which placed the boys inside the building when he met them'.
On the medical evidence, Mr Whyms said: 'Nobody wants to see a child being injured and it would be much better if that didn't happen and the boy was injured in this case.
There doesn't seem to be much room for argument that he was injured from the actions of Niall Gilligan.
Mr Whyms said that a displaced fracture of a finger on the boy's left hand 'is the only fracture in this case'. He said 'There was mention of dislocated shoulders, broken tibias and broken wrists all over the evidence but none of those things happened."
'There is an undisplaced fracture of a finger - that is not a good thing to happen but that it is what happened. There were injuries and these were sustained in the incident but by and large, most were cleared up in the week and the last one was pretty well cleared up in two weeks."
Mr Whyms said that the injuries 'don't look nice on the photographs - there is no getting away from that and injuries that are photographed immediately after don't look nice'.
Prosecution closing speech
Earlier in her closing speech Ms Comerford, instructed by State Solicitor for Clare, Aisling Casey, told the jury: 'This is a story of a man who lost his cool.'
She said: 'Instead of picking up the boy after he slipped and bringing him out to his car and driving him home and telling his parents, he hit him and lost it and he was angry and frustrated.'
Ms Comerford said that the alleged assault in broad daylight 'is the action of a man who took out his anger and frustration on a child. There is no evidence that his injuries were caused by anything other than his interactions with Niall Gilligan.'
She said that Niall Gilligan 'lost control and punished the boy for the damage and inconvenience caused to his property on a morning when he had to clean up human faeces and urine from his property'.
Ms Comerford said that the evidence of the then 12-year-old boy and his friend 'is credible and can be relied upon to the high standard beyond reasonable doubt'.
She said that the boy 'of course he knew that it's not okay to explore a building without permission, to let off fire extinguishers, to remove keys so he would have access to the building again, but he was a 12-year-old child and he was exploring and knew that others had been there before'.
Ms Comerford said that the boy "thought Niall Gilligan would threaten him with a stick. He didn't think he was actually going to hit him, but he did and he kept hitting him'.
She told the jury: 'I would suggest to you that the boy was shocked and in disbelief that this could happen - that a grown man would hit a child and not once and not a clip around the ear and a kick up the backside followed by a drive home to tell his parents to say what the child had been up to.'
Ms Comerford said that the boy knew that Mr Gilligan 'was a big strong man who he never thought would viciously assault him. You will recall him saying 'he was so big and I was so little' and Mr Gilligan was so big and the boy was so little.'
Highlighting the medical evidence, Ms Comerford said that the first medical report stated: 'Head injury, loss of consciousness, bowel incontinence, right shoulder injury query, right posterior elbow wound? left hand and wrist injury, left tibia wound exposure and maybe fracture.'
She said: 'In the later reports, there is a reference to an x-ray to his tibia and fibula which was suggestive of a non-displaced fracture and ultimately it doesn't appear that this was a fracture."
Ms Comerford said that 'it is understandable when you look at the photos why there may have been a query on fractures when you look at the level of bruising sustained by the body of the boy'.
She said that the boy slipped outside the Jamaica Inn and was lying on his stomach 'and you can see clearly the marks on both buttocks, the wrist injury, the shoulder bruising, the arm injury and the bruising around the ribs and the gash to his shin bone when he was hit over and over again".
She said: 'He lost consciousness for a while. He must have been hit multiple times in order to have sustained as many injuries as he did in the various locations you can see in the photos taken on the night and following day.
'The only evidence you have on how those injuries were caused is the boy's video statement who said that he was hit with a stick a number of times before he was knocked out.
'The reason why he knew he was knocked out is that he didn't remember that he was dragged and also had incontinence… He can be forgiven for thinking that he disclosed his shoulder when you see the extensive bruising all around his shoulder.'
Ms Comerford described Ms Gilligan's prepared statement given to gardaí at Shannon Garda Station in February 2024 as 'a self-serving fabricated story to justify an encounter with a 12-year-old child'.
She said that the account 'is purposefully vague' and 'I don't think you can believe anything that Niall Gilligan says about how he came to assault the young boy'.
Ms Comerford said in his statement Mr Gilligan says he got 'entangled in the dark and they fell on top of each other'.
She said:
Mr Gilligan didn't fall and get entangled with the boy. He beat him there and he knew it. He lost control, he was angry and frustrated and he needed to cover all angles and that is why he said that to the gardaí.
Ms Comerford told the jury that they should give greater weight to the evidence of the 12-year-old boy and his friend who allowed themselves to be subject to cross-examination from Mr Whyms on their evidence and 'withstood the cross-examination'.
Ms Comerford said that due to the level of force used by Mr Gilligan in the assault, the defence of self-defence should not be available to him.
At the conclusion of the closing speeches Judge Francis Comerford commenced his charge to the jury. Judge Comerford said that he will continue his charge to the jury on Tuesday.
When Judge Comerford completes his charge, the jury will then commence their deliberations.
Read More
Former Clare hurler Niall Gilligan accused of repeatedly beating 12-year-old boy with stick

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Irish Examiner
16 minutes ago
- Irish Examiner
Healy-Rae to make complaint against garda over 'shoving' incident on All-Ireland final day
Kerry TD Danny Healy-Rae has said he will make a complaint against a garda after an alleged shoving incident ahead of the All-Ireland football final. The incident took place on Sunday afternoon in Dublin City, where Kerry and Donegal fans were gathered ahead of the All-Ireland football final in Croke Park. Multiple videos, circulating on social media, shows Mr Healy-Rae walking through a large crowd of Kerry supporters near Brannigans pub. In the videos, Mr Healy-Rae raises his arms as he walks through the crowd to cheers from Kerry supporters, before a garda appears to shove him away. Mr Healy-Rae turns to talk with the garda, before walking away while the crowd boos. Mr Healy Rae said: I don't know what happened. I was walking here, minding my own business and the next thing this garda shoved me and he shouldered me. The TD also said that the garda 'effed and blinded' at him during the alleged incident. Asked if he planned on making a complaint against the garda, Mr Healy-Rae sad: 'I will, I will.' 'He needs to be brought to account for it,' Mr Healy-Rae said. However, Mr Healy-Rae said he has 'fierce respect' for the gardaí and they have a 'tough job'. 'It was just a very, very isolated incident.' He added the garda involved must have 'some spite for me'. In a statement, An Garda Síochána said it 'does not comment on unverified social media content'. 'Any person who wishes to report the conduct of a member of An Garda Síochána can do so by contacting Fiosrú,' the spokesperson added.


Sunday World
3 hours ago
- Sunday World
Gang boss's nephew named as ‘pivotal player' in crime gang was chief suspect in gun attack
Cab target Richard Treacy was undone by quantity surveyor's €315,713 estimate Richard Treacy is involved in the day-today running of the gang A nephew of Limerick crime boss Christy Keane, described as 'a pivotal player' in the notorious crime clan after pleading guilty to money laundering, was the chief suspect in a gun attack on hitman Nathan Killeen's brother. Richard Treacy admitted €100,000 from unknown sources had been spent on the house where he lives in Garryowen, Limerick. But a quantity surveyor who accompanied gardaí when a search warrant was executed at the house estimated the cost of the renovations was three times higher. The higher figure from the surveyor's report was referred to in High Court evidence last month in a case against his cousin Kieran Keane Jnr. Crime boss Christy Keane The Special Criminal Court heard this week that Treacy pleaded guilty on the basis that €100,000 had been spent on the house ,which was accepted by the State. Richard Treacy is a nephew of gang boss Christy Keane and a younger brother of Owen Treacy Snr. Owen Treacy Snr survived being abducted and stabbed multiple times by members of the Dundon-McCarthy gang in one of the most infamous incidents in Limerick's gangland feud. Kieran Keane Snr died in the same incident in 2003 for which five men were jailed for life. Richard Treacy is involved in the day-today running of the gang Today's News in 90 Seconds - July 27th Last month his first cousin Kieran Keane Jnr lost a case brought by the Criminal Assets Bureau to have properties and cash in Limerick declared the proceeds of crime. As part of that case there was evidence given to the High Court which gave an account of Richard Treacy's alleged criminal activity. An officer stated: 'He currently operates at the highest level within the Keane OCG and is a pivotal player in the day-to-day running of the criminal organisation.' The house in Garryowen 'He is very close with his cousin Kieran Keane and both are regularly observed in each other's company.' The same witness also stated how a surveyor carried out a detailed review of Treacy's home which included 'refurbishment, extension and redecoration.' The final estimate from the review carried out in 2021 came to €315,713. It was also stated that in the early stages of the feud with the McCarthy-Dundon gang that 'Richard was an active participant. 'He was a target of an attack by Frank 'Fat Frankie' Ryan (deceased) and Christopher McCarthy in June 2006 where he was attacked with weapons. He fled uninjured.' It also mentioned the killing of Daren Coughlan in November 2005 for which Treacy along with his cousin Joe Keane and Shane Kelly were convicted of manslaughter. It was stated this was 'a feud related attacked' as the victim had been a relation of David 'Frog Eyes' Stanners. Stanners, who has since died in prison, was serving a life sentence for the murder of Kieran Keane Snr and the attempted murder of Owen Treacy, Richard's brother. His brother Daniel Treacy, who was not involved in organised crime, was shot dead in 2010 by John Coughlan, Darren's brother. Treacy was also stated as being 'the principal suspect in the shooting of Gavin Killeen at O'Malley Park, Southill Limerick on 20 July 2006'. Gavin Killeen was a brother of McCarthy-Dundon gunman Nathan Killeen who is currently serving a life sentence for his role in the murder of businessman Roy Collins. Their sister Ciara was in a long-term relationship with gang boss John Dundon. Also cited were two incidents of violent disorder in in 2006 and 2015 in which Treacy was involved when members of the rival factions clashed in public. During this week's Special Criminal Court hearing, counsel for Treacy objected to garda evidence at the hearing that his manslaughter conviction was 'feud-related'. Counsel said it was an attempt to 'colour' the minds of the three-judge panel and made an application they recuse themselves. The application was denied. The case has now been adjourned for sentencing on October 20.


Irish Daily Mirror
4 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
GAA pay tribute to Fermanagh shooting victims at All-Ireland football final
The GAA have paid tribute to the victims of a fatal shooting in Maguiresbridge with a minute's applause at Croke Park ahead of Sunday's All-Ireland SFC final. Vanessa Whyte, who was 45, and her children, Sara (13) and James (14) died after they were shot at their home in the Co Fermanagh village on Wednesday. A male who also suffered gunshot wounds remains in a serious condition in hospital. Vanessa Whyte and her children were active members of two local GAA teams. In separate statements on Wednesday night, both St Mary's Maguiresbridge Gaelic Football Club and Lisbellaw St Patrick's Hurling Club offered "heartfelt condolences to the families and friends of those impacted by the tragic incident. Vanessa Whyte and her children, Sarah and James "We are working with the GAA at county, provincial and national level, to implement the Association's critical incident protocols. We will work closely with all appropriate services to ensure that those who require support at this difficult time can access it. "The deceased were all active and beloved members of our club. We will not be making any further comment at this difficult time." A murder investigation has been launched, and police are probing a triple murder and attempted suicide line of inquiry. Ahead of today's All-Ireland SFC final at Croke Park between Donegal and Kerry, a minute's applause was warmly received with a picture of the mother and children displayed on the big screen at Croke Park. Ulster champions Donegal, managed by Jim McGuinness, are hoping to win their third All-Ireland title today as they take on Jack O'Connor's Kerry, who are bidding to win the Sam Maguire Cup for the 39th time.