Could Maine finally create a statewide system for tracking rape kits?
Proponents fear hundreds of kits throughout Maine are being overlooked and that a majority have never been tested and will never lead to arrests or convictions. But it will cost millions of dollars to identify and test all of them — and the proposal has returned to lawmakers during an even more competitive year for the state budget.
Ever since a bill to pay for a statewide system died at adjournment in the last session, momentum has only grown. Both Kennebec and Penobscot counties have launched their own tracking systems using federal funds. Cumberland County received a $2.5 million grant in December to send an estimated 500 untested kits to an out-of-state lab.
But the grant that helped Kennebec and Penobscot counties is about to dry up. If the state doesn't step in now, that work "might not move forward to anything," said Melissa Martin, policy director for the Maine Coalition Against Sexual Assault.
"This is really the point where I think the state needs to step in," Martin said at a hearing for the bill Monday.
The Legislature's Judiciary Committee is considering two bills this year, both of which call on the Maine Department of Public Safety to create a statewide tracking system for all of the state's sexual assault kits that would allow victims to receive updates on the status of their kits.
Both bills would also require the department to compile an inventory of all its backlogged and shelved cases, and to share a report on its progress with lawmakers by January 2027.
"We have no idea — we truly just don't know — how many kits are in storage," said Keri Kapoldo, who coordinates the Sexual Assault Forensic Examiner program for St. Joseph Hospital in Bangor.
"We just can't fix something we can't see," Kapoldo said.
In March, the committee voted "ought to pass" on LD 549, a proposal introduced by Sen. Rick Bennett, R-Oxford. The bill would cost about $1.1 million over the next two years, about one-third of which would be covered by the state Highway Fund.
Bennett said in February that Maine is drastically behind other states when it comes to tracking and testing its rape kits. A majority of kits collected from hospitals never get tested, he said.
"But victims don't know this," Bennett said. "They expect that after they go through the traumatic experience of reliving an event, it will help lead to justice. ... It should be a dark mark of shame that this is so far from the truth."
LD 1816, which had its public hearing Monday, is slightly different because it wouldn't mandate that kits be sent to law enforcement agencies, according to its sponsor, Sen. Jill Duson, D-Portland. Whether kits are tested would be up to the person who has been sexually assaulted. Not everyone wants to move forward with an investigation or seek prosecution.
"We want to leave room for the victim, whose trauma created the kit," said Duson during the hearing.
Both proposals are bipartisan; Bennett is also a co-sponsor on Duson's bill. He said Monday afternoon that his biggest priority is establishing a statewide tracking system.
"These other questions are moot if we don't get the tracking and inventory part going," he said in a phone interview.
Advocates for sexual assault victims said Monday said that they support this too, although some said during Monday's hearing they preferred legislation that would allow victims the choice to opt out from sharing their kits' results.
Kapoldo said that in 2024, roughly two-thirds of the 70 people who completed exams agreed to share their results with law enforcement.
About half of those people were ready to share evidence at the time of their exams. Others wanted to wait.
"These numbers tell a powerful story," Kapoldo said. "Survivors are seeking the care but they're not always ready to engage in the judicial system or the criminal justice system."
A similar bill last year, LD 2129, would have cost roughly $350,000 in its first year, a little less than a third of which would have come from the state's Highway Fund.
Maine State Police Crime Lab Director Mike Zabarsky said in February that he was concerned by provisions in LD 549 that would require his staff to test all completed kits starting in 2027. (The same provisions are included in LD 1816.) He questioned whether the lab would have the capacity to take on this extra work, given its limited resources.
"Without more data from the pilot project, I cannot tell you whether the lab will be swamped with untested kits," Zabarsky testified. "What I can tell you is that the lab has a backlog of kits today and any additional kits submitted to us will have a chilling effect on our ability to prioritize violent crimes against people and process kits in a timely manner without detrimentally impacting our goal to maximize throughput and achieve reasonable turnaround times."
Supporters on Monday said the proposal under LD 1816 could cost less, because it only seeks to scale existing pilot programs in Kennebec and Penobscot counties to cover the whole state.
------
IF YOU or someone you know has experienced sexual violence, you can call 1-800-871-7741 for free and confidential help 24 hours a day.
TO LEARN more about sexual violence prevention and response in Maine, visit the Maine Coalition Against Sexual Assault website.
Copy the Story Link
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Los Angeles Times
32 minutes ago
- Los Angeles Times
As California's behavioral health workforce buckles, help is years away
REDDING, Calif. — This spring, the Good News Rescue Mission, which runs the only emergency homeless shelter in Shasta County, received a game-changing, $17.8-million state grant to build a 75-bed residential treatment facility in a region where thousands struggle with drug and alcohol addiction. Now comes the hard part — recruiting and hiring 10 certified substance use counselors and about a dozen other staff members to work at the new site, about 170 miles north of the state capital. 'Ask anyone trying to get staff and it's difficult,' said Justin Wandro, the mission's head of development. 'Try to get people who are willing to work in very intense, very difficult environments. It's hard.' California has long struggled to revitalize its behavioral health system and expand its workforce to meet the needs of its residents, particularly in rural parts of the state like the far north. Six years ago, the California Future Health Workforce Commission warned of a 'severe and growing' shortage across the behavioral health field, including psychiatrists, therapists, social workers and substance use counselors, and noted that two-thirds of Californians with a mental illness go without treatment. Since then, Gov. Gavin Newsom and state lawmakers have set out to transform the behavioral health system, with the Legislature dedicating more than $1 billion to train and recruit providers. Yet, the shortage has only worsened since the pandemic, which exacerbated mental health and addiction issues for many. In April, state health officials revealed that California was short roughly a third of the 8,100 psychiatrists and 117,000 licensed therapists it needed based on 2022 data. And the state's limited training capacity is making it hard to replace the number of retiring practitioners. As a result, existing workers are buckling under the workload while patients without quick access to help during a crisis are turning to costly emergency care. 'It feels helpless, because there is more than you can fix,' said Nick Zepponi, a social worker at the Hill Country Community Clinic CARE Center in Redding. The mental health urgent care clinic is one of the last lines of defense in the fraying behavioral health system in Shasta County, where the suicide rate is more than double the state average and overdose deaths increased more than threefold during the pandemic. 'There's more people than you can help that need it,' Zepponi said. Playing catch-up Under Newsom, the state has increased funding for youth preventive care, revised conservatorship laws, and set up a court-based program to compel treatment for some of the state's most severely mentally ill residents. The Democrat also championed the passage of Proposition 1, a cornerstone of his response to the state's homelessness and drug crises, saying it would add 10,000 treatment beds and housing units and increase access. One of the biggest remaining bottlenecks is the acute shortage of psychiatrists — licensed medical doctors who can prescribe medications such as antidepressants as well as antianxiety and antipsychotic drugs. While the state has opened more slots for training in recent years, it can cost as much as $250,000 a year and requires 12 years of postsecondary education. In 2025, 239 first-year residents enrolled in California psychiatry programs, an all-time high and up from 152 seven years ago. Yet it was far below the 527 first-year psychiatry residents the workforce commission estimated are needed annually from 2025 to 2029. 'The investments have lagged, and because they've been more recent, we're not really seeing as much of the fruit of those investments yet,' said Janet Coffman, a University of California-San Francisco associate professor who specializes in health care workforce issues. 'Some of these psychiatry programs that the state has funded haven't graduated their first class yet.' The state has also expanded the role of other providers, such as nurse practitioners trained to prescribe behavioral health drugs and certified peer counselors who might be able to meet with patients more frequently. Mark Ghaly, former secretary of the state Health and Human Services Agency and one of the architects of Newsom's behavioral health overhaul, said it's better to spread responsibilities among various providers, including some with shorter training timelines, to expand capacity faster. 'You're building workforce plans around models that, frankly, aren't meeting people's needs,' Ghaly said. 'If we try to chase the current models today with the demand that has grown, I don't think you catch up.' In addition to the state's own investments, California is tapping $1.9 billion in Medicaid funds to train, recruit, and retain behavioral health workers, enticing them with scholarships and loan repayments, and helping schools fund new residencies and fellowships. But the program took effect only recently, in January, and there is the looming threat that the Trump administration could rescind the funds at any time. In a statement, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services spokesperson Emily Hilliard said the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services has made clear that approved waivers remain in effect. 'That said, states should not rely on temporary demonstration funding as a substitute for sustained, direct investment in their healthcare workforce,' Hilliard added, saying the agency would continue to evaluate the outcomes of California's experiment, which sunsets at the end of 2029. Health advocates warn that California is so behind that any slowdown in behavioral health workforce funding would be detrimental. HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s move to fold the nation's mental health agency into a new department focused on chronic care and disease prevention, national advocates say, could spell trouble for program funding generally. Uber to the ER Kelly Monck, who lives in a pool house behind her mother's middle-class suburban home in Redding, struggles with depression. Despite having health coverage and knowing her way around the healthcare system, she often can't get an appointment with her psychiatrist when thoughts of suicide creep in. 'We've been fighting this demon since I was 15 years old,' said Monck, 38, who is deaf and has Ehlers-Danlos syndrome, a connective tissue disorder that has collapsed her airway and left her reliant on a ventilator and feeding tube. In April, Monck overdosed on her heart medication. Seeking help, she called her therapist, who eventually persuaded her to go to the emergency room. She took an Uber and waited in the ER for hours, she said, but there was no open treatment bed and she was released. Rather than go to the ER a second time, Monck called Hill Country when suicidal thoughts returned the following week. She had hoped that providers there could expedite an appointment with her county psychiatrist or adjust her medications. But clinic counselors aren't licensed to prescribe medication and could do little more than ensure she wasn't an immediate danger to herself. It wasn't until her mother drove her 250 miles to Stanford Medicine's psychiatry unit that she was able to get her medications adjusted. She didn't see her regular psychiatrist for two more weeks. Monck isn't alone. In some regions of the state, it can take patients months to see a psychiatrist, and those who urgently need help are increasingly turning to costly ER care. In 2022, patients with mental health or substance use disorders accounted for 1 in 3 inpatient hospitalizations and 1 in 6 emergency room visits, state data show. In ERs, doctors can often do little more than temporarily stabilize these patients, since long-term treatment beds are nearly impossible to find. Shasta Regional Medical Center, one of Shasta County's two major hospitals, has created a temporary holding area in the ER for mental health patients, in addition to 18 existing inpatient beds, said Brenten Fillmore, the hospital's director of behavioral health. 'It's not how the system is designed to work,' Fillmore said. 'There just are not enough beds to service the need, particularly when it comes to difficult cases.' Healthcare providers say most patients are better served in office and outpatient settings where regular appointments with clinicians could help them avert a crisis. The state estimates Shasta County has about a third of the psychiatrists and little more than half the licensed therapists it needs, significantly below the state average. More than once, clinicians at Hill Country have made the three-hour journey to take a client to the nearest medication-assisted detox facility, in Eureka, or farther south to San Francisco, said Brandy Gemmill, a substance use counselor. But once patients are sober, it's rare to find an opening in a longer-term residential program. 'What I struggle with is the lack of resources,' Gemmill said. 'Where do we send them? So then, they're back on the street and it's happening all over again.' When patients repeatedly fall through the cracks, Zepponi said, workers like him are at high risk of burnout, something that has hit behavioral health clinicians particularly hard. Every six months or so, when a slight twinge of dread starts to creep in at work, Zepponi knows he needs to schedule a week off if he wants to keep doing the job he loves. 'That's when I know I really need time off, and I have to act quickly.' Turning to GoFundMe In 2018, the Camp fire tore through the foothills of the Sierra Nevada in Butte County, killing 85, destroying about 14,000 homes, and displacing more than 50,000 people. Within weeks, patients with post-traumatic stress disorder, depression, and anxiety flooded into local hospitals and doctors' offices, but few providers were equipped to help them. An estimated 40 to 60 physicians left the region after the fire, deepening the shortage. A group of local doctors set out to reverse the trend, and last year the nonprofit Healthy Rural California launched the state's first psychiatric residency program north of Sacramento. Rachel Mitchell, director of the program, said even with a $1.5-million grant from the state for planning, the organization had to cobble together roughly $75,000 via private donations and a GoFundMe campaign to welcome its first class of four psychiatry residents. The federal grant money they rely on for operations, administered by the Health Resources and Services Administration, has been a volatile funding source. 'We'd love to get six students per class, but at this point we can't afford to,' Mitchell said. Program administrators want to tap into a more stable funding stream through CMS but must first wait for its partner, Enloe Medical Center in Chico, to recruit psychiatrists to teach and supervise residents. Its first class will graduate in 2028. Mai-Duc writes for KFF Health News, which publishes California Healthline, an editorially independent service of the California Health Care Foundation.
The Hill
3 days ago
- The Hill
Paxton seeks to remove 13 Texas Democrats from their seats
Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton (R) filed a lawsuit on Friday looking to vacate the seats of 13 Democratic state lawmakers who fled Texas in a bid to block Republicans from passing a new GOP-friendly House map. Paxton is asking the Texas Supreme Court to declare that the 13 lawmakers have vacated their offices after roughly 50 lawmakers left the state beginning on Sunday in a bid to block the passage of new maps. The 13 lawmakers affected include Democratic state Reps. Ron Reynolds, Vikki Goodwin, Gina Hinojosa, James Talarico, Lulu Flores, Mihaela Plesa, Suleman Lalani, Chris Turner, Ana-Maria Ramos, Jessica Gonzalez, John Bucy III, Gene Wu and Christina Morales. 'When members of the Legislature disregard arrest warrants, refuse to perform their duties, and announce that they intend to prevent the Legislature from exercising its constitutional responsibilities, they have, through words and conduct, demonstrated an intent to relinquish and abandon their offices,' the lawsuit states. 'The alternative would empower a minority faction to disrupt the operation of the chamber.' In a post on X touting the new lawsuit, Paxton described the Democrats as 'cowards' who had 'deliberately sabotaged the constitutional process.' Gov. Greg Abbott (R) already filed a lawsuit earlier this week looking to have Wu removed from his seat. Several of the impacted Democrats denounced the new lawsuit in separate statements. 'Texas Republicans have never been more desperate. First they put warrants out for our arrest, then they told their supporters to 'hunt us down,' and now they're trying to remove me from elected office,' Bucy said in a statement reacting to the lawsuit. 'This is what it looks like when a President, a Governor, and an entire political party work together to cheat in an attempt to steal an election,' he added. 'They are doing everything they possibly can to cling to power and subvert the will of millions of Americans.' Talarico taunted Paxton in a statement on X, saying 'come and take it.' 'Ken Paxton just filed a lawsuit to remove me from office,' he wrote. 'But this seat doesn't belong to him or me — it belongs to the people.' Republicans are putting pressure on Democrats to come back as the GOP looks to wrap up its special session. Republicans are looking to pass a new House map that would give their party five more pickup opportunities next year in addition to other priorities like flood recovery. Democrats are remaining out of the state for the time being over the new House map Republicans are pursuing. In response, Republicans have called for Democrats to be arrested and are requiring them to pick up their paychecks in-person rather than by direct deposit, another way to lure Democrats back.
Politico
4 days ago
- Politico
FBI agrees to help chase down quorum-breaking Texas Democrats
It is unclear what resources the FBI is investing in fulfilling Cornyn's request, or how it is approaching the situation as there is no apparent legal breach under its purview. A campaign aide for the senator on Thursday said his team isn't clear on what the FBI's green light means in terms of practical next steps. The FBI declined to comment for this story. Dozens of Democrats departed the state over the weekend in an attempt to thwart the state Legislature's passage of a newly redrawn congressional map that would grant Republicans five more favorable districts ahead of the 2026 midterms. In response, the state's Republican leaders have threatened to remove the truant Democrats from office, with Texas Gov. Greg Abbott declaring that they had 'forfeited their seats' and the state's Attorney General Ken Paxton moving to expel the lawmakers from the Legislature. Quorum-breaking is legal in the state, which lawmakers and experts have highlighted amid Republican attacks. Democrats have doubled down in their efforts, with Democratic National Committee Chair Ken Martin declaring during a press conference Tuesday that 'This is a new Democratic Party. We're bringing a knife to a knife fight.' But Republicans are pressing on in their attacks. In an appearance on conservative talk show host Dana Loesch's program on Wednesday, Abbott previewed the FBI's mobilization to search for and bring back the fleeing Democrats. 'It's my understanding that the FBI is going to search for these derelict Texas House members, in whatever state they may be in, and help identify them — and maybe work with us to bring them back,' Abbott said, adding that the lawmakers are 'not going to go to their cozy home; they will be arrested and taken to the Capitol.' The Republican governor on Tuesday also generated infighting within his own party when he bypassed district courts to file an emergency petition in the state's Supreme Court demanding the removal of Texas Democratic Caucus Chair Rep. Gene Wu. The move prompted immediate pushback from Paxton, who criticized the governor's disregard for the legal order of operations and emphasized that the legal maneuver could 'only be brought by the attorney general, a county attorney, or a district attorney.' Kyle Cheney and Adam Wren contributed to this report.
