Evil ex who knifed mum to death after she went to cops SIX times about his stalking including on day she died is jailed
Claire Chick, 48, was suffered 23 knife wounds after Paul Butler ambushed her outside her home in Plymouth,
Devon
, in January.
Advertisement
5
Claire Chick was stabbed to death in the street
Credit: FACEBOOK/UNPIXS
5
Paul Butler has been jailed for life for murder
Credit: PA
Tragically the mum-of-two could not be saved and was declared dead in hospital the following morning.
Claire, who worked as a lecturer at the University of Plymouth, had gone to the police six times to make a statement in the months leading up to her death due to her ex-husband's stalking campaign.
On the day she was murdered, the mum told police: "I only feel that Butler will kill me if further action is not taken. I am in fear of leaving my house."
Butler was arrested three times for assault, harassment and stalking but refused to stop harassing Claire.
Advertisement
Read more news
He has now been jailed for life with a minimum of 27 years after he previously pleaded guilty to murder.
Sentencing, Judge Robert Linford said Butler had carried out a "frenzied, brutal, murderous" attack.
Plymouth Crown Court heard the 53-year-old, who also admitted possessing a knife, first got with Claire in 2021 after they met as neighbours.
The pair married in June 2024 but split just two months later due to Butler's behaviour.
Advertisement
Most read in The Sun
Exclusive
The former doorman then launched a terrifying stalking campaign against Claire after refusing to accept the break up.
After she started a new relationship with Paul Maxwell, Butler was seen on CCTV buying three knives from Sainsbury's.
He also changed his name on Facebook to Stangray Strangler after his road name and put a tracker on the mum's car to follow her.
On one of these occasions, she messaged her daughter saying: "I wish he would just get on with it and put me out of my misery".
Advertisement
Jo Martin KC, prosecuting, said: "After the relationship was over there was constant texting, the tracking of her car, placing the restriction on the sale of her house, threatening suicide.
"She felt that he had made her life hell. She did repeatedly tell him to leave her alone and she felt violated by him.
"Then on the day of her murder, going to her workplace to watch her. She believed he would murder her."
Despite being on bail and banned from going near her, Butler went to her home dressed in a camo hoodie and lay in wait for Claire.
Advertisement
When she left, the thug ambushed her - stabbing her more than 20 times with one of the knives he bought.
She was found seriously injured in West Hoe Road, Plymouth, at around 8.55pm on January 22.
Butler fled the scene but not before chasing Claire's new partner, who had returned from a regular evening run and witnessed the murder.
The killer shouted at him: "I'll f***ing do you too."
Advertisement
An inquest heard Claire died after suffering multiple stab wounds.
Claire's eldest daughter Bethany Hancock-Baxter said her mum's murder had left a "huge void".
She said: "I want this evil man to listen to me. I want you to know what you have done to us as a family.
"Despite all the hate I have for you, I cannot bring myself to do what you did to my mum - that's because I am not evil like you."
Advertisement
Devon and Cornwall conducts 'urgent' review of stalking cases
Assistant Chief Constable Glen Mayhew added: 'My thoughts and condolences are with Claire's family and friends over the devastating impact this abhorrent crime committed by Paul Butler has had on them. I also acknowledge the details of this case heard by the court today are horrific and I know the anguish and pain will stay with Claire's family.
'The Force made a mandatory referral to the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) due to our previous contact with Claire.
'We are committed to fully co-operating with an ongoing independent investigation by the IOPC. It would be inappropriate to comment in more detail at this stage to ensure we do not compromise the investigation.
'Having met some of Claire's family following her tragic death, the Force has conducted an urgent review of all our active stalking investigations.
'This has resulted in immediate changes to our stalking and harassment procedures. New policies have been implemented to ensure we provide greater focus on safeguarding victims, targeting perpetrators at the earliest opportunity and encouraging reporting.
'One of our priorities is to ensure we continue to improve how we investigate stalking and harassment, focusing on dealing proactively with dangerous perpetrators and giving greater confidence to victims of this harmful and dangerous crime.'
While Claire's dad Alan Butler described Butler as a "nasty narcissist".
He added: "You have brutally killed the most beautiful human being and robbed the world of a high achiever.
"You have murdered my daughter, taken her future, broken my heart and will go straight to hell.
"I can never forgive you for what you have done. I rage with anger with what you have done.
Advertisement
"There are too many men who take the lives of women because they can't have what they want. They are evil, he is evil."
Following Claire's death, Devon and Cornwall Police made a referral to the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) due to previous contact.
"Our investigation into Claire Chick's contact with Devon and Cornwall Police prior to her murder in January is ongoing," an IOPC spokesman said.
"Our thoughts and sympathies remain with Ms Chick's family and we are keeping them updated on the progress of our investigation."
Advertisement
Domestic abuse - how to get help
DOMESTIC abuse can affect anyone - including men - and does not always involve physical violence.
Here are some signs that you could be in an abusive relationship:
Emotional abuse
- Including being belittled, blamed for the abuse - gaslighting - being isolated from family and friends, having no control over your finances, what you where and who you speak to
Threats and intimidation
- Some partners might threaten to kill or hurt you, destroy your belongings, stalk or harass you
Physical abuse
- This can range from slapping or hitting to being shoved over, choked or bitten.
Sexual abuse
- Being touched in a way you do not want to be touched, hurt during sex, pressured into sex or forced to have sex when you do not consent.
If any of the above apply to you or a friend, you can call these numbers:
on
0808 2000 247
for free at any time, day or night
Men who are being abused can call Respect Men's Advice Line on 0808 8010 327 or
on
0182 3334 244
Those who identify as LGBT+ can ring
on
0800 999 5428
If you are in immediate danger or fear for your life, always ring 999
Remember, you are not alone.
1 in 4 women and 1 in 7 men will experience domestic abuse over the course of their lifetime.
Every 30 seconds the police receive a call for help relating to domestic abuse.
5
Butler sobbed as he previously pleaded guilty to murder
5
Claire died in hospital following the horror
Credit: FACEBOOK/UNPIXS
5
Tributes flooded in for the university lecturer
Credit: PA
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sunday World
15 hours ago
- Sunday World
Electronic data to be analysed in triple murder-suicide probe
Ms Whyte (45) and her two children, James (14) and Sara (13), died from gunshot injuries inflicted at their Maguiresbridge home on July 23 The coffins of murder victims Vanessa Whyte and her children Sara and James Rutledge are carried from St Mary's Church in Maguiresbridge, Co Fermanagh, following a service of removal. Photo: Liam McBurney/PA Wire Vanessa Whyte with her children Sara and James Rutledge. Photo: PSNI/PA Northern Ireland authorities believe triple murder suspect Ian Rutledge moved back into the Fermanagh home of his wife Vanessa Whyte and their two teenage children after his family became aware of his deteriorating eyesight. PSNI detectives are investigating whether the suspected triple murder-suicide had been planned in advance by the former truck driver – or whether it was triggered by a dispute in the family home. Ms Whyte (45) and her two children, James (14) and Sara (13), died from gunshot injuries inflicted at their Maguiresbridge home on July 23. The only suspect in the triple shooting, Rutledge (43), was discovered by PSNI officers at the property with gunshot wounds. He died in hospital last Monday from his injuries. The former agricultural contractor had suffered catastrophic brain injuries. He was Ms Whyte's husband and the father of James and Sara. Ian Rutledge A legally held firearm was recovered from the scene. The PSNI believe Rutledge shot his wife and children before turning the firearm on himself. Ms Whyte – who is survived by her mother, Mary, and her siblings, Geraldine, Regina, Anita, Ivor and Stephen – was buried alongside her two children in her native Clare last Saturday. Friends and family hailed her as a kind-hearted and caring individual who was devoted to her family. One friend said that trying to help someone in need was second nature to Ms Whyte. Thousands attended the funeral in Barefield, Co Clare. There were emotional scenes as the three coffins were carried into the Church of the Immaculate Conception, the church where Ms Whyte made her holy communion and confirmation. The University College Dublin veterinary studies graduate had planned to travel back to her native Clare for the August bank holiday weekend with her children to visit her family and attend some Clare hurling championship matches. The only comfort we have is that Vanessa, James and Sara are together and finally safe She was a lifelong Clare hurling fan and attended the 2024 All-Ireland final with her children. The funeral had guards of honour from GAA clubs in Clare, Galway and Fermanagh. Ms Whyte's sister, Regina, said she had been taken from the world and her loving children in a cruel and vicious manner. 'For us, as a family, the only comfort we have is that Vanessa, James and Sara are together and finally safe,' she said. The coffins of murder victims Vanessa Whyte and her children Sara and James Rutledge are carried from St Mary's Church in Maguiresbridge, Co Fermanagh, following a service of removal. Photo: Liam McBurney/PA Wire The Bishop of Ferns, Ger Nash, who was previously a cleric in Killaloe, noted that the Whyte family had asked people to wear bright colours in tribute to Ms Whyte and her two children. Outside the church, three flagpoles had the Irish, Clare and St Joseph's- Doora Barefield colours flying at half mast. Dozens of balloons in the saffron and blue colours of Clare surrounded the three coffins, with Ms Whyte's coffin covered by the maroon and white colours of St Joseph's-Doora Barefield, the club her late father and two brothers proudly played for. 'We need that light,' Bishop Nash said. He told mourners that darkness cannot overcome light for those of faith. 'It is hinted at in the bright colours that Vanessa, James and Sara's family have asked people to wear.' 'The darkness will not conquer.' Dozens of mourners attended from Fermanagh, where a special memorial service for the mother and children was held last Wednesday evening. The PSNI are now trawling through all electronic data from mobile phones and computers to determine the precise sequence of events that led to the deaths. Detectives are aware that Rutledge had been experiencing depression over recent weeks and months.
The Irish Sun
a day ago
- The Irish Sun
Woman ‘sexually assaulted' in city suburb in the early hours – as cops release CCTV of man
The incident happened during the early hours of Saturday morning URGENT SEARCH Woman 'sexually assaulted' in city suburb in the early hours – as cops release CCTV of man COPS have launched an investigation following reports of an alleged sexual assault. The incident is said to have taken place during the early hours of Saturday morning in the area of Mannamead, Devon. Advertisement 1 Cornwall Police have released CCTV images of a man they believe can assist with enquiries Credit: Devon & Cornwall Police Cornwall Police added that officers were told a woman was sexually assaulted during the incident. Officers investigating the incident have released images of a man who they say can assist with enquiries. Cops have appealed to anyone with information regarding the incident to get in contact with police either by calling 101, or via their website, quoting the reference number 50250199534. More to follow... For the latest news on this story keep checking back at The Sun Online Advertisement is your go-to destination for the best celebrity news, real-life stories, jaw-dropping pictures and must-see video. Like us on Facebook at and follow us from our main Twitter account at @TheSun.
The Irish Sun
a day ago
- The Irish Sun
Constance Marten's hellhole life at ‘female Monster Mansion' revealed as baby killer fends off brutal prison attacks
Marten's childhood was so privileged, her family's sprawling mansion was used in a 1996 Oscar winning film TARGET ON HER BACK Constance Marten's hellhole life at 'female Monster Mansion' revealed as baby killer fends off brutal prison attacks ARISTOCRAT Constance Marten once began her day with maids drawing the curtains at her palatial family home, but now her mornings start with a rattle from the prison guard at 8am. Today, we can reveal how the former socialite, who is awaiting sentence for killing her 16-day-old baby daughter, faces a hellish new life at a jail nicknamed the women's Monster Mansion, where her 'delusional' behaviour has already put a target on her back and even seen her advised to become pals with two notorious child killers. 10 Aristocrat Constance Marten faces a hellish new life at a jail nicknamed the women's Monster Mansion 10 She is being held at HMP Bronzefield in Surrey Credit: Alamy 10 The prison is home to many of Britain's most infamous female murderers Credit: PA:Press Association After being found guilty last month of gross negligence manslaughter, Marten, 38, is being held at HMP Bronzefield in Surrey, home to many of Britain's most infamous female murderers. Among the inmates serving life at the Surrey women's prison are baby-killer nurse Lucy Letby and Beinash Batool, who murdered her ten-year-old step- daughter Sara Sharif. A source tells The Sun: 'Violence is rife on the block, as is abuse and self-harm. 'Letby and Batool have become friends, and that is partly for their own protection, because child killers are a target for all the women there. 'Marten comes out in the same group as Letby and Batool. She is not yet friendly with them and mostly keeps herself to herself. Easy ride 'She would be a massive target for others in Bronzefield if she was allowed to mix more freely. 'It might be wise for Marten to try to pal up with Letby and Batool, otherwise her time at Bronzefield could become extremely tough. 'She has had a fairly easy ride so far but that can change at the drop of a hat in a rough prison.' Life as Prisoner A9624X is a world away from Marten's upbringing. She is the daughter of aristocrat Napier Marten, who was a page to the Queen, and the young Constance grew up at the family home, Crichel House in Dorset — one of Britain's finest stately homes, which was the backdrop to the 1996 movie Emma, starring Gwyneth Paltrow. Moment cops arrest and ask Constance Marten 'where is your child?' after she killed newborn baby while on the run with rapist partner She and her partner Mark Gordon, a convicted rapist, had already had four children when in 2023 they hid the body of their fifth child, a girl, in a Lidl supermarket bag on an allotment and went on the run. They were arrested in Brighton on February 27, 2023 following a nationwide manhunt. At their first trial, which began in January 2004, they were convicted of perverting justice, concealment of a baby's birth and child cruelty. And when their 'chaotic' second trial ended last month, a jury found the couple guilty of manslaughter. The two lengthy hearings had cost taxpayers more than £10million. Following the trial, sources say Marten 'swanned' into privately run Bronzefield jail, where she now will be held in Unit 4, along with other child killers, until her sentencing hearing at the Old Bailey next month. 10 Among the inmates serving life at the Surrey women's prison are baby-killer nurse Lucy Letby 10 Beinash Batool, who murdered her ten-year-old step-daughter Sara Sharif, also resides there Credit: AP 10 Farah Damji, who describes herself as 'London's most dangerous woman', is another inmate Another inmate was found to have committed suicide on the unit last Thursday morning, and while Marten is in the prison she has been put under 24-hour observation over fears for her safety, with guards checking her at least every five minutes. After her conviction for killing her baby, Marten is also a target for attacks from violent fellow prisoners. Others on the block at the 527-inmate jail are thought to include Sian Hedges, who, along with her partner, killed her 18-month-old son, and Nicola Edgington, who is serving time for murdering a grandmother in the street with a butcher's knife. Marten is on a 'standard' regime, which means she gets a £15.50-a-week allowance to spend at a canteen, where she can top up her prison food with treats such as Snickers bars and cans of Pepsi. Inmates can also order shampoo and phone credit. Marten's behaviour since she arrived has been odd, to say the least. It's like she doesn't understand where she is and is deluded about what's happened. Source Her cell has a desk, ensuite toilet and Freeview TV with a built-in DVD player. She does not yet have a job but has access to workshops including sewing, catering and cleaning. Our source says: 'Marten's behaviour since she arrived has been odd, to say the least. 'It's like she doesn't understand where she is and is deluded about what's happened. 'She swanned in after the trial and seemed to have taken everything really lightly. But something she said, or in her behaviour, set off alarm bells and she was classified as a risk to herself.' After her trial ended, prison authorities compiled an ACCT document for Marten — meaning Assessment, Care in Custody and Teamwork — setting out reasons why she will need regular checks, including during the night, when the supervision is done by torchlight shone into her cell. 10 Mark Gordon, a convicted rapist, went on the run with Constance Credit: PA 10 Constance appeared on the cover of The View, a magazine produced for female prisoners Credit: Supplied The insider adds: 'Prisoners don't like being on constant watch because it makes it hard to sleep, and most try to come off it. 'But the staff were duty-bound to report their concerns about Constance. The reception team have to ask prisoners if they feel suicidal, and can also raise concerns if they spot behaviour that worries them. 'Marten's behaviour has been very strange and a bit unpredictable. 'It is like she does not believe she is in jail and should not be here. 'She has been heard saying she thinks she will only be in for a couple of years and seems to think that manslaughter is not that serious. 'But you can get a life sentence for it. A long jail term would be a massive shock to the system for her. 'Other inmates and prison officers think she is deluded and is in for an extremely rude awakening when she gets sentenced. Privileged existence 'She could also come unstuck with the other women in there if the guards don't keep a very close eye on her.' Marten's day in the Category A jail starts with that ignominious wake-up call at 8am. She is then escorted to a kitchen, where breakfast is a cereal pack plus milk. In the kitchen, Marten is allowed to mix with only a handful of inmates, including Letby, 35, and Batool, 31, who The Sun recently revealed had become firm friends over the card game Uno. In 2023 maternity nurse Letby was convicted of murdering seven babies and attempting to kill seven more. Our source says: 'Prisoners don't get to decide who they mix with. 'There is a process when they arrive so they can be placed in the safest place for them. There are limits on who she can safely mix with and Marten is restricted to other women who have hurt children.' Her current life seems a far cry from the privileged existence she had known in her youth. After private schooling she went on to study Arabic at Leeds University. 10 While on remand Constance constantly lodged complaints about conditions behind bars Credit: AFP 10 Constance grew up at Crichel House in Dorset — one of Britain's finest stately homes Credit: Alamy While there, aged 18, Marten appeared in the society magazine Tatler as its 'babe of the month'. But 20 years later, during her second trial, she appeared on the cover of an altogether different magazine. The View — produced for female prisoners — is edited by art gallery owner and convicted criminal Farah Damji, who describes herself as 'London's most dangerous woman'. In the magazine Marten, pictured in a low-cut dress, moaned about the 'disgusting' microwaved food that was served to prisoners on trial at the Old Bailey. She also complained about the two-hour journey to the court from Bronzefield, where she was being held on remand, accompanied by guards 'on minimum wages'. Marten blamed Sodexo, the private firm that runs Bronzefield prison, 'for adversely affecting my trial, preventing me from accessing my lawyers and for my mental health, which is in pieces'. While on remand she constantly lodged complaints about conditions behind bars. During her retrial, Marten repeatedly claimed to have toothache and refused to attend court to give evidence. But after special arrangements were made for a dentist to visit, she refused treatment. Our source adds: 'The unit is developing a really grisly reputation because of the characters on it. 'It is now called the female Monster Mansion, after Frankland Prison [in County Durham], which holds people like Ian Huntley, Wayne Couzens and Levi Bellfield, which is the male version. 'And it is an odd environment for someone like Marten to end up on. 'Guards are keeping a close eye on her at the moment but they won't be able to keep watch on her for ever.' A spokesman for HMP Bronzefield's operator Sodexo, says: 'We cannot comment on individuals.'
