Environmentalists question Henry Puna's role in deep sea mining firm
Henry Puna.
Photo:
Pacific Islands Forum
Environmentalists in the Cook Islands have criticised former Prime Minister and Pacific Islands Forum (PIF) head Henry Puna for joining the board of a deep sea mining company.
Puna, who finished his term as PIF secretary general in May last year, played a pivotal part in the creation of multi-use marine park,
Marae Moana
, in 2017.
The marine protected area extends over the entire country's exclusive economic zone (EEZ), covering an area roughly the size of Mexico. It prohibits large-scale commercial fishing and seabed mining within 50 nautical miles of each of the 15 islands.
Puna has now joined the board of deep sea mining company Cobalt Seabed Resources (CSR) - a joint venture between the Cook Islands government and the Belgium company Global Sea Mineral Resources.
CSR is currently undertaking exploration in the Cook Islands EEZ, along with two other companies. It also has an exploration licence in the Clarion-Clipperton Zone, located in the high seas in the central Pacific Ocean.
Also read:
Environmental advocates say Puna's new role conflicts with his conservation work.
The Te Ipukarea Society said Puna was interested in the deep sea mining industry while simultaneously pushing for the creation of Marae Moana during his time as Prime Minister.
"It is something to be wary about with his new role and maybe how he will go about green washing how the deep sea mining company operates within our waters and their actions," the environmental charity's director Alana Smith said.
While in parliament, Puna was an MP for the Northern Group atoll, Manihiki.
Manihiki resident Jean-Marie Williams said Puna is a good man
However, Williams believes the benefits of deep sea mining will not be seen on his island.
"We could make money out of it," he said. "But who's going to make money out of it? Definitely not the people of Manihiki.
"The corporat[ions] will make money out of it."
However, William Numanga, who previously worked for Puna as a policy analyst, does not view it like that.
"Remember, Henry lives on an atoll, up north, so if there is any effect on the environment, he would be first to know," Numanga said.
"I do not think he will be putting aside a lot of the environmental concerns or challenges. He will be making sure that those environmental concerns are factored into this development process," he added.
Henry Puna ended his term as the PIF secretary general in May 2024.
Photo:
RNZ Pacific / Eleisha Foon
He believes Puna's "passion for environmental protection", coupled with his desire for economic development, makes him a good fit for the role.
Auckland doctoral student Liam Koka'ua said the company, which has the aim of extracting valuable minerals from the seabed, goes against the purpose of Marae Moana.
"If you truly believe Marae Moana is a place that must be protected at all costs and protected for our sustained livelihood and future and be protected for generations to come, then I don't think rushing into an experimental industry that could potentially have huge impacts is aligned with those intentions," Koka'ua said.
RNZ Pacific has made multiple attempts to reach Puna for comment, but has yet to receive a response.
However, in a statement, he said CSR is "uniquely placed to make advances for the people of the Cook Islands".
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
3 days ago
- RNZ News
Nauru, Metals Company revise deep sea mining agreement
Nauru President David Adeang at the 53rd Pacific Islands Forum Leaders' Meeting in Nuku'alofa, Tonga. 25 August 2024 Photo: RNZ Pacific / Lydia Lewis Nauru has revised its commercial agreement with Canadian mining group The Metals Company for deep sea mining in international waters. The updated "sponsorship agreement" was announced in a press release from The Metals Company. It comes at a time of increasing uncertainty in the deep sea mining industry with both the US and International Seabed Authority (ISA) respectively stating each offers a licencing pathway to mine the seabed in international waters. Nauru president David Adeang said in the press release that The Metals Company has been a "trusted and respectful" partner to Nauru. "We have worked to establish a responsible pathway for deep sea mineral development, one that can serve for a model for other developing states." The area of international waters currently under the spotlight is the Clarion Clipperton Zone - a vast area of the Pacific Ocean that sits between Hawai'i, Kiribati and Mexico, and spans 4.5 million square kilometres. The zone is of high commercial interest because it has an abundance of polymetallic nodules that contain valuable metals like cobalt, nickel, manganese and copper, which are used to make products such as smartphones and electric batteries. The minerals are also used in weapons manufacturing. Nauru has special rights in the Clarion Clipperton Zone through the ISA, which under the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) has jurisdiction over it. Since 2011, Nauru has partnered with The Metals Company to explore its area of the zone for minerals through that framework. At the same time, the ISA - which counts all Pacific nations among its 169-strong membership - has been developing a commercial mining code. The process, which began in 2014 and is ongoing, has been criticised by The Metals Company as effectively blocking it and Nauru's commercial mining interests. The company has also praised the US deepsea mining licencing pathway , which was effectively reactivated through an executive order President Donald Trump issued in April. That legislation, the Deep Sea Hard Mineral Resources Act, states the US can grant mining permits in international waters. At face value, it offers an alternative licencing route to commercial seabed activity in the high seas to the ISA. However, any cross-over between jurisdictions and authorities remains untested. The Metals Company Photo: Facebook / The Metals Company In the press release from The Metals Company, its chief executive Gerard Barron made direct reference to Trump's order, titled 'Unleashing America's Offshore Critical Minerals and Resources'. He said he was heartened by its call "for a joint assessment of a seabed benefit-sharing mechanism" and was certain that "big ocean states" like Nauru would continue to play a leading role in the deep sea mining industry. The company confirmed two weeks ago it would not be applying for a commercial mining license through the ISA in June. Instead, it has said it would apply exclusively apply through US regulations. No mention of that decision was made in the press release. "We remain unshakeable in our commitment to developing this project responsibly, transparently, and in a way that delivers real benefits to Nauruans," Barron said. ISA secretary general Leticia Carvalho has previously said the US had no authority to offer permits in the Clarion-Clipperton Zone. "Circumventing the regulatory authority of the ISA not only breaches international law, but also erodes trust," Carvalho said. In addition to Nauru, Tonga, Kiribati and the Cook Islands have special rights in the Clarion Clipperton Zone through the ISA.
RNZ News
3 days ago
- RNZ News
Nauru, Metals Company announce revised deep sea mining agreement
Nauru President David Adeang at the 53rd Pacific Islands Forum Leaders' Meeting in Nuku'alofa, Tonga. 25 August 2024 Photo: RNZ Pacific / Lydia Lewis Nauru has announced an update to its commercial agreement with Canadian mining group The Metals Company for deep sea mining in international waters. The updated "sponsorship agreement" was announced in a press release from The Metals Company. It comes at a time of increasing uncertainty in the deep sea mining industry with both the US and International Seabed Authority (ISA) respectively stating each offers a licencing pathway to mine the seabed in international waters. Nauru president David Adeang said in the press release that The Metals Company has been a "trusted and respectful" partner to Nauru. "We have worked to establish a responsible pathway for deep sea mineral development, one that can serve for a model for other developing states." The area of international waters currently under the spotlight is the Clarion Clipperton Zone - a vast area of the Pacific Ocean that sits between Hawai'i, Kiribati and Mexico, and spans 4.5 million square kilometres. The zone is of high commercial interest because it has an abundance of polymetallic nodules that contain valuable metals like cobalt, nickel, manganese and copper, which are used to make products such as smartphones and electric batteries. The minerals are also used in weapons manufacturing. Nauru has special rights in the Clarion Clipperton Zone through the ISA, which under the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) has jurisdiction over it. Since 2011, Nauru has partnered with The Metals Company to explore its area of the zone for minerals through that framework. At the same time, the ISA - which counts all Pacific nations among its 169-strong membership - has been developing a commercial mining code. The process, which began in 2014 and is ongoing, has been criticised by The Metals Company as effectively blocking it and Nauru's commercial mining interests. The company has also praised the US deepsea mining licencing pathway , which was effectively reactivated through an executive order President Donald Trump issued in April. That legislation, the Deep Sea Hard Mineral Resources Act, states the US can grant mining permits in international waters. At face value, it offers an alternative licencing route to commercial seabed activity in the high seas to the ISA. However, any cross-over between jurisdictions and authorities remains untested. The Metals Company Photo: Facebook / The Metals Company In the press release from The Metals Company, its chief executive Gerard Barron made direct reference to Trump's order, titled 'Unleashing America's Offshore Critical Minerals and Resources'. He said he was heartened by its call "for a joint assessment of a seabed benefit-sharing mechanism" and was certain that "big ocean states" like Nauru would continue to play a leading role in the deep sea mining industry. The company confirmed two weeks ago it would not be applying for a commercial mining license through the ISA in June. Instead, it has said it would apply exclusively apply through US regulations. No mention of that decision was made in the press release. "We remain unshakeable in our commitment to developing this project responsibly, transparently, and in a way that delivers real benefits to Nauruans," Barron said. ISA secretary general Leticia Carvalho has previously said the US had no authority to offer permits in the Clarion-Clipperton Zone. "Circumventing the regulatory authority of the ISA not only breaches international law, but also erodes trust," Carvalho said. In addition to Nauru, Tonga, Kiribati and the Cook Islands have special rights in the Clarion Clipperton Zone through the ISA.
RNZ News
6 days ago
- RNZ News
Air Rarotonga founder knighted in King's Birthday Honours
Ewan Smith with his wife Fenny Photo: Supplied Air Rarotonga chief executive officer and owner Ewan Francis Smith has been knighted for services to Cook Islands business and tourism. Smith said he is still coming to grips with the award. He started Air Rarotonga in 1978 and had grown to be one of the largest businesses in the country, employing more than 95 percent of locals. "The last 50 years have gone in a blur really; it's been so busy," Smith told RNZ Pacific. Read more: Smith said he didn't expect the company to become such a success. "You have obviously high hopes and aspirations for it, but it's had its moments. "It's only when you look back over that length of time that you realise how significant the company's become." A tough moment for the company was when the Cook Islands shut its borders in 2020. All Air Rarotonga employees were put on minimum wage, including Smith. "It was the only way we were going to survive. You had to figure out how to how to get through a two or three-year hiatus without burning all your cash and that's how we did it." Smith provided mentorship, counselling and budget advice to staff during the period. Air Rarotonga CEO Ewan Smith has been knighted for services to Cook Islands business and tourism Photo: Supplied He said staff are considered family and many people had been working with the company their entire lives. "There's no way anybody's going to be left behind. We couldn't do that; we were all in that together." During the pandemic the airline maintained essential cargo and medevac services throughout the Cook Islands including air logistics for the Covid vaccine rollout. The airline also helped get vaccines out to eastern Kiribati. Smith arrived in Rarotonga in 1973 as a 22-year-old pilot and aircraft engineer and only expected to be on the island for three or four years. Smith said he's always had an entrepreneurial desire. "If you spend some of your childhood selling plums on the side of the road, you kind of get it. "Once you get into things, they just get bigger and bigger and more and more complex, and you develop a lot of experience at it." Ewan Smith with his wife Fenny Photo: Supplied He said his contributions that led to his award were not done on his own. "I relied on a lot of other people and I share this honour, particularly with my wife, Fenny and the family, along with everybody at Air Raro, Paradise Islands and Cook Islands tourism. "They've all committed their working lives, through thick and thin." In 2019 Smith was appointed a Companion of the New Zealand Order of Merit for his services to Cook Islands business and tourism. He has chaired Cook Islands Tourism since 2010, has previously chaired the Association of South Pacific Airlines and is a former President of the Cook Islands Chamber of Commerce. In 2023 he oversaw the launch of the new vaka Teariki Moana in Aitutaki, hosting Pacific leaders attending the 52nd forum leaders meeting. Smith has been a patron of the Rarotonga Golf Club since 2005 and is a fellow of the King's College Foundation.
