Calcutta High Court denies bail to law student held for alleged communal post
The
Calcutta High Court
Tuesday denied the bail plea of
Sharmistha Panoli
, a 22-year-old law student and social media influencer, who was arrested by Kolkata Police for alleged offensive comments that - although retracted later - were deemed to have hurt the sentiments of a religious community.
"This case and this incident have given rise to three or four more cases. So, admittedly, the sentiments of a section of people in our country has been hurt," observed Justice Partha Sarathi Chatterjee, who was hearing the case Tuesday at the High Court. "We have
freedom of speech
and expression. That does not mean you will go on to hurt the sentiments of others. Our country is full of diversity--various languages, caste, creed and community. While making such a submission, we have to be cautious."
The High Court also requested the state government for submission of the case diary in the next hearing on June 5.
She was arrested from Gurgaon for allegedly publishing offensive contents and hurting the sentiments of a particular community in the wake of
Operation Sindoor
.
A trial court has ordered a 14-day judicial remand for Panoli after she was brought to West Bengal following her arrest in Gurgaon.
Live Events
"This video was made on social media, it was heard. This incident has led to a section of people's sentiment being hurt," the High Court observed. Panoli's counsel had alleged that she was being denied the basic amenities at the correctional facility where she is being held in judicial remand.
Economic Times WhatsApp channel
)
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
31 minutes ago
- Mint
Shashi Tharoor flags false equivalence with Pakistan on US mediation role – ‘this is about India versus terrorism'
Congress leader Shashi Tharoor has said having United States as a mediator between India and Pakistan would imply an equivalence which doesn't exist. "Mediation is not a term that we are particularly willing to entertain. You're implying an equivalence which simply doesn't exist, Tharoor said speaking at an event in Washington DC when asked if it is helpful to have the United States available as a mediator. Tharoor is part of all-party delegation traveling abroad as part of the Prime Minister Narendra Modi government's diplomatic outreach to highlight India's stand on terrorism following'Operation Sindoor'. 'There is no equivalence between terrorists and their victims. There is no equivalence between a country that provides a safe haven to terrorism and a country that's a flourishing multi-party democracy that's trying to get on with its business,' the Congress MP said. Tharoor said that Modi government also received calls at high levels from the US government and India appreciated their concern and their interest. At the same time, he said, they must have been making similar calls at the highest levels to the Pakistan side. "Because that's the side that needed persuading to stop this process, that may well have been where their messages really had the greatest effect. But that's guesswork on my part. I don't know what they said to the Pakistanis," he said. The Congress leader reiterated that India hit terror bases in Pakistan during Operation Tharoor while Pakistan hit civilains in retailiation since there are no terror bases in India. "There are no terror bases in India to hit. There are no terrorist organisations in India listed in the UN or the State Department anywhere else. So, what do you hit? You hit civilians, innocent people. That is the asymmetry of this particular conflict. We have tried not just to be precise and calibrated in our response, but we have tried systematically to signal we are not interested in war with Pakistan. We're not interested in attacking Pakistani civilians, ordinary people. This is about India versus terrorism," he said. As many as 26 people were killed and several others injured in the terrorist attack in Jammu and Kashmir's Pahalgam on 22 April. Indian Armed Forces launched Operation Sindoor on May 7, targeting terror infrastructure in Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied Jammu and Kashmir. There is no equivalence between terrorists and their victims. Key Takeaways Mediation by the US is viewed as inappropriate due to the lack of equivalence between India and Pakistan. Tharoor highlights the asymmetry in the conflict, stressing that India targets terror bases while Pakistan retaliates against civilians. The focus should remain on countering terrorism rather than establishing diplomatic parity.
India Today
38 minutes ago
- India Today
Same name as sanctioned terrorist: Bilawal Bhutto defends LeT commander at UN event
From the stage of the United Nations, former Pakistani Foreign Minister Bilawal Bhutto once again defended Hafiz Abdur Rauf, the man seen leading funeral prayers after India's airstrikes on terror camps in Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied Kashmir under Operation Sindoor, claiming he is not a terrorist. Repeating a line earlier pushed by Pakistan's military media wing, ISPR (Inter-Services Public Relations), Bhutto argued that Rauf merely shares a name with a sanctioned delegation (India's global outreach) goes around violently shoving this picture in everybody's face. They say 'Look, this guy is a terrorist'. The fact of the matter is that this man is not a terrorist. He happens to have a name similar to one of the sanctioned people, but he's not," Bilawal said at the UN briefing, referring to India presenting evidence of Rauf's presence at the ISPR's own evidence has contradicted this claim. A CNIC (computerised national identity card) shared by the ISPR showed a date of birth and identification number that exactly match those on the US Treasury Department's Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) list of designated global terrorists. The CNIC also confirms Rauf is affiliated with the Pakistan Markazi Muslim League (PMML), the successor to MML - both parties designated by the US as fronts of the terror group Lashkar-e-Taiba on 2 April US Treasury had earlier stated: "Few individuals are more integral to LeT's fundraising than Hafiz Abdur Rauf." Despite the evidence, Bilawal maintained his position, echoing ISPR's portrayal of Rauf as a "local cleric" and "family man". The Pakistani military had earlier tried to whitewash Rauf's presence at the funeral of LeT operatives killed in the strikes, claiming he was simply a party the same UN event, Bilawal also appeared to soften his stance on India by calling for cooperation between RAW and ISI to curb terrorism."Pakistan would still like to cooperate with India to combat terrorism," he said, suggesting a "dispute resolution mechanism" and asserting, "I am completely confident that if ISI and RAW sat down to work together, we'd see a significant drop in terrorism on both sides."Bhutto further claimed that 1.5 to 1.7 billion people in South Asia should not be left at the mercy of non-state actors, warning against the risk of war between nuclear powers triggered by terrorist an interaction with the Pakistani community in New York, Bhutto made a provocative remark, claiming that Pakistan has mastered the art of asserted that if India genuinely wants to combat terrorism, it should take lessons from Pakistan's intelligence agency, the ISI. "We have learnt how to deal with terrorism. We are experts. India should come and learn from the ISI how to fight it," Bhutto Pakistan continues to face backlash for attempting to mislead the international community regarding the presence of a US-designated terrorist at the funeral in Muridke, a known LeT evidence shared by India, including by Foreign Secretary Vikram Misri, clearly showed Hafiz Abdur Rauf leading the prayers, with uniformed Pakistani Army and police officers in attendance."These are not clerics or civilians - they are designated terrorists and those who support them," Misri had earlier said, rebutting Pakistan's also drew criticism during the UN interaction for alleging that Indian Muslims were being demonised in the wake of the recent terror attack in Pahalgam that killed 26 civilians. When questioned by a journalist, who noted that Indian Army briefings were led by Muslim officers themselves, Bilawal was visibly unsettled and admitted, "As far as the operations are concerned, you're absolutely right."Must Watch
United News of India
an hour ago
- United News of India
All-Party Delegation led by Shashi Tharoor briefs key interlocutors in US about cross-border terrorism
Washington/New Delhi, June 5 (UN) The All-Party Parliamentary Delegation led by Congress MP Shashi Tharoor briefed the leadership of the House Congressional Caucus on India, the House Foreign Affairs Committee, media and the Indian diaspora on the cross-border terrorism faced by India. The Congressmen, including Rep. Ro Khanna and Rep. Rich McCormick, expressed unequivocal and bipartisan condemnation for the terror attack in Pahalgam, a statement by the Indian Embassy in the US said. The All-Party team is visiting USA to brief key interlocutors about the threat of Pakistan backed terrorism faced by India and India's strong stand against terrorism. On Wednesday, in the US Congress, the delegation met the leadership of the House Congressional Caucus on India and Indian Americans in the 119th Congress, the co-chairs Rep. Ro Khanna and Rep. Rich McCormick and the two vice co-chairs Rep. Andy Barr and Rep. Marc Veasey. The parliamentary delegation briefed the Caucus members on the cross-border terrorism faced by India. The Congressmen expressed unequivocal and bipartisan condemnation for the terror attack in Pahalgam. They also expressed their support for India's right to respond to terrorism in the spirit of zero tolerance against terrorism. The Caucus members also hailed the strong strategic partnership between India and USA. Thereafter the delegation met the leadership of the House Foreign Affairs Committee (HFAC) in a special high-power meeting hosted by Committee Chairman Rep. Brian Mast and Ranking Member Rep. Gregory Meeks. Also, in attendance were HFAC's South and Central Asia Subcommittee Chairman Rep. Bill Huizenga, Ranking Member Rep. Sydney Kamlager-Dove, and HFAC's East Asia & Pacific Subcommittee Chairperson Rep. Young Kim and Ranking Member Rep. Ami Bera. The interaction saw a constructive exchange of views on the developments relating to the attack in Pahalgam and India's stand on dealing with such attacks in the future. The Committee Leadership condemned the Pahalgam attack unequivocally. The All Party Parliamentary Delegation was received at the United States Capitol by a bipartisan group of senior U.S. Senators, including leading members from the Senate Foreign Relations Committee (SFRC), Senate Select Committee on Intelligence, and the Senate India Caucus. Senator James Risch, Chairman of the U.S. Senate Foreign Relations Committee, Leaders of the SFRC subcommittee dealing with South Asia and Counterterrorism Senator Dave McCormick and Senator Jacky Rosen, Vice Chairman of the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence Senator Mark Warner, Member of SFRC and Intelligence Committee Senator John Cornyn and Member of Homeland Security Committee Senator Elissa Slotkin were in attendance. The parliamentary delegation discussed the success of Operation Sindoor, laid out details of Pakistan-sponsored cross-border terrorism, and outlined India's firm resolve to appropriately deal with any such future incidents. In a separate interaction, members of the delegation also met with Rep. Lisa McClain, Chairwoman of the House Republican Conference for the 119th Congress- the highest-ranking woman in Congress. In media interactions, a panel comprising of Shashi Tharoor, Milind Deora, Tejasvi Surya and Ambassador Taranjit Singh Sandhu spoke at the historic National Press Club Newsmakers event on Operation Sindoor, regional security and India's diplomatic outreach to the United States. In another media briefing, hosted at the Embassy of India, the delegation interacted with the American and Indian press corps and conveyed India's resolute stance in dealing with cross-border terrorism. At the close of the day, the All Party delegation met with prominent members of the Indian diaspora wherein they highlighted India's resolute and united stand against terrorism. The Indian diaspora members shared their message of solidarity with the victims of terrorism and support for India's fight against terrorism. UNI RN
