Third-level fees causing tension between Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael
Good morning.
The Taoiseach is swanking around the land of the rising sun. There's
a heatwave in Europe
. And at home there's a bit of a tension convention
between Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael over third level fees
.
The Fianna Fáil Minister for Higher Education James Lawless is in Fine Gael's bad books after suggesting that third level fees may rise by as much as €1,000 a year as the cost-of-living supports in recent budgets come to an end.
Lawless has actually been talking about this for months –
we reported on it back at the start of April
– but as the budget maneuvering enters a more active phase, he returned to the subject in recent days. Third level fees of €3,000 a year have been reduced by €1000 by cost of living supports in recent years. Get rid of those supports – as the Government is pledged to do – and fees must go up, Lawless reasons.
READ MORE
But Fine Gael, ever attuned to many hardships faced by middle Ireland, is wondering out loud how you can fulfil the Programme for Government pledge to cut the cost of third level education by, er, increasing the cost of third level education.
The situation was sufficiently grave to
warrant a voice note from Tánaiste Simon Harris
to Fine Gael TDs last night. 'The budget will be agreed by Government with key input from the party leaders. But it does need to help families with the cost of putting a young person through college,' Harris told his party. Expect this to be put to him when he takes leaders questions today.
*
Budget matters are also up for discussion when the Irish Fiscal Advisory Council (Ifac) visits the Budget Oversight Committee today, where Ifac chairman Seamus Coffey will tell the TDs and senators that
the Government is on course for €2 billion of unbudgeted overspends this year
– and that's just in current spending, not to mind ballooning capital projects.
The finding is among a number of criticisms and warnings that Ifac is likely to make. The Government is currently preparing its summer economic statement, a key budgetary document that will indicate the parameters for spending increases in the October budget.
The council will urge the Government not to continue with the pro-cyclical budgetary policies of recent years, which saw billions of euros in giveaways to voters announced on budget day, as well as longer term spending increases.
'Given the economy is in a strong position, it does not require support from budgetary policy. Standard economics suggests the government should support the economy when it is weak, but show restraint when the economy is strong,' Coffey is expected to tell the committee.
Budgetary restraint, of course, in a time of plenty for the Exchequer, is a hard political sell.
*
The Cabinet meets this morning, sans Taoiseach, and the agenda features a number of housing related memos. As Harry McGee reports, the Government
intends to establish a league table of how local authorities are performing
when it comes to building social housing, which will be useful for blaming someone else.
*
Dublin
has a new Lord Mayor
. He is Ray McAdam, a Fine Gael councillor – the third FGer in a row to hold the position – and chum of the Minister for Finance, Paschal Donohoe.
Best reads
One of the largest estate agents in Ireland has launched an internal investigation after one of its staff allegedly offered to split the sale of a new build home in Newtownmountkennedy in order for it to qualify for the Help to Buy scheme.
Niamh Towey has the story
, and it's our lead this morning.
A telecoms company with suspected ties to a key arm of the Iranian regime asked Irish diplomats
for help setting up business deals in the Republic with Eir, Vodafone and Three
, Jack Power reports.
Fintan O'Toole finds that
he has more wives than Henry VIII
– thanks to AI.
Playbook
As mentioned above, Taoiseach Micheál Martin is in Japan for an official visit, with the agenda mostly dominated by trade and investment. China Correspondent Denis Staunton is covering the trip
and has a preview here
.
Back at home, the Cabinet meets at Government Buildings this morning under the chairmanship of Simon Harris.
Dáil business starts at 2pm with Leaders' Questions – Harris in the hot seat again – followed by the usual weekly row over the order of business. There's housing questions later, and a private members motion from Sinn Féin on the GPO and Moore St – which the party wants to see developed as a 1916 quarter. How long has this been going on now?
Two Government Bills are due to conclude in the Seanad – the Supports for Survivors of Residential Institutional Abuse Bill and the Finance (Local Property Tax and Other Provisions) bill.
At the committees, there's a few things to watch. The foreign affairs committee
will begin pre-legislative scrutiny of the Occupied Territories Bill
when senior officials from the Department of Foreign Affairs come in.
The Committee on Defence and National Security is also doing pre-legislative scrutiny on the bill to abolish the triple lock, while the Budget Oversight Committee – as mentioned above – have the Fiscal Council in. Senior wallahs from the Department of Arts and Media are in to talk about the Arts Council and the controversy over its abandoned IT project. Full list of committee and details of the Dail and Seanad sittings
are here
.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

Irish Times
27 minutes ago
- Irish Times
From India to Ireland: ‘The first day I came to Dublin, I felt like I'm home, like I belong'
After the death of Sumyrah Khan's father, she questioned her future in Ireland. But when she heard how proud he had been of her for moving away on her own, she felt encouraged to continue her studies at Dublin City University (DCU). Growing up in Chennai, India, Khan attended an English-speaking school. 'My mom was very particular that we would go to a school like that. So, that's why my English is near to perfect.' 'A very strong work ethic was instilled in me from a very young age. I always knew that if I wanted something, I'd have to work towards it. It set my values very young.' After graduating in 2020 with a degree in economics and political science, she had planned to pursue a master's degree in Paris. But when Covid-19 hit, she instead decided to take a gap year. READ MORE Things changed when DCU offered her a scholarship to complete her master's in Dublin in 2021. 'I had never really thought about Dublin as an option, but it made sense because everyone here spoke English, it's a European country and well, it'd be a little bit of fun. So, I was like, I'm going to go there for a year, and I'll finish my master's, and then I will go back home.' After living in Dublin for more than four years, she has fallen in love with the city in ways she didn't expect. 'I remember the first day I came to Dublin, I was like – this weirdly feels like I'm home, like I belong here. I've never felt that feeling before, anywhere that I've travelled.' [ 'I came to Ireland in 2016. If I came in 2024 I wouldn't survive because now the rents are like €3,000' Opens in new window ] The first culture shock she got was the temperature. Coming from the south of India, she found the Irish winter harsh. Sumyrah Khan's favourite thing about Ireland is the people. Photograph: Nick Bradshaw While Ireland's rental crisis was something she was aware of, she didn't realise 'how bad it was' until she struggled to find somewhere to live close to DCU's Glasnevin campus. Ireland's cost-of-living crisis pushed her into getting a part-time job that she balanced with her studies. 'I didn't know there was a cost-of-living crisis as well. I would have to think a thousand times before I bought a Snickers bar because everything was so expensive.' In December of 2021, Khan received a heartbreaking phone call informing her that her father had died. 'I was doing my assignments and I got this call in the morning, that this had happened. It was incredibly traumatic and it was one of those things where it feels like your world's broke and you're trying to figure out what to do as you're 22 years old.' Later she returned to India and questioned whether it was right for her to go back to Dublin. 'I feel like I've missed such a big thing. It changes a person's life. My mom would tell me how proud my dad was that I ventured out by myself, so young to a different country. That motivated me to go back and finish my degree.' 'Something just clicked in my brain, where I was like, 'You know what? I think I'm going to try to make it.' I felt that missing out on such a personal loss or not being there for such an event to follow my dreams, should have meant something. When I realised that my dad would have been so proud of me for finishing my degree, I stayed on.' [ From Mumbai to Dublin: 'Ireland has been cold, yes – but not the people' Opens in new window ] While working part-time and finishing her degree, Khan started applying to other jobs. After applying to over 100 posts and conducting over 20 interviews, she secured a position as a youth and equality officer for the Labour Party. 'I went from cleaning toilets in a bar, the next week, I was in Leinster House,' she says with a laugh. 'Aideen Blackwood, the national organiser in the Labour Party, without doubt, changed my life.' 'I don't really think people realise giving a chance to an immigrant means so much to them. Getting a barista job when you really need it, when you're on your knees, could mean everything. It's like your ticket to stay in this country. That's why there's such a culture of working twice as hard for immigrants here in this country.' After her temporary job with the Labour Party ended, she had to search for work again, as maintaining a job is an essential part of her visa, and she needed one to stay in Ireland. She got a job with Aontas na Mac Léinn in Éirinn (AMLÉ) (formerly Union of Students in Ireland) as a communications manager. I see myself being here for the rest of my life. I am completely in love with this country and I want to be buried here For Khan, securing the general employment visa was one of the 'toughest' parts of moving to Ireland. 'The problem with this visa is that your employer needs to support you throughout that process.' She also explained the labour market test that applicants must undergo as 'having to prove to the Irish Government that no Irish person can do your job.' Immigrants 'don't having the luxury of a slow start,' she says. 'Your Irish friend is already five years ahead of you because they have the networks, they know how things work.' She wants to run for politics some day. 'It sometimes feels impossible, but I feel I have people around me who really believe that I can do it. I don't think I would have wanted to be a politician if I had not worked so closely with all these women within the Labour Party.' She particularly praises the party leader, Ivana Bacik . 'I'm just so in awe of her. She's so brilliant and powerful.' Her favourite thing about Ireland is the people. 'Irish people are a special kind of people. There's this unexplainable energy that Irish people have that you can't really put a finger on.' She says the Irish know how to throw a party. 'It's great craic, the most fun I've had. They're the most warm, inviting people that you'll ever meet.' However, she says the existence of the far-right movement has been the worst part of moving to Ireland. 'When I first moved here in 2021, it wasn't as bad. It is incredibly scary that you could be attacked for how you look. I think my communication style helps me most of the time because people are confused that I have an American accent or I speak perfect English and somehow I'm a little more socially acceptable to people.' She wants to help 'bridge the gap of misunderstanding that people have about immigrants.' She finds the people of Ireland and India to be similar: being warm, having a strong sense of community and loving a good party. She also feels that Ireland and India's shared experience of colonialism unites them. 'Every time I hear a traditional song or a harp play, something spiritually moves in me. I've never been able to explain it. There's no trace of Irish in me. But I've felt so connected to this country. 'I've lived here for four years and I see myself being here for the rest of my life. I am completely in love with this country and I want to be buried here.' 'Maybe I'll move to the west coast when I turn 40. Maybe I'll win a cottage in a raffle or something,' she says, laughing. We would like to hear from people who have moved to Ireland in the past 10 years. To get involved, email newtotheparish@ or tweet @newtotheparish


Irish Independent
30 minutes ago
- Irish Independent
Taoiseach describes budget meeting with Tánaiste and ministers Donohoe and Chambers as ‘sobering'
As the EU awaits the final agreement to be secured on trade tariffs with the US, Mr Martin said this year's budget would be different to those of previous years with no cost of living package. Speaking in Tokyo where Mr Martin is currently on a trade mission, the Taoiseach said that 'challenges lay ahead' as the budget negotiations begin as the international trade outlook remains uncertain. 'Public expenditure has risen on average, 8pc to 9pc over the last number of years. Such high levels of expenditure are not sustainable on the current basis,' Mr Martin said. Mr Martin said the meeting last Saturday between the senior ministers also included discussions on the National Development Plan, budgetary matters and the median term financial framework. 'It was a sobering enough meeting, to be frank, in terms of the challenges that lie ahead, given the backdrop of tariffs and uncertainty in trade, and also the warnings we've received in terms of the once-off nature, or the temporary nature, perhaps, of certain corporation tax revenues,' the Taoiseach said. Meanwhile, the Government remains committed to reducing the student contribution fees at third level, but this will happen over the lifetime of the Government, Mr Martin said. It comes as Higher Education Minister James Lawless confirmed over the weekend that the fee would revert back to the amount owed before the €1,000 reduction was introduced as a cost of living measure. He added that supports and other commitments would have to be included in mainstream measures, which created difficulty for the Government in the first year. 'Last year and the year before, we got a lot done through the cost of living packages, which were once-off packages, and they were not in the mainstream budget. So therein lies difficulty,' Mr Martin said. 'What we're going to try and do is mainstream forms and commitments in the Programme for Government into the budget that will be sustained in over a period of time. But that will create challenges for us in the first year,' he added. Mr Martin added that the Government had other commitments in the Programme for Government aside from reducing student contribution fees, including the carer's allowance commitment, and the income disregard. On the US trade tariffs due to be announced next week, Mr Martin said 'we are in more uncertain waters' and that it was now about damage limitation. 'I think the EU is basically saying, and I think President von der Leyen said we're not going to go back to where we were. We are in a changed environment. The issue is, can we limit the damage?' On the upcoming presidential election, Mr Martin said Fianna Fáil would take a decision 'in due course' on whether to run a candidate but seemed to indicate there would be no announcement until the end of the summer. 'We didn't run a candidate last time and we didn't run a candidate before that. But of course, we're examining the situation. We're taking soundings,' Mr Martin said. 'I think John Burton said recently, I believe she said it that if she was any candidate or any party she wouldn't announce anything until August 28, from previous experiences,' Mr Martin said.

Irish Times
41 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Sinn Féin needed for left presidential candidate, says PBP
A joint left candidate for the presidency largely depends on whether Sinn Féin decides to run its own candidate, People Before Profit TD Paul Murphy has said. He said he hoped that Sinn Féin's intentions might become clear next week. 'I would be very hopeful that we would have progress towards a joint left candidate before the Dail recess,' Mr Murphy said. 'There is a meeting being scheduled for next week. 'Obviously Sinn Féin is having its own internal process to decide whether it will run a candidate or not . . . That's pretty crucial. If they have their own candidate then there isn't going to be a joint left candidate, certainly including Sinn Féin,' he said. READ MORE 'My understanding is that is due to end around now. So it makes sense to come back together, for Sinn Féin to report on the internal process, to say whether Sinn Féin, are they interested in pursuing further a joint left candidate or are they going to go their own way. And that's a choice for them to make,' he said. He said he hoped there would be a meeting to discuss this next week. If Sinn Féin are agreeable to a joint left candidate, then the parties of the left should move 'rapidly enough' to selecting a candidate. Sinn Féin , Labour , the Social Democrats , People Before Profit-Solidarity and the Greens have held exploratory talks about agreeing a 'consensus candidate' in recent months, on the basis that their combined votes would be more than enough to secure a nomination and could also funnel significant numbers of voters towards a chosen candidate. Mr Murphy said that People Before Profit was 'very enthusiastic' about a candidate of the left. 'We think it can be won and we think Michael D Higgins is an example of how that position can be quite important, in the context of genocide, of rising racism, of homophobia, having a progress left voice in the presidency is politically important,' he said. He said winning the presidency would be step in the direction of having a left-led government without Fianna Fáil or Fine Gael. Asked if he had floated the names of possible candidates, Mr Murphy replied: 'Yes.' However, he would not be drawn on who they were. If Sinn Féin decides to run its own candidate Mr Murphy said the rest of the left would have to decide how to respond but from People Before Profit's perspective, it would be 'much, much, much more preferable' to have Sinn Féin on board. Also speaking on Tuesday, Labour TD Marie Sherlock said that there was 'a whole kaleidoscope of names out there at the moment' but she expected that decisions would not be made until the end of August or the start of September But she said that there was a 'massive appetite out there' for someone to continue the 'incredible legacy' of Mr Higgins. 'I think across the left we want to see there's a strong and viable candidate going into November but I think those conversations are continuing,' she said.