Justice or show? Maradona death trial at risk of collapse over judge's role; lawyer claims she was more like an ‘actress'
SAN ISIDRO (Argentina), May 27 — More than two months after it started, the trial of seven Argentine health professionals accused in the death of football legend Diego Maradona hangs in the balance over questions about a judge's impartiality.
The trial was suspended last week after defense lawyers said the judge's involvement in a documentary related to the case constituted a possible breach of her duty, influence peddling and even bribery.
The possible removal of Julieta Makintach, one of three judges presiding over the case, risks nullifying the proceedings.
Maradona died on November 25, 2020, at age 60, while recovering at home from brain surgery for a blood clot after decades battling cocaine and alcohol addictions.
He died of heart failure and acute pulmonary edema two weeks after going under the knife, and was found dead in bed by his day nurse.
Maradona's medical team is on trial in the Buenos Aires suburb of San Isidro over the conditions of his convalescence at a private home.
Prosecutors have described the football icon's care in his last days as grossly negligent.
The trial is set to reconvene Tuesday, where at least one lawyer is expected to ask for Makintach's recusal.
If she is removed from the case, it must be determined whether she can simply be replaced, or whether the trial must start afresh with a new panel of judges.
'This is a scandal of such magnitude that the whole world is talking about Argentine justice as the worst example,' Fernando Burlando, a lawyer for Maradona's daughters, told local radio last week.
At issue is the alleged use of cameras in the courtroom in violation of a ban on filming the trial.
Makintach had denied participating in or authorizing any filming, but footage shared in Argentine media over the weekend shows her allegedly being interviewed by a film crew on the eve of the trial starting.
'Compromised'
A producer, in a deposition seen by AFP, said they were filming a documentary about Makintach, as 'a judge and a woman,' but not the trial itself.
Burlando rejected the explanation and said he would ask for Makintach's recusal on Tuesday.
'She did not act like a judge but like an actress,' he charged.
'Everyone now feels that this (trial) is compromised,' added Mario Baudry, the lawyer for Maradona's ex-partner Veronica Ojeda.
'It's healthiest to start over from scratch,' he added.
The defendants risk prison terms between eight and 25 years if convicted of 'homicide with possible intent' – pursuing a course of action despite knowing it could lead to death.
The case so far has focused on the decision by Maradona's doctors to allow him to recuperate at home with minimal supervision and medical equipment, instead of a medical facility.
In her testimony, Maradona's daughter Gianinna said her father's carers had kept him in 'a dark, ugly and lonely' place and claimed they seemed more interested in money than his welfare. — AFP
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Free Malaysia Today
3 days ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Argentine court declares mistrial in Diego Maradona's death
Football legend Diego Maradona led Argentina to the World Cup in 1986. (EPA Images pic) BUENOS AIRES : A controversial decision by an Argentine judge paved the way for the court to declare a mistrial today in the case concerning the death of football legend Diego Maradona. One of three judges sitting on the bench, Julieta Makintach, resigned from the case on Wednesday, prompting the court to declare the mistrial. Maradona's seven-member medical team has been accused of negligence in his Nov 25, 2020 death as a result of cardiac arrest. Makintach had permitted a forthcoming documentary about the case entitled 'Divine Justice' to be filmed at the trial. Moreover, the prosecution showed clips of the judge walking through the court as part of a 90-second trailer. The trailer caused such a national outcry that Makintach said on Wednesday that she had 'no choice' but to resign from the proceedings. The judges stated that there would be a new trial, but did not indicate when that would occur. In addition, new judges will be selected via a lottery. The trial began on March 11 and dozens of witnesses had already testified. It was expected to conclude in the summer, but now that could be a new starting point. 'I trust we could have a sentence by the end of the year,' said Fernando Burlando, an attorney for Maradona's daughters Dalma and Gianinna Maradona. The family accused the medical team of failing to provide appropriate care for Maradona, 60, after his surgery for a hematoma that formed between his skull and brain. The surgery was performed in early November and he died weeks later during his recovery at a private home. The seven defendants all deny the charges and claim that Maradona fought against them during the recovery period. Maradona led Argentina to the World Cup in 1986 and the football-crazed nation did not capture it again until 2022.
The Sun
5 days ago
- The Sun
Judge in Maradona death trial steps aside after scandal
A judge under fire in the trial over Argentine football legend Diego Maradona's death stepped aside on Tuesday after defense lawyers questioned her impartiality. Julieta Makintach, one of three judges in the case, said she had 'no choice' but to recuse herself following a furor over her involvement in a documentary touching on the case. Her exit means Makintach might be replaced in the trial or it might even start over from scratch. Maradona died on November 25, 2020, aged 60, while recovering in a private home from brain surgery for a blood clot. His seven-person medical team is on trial over the conditions of his home convalescence, described by prosecutors as grossly negligent. The trial has been hanging by a thread for the past week after it emerged that Makintach was interviewed for a documentary relating to the case, for which unauthorized recordings were allegedly made inside the courtroom. Defense lawyers argued Makintach's actions may have constituted a breach of her duty to be impartial, as well as influence peddling and even bribery. Faced with demands for her recusal, the court suspended the trial a week ago. Makintach roundly rejected any bias but, under pressure, finally agreed to step down from this case. 'Given the request of all parties, I have no choice but to grant the recusal,' she said. 'Dark, ugly and lonely' Her removal means the proceedings might be nullified. At issue is the alleged use of cameras in the courtroom in violation of a ban on filming the trial. Makintach, 47, denied authorizing any filming during the trial, but her credibility was questioned after a trailer for a documentary showed her being interviewed by a film crew and walking through the courtroom. Maradona died of heart failure and acute pulmonary edema two weeks after going under the knife and was found dead in bed by his day nurse. The people responsible for his medical care in the final days of his life risk prison terms between eight and 25 years if convicted of homicide with possible intent -- pursuing a course of action despite knowing it could lead to death. The charges relate to their decision to allow him to recover at home and the conditions of his care. In her testimony, Maradona's daughter Gianinna said her father's carers had kept him in 'a dark, ugly and lonely' place and claimed they seemed more interested in money than his welfare. Some of the plaintiffs in the case called for a new trial, saying they felt the current proceedings has been tainted by the scandal involving Makintach. 'Everyone now feels that this (trial) is compromised,' said Mario Baudry, the lawyer for Maradona's ex-partner Veronica Ojeda. 'It's healthiest to start over from scratch,' he added.
The Sun
5 days ago
- The Sun
Judge recused in Maradona trial after documentary scandal
A judge under fire in the trial over Argentine football legend Diego Maradona's death stepped aside on Tuesday after defense lawyers questioned her impartiality. Julieta Makintach, one of three judges in the case, said she had 'no choice' but to recuse herself following a furor over her involvement in a documentary touching on the case. Her exit means Makintach might be replaced in the trial or it might even start over from scratch. Maradona died on November 25, 2020, aged 60, while recovering in a private home from brain surgery for a blood clot. His seven-person medical team is on trial over the conditions of his home convalescence, described by prosecutors as grossly negligent. The trial has been hanging by a thread for the past week after it emerged that Makintach was interviewed for a documentary relating to the case, for which unauthorized recordings were allegedly made inside the courtroom. Defense lawyers argued Makintach's actions may have constituted a breach of her duty to be impartial, as well as influence peddling and even bribery. Faced with demands for her recusal, the court suspended the trial a week ago. Makintach roundly rejected any bias but, under pressure, finally agreed to step down from this case. 'Given the request of all parties, I have no choice but to grant the recusal,' she said. 'Dark, ugly and lonely' Her removal means the proceedings might be nullified. At issue is the alleged use of cameras in the courtroom in violation of a ban on filming the trial. Makintach, 47, denied authorizing any filming during the trial, but her credibility was questioned after a trailer for a documentary showed her being interviewed by a film crew and walking through the courtroom. Maradona died of heart failure and acute pulmonary edema two weeks after going under the knife and was found dead in bed by his day nurse. The people responsible for his medical care in the final days of his life risk prison terms between eight and 25 years if convicted of homicide with possible intent -- pursuing a course of action despite knowing it could lead to death. The charges relate to their decision to allow him to recover at home and the conditions of his care. In her testimony, Maradona's daughter Gianinna said her father's carers had kept him in 'a dark, ugly and lonely' place and claimed they seemed more interested in money than his welfare. Some of the plaintiffs in the case called for a new trial, saying they felt the current proceedings has been tainted by the scandal involving Makintach. 'Everyone now feels that this (trial) is compromised,' said Mario Baudry, the lawyer for Maradona's ex-partner Veronica Ojeda. 'It's healthiest to start over from scratch,' he added.
