Latest news with #TeIpukareaSociety
RNZ News
19-05-2025
- Business
- RNZ News
Environmentalists question Henry Puna's role in deep sea mining firm
Henry Puna. Photo: Pacific Islands Forum Environmentalists in the Cook Islands have criticised former Prime Minister and Pacific Islands Forum (PIF) head Henry Puna for joining the board of a deep sea mining company. Puna, who finished his term as PIF secretary general in May last year, played a pivotal part in the creation of multi-use marine park, Marae Moana , in 2017. The marine protected area extends over the entire country's exclusive economic zone (EEZ), covering an area roughly the size of Mexico. It prohibits large-scale commercial fishing and seabed mining within 50 nautical miles of each of the 15 islands. Puna has now joined the board of deep sea mining company Cobalt Seabed Resources (CSR) - a joint venture between the Cook Islands government and the Belgium company Global Sea Mineral Resources. CSR is currently undertaking exploration in the Cook Islands EEZ, along with two other companies. It also has an exploration licence in the Clarion-Clipperton Zone, located in the high seas in the central Pacific Ocean. Also read: Environmental advocates say Puna's new role conflicts with his conservation work. The Te Ipukarea Society said Puna was interested in the deep sea mining industry while simultaneously pushing for the creation of Marae Moana during his time as Prime Minister. "It is something to be wary about with his new role and maybe how he will go about green washing how the deep sea mining company operates within our waters and their actions," the environmental charity's director Alana Smith said. While in parliament, Puna was an MP for the Northern Group atoll, Manihiki. Manihiki resident Jean-Marie Williams said Puna is a good man However, Williams believes the benefits of deep sea mining will not be seen on his island. "We could make money out of it," he said. "But who's going to make money out of it? Definitely not the people of Manihiki. "The corporat[ions] will make money out of it." However, William Numanga, who previously worked for Puna as a policy analyst, does not view it like that. "Remember, Henry lives on an atoll, up north, so if there is any effect on the environment, he would be first to know," Numanga said. "I do not think he will be putting aside a lot of the environmental concerns or challenges. He will be making sure that those environmental concerns are factored into this development process," he added. Henry Puna ended his term as the PIF secretary general in May 2024. Photo: RNZ Pacific / Eleisha Foon He believes Puna's "passion for environmental protection", coupled with his desire for economic development, makes him a good fit for the role. Auckland doctoral student Liam Koka'ua said the company, which has the aim of extracting valuable minerals from the seabed, goes against the purpose of Marae Moana. "If you truly believe Marae Moana is a place that must be protected at all costs and protected for our sustained livelihood and future and be protected for generations to come, then I don't think rushing into an experimental industry that could potentially have huge impacts is aligned with those intentions," Koka'ua said. RNZ Pacific has made multiple attempts to reach Puna for comment, but has yet to receive a response. However, in a statement, he said CSR is "uniquely placed to make advances for the people of the Cook Islands".
RNZ News
05-05-2025
- Politics
- RNZ News
Cook Islands environment group calls on govt to speak out against US Trump's deep seabed mining order
By Losirene Lacanivalu , Cook Islands News Hundreds of people peacefully rallied at sea in Rarotonga to protect the ocean from seabed activities in August 2024. Photo: Supplied / Ocean Ancestors Cook Islands' leading environmental lobby group is hoping that the Cook Islands government will speak out against the recent executive order from United States President Donald Trump aimed at fast-tracking seabed mining. Te Ipukarea Society (TIS) says the arrogance of US president Trump to think that he can break international law by authorising deep seabed mining in international waters is "astounding", and an action of a "bully." Trump signed the Unleashing America's offshore critical minerals and resources order late last month, directing the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) to allow permitting for deep sea mining. The order states, "It is the policy of the US to advance United States leadership in seabed mineral development." NOAA has been directed to, within 60 days, "expedite the process for reviewing and issuing seabed mineral exploration licenses and commercial recovery permits in areas beyond national jurisdiction under the Deep Seabed Hard Mineral Resources Act." It directs the US science and environmental agency to expedite permits for companies to mine the ocean floor in the US and international waters. In addition, a Canadian mining company - The Metals Company has indicated that they have applied for a permit from Trump's administration to start commercially mining in international waters. The mining company had been unsuccessful in gaining a commercial mining licence through the International Seabed Authority (ISA). Te Ipukarea Society's technical director Kelvin Passfield told Cook Islands News , "The arrogance of Donald Trump to think that he can break international law by authorising deep seabed mining in international waters is astounding. "The United States cannot pick and choose which aspects of the United Nations Law of the Sea it will follow, and which ones it will ignore. This is the action of a bully." "It is reckless and completely dismissive of the international rule of law. At the moment we have 169 countries, plus the European Union, all recognising international law under the International Seabed Authority. "For one country to start making new international rules for themselves is a dangerous notion, especially if it leads to other States thinking they too can also breach international law with no consequences," he said. TIS president June Hosking says that the fact that a part of the Pacific (CCZ) was carved up and shared between nations all over the world is yet another example of 'blatantly disregarding or overriding indigenous rights'. "I can understand why something had to be done to protect the high seas from rogues having a 'free for all', but it should have been Pacific indigenous and first nations groups, within and bordering the Pacific, who decided what happened to the high seas. "That's the first nations groups, not for example, the USA as it is today." President Trump signs a proclamation in the Oval Office at the White House on 17 April 2025 in Washington. Photo: AFP / Win MCNAMEE Hosking highlighted that at the March International Seabed Authority (ISA) assembly that she attended it was obvious that South American countries are worried. "Many have called for a moratorium. Portugal rightly pointed out that we were all there, at great cost, just for a commercial activity. The delegate said, 'We must ask ourselves how does this really benefit all of humankind?' Looking at The Metals Company's interests to commercially mine in international waters, Hosking said, "I couldn't help being annoyed that all this talk assumes mining will happen. "ISA was formed at a time when things were assumed about the deep sea e.g. it's just a desert down there, nothing was known for sure, we didn't speak of climate crisis, waste crisis and other crises now evident. "The ISA mandate is 'to ensure the effective protection of the marine environment from the harmful effects that may arise from deep seabed related activities. "We know much more (but still not enough) to consider that effective protection of the marine environment may require it to be declared a 'no go zone', to be left untouched for the good of humankind," she added. Meanwhile, technical director Passfield also added, "The audacity of The Metals Company (TMC) to think they can flaunt international law in order to get an illegal mining licence from the United States to start seabed mining in international waters is a sad reflection of the morality of Gerard Barron and others in charge of TMC. "If the USA is allowed to authorise mining in international waters under a domestic US law, what is stopping any other country in the world from enacting legislation and doing the same? He said that while the Metals Company may be frustrated at the amount of time that the International Seabed Authority is taking to finalise mining rules for deep seabed mining, "we are sure they fully understand that this is for good reason. The potentially disastrous impacts of mining our deep ocean seabed need to be better understood, and this takes time." He said that technology and infrastructure to mine is not in place yet. "We need to take as much time as we need to ensure that if mining proceeds, it does not cause serious damage to our ocean. Their attempts to rush the process are selfish, greedy, and driven purely by a desire to profit at any cost to the environment. "We hope that the Cook Islands Government speaks out against this abuse of international law by the United States." Cook Islands News has reached out to the Office of the Prime Minister and Seabed Minerals Authority (SBMA) for comment.
