logo
Sharia Court, in any name & form, has no recognition in law: SC

Sharia Court, in any name & form, has no recognition in law: SC

NEW DELHI:
In a significant judgment, the Supreme Court has held that a 'Court of Kazi,' 'Court of (Darul Kaja) Kajiyat,' 'Sharia Court,' etc., by whatever name or style, have no recognition in law. The Court made this ruling while allowing a Muslim woman's maintenance plea filed under Section 125 of the Criminal Procedure Code.
The bench of the top court delivered this judgment after hearing a plea filed by a woman, Shahjahan, who was challenging the Allahabad High Court's 2018 order.
The order had dismissed her revision petition against a 2010 family court decision in Jhansi, which denied her maintenance. The family court had only allowed Rs 2,500 for her two children.
A two-judge bench of the top court, led by Justice Sudhanshu Dhulia and Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah, stated that any declaration made by such courts is not binding on anyone and is unenforceable by coercive measures.
"The only way such a declaration or decision can withstand scrutiny in the eyes of the law is when the affected parties accept such declaration/decision by acting on it or accepting it, and when such action does not conflict with any other law. Even then, such declaration/decision, at best, would only be valid inter se the parties that choose to act upon/accept it, and not a third party," the bench said.
Explaining the legal position, the top court referred to various previous judgments, including Vishwa Lochan Madan versus Union of India. It cited a case where a Muslim man initially filed a plea in a 'Court of Kazi' and 'Court of (Darul Kaja) Kajiyat' seeking divorce from his wife.
In the present case, the family court had allowed only Rs 2,500 for her two children.
As per records, the marriage between the appellant and the respondent (husband) was solemnized on September 24, 2002, according to Islamic customs, rituals, and traditions. This was the second marriage for both parties.
The top court held that maintenance could not have been denied to the appellant-wife under the prevailing circumstances. It directed the payment of Rs 4,000 per month as maintenance to her, starting from the date of filing the maintenance petition before the family court.
The top court also said, "A family court is not an institution to sermonize society on morality and ethics."
The appellant woman had claimed that her husband had caused mental harassment and cruelty to her because she was unable to fulfill his demand for a motorcycle and Rs 50,000.
On this, the family court had stated that since it was their second marriage, there was no possibility of the man demanding dowry, as he would be trying to rehabilitate his household.
The top court, after reviewing the family court's observations and order, stated that such reasoning or observations were unknown to the canons of law and were based on mere conjecture and surmise.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Kolkata wards stay on edge after night of violence, locals blame outsiders for unrest near police stations
Kolkata wards stay on edge after night of violence, locals blame outsiders for unrest near police stations

Time of India

timean hour ago

  • Time of India

Kolkata wards stay on edge after night of violence, locals blame outsiders for unrest near police stations

People in Maheshtala stayed awake the whole of Wednesday night as fear of vandalism and looting continued to grip this locality where Hindus and Muslims have always lived peacefully. The locals claim that the rampage of the previous day was the handiwork of outsiders who destroyed people's vehicles, pelted stones on houses and looted shops even as policemen and the residents were attacked. And what baffles them the most is that the violence erupted in Kolkata's Ward No-7 which is in close proximity to Nadial police station in South 24 Parganas and Rabindranagar Police Station. Shah Alam Shah, who owns a readymade garment shop in Akra Fatak Fultala area, blamed the police for not taking action promptly. "The incident happened at a stone's throw from the police station but no one intervened for the first few hours. Hindus and Muslims have been living together in harmony. We never attack each other," Shah told ET. Opposite Alam's house, lives Piyali Devi, who said, "I was born here and have been living here for the past 50 years. I have never seen an incident like this. We have Muslim neighbours and the locals were not engaged in the attack. We are very scared. Stones were pelted and the attack continued for hours." by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Elegant New Scooters For Seniors In 2024: The Prices May Surprise You Mobility Scooter | Search Ads Learn More Undo According to the Diamond Harbour Police Superintendent Rahul Goswami, trouble started over building of a tulsi mancha where a woman from the minority community used to sell fruits. "There is an allegation by a group of a tulsi mancha," he said. What followed was mayhem. Live Events "I had a narrow escape. It all started when a mob of Muslims gathered and headed to the market. They vandalised my shop. The miscreants have broken the lock and destroyed everything. I have six family members and they are scared. There has been loss of over ₹50,000," Kuldeep Thakur, who runs a barber's shop, told ET. Thakur's shop was strewn with glasses, pieces of cosmetics bottles, scissors and broken chairs. Gopal Basu and RajKamal Das, who work at a roadside eatery, said, "Our eatery was vandalised and we were beaten up. There were young boys in the mob who were around 12 to 15 years."

Day after clashes on Kolkata outskirts: 40 arrestehttps://twitter.com/homed, 7 FIRs registered
Day after clashes on Kolkata outskirts: 40 arrestehttps://twitter.com/homed, 7 FIRs registered

Indian Express

timean hour ago

  • Indian Express

Day after clashes on Kolkata outskirts: 40 arrestehttps://twitter.com/homed, 7 FIRs registered

At least 40 people have been arrested and seven FIRs have been registered within 24 hours of the clashes that broke out in the Rabindranagar area of Maheshtala in South 24 Parganas district, and soon spread to the adjacent Nadiyal area in Kolkata on Wednesday afternoon. Five policemen, including a woman cop, were injured in the clashes that broke out over a dispute regarding the spot of a Muslim fruit vendor's cart and the planting of a Tulsi plant near a temple in the Rabindranagar area. While 28 people were arrested by police in South 24 Parganas district, 12 were arrested by the Kolkata Police. DIG (Presidency Range) Akash Magharia said, 'So far, three cases have been filed and 28 people arrested by the West Bengal Police.' Joint Commissioner of Police (Crime, Kolkata) Rupesh Kumar said: 'A total of four FIRs have been registered at the Nadiyal police station based on complaints from police personnel. Twelve people were arrested by the Kolkata Police last (Wednesday) night.' The West Bengal Police, in a statement on X, confirmed the coordinated action, saying, 'None of those who have indulged in violence will be spared.' 'The situation is now peaceful and under control. Prohibitory orders under 163 BNSS have been imposed in the Rabindranagar PS area in the interest of peace. Representatives of all political parties or groups are advised not to visit the area till 163 BNSS is in place,' it said. The authorities have also appealed for calm and urged citizens to refrain from spreading misinformation on social media. 'Those attempting to incite unrest will be dealt with strictly, in accordance with the law,' the police said. Earlier in the day, police stopped state BJP president Sukanta Majumdar from going to Maheshtala. Majumdar then went to Kalighat to protest outside Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee's residence along with supporters. He was detained, and later released. Sweety Kumari Police on Thursday said they have seized explosives in Budge Budge area, near Rabindranagar where clashes took place a day ago. Police said they arrested five people while they were carrying materials used in bomb-making and are investigating whether it was linked to the clash. Superintendent of Police (Diamond Harbour) Rahul Goswami said: 'Around 8:45 pm yesterday (Wednesday), acting on intelligence inputs, the police intercepted three bikes and recovered a large cache of explosive materials. These included substantial quantities of sodium powder, over 10 kg of aluminium powder, phosphorus dust, red sulphur, and iron dust — all used in making crude bombs.' 'Five arrests have been made in connection with the seizure', the SP said, adding one of them — Nabin Chandra Roy — has admitted, during the questioning, that he is an active RSS and BJP worker. 'On the day of Ram Navami, he was seen at the Bata More, where a verbal altercation occurred over the rally route and barricades. We have video footage where he could be seen throwing police barricades,' the SP said.

Action Against Former Delhi Official Over Irregularities In Educational Infrastructure
Action Against Former Delhi Official Over Irregularities In Educational Infrastructure

NDTV

timean hour ago

  • NDTV

Action Against Former Delhi Official Over Irregularities In Educational Infrastructure

New Delhi: Disciplinary proceedings will be held against SR Meena -- a former Executive Engineer of the Public Works Department -- for alleged irregularities in the construction of classrooms under Samagra Shiksha Abhiyan during the Aam Aadmi Party government. Delhi's Lieutenant Governor VK Saxena has approved a proposal from the vigilance department for this. The decision comes after serious irregularities were allegedly identified in the implementation of the Samagra Shiksha Abhiyan, a Central initiative aimed at enhancing educational infrastructure in Delhi, which was allocated Rs. 38.37 crore for the construction of 226 classrooms across various schools. SR Meena is currently serving with CPWD in Amritsar. The misconduct dates back to 2019, but the case against another officer, Krishan Pal. Former AAP ministers Manish Sisodia and Satyendra Jain were summoned by the Anti-Corruption Branch earlier this week over allegations of financial irregularities of around Rs 2,000 crore in the construction of over 12,000 classrooms and semi-permanent structures in the city's government schools. Officials said investigation revealed several lapses on the part of the PWD, including how the funds were diverted from one school to another - instead of classrooms, halls were being made. The situation escalated when a petition was filed in the Delhi High Court, asking the court to direct the government to hand over possession of six newly built school buildings. The litigation prompted the Chief Secretary to investigate the matter, during which significant irregularities in construction practices and fund management were uncovered.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store