Western Digital convinces US judge to throw out $552.7 million patent award
By Blake Brittain
(Reuters) -Data storage provider Western Digital has convinced a California federal judge to reduce a $552.7 million award against it in a patent dispute over data encryption to just $1, according to a court order made public on Monday.
U.S. District Judge James Selna said the award for patent licensing company SPEX Technologies wrongly included damages for aspects of Western Digital's products that did not infringe the patent, wiping out a $315.7 million jury verdict plus an additional $237 million that he had previously determined Western Digital owed SPEX in interest.
Spokespeople and attorneys for the companies did not immediately respond to requests for comment on the decision.
San Jose, California-based SPEX was originally formed to license technology from Spyrus, a cryptography company that developed technology for encrypting sensitive communications. SPEX said in its 2016 lawsuit that Western Digital's self-encrypting hard drive products infringed a Spyrus patent covering data encryption innovations.
The lawsuit alleged that Western Digital data storage devices, including its Ultrastar, My Book and My Passport products, infringed the patent. Western Digital denied the allegations.
A jury in Santa Ana, California, ruled for SPEX last October. Selna said in his decision made public Monday that SPEX could only receive "nominal" damages for Western Digital's infringement, slashing the award to $1.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
10 minutes ago
- New York Post
NYC biz leaders left shaking over prospect of Zohran Mamdani mayoral win: ‘It would be disastrous'
They want none of his business. Big Apple business leaders are shaking in their boots that socialist Zohran Mamdani will pull off an upset win in Tuesday's Democratic mayoral primary and coast into Gracie Mansion, The Post has learned. Frightened movers and shakers said that a Mayor Mamdani would be 'disastrous' for New York City — with some loath to speak out publicly for fear of ticking off progressives and galvanizing the Queens assemblyman's lefty, anti-business base. 'It would be disastrous for the city,' said startup entrepreneur John Borthwick — who recently met the surging candidate during a Partnership For New York City meeting. Mamdani, who spent just three years in the workforce between graduating college in 2014 and being elected to the state Assembly in 2020, struck Borthwick as out of his depth. 'He's a very nice charming human who I think who has absolutely no idea what it would take to run a city government,' Borthwick, the CEO of Betaworks, said. 3 Zohran Mamdani's surge in the Democratic mayoral primary has some business leaders running scared. LP Media 'Given the challenges the city faces with the state budget and federal government, they will eat him for breakfast.' The business community's fear has been rising along with Mamdani's standing in the polls — culminating with an Emerson College Polling/Pix 11/The Hill survey Monday shockingly finding him edging out former Gov. Andrew Cuomo in eight rounds of ranked-choice voting. Mamdani's surge in the polls has been driven by his unabashedly socialist, freebie-heavy platform promising free buses, city-run grocery stores and higher taxes on the rich. But many business leaders such as billionaire John Catsimatidis — who threatened to close his Manhattan-based grocery chain Gristedes if Mamdani wins — have claimed that the Democratic socialist's proposals will lead to an exodus from the city. 3 Billionaire John Catsimatidis threatened to move his Gristedes grocery chain out of New York City if Mamdani wins. Stefan Jeremiah for New York Post Florida's Republican Gov. Ron DeSantis gleefully weighed in on the recent poll showing a Mamdani win by boasting of boon for the Sunshine State — at least for the well-to-do. 'Just when you thought Palm Beach real estate couldn't go any higher…' he wrote on X. Frank Garcia, national chairman of the Hispanic Chamber of Commerce, who lives in New York, bluntly said business leaders were very concerned about Mamdani getting elected. 'He's like Bill de Blasio. He's anti-business,' Garcia said. One New York business industry leader, who spoke with The Post under the condition of anonymity out of concern that Mamdani may actually win, said the outspoken progressive would bring 'uncertainty.' 'Uncertainty is never good for businesses, it's never good for the market,' he said, even going so far as comparing Mamdani to President Trump and his erratic tariff policy. 'It's almost like Trump in reverse,' he said. One of Mamdani's people-pleasing planks is a promise to raise New York City's minimum wage to $30 an hour by 2030. 'In the world's richest city, making the minimum wage shouldn't mean living in poverty,' his campaign's platform states. Tom Grech, president of the Queens Chamber of Commerce, said his borough's merchants — of whom 90% have 10 or fewer employees — are worried about Mamdani's promises. 'A $30 minimum wage is unsustainable,' he said. 'The average merchant can't afford a minimum wage increase now. That would kill the bottom line. They'd have to cut employees.' But other business leaders have publicly kept their concerns to themselves. 3 Kathryn Wylde, CEO for the Partnership For New York City, said business leaders have stayed silent in the Democratic primary because their 'kind words' are not helpful. Bloomberg via Getty Images Kathryn Wylde, CEO for the powerful Partnership For New York City nonprofit business group, said their silence isn't necessarily unusual, noting they don't typically comment on political races. 'Plus, they are not plugged into social media, so few were forewarned about the possible far-left direction of the mayoral race,' she said. 'Many have some history with Cuomo — as some pundit put it 'the devil they know' — who was looking for their dollars but not for public endorsement in a Democratic primary, where kind words from the business community are not helpful.'
Fox News
10 minutes ago
- Fox News
Top 5 scams spreading right now
Lately, I've had way too many calls on my shows from people who have lost thousands (sometimes hundreds of thousands) to scams. These are so cleverly evil, it's like Ocean's Eleven but starring a dude with three Instagram followers and a ChatGPT subscription. Last chance to enter to win $500 in giveaway. Enter now! You see, we're way past scam emails from sketchy Nigerian princes. Today's scams are slick, personalized and powered by scary-good tech like AI voice cloning and deepfakes. And yep, people fall for them every single day. Here are today's scummy front-runners, plus how to protect your cash, pride and sanity: 1. The AI voice clone This one's horrifying because it sounds like someone you trust. Scammers grab a clip of your child's, spouse's, boss' voice from social media, podcasts or even your voicemail. Then they call your mom, your grandpa, your partner: "Hi, it's me. I'm in big trouble. I need money. Don't tell anyone." It's not them. It's AI. And it works because it feels real. Anthony in Los Angeles was deceived by scammers who used AI to replicate his son's voice. Believing his son was in distress, Anthony transferred $25,000 to the fraudsters. If you get a call like this, call or text the person. Try someone they live or work with. 2. 'Your bank account's frozen' You get a text or call from your "bank," and the number looks legit. They say your account is locked due to suspicious activity and you need to confirm your info. Stop right there. That link? Fake. The person on the phone? Also fake. Charles in Iowa lost over $300,000. Always open your bank's app or type the web address in yourself. Never tap the link they send. 3. Crypto investment 'friend' This starts on Instagram, Facebook or LinkedIn. Someone friends you, chats you up, gains your trust, then casually mentions they're making a fortune in crypto. They even offer to show you how. Suddenly you're handing over money or access to a wallet, and poof, it's gone. A couple in Georgia lost $800,000 after falling victim to a cryptocurrency scam. Just because someone's friendly doesn't mean they're honest. Don't fall for a stranger friending you on social media. If you're lonely, volunteer somewhere. 4. Gold bar scam You get a call from someone claiming to be with the FBI or your bank's fraud team. They say your money's at risk, and you need to withdraw it, convert it into gold bars and turn it over for "safekeeping." A 72-year-old retiree from New Hampshire was scammed into purchasing $3.1 million worth of gold bars and turned it over to the scammer. Yes, it sounds insane, but it's happening, and people are losing everything. Come on, you know that real law enforcement doesn't operate this way. 5. Vet emergency A neighbor's crying. Your dog's been hit by a car. They rushed your fur baby to the vet and paid the bill. You owe them $1,200. But wait ... your pup is fine, snoring on the couch. You've been pet-shamed into Venmoing a scammer. If any of this sounds familiar, your gut is whispering danger or you're not sure what might be happening in a situation, reach out to me. I'll help you figure out what's real and what's a scam. Better to ask than get burned. I won't judge you, I promise. Get tech-smarter on your schedule Award-winning host Kim Komando is your secret weapon for navigating tech. Copyright 2025, WestStar Multimedia Entertainment. All rights reserved.
The Verge
18 minutes ago
- The Verge
Phew: Apple fixed the Finder icon in macOS Tahoe 26
Apple's first macOS Tahoe 26 developer beta introduced a big change to the Finder icon that I really didn't like, but thankfully, the company has reversed it with the second beta released today. A big feature of macOS 26 is Apple's new Liquid Glass design language, which it has applied across the operating system to give it a new look. But for some reason, for the initial version of the updated Finder icon, Apple bucked tradition and flipped the location of its blue and white elements. An outrage! Fortunately, Apple has seen reason and shifted the colors back to their rightful places with the Finder icon in developer beta 2. 9to5Mac has a handy comparison. The second macOS 26 developer beta also includes an option to add a background back to the menu bar, 9to5Mac reports, which should help make it more legible. The second iOS 26 developer beta got a good change to Control Center to help improve legibility, too.
