Some ECE rule changes ‘dangerous'
Unreported broken bones, a child being thrown in the bin and staff openly contemplating suicide are among the complaints being highlighted by a Dunedin early childhood education campaigner.
ECE Parents' Council spokeswoman Michelle De Bono said the complaints were made by parents using a form on the organisation's website.
The complaints showed the situation was already concerning enough, but she was worried changes the government was introducing to the sector could make it even worse.
The changes — which have come from the Ministry of Regulation — that will be implemented over the coming months would no longer require Early Childhood Education (ECE) services to prominently display information about how to make a complaint to the ministry.
ECE centres would also not have to display a copy of the regulations, the current licence certification, and the names and qualifications of staff.
"They're literally gutting the licensing criteria."
She said while many in Dunedin and nationwide were spoilt for choice when it came to "quality" ECE centres, many others were not so lucky.
This was made clear in the 80 complaints her organisation had received and passed on to the Ministry of Education.
Mrs De Bono said one parent made a complaint to the ECE centre their child attended when a head teacher put her child in a rubbish bin for swearing.
The parent said the centre then shared her identity to the head teacher, leaving them feeling "vulnerable and distressed".
A father also reported his son's arm being broken twice within the span of eight weeks while attending their ECE centre.
The child's parents requested the CCTV footage, but were told they would not be able to see anything in the video anyway.
The father said he felt "that they have neglected my son in taking care of him".
A teacher at an ECE centre reported other staff working at their centre had talked about killing themselves on the floor.
They said the staff member said "f ... this" and talked about drugs and rape in front of the children.
Vapes would fall out of a colleague's pocket while she was working and the woman made obscene gestures at children and told them to shut up, the teacher said.
Mrs De Bono said removal of signage meant parents would not be able to easily find out how to go about filing a complaint, and sometimes it would not be appropriate to ask the ECE centre directly for that information.
"Those who are fortunate enough to be sending their babies and children to quality centres should be also advocating against these changes because it could all just change with this current government."
She said there were "a whole heap of Kiwi parents out there" who were not satisfied and happy, and many others who were afraid to come forward.
She said parents should know that sleep checks were going to be changed to every 15 minutes, and there would be no requirement for an adult to be present in the sleep room at all times.
"The report has been accepted by Cabinet, and this is happening, and this involves your children and babies."
"It's pretty significant, and dangerous — and it seems to be flying under the radar."
Mrs De Bono said she encouraged caregivers who were unhappy with the standard of care or education at their children's ECE centre to complain using MyECE's online form.
"Complaining about poor-quality practice can help raise the bar for ECE services for all whānau and tamariki," she said.
The Ministry of Regulation did not respond to a request for comment.
laine.priestley@odt.co.nz
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scoop
a day ago
- Scoop
Faster Access To Neurosurgery For South Islanders
Minister of Health Fewer South Island patients are waiting for life-changing neurosurgery, with more people getting the specialist treatment they need faster, Health Minister Simeon Brown says. 'Neurosurgery is vital for treating serious brain and spinal conditions that can dramatically affect lives if left too long,' Mr Brown says. 'Putting patients first means making sure every Kiwi can access timely, quality healthcare when they need it, and that is exactly what our focus is on for the South Island.' Between November 2023 and March 2025, the number of people waiting for neurosurgery in the South Island has fallen by 22 per cent, from 98 to 76. The number waiting longer than four months for surgery has dropped by 45 per cent, from 31 to 17. 'This is great progress, and it is making a real difference to people's lives. 'Whether it is a parent needing urgent brain surgery to be there for their children, or a worker recovering from spinal treatment and returning to their community, this is about delivering for patients.' This improvement follows a difficult period when the neurosurgery waitlist in the South Island rose by 92 per cent between 2020 and 2023, putting extra pressure on patients and health services. 'These results show our focus on reducing waitlists is delivering. We are investing in surgical teams, boosting capacity, and working closely with hospitals to ensure more New Zealanders get the specialist care they need sooner. 'This progress also reflects the hard work and dedication of our frontline health professionals, whose commitment to patient care is critical to achieving these results. 'We're also focused on ensuring that the longest waiting patients get the care they need. That's why it's encouraging to see not only the total waitlist coming down, but the number of people waiting more than four months reducing at a faster rate of 45 per cent. 'This is all part of our plan to provide timely, quality healthcare for every New Zealander. If you need specialist treatment like neurosurgery, you should be able to get it when you need it.' Reducing wait times for elective procedures is a key priority for this Government. Our health target is clear – by 2030, 95 per cent of patients will be treated within four months. 'Patients are still waiting too long, and there is still more work to do, but this latest data shows we are heading in the right direction,' Mr Brown says.
NZ Herald
3 days ago
- NZ Herald
Letters: We shouldn't rush NCEA education reforms
It seems that this discussion is only just getting started, and if the Government truly wants a better system, it must listen to all those affected, not just industry leaders. If we really want a better system, proper consultation is needed, not yet another flawed scheme for teachers and students to grapple with. Vivien Fergusson, Mt Eden. Putting faith in AI After listening to Erica Stanford: AI marking will save money clearly but, having been on a marking panel, teachers learn valuable skills by marking that cannot be learned any other way. Also, student misconceptions abound. AI marking will save teachers from the internal marking. So what do they have left? Mock exams and homework? Learning is the key now, not understanding. One just needs to be able to say the right phrase. After all, AI has to mark it. I suppose the devil is in the fine print. Looks like we need to start teaching our grandchildren times tables again. It is as if we are back in the 1990s: Academic and non-academic pupils. Bright and dumb. The neurodiverse have just been sold out? We need to climb up the international rankings just to look good - a political stunt. Steve Russell, Hillcrest. Humans and the health system In 1999, a landmark report on patient safety in the American healthcare system was published. Its abbreviated title was 'To Err is Human'. The burden of that report was that human error occurs throughout the healthcare system and has patient safety consequences. The answer is not to blame the humans involved but to design a system that makes such errors less likely. A case in point is the recent instance reported in the Herald of a series of errors in the dispensing of the adult dosage of a medication to a baby. It might seem surprising that this could happen passing through the hands of three different people, but one wonders about the underlying system. In a properly designed electronic system for prescribing and dispensing medications, an entry of an adult dosage against a baby's identification should automatically generate a red flag. This would be a fail-safe. We should be paying more attention to enhancing the digital capabilities of our health system with inbuilt checks to make such instances of human error less likely. Peter Davis, Emeritus Professor, University of Auckland. Milk it for all it's worth A spoof announcement from the Ministry of Crypto-Dairy Affairs (MoCDA): In response to spiralling global butter prices — and the unwavering Kiwi passion for innovation — we proudly unveil ButterCoin, New Zealand's first dairy-backed digital currency. Finally, a coin as smooth as our export spreads. Key features of ButterCoin: Temperature-Sensitive Risk Protocol: Market stability will now hinge entirely on keeping things chilled. Once the market curdles, spreading risk becomes as futile as warm toast. Powered by ByreChain: Our revolutionary blockchain — or 'cowchain' — technology tracks every pat of ButterCoin from pasture to portfolio. Moo-ve over Bitcoin. Trading floor renamed The Churn: Investors will churn out profits daily, provided they don't get skimmed in the process. Elite trader upgrade – CreamCoin: High-volume dairy tycoons will be granted CreamCoin status, giving them exclusive access to the VIP Milking Lounge and first dibs on pasturefront NFTs. MoCDA Statement: 'This currency isn't just dairy-driven — it's full-fat financial futurism. Finally, a way to milk economic volatility for every drop.' Coming soon: Our launch event, Crypto & Cows, featuring live blockchain branding and a butter sculpture of Satoshi Nakamoo-to. Ready to churn your future into riches? Let's whip this market! Paul Coyle, Browns Bay. Names and passports In regards to the editorial last week (July 30) and the name on our passports, the passport is a legal document. 'Aotearoa' is not yet officially or legally a name for New Zealand. Therefore, it should not have the prominent position. The country's official name must take precedence. This is not to say that 'Aotearoa' should not be on the cover. Maybe we could have 'Nu Turani' on the passport, as this was the name used in the Māori version of the Treaty of Waitangi, or Nu Tīreni, which was used in the Declaration of Independence in 1835. Ian McGovern, Kerikeri.
NZ Herald
3 days ago
- NZ Herald
Three evacuated from Antarctica in RNZAF daring mid-winter rescue
Three people in urgent need of medical attention were rescued by a Royal New Zealand Air Force C-130J Hercules crew. Photo / Supplied 'Although they determine it is safe, it's still an extremely challenging environment to fly in on night vision goggles due to the extreme weather conditions, which are highly changeable at this time of year and makes accurate forecasting a challenge. 'This, coupled with there being no airfields available to divert to once the aircraft is past a certain point south adds to the risk, so these missions are not taken lightly. The patients are now getting the medical treatment they need in Christchurch, he said. The medical evacuation was launched after the United States' National Science Foundation requested urgent help. Photo / Supplied The aircraft flew to Antarctica with NZ Defence Force medical personnel, including a medical officer on board. The aircraft had been pre-positioned from Auckland to Christchurch on Sunday afternoon, with the crew waiting for a window in the weather to complete the flight. The crew made the decision to fly on Tuesday afternoon and worked through the night. Antarctica is in 24-hour darkness at this time of year. Photo / Supplied Once on the ice, the aircraft's engines were kept running to keep them warm while it was refuelled, known as 'hot refuelling', before the aircraft returned to Christchurch. The evacuation took about 19.5 hours, including the short time on the ice. The US Embassy has since expressed its deep appreciation to the Royal NZ Air Force. The patients are now receiving medical treatment in Christchurch. Photo / Supplied 'This mission wasn't just difficult; it was one of the most technically demanding operations an aircrew can face. In extreme conditions, with little margin for error, the RNZAF executed this mid-winter Antarctic medevac flawlessly,' said Chargé d'Affaires, Melissa Sweeney. The Embassy said this RNZAF mission brought hope in the middle of the Antarctic night. 'We are so very grateful. Our Kiwi partners didn't hesitate to undertake this mission in one of the most unforgiving environments on Earth. Their skill and readiness are truly world-class,' she said. RNZAF successfully undertook similar rescues in 2021 and 2024. 'Only the best crews can pull off something like this and the RNZAF proved, again, that they're among the very best. This isn't luck, its professionalism, planning, and a level of capability that few can match,' said Chargé d'Affaires, Sweeney. She noted that the aircrew had to contend with a challenging combination of extreme conditions to land a large aircraft in freezing temperatures, on ice and in darkness wearing night vision goggles. 'This required absolute precision. It was daring, dangerous, and deeply courageous. This is the kind of mission that tests every ounce of skill and bravery. RNZAF delivered, just as they always do.'
