Court dismisses Running Aces lawsuit against 5 tribal casinos
A lawsuit filed by Running Aces Casino accusing other casinos of allowing illegal games was dropped in federal court.
The lawsuit alleged the casinos were illegally offering class III card games and video games of chance.
Five tribal casinos, Treasure Island Resort and Casino, Grand Casino Hinckley, Grand Casino Mille Lacs, Mystic Lake and Little Six, were all named in the lawsuit.
(FOX 9) - A Running Aces Casino lawsuit that accused five tribal casinos of offering illegal card and video games of chance was dismissed.
The lawsuit, filed in spring 2024, was dismissed in federal court on Tuesday.
READ MORE: Mystic Lake, Little Six casinos named in Running Aces lawsuit alleging illegal video games
Court records show the lawsuit aimed to recover damages and that Running Aces was seeking an injunction against the illegal gambling activities.
What they're saying
The concluding line in the dismissal filing states, "As noted, the gaming that is challenged in this lawsuit is of enormous economic importance to the absent Tribes, and protecting the economic sustainability of tribes is a primary goal of IGRA specifically and federal Indian policy generally. The Court therefore has little trouble concluding that the Tribes' interests in protecting a critical source of funds and jobs outweigh Running Aces's interest in a forum for its claims of competitive injury."
The court document also states, "Running Aces—a bitter competitor of the Tribes—is seeking to impose crushing personal financial liability under RICO on dozens of current and former employees of the casinos."
READ MORE: Running Aces Casino files federal lawsuit against 3 Minnesota casinos
When the lawsuit was first filed last year, Shakopee Mdewakanton Sioux Community, which owns Mystic Lake and Little Six, shared this statement in response:
"Running Aces' lawsuit has no merit. All gaming conducted at Mystic Lake and Little Six Casinos complies with tribal law, federal law, and the gaming compact that was executed in 1989.
"Winning in court is not Running Aces' real purpose in filing this case. It is a desperate stunt to attack the good reputation of tribes and tribal gaming. This lawsuit is intended to mislead the public and influence the final stages of the Minnesota Legislature's 2024 session."
The full dismissal can be viewed below:
Click to open this PDF in a new window.
The other side
Running Aces President and CEO Taro Ito said he was surprised by the dismissal, saying the case wasn't dismissed on merit, but on procedural issues.
He maintained the casinos named in the lawsuit are offering illegal gambling activity.
"What recourse does a competitor or individual have when they feel like they've been harmed or damaged by a tribal casino? It appears there isn't any available, because it's required to have tribes as an indispensable party. Obviously, the tribes will just claim sovereign immunity and the case is thrown out."
Ito added that Running Aces will seek to appeal the dismissal and will pursue all legal remedies available.
The full lawsuit filed by Running Aces can be viewed below:
Click to open this PDF in a new window.
The backstory
The lawsuit was initially filed under the federal Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organization (RICO) Act, naming high-level executives at tribal-owned casinos.
Those casinos include Mystic Lake and Little Six, which are owned by the Shakopee Mdewakanton Sioux Community, Grand Casino Hinckley and Grand Casino Mille Lacs, which are owned by Mille Lacs Band of Ojibwe, and Treasue Island Resort and Casino, owned by the Prairie Island Indian Community.
The lawsuit alleged the casinos have "illegal and unfair competitive advantages over Running Aces" by offering class III card games that were not authorized by the Tribal Gaming Compact or the State of Minnesota.
According to the Minnesota Alcohol and Gambling Enforcement, Class III gambling includes "common casino games such as video games of chance (slot machines and video poker), roulette, craps, baccarat, and banking card games such as blackjack. Class III gambling is conducted under a compact that each tribe negotiates with the government of the state in which it is located."
The lawsuit aimed to recover damages, with Running Aces seeking an injunction against the alleged illegal gambling activities, according to a press release from the casino.
The Source
Documents filed in federal court and past FOX 9 reporting.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Boston Globe
a day ago
- Boston Globe
Michael Cardozo, 84, New York City's longest-serving chief lawyer, dies
'Some people thought I was going to be a lawyer from the day I was born,' he told Advertisement From 1996 to 1998, Cardozo served as president of the New York City Bar Association, which was established in 1870 to ferret out corruption in the court system. One of its first investigations led to the resignation of Albert Cardozo, a state Supreme Court justice who was Benjamin Cardozo's father. Get Starting Point A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday. Enter Email Sign Up Michael Cardozo was a partner at Proskauer Rose (formerly Proskauer, Rose, Goetz & Mendelsohn) when he was appointed as the city's corporation counsel by Mayor Michael Bloomberg in 2002. He stepped down in 2014, returning to Proskauer after setting a record for longevity in that municipal role, which was established in 1839. As corporation counsel, Cardozo presided over almost 700 lawyers, who juggled a caseload of some 80,000 lawsuits and other legal matters at the city's Law Department. Advertisement As the city government's top lawyer, he successfully argued before the U.S. Supreme Court in 2007 that the federal courts could resolve disputes between localities and foreign governments over delinquent property taxes. The case, Permanent Mission of India v. City of New York, involved the Indian and Mongolian missions to the United Nations in New York. Cardozo successfully oversaw the case in which a federal judge ruled in 2009 that legislation by the City Council enabled Bloomberg to seek a third term, despite limits imposed by the city charter. He also defended the Police Department's stop-and-frisk strategy, whose critics said it disproportionately singled out Black and Hispanic men (the tactics were ruled unconstitutional by a federal judge in 2013). He defended a city policy of inspecting carry-on bags in the subway; argued in favor of a provision that would have allowed the city to borrow $2.5 billion to pay off 1970s-era debt; and argued, again successfully, for the city's right to impose smoking bans in bars and restaurants as well as additional gun controls. In 2019, back at Proskauer, Cardozo represented Judith Clark, the getaway driver in a 1981 robbery of a Brink's armored car in Rockland County, New York, in her efforts to win parole after serving 37 years in prison. She won the case. Cardozo retired from the law firm in 2022, a month after Gov. Kathy Hochul of New York named him to the state ethics commission. In a recent statement on Instagram, Bloomberg said he had recruited Cardozo 'not only for his sharp legal acumen, but also for his unassailable integrity and lifelong commitment to the city's civic health.' Michael Alan Cardozo was born June 28, 1941, in Manhattan. His mother, Lucile (Lebair) Cardozo, was a school administrator; his father, Harmon Cardozo, was a real estate executive. Advertisement Cardozo grew up on the West Side of Manhattan and in Westport, Connecticut. After graduating from Staples High School in Westport, he earned a bachelor's degree in political science from Brown University in 1963 and a Juris Doctor degree from Columbia Law School in 1966. He went on to clerk for Judge Edward C. McLean of U.S. District Court in Manhattan and then joined Proskauer in 1967; he became a partner in 1974. When David Stern, a law school classmate who was also a partner at the firm, was named commissioner of the NBA in 1984, Cardozo began representing the NBA, and later MLS and the NHL as well. In 2002, as the city's new corporation counsel, Cardozo inherited a department that was scattered in dozens of locations after being displaced the year before by the 9/11 attack on the World Trade Center, which was a block from the main office. At the Law Department, he created new divisions that focused on volunteer work and specialized in labor law and other issues, and he refused to settle suits against the city that were deemed frivolous. 'We certainly want to send the message,' he told The New York Times in 2013, 'that if you don't bring what we view to be a meritorious case, you're going to have a big battle on your hands.' During his time with the Law Department, the city settled a number of lawsuits involving police abuse and also defended against challenges to the beefed-up security it imposed after the 9/11 attack. Reflecting on his tenure as the city's chief legal officer, Cardozo told students at Columbia Law School in a 2014 lecture that in defending or enforcing existing laws on behalf of the city, he was sometimes compelled to take a stance that he may have disagreed with personally. One example, he said, was when the city appealed a court ruling declaring that the state's prohibition on same-sex marriage was unconstitutional. Advertisement In addition to his daughter Sheryl, Cardozo is survived by his wife, Nancy (Cogut) Cardozo, whom he married in 1965; another daughter, Hedy Cardozo; and three grandchildren. Cardozo was particularly focused on the judicial system. He lobbied for higher pay for judges, who were overworked, he said. (At one point, he was a member of the New York State Commission on Legislative, Judicial and Executive Compensation.) And he expressed frustration with the court system over what he called its repeated delays in trial decisions. In 2009, he said publicly that the 'entire culture' of the judicial system 'must be changed' to 'improve judicial accountability and, with it, judicial performance.' For those comments, he was rebuked in a letter published in The New York Law Journal and signed by 18 of 20 state Supreme Court justices. In an online tribute after Cardozo's death, Bret Parker, the executive director of the New York City Bar Association, singled out Cardozo's 'long-standing commitment to the rule of law and tireless advocacy for an independent judiciary.' This article originally appeared in
New York Post
a day ago
- New York Post
NY grandparents who vanished on religious trip found dead in embankment
A family of upstate New York grandparents who went missing while on a religious road trip were found dead next to their car in West Virginia on Saturday, police said on Saturday. The four elderly relatives, identified by authorities as Dr. Kishore Divan, 89, Asha Divan, 85, Shailesh Divan, 86, and Gita Divan, 84, were on a road trip from Buffalo to the Palace of Gold, a historic Hindu site in Marshall County, West Virginia, when they disappeared Tuesday. They were found dead next to their wrecked Toyota Camry along Big Wheeling Creek Road on Saturday, the Marshall County Sheriff's Office said on Facebook. 3 Four elderly members of the Divan family from upstate New York disappeared on a road trip and were found dead. Facebook Sheriff Mike Dougherty said their bodies were found along a steep embankment around 9:30 p.m. 'First responders were on the scene for more than five hours,' he said. 'Sheriff Dougherty extends his condolences to the families of the victims. The group was last seen around 2:45 p.m. Tuesday when their license plate was detected by a Pennsylvania state trooper while they traveled on I-79, WTOL-TV News reported. It is unclear exactly how the four, who are all of Indian descent, are related. 3 The Divan grandparents had booked a room at the Palace of Gold retreat in West Virginia but never arrived. Associated Press Photo 3 Police said the four missing New Yorkers were last seen in Pennsylvania Tuesday and were found Saturday. Christopher Sadowski According to the Hindustan Times, they had booked a room at the religious retreat for Tuesday night but never arrived — with their last known stop a Burger King in Pennsylvania. Prabhupada's Palace of Gold in Moundsville was erected in the 1970s by the followers of Srila Prabhupada, a spiritual leader from India who spread the teachings of Hare Krishna before his death in 1977. It remains a historic Hindu retreat.
Miami Herald
a day ago
- Miami Herald
4 missing on trip to ‘America's Taj Mahal' found dead in WV mountains, cops say
Four New York residents who went missing while on a road trip to a famous Hindu temple have been found dead in the West Virginia mountains, officials told news outlets. The group of four — identified as Kishore Divan, Asha Divan, Shailesh Divan and Gita Divan — died in an apparent crash, and they and their vehicle were found Saturday, Aug. 2, at 9:30 p.m., the Marshall County Sheriff's Office said in a news release. Authorities have not said what may have led to the crash, but the vehicle was located 'off a steep embankment along Big Wheeling Creek Road' in northern West Virginia. According to the sheriff's office, a family member called and reported that the group left from Buffalo earlier in the week and was heading to Prabhupada's Palace of Gold, but days passed and they never arrived, WIVB reported. A motorist driving along Big Wheeling Creek Road noticed damage to a road sign and vehicle debris, which led deputies to the crash location, the station reported. The group ranged in age from 81 to 89, according to the station. Big Wheeling Creek Road is about 5 miles away from Prabhupada's Palace of Gold. The palace, sometimes referred to as 'America's Taj Mahal,' was constructed in the late 1970s, on top of what was once a garbage dump, by followers of the Hare Krishna movement, according to the Smithsonian. It is a shrine inside the community of New Vrindaban, in honor of Hare Krishna's founder, who died before construction was completed. Investigators say there were signals from cell phones belonging to the group in the nearby areas of Moundsville and Wheeling on Wednesday, July 30, but they had not answered their phones since the previous day, WTRF reported. The 'Divan family is a pillar of Indian Community of (Western New York),' the Hindu Cultural Society of Western New York said in an Aug. 3 Facebook post. 'It is with deep sadness that we announce the passing away of Dr. Kishore Divan, Mrs. Asha Divan, Mr. Shailesh Divan and Mrs. Gita Divan,' the post read. 'Dr. Divan's contributions to our community has been long and sustained. He was the founding member of Hindu Cultural Society of WNY and the India Association of Buffalo. Both Dr. Kishore Divan and Mrs. Asha Divan were well-known, familiar and recognizable faces in the Indian community. Their absence will leave a lasting void in our WNY community.' New Vrindaban is a roughly 270-mile drive southwest from Buffalo.
