Man jailed for nine years after leaving woman brain damaged
She told BBC Scotland News she has had to learn how to walk, talk and swallow again after spending six months in hospital.She said the way she speaks has changed since the attack."I don't like my speech now," she said. "Sometimes, I listen back to old voice notes [of myself]. I used to speak really fast."
Ms O'Reilly had broken bones in her back, neck, cheek bone, eye-socket and nose.She has had three surgeries on her brain, including a craniectomy. This is where part of the skull is removed to operate and the bone is kept alive in the abdomen.She said she now struggles to do some everyday things such as putting a bobble in her hair."I can't put a bra on either, I need to wear a sports one," she said. And trying to grab stuff with my hand is hard."I'm just tired all the time, I don't really go out that much, I don't trust people."Ms O'Reilly has questions over how police handled events that night.Officers turned up at the scene but the court heard it appeared Harvey had managed to "talk his way out of handcuffs", despite Ms O'Reilly's condition.She said police then put her in their van with her attacker and dropped them at Glasgow Royal Infirmary.Harvey made her leave without receiving medical treatment.The pair returned to the hotel they were sharing in Glasgow city centre. Harvey had to carry Ms O'Reilly back to their room where the assault continued.She was discovered unconscious by hotel staff the following morning when they were late for checkout and police were called."Why, why did they leave me with him and put me in the back of the van with him," she said."They should have separated us - one of them take me to the hospital, the other take him to the cells, until they could watch the CCTV."She said the footage showed her head being hit off bus stops."It could've been a murder, I could've died. And my kids would've been left without a mum."
No access to report
The BBC put these points to Police Scotland, asking why Ms O'Reilly was not separated from her attacker, why Michael Harvey was not arrested and if Police Scotland would apologise to her.Police Scotland said: "On Sunday, 1 October, 2023, officers attended at Waterloo Street, Glasgow following a report of an assault. After carrying out inquiries at the scene and speaking to witnesses, no criminality was established at the time."The injuries presented did not require an ambulance to be called, however the attending officers took two people to hospital for assessment."Police Scotland referred the circumstances of the incident to the Police Investigations & Review Commissioner (Pirc) who made one recommendation which has been implemented."We have not received a complaint relating to this case, however we would encourage anyone with concerns to come forward and speak to us."Pirc gave its findings to the chief constable in December last year.Ms O'Reilly has never been given access to the report. The BBC also requested to see it but was refused.BBC Scotland News asked Police Scotland who Ms O'Reilly should contact directly to ask for the report but they declined to answer.
'Carol has changed as a person'
Her sister Donna O'Reilly said it shouldn't be so difficult for the family to get answers."The victim should be priority. Because it's them that need the answers to move forward," she said."It's been very hard because Carol has changed as a person and obviously we're trying to make sure she's OK."And we can't give her the answers she needs because we don't know them…so it's been hard."The family say what they need now is closure.The sentencing of Harvey is one step towards that.But Ms O'Reilly is still left with questions and no clear direction as to how she gets answers.When asked what she wants for the rest of her life, she said: "To be a mum again, obviously it's hard being a full-time mum."But I was always active with them. And now I can't do stuff like that."BBC Scotland News asked Pirc for its findings in the case.It said: "We investigated the circumstances surrounding the serious injury of a 39-year-old woman on 1 October 2023 in Glasgow following police contact."Our report was provided to the chief constable and is now a matter for Police Scotland. We consider our report to be confidential and therefore have nothing further to add."Our reports are confidential for various reasons such as ongoing legal proceedings, protection of anonymity or matters relating to data protection."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
29 minutes ago
- The Independent
Why three concert-goers are suing Royal Albert Hall for £500,000
Three long-standing Royal Albert Hall seat holders have launched a High Court lawsuit against the venue's corporation, seeking over £500,000 in damages. Arthur George and William and Alexander Stockler allege the Royal Albert Hall has "unlawfully" deprived them of their rights to their seats by excluding them from more performances than its rules permit. Their legal representatives are asking a judge to declare the exclusion practice unlawful, grant an injunction, and award an interim payment of £500,000. The Royal Albert Hall corporation opposes the application, arguing the case should proceed to trial. The corporation also suggests the claimants' complaints are linked to "various financial matters" and that they consented to or acquiesced in the granting of additional exclusive lets.
The Independent
29 minutes ago
- The Independent
Essex Police aware of video which appears to show vehicle drive into protester
Police have confirmed a video which appeared to show a police vehicle drive into a protester in Essex has been reported to them. It comes after violent clashes outside the Bell Hotel in Epping, which is believed to house asylum seekers, in recent days. On Thursday night, eight officers were injured during altercations between protesters and police with those hurt sustaining injuries to their hands as well as cuts and grazes. A video circulating on social media on Thursday evening appeared to show a police vehicle as it drove towards a number of protesters who were standing in the road, before appearing to collide with at least one person. Essex Police Assistant Chief Constable Stuart Hooper told the PA news agency the video had been reported to the force, but said they had seen another video 'which maybe shows it from a different angle'. 'And I guess the angles and perceptions show a different thing,' he added. 'So I'm not sure that exact incident is as it's been reported in the media.' The police chief promised to hold criminals to account for 'selfish and mindless' violence and vandalism following the events on Thursday night. A group of protesters started with a peaceful demonstration in Epping town centre, before moving onto the Bell Hotel, where things later turned violent. There have been a number of demonstrations outside the hotel since Essex Police charged 38-year-old asylum seeker Hadush Gerberslasie Kebatu with sexual assault following an incident where he is alleged to have attempted to kiss a 14-year-old girl. He denied the charge when he appeared at Chelmsford Magistrates' Court on Thursday. Mr Hooper said his team were now combing through CCTV to identify those responsible 'for assaults on our staff, through to damage and abhorrent language that was used'. 'Then we can start knocking on doors and bring those involved to justice that were responsible for that selfish criminality,' he said. 'But we also want to work with the community to facilitate people using their voice in peaceful protests.' At a press conference on Friday, Mr Hooper spoke of two people who have been arrested – one on suspicion of affray following reports of an assault during a protest on Sunday, and the other for failing to comply with dispersal orders. Mr Hooper said the man accused of affray, 65-year-old Dean Walters, has since been charged and the second suspect remains in custody. During a protest on Sunday, fireworks were let off and eggs were thrown outside the hotel. On Friday afternoon, a security guard remained on site at the Bell Hotel, opening the gate in the fencing and the door of the hotel to let people in and out. Fencing has since been put up to surround the hotel, accompanied with no entry signs. There are also warnings forbidding photography and filming in the vicinity of the hotel. Broken glass and remnants of flares remain on the ground from the incident. Mr Hooper believes that, although there are polarised views in Epping surrounding the hotel holding asylum seekers, a lot of those responsible for the violence came from further afield. He said: 'We actually saw last night we believe outsiders from our communities. People have come from outside their local areas into Epping to commit acts of violence and damage. 'That was really disappointing to see, because we know our communities wanted a voice and wanted to tell us what was going on, and they were peaceful in their activity. 'I've seen some of the social media comments and spoken to a number of members of the community, and there are polarised views. 'But it's our role as police to be independent and to, without fear or favour, make sure that people have the right to peaceful protest. 'What I won't stand for is those mindless acts of vandalism and violence that we saw and making sure that we are very robust in supporting our communities. 'Our communities don't want to see this violence, and they want to have their voice heard peacefully.' One resident living next to the Bell Hotel, who did not want to be named, said: 'It's all horrible. Epping is a very nice place. 'It is very unfortunate that this has attracted people from outside the area. 'They [those staying in the hotel] haven't given us any safety concerns. The safety concerns are from those protesting. 'The police will be here tonight, they were here last night. 'But I know there's a lot of mixed views in the town about the hotel.'
The Independent
29 minutes ago
- The Independent
UK sanctions Russian spies who ‘targeted Britain in sustained campaign'
Britain has hit more than a dozen Russian spies with a wave of sanctions, targeting those it accused of running a 'sustained campaign' of malicious activity against the UK. The Foreign Office named 18 officers from Russian spy agency the GRU, as well as hitting three of its units with measures aimed at cracking down on Vladimir Putin's increasing aggression abroad. It said the military intelligence officers targeted were 'responsible for spreading chaos and disorder on Putin's orders', and included those who had targeted the family of former Russian spy Sergei Skripal. The officers sanctioned had targeted a device belonging to Mr Skripal's daughter Yulia with malicious malware known as X-Agent five years before GRU attempted to murder them in Salisbury with the deadly Novichok nerve agent. The units are also accused of conducting a prolonged campaign of cyberattacks across Europe, including in Britain, aimed at destabilising the continent and undermining democratic institutions. 'GRU spies are running a campaign to destabilise Europe, undermine Ukraine 's sovereignty and threaten the safety of British citizens," Foreign Secretary David Lammy said. He added: 'The Kremlin should be in no doubt: we see what they are trying to do in the shadows and we won't tolerate it. That's why we're taking decisive action with sanctions against Russian spies.' On 15 March 2022, shortly after Russia invaded Ukraine, Unit 26165 carried out online reconnaissance on civilian bomb shelters in Mariupol, southern Ukraine and in Kharkiv, eastern Ukraine, the Foreign Ministry said. One of the targets was the Mariupol theatre. Civilians sheltering inside from Russian bombs had painted the word 'children' outside in the hopes they would be spared. But the next day, the theatre was hit by Russian airstrikes, killing about 600 people, including children, according to an Associated Press investigation. In 2013, officers from the same unit had targeted the daughter of former Russian spy Sergei Skripal with malware, designed to harm or infiltrate computer systems, the foreign ministry said. In 2018, Mr Skripal and his daughter Yulia were poisoned with the nerve agent Novichok in the English city of Salisbury, in an attack the British government said was organised by Russian intelligence. The sanctions also targeted the Africa Initiative, which the Foreign Ministry said employed Russian intelligence officers to carry out information operations in Africa, including undermining public health programs and destabilising various countries. Russia's campaign of sabotage and disruption across Europe ranges from cyberattacks and propaganda to arson and attempted assassination. Mr Lammy said: 'Putin's hybrid threats and aggression will never break our resolve. The UK and our allies' support for Ukraine and Europe's security is ironclad.' More than 70 different attacks have been attributed to Russia by Western officials since the invasion. The military intelligence units sanctioned Friday also targeted foreign aid to Kyiv, ports, infrastructure and border crossings as well as technology companies, the Foreign Ministry said. Although targeting GRU officers with sanctions is likely to have limited effect, the ministry said the goal is to raise awareness of Russia's campaign and raise the cost to people working for its services, including making it harder for them to travel.
