Latest news with #AlanKane
The Irish Sun
15 hours ago
- Politics
- The Irish Sun
Omagh bombing victims to ‘heap shame' on Irish Govt during public inquiry amid ‘broken promises' and ‘false assurances'
VICTIMS of the Omagh bombing intend to use a public inquiry to 'heap shame' on the Irish Government for its failings over the atrocity, a barrister has said. The inquiry also heard that victims are 'sick and tired of platitudes, false assurances and broken promises' from Advertisement 5 The injury is investigating whether the explosion could have been prevented by authorities Credit: pACEMAKER pRESS 5 The hearing room at the Silverbirch Hotel in Omagh where the inquest gathered today Credit: Liam McBurney/PA Wire 5 Alan Kane delivered a statement on behalf of bereaved families Credit: Liam McBurney/PA Wire The Omagh Bombing Inquiry, chaired by Lord Turnbull, is hearing opening statements from core participants. On Tuesday the focus moved to statements from the legal representatives of bereaved families. The Real The public inquiry was set up by the previous government to examine whether Advertisement READ MORE IN IRISH NEWS Barrister Alan Kane KC delivered a statement on behalf of the families of These include the families of Debra-Anne Cartwright, Olive Hawkes, Julia Hughes, Philomena Skelton, Samantha McFarland, Alan Radford, Lorraine Wilson, who were all killed in the massacre, as well as several other people who were injured. He told the inquiry: 'It is important that we always keep in focus that it was republican terrorists under the name Real IRA who planned and planted the Omagh bomb. "They alone are responsible for the loss and hurt caused by it. Advertisement Most read in Irish News Latest 'On hearing the accounts of so many at the commemorative hearings, it beggars all belief as to what else was intended other than murderous carnage by leaving a bomb in a peaceful town's main street on a busy sunny Saturday afternoon where so many 'The preventability of the murders and injuries was at all times within the absolute control of the Real IRA.' Omagh service held to remember victims 20 years after bombing He added: 'Our clients are of the clear belief that whatever aspects of preventability may lie at the door of the 'Our clients again renew their call for a parallel inquiry to be immediately established by the Government of the Republic of Ireland, a call that they should not be required to repeat. Advertisement 'Our clients remain greatly disappointed at the lack of any commitment of the authorities in the Republic of Ireland to meaningfully assist this inquiry. 'They regard the memorandum of understanding, agreed with the Minister of Justice of the Republic of Ireland as wholly unsatisfactory. 'Our clients wish to use this inquiry to heap shame on the Government of the Republic of Ireland for their failures.' 5 Caroline Martin, sister of Esther Gibson attened the Silverbirch Hotel in Omagh today Credit: Liam McBurney/PA Wire Advertisement 5 Michael Gallagher, father victim Aiden Gallagher, was also in attendance Credit: Liam McBurney/PA Wire
The Independent
16 hours ago
- Politics
- The Independent
Omagh victims intend to use public inquiry to ‘heap shame' on Irish Government
Victims of the Omagh bombing intend to use a public inquiry to 'heap shame' on the Irish Government for its failings over the atrocity, a barrister has said. The inquiry also heard that victims are 'sick and tired of platitudes, false assurances and broken promises' from Dublin over the bombing. The Omagh Bombing Inquiry, chaired by Lord Turnbull, is hearing opening statements from core participants. On Tuesday the focus moved to statements from the legal representatives of bereaved families. The Real IRA bomb in the Co Tyrone town in August 1998 killed 29 people, including a woman who was pregnant with twins, in the worst single atrocity in the Troubles in Northern Ireland. The public inquiry was set up by the previous government to examine whether the explosion could have been prevented by the UK authorities. Barrister Alan Kane KC delivered a statement on behalf of the families of Omagh victims represented by solicitor John McBurney. These include the families of Debra-Anne Cartwright, Olive Hawkes, Julia Hughes, Philomena Skelton, Samantha McFarland, Alan Radford, Lorraine Wilson, who were all killed in the massacre, as well as several other people who were injured. He told the inquiry: 'It is important that we always keep in focus that it was republican terrorists under the name Real IRA who planned and planted the Omagh bomb. They alone are responsible for the loss and hurt caused by it. 'On hearing the accounts of so many at the commemorative hearings, it beggars all belief as to what else was intended other than murderous carnage by leaving a bomb in a peaceful town's main street on a busy sunny Saturday afternoon where so many innocent women, children and men were likely to be. 'The preventability of the murders and injuries was at all times within the absolute control of the Real IRA.' He added: 'Our clients are of the clear belief that whatever aspects of preventability may lie at the door of the UK state authorities, blame, to a greater or lesser extent, rests with the state authorities in the Republic of Ireland. 'Our clients again renew their call for a parallel inquiry to be immediately established by the Government of the Republic of Ireland, a call that they should not be required to repeat. 'Our clients remain greatly disappointed at the lack of any commitment of the authorities in the Republic of Ireland to meaningfully assist this inquiry. 'They regard the memorandum of understanding, agreed with the Minister of Justice of the Republic of Ireland as wholly unsatisfactory. 'Our clients wish to use this inquiry to heap shame on the Government of the Republic of Ireland for their failures.' Mr Kane said there was a 'moral, human and legal imperative' on the Dublin Government to set up its own inquiry. He said: 'As a country with a professed European inclination, it is extremely regrettable that the Republic of Ireland continues to be in breach of Article 2 of the European Convention on Human Rights in failing to ensure there has ever been any effective investigation into the death of the people to whom they owe that duty. 'There are preventability issues which clearly arise from the territorial origin of the Omagh bomb, and the cowardly refuge which its perpetrators enjoyed within the boundaries of the Republic of Ireland.' The barrister said his clients had likened the work of the public inquiry to an MOT vehicle test. He said: 'To their disbelief, they are told only the engine can be inspected, all that exists beyond the engine, including the body, the suspension, the brakes, the contents of the boot, cannot be examined. 'Such an MOT would clearly be unfit for purpose. 'This inquiry can only examine the parts of the car made in the UK as it were, the preventability, it cannot examine the rest of the car where the terrorists sat, or the boot area where the deadly bomb was hidden. 'If this inquiry could examine the whole car then it would also be able to examine any preventability issues which fall on the Republic of Ireland state authorities and all the faults and defects in the vehicle could be identified.' The barrister referred to comments from former Taoiseach Bertie Ahern that no stone would be left unturned to bring those responsible for the 1998 atrocity to justice. He said: 'That is a promise which has significance only for the ignoring and disregarding of it which has taken place over the almost 27 years which has passed since the Omagh bombing.' Mr Kane added: 'I have the authority of those I represent to say they are sick and tired of platitudes, false assurances, broken promises and grand but empty words from the state authorities of the Republic of Ireland. 'Their resolute refusal to institute a parallel inquiry and their ongoing failure to provide real and meaningful cooperation with this inquiry speaks far louder than their words.' The barrister referred to a memorandum of understanding (MOU) agreed between the inquiry and the Irish Government to allow access to material held in Dublin. Mr Kane said the MOU is 'redundant' due to the terms of how it was drafted. He said: 'First because the assessment of relevance is in the power of the Republic of Ireland, secondly because it only relates to relevance concerning preventability by the UK state authorities. 'This is an unacceptable yet significant escape clause for the Republic of Ireland. 'Under the memorandum the Republic of Ireland state authorities, and therefore any information which reflects badly on them, could be determined by them to be irrelevant.' He added: 'This voluntary statement of participation by the Government of the Republic of Ireland lacks any degree of real commitment and does nothing to give our clients any degree of confidence in it.'
BreakingNews.ie
19 hours ago
- Politics
- BreakingNews.ie
Omagh victims intend to use public inquiry to ‘heap shame' on Irish Government
Victims of the Omagh bombing intend to use a public inquiry to 'heap shame' on the Irish Government for its failings over the atrocity, a barrister has said. The inquiry also heard that victims are 'sick and tired of platitudes, false assurances and broken promises' from Dublin over the bombing. Advertisement The Omagh Bombing Inquiry, chaired by Lord Turnbull, is hearing opening statements from core participants. On Tuesday the focus moved to statements from the legal representatives of bereaved families. The hearing room at the Silverbirch Hotel in Omagh, Co Tyrone (Liam McBurney/PA) The Real IRA bomb in the Co Tyrone town in August 1998 killed 29 people, including a woman who was pregnant with twins, in the worst single atrocity in the Troubles in Northern Ireland. The public inquiry was set up by the previous government to examine whether the explosion could have been prevented by the UK authorities. Barrister Alan Kane KC delivered a statement on behalf of the families of Omagh victims represented by solicitor John McBurney. Advertisement These include the families of Debra-Anne Cartwright, Olive Hawkes, Julia Hughes, Philomena Skelton, Samantha McFarland, Alan Radford, Lorraine Wilson, who were all killed in the massacre, as well as several other people who were injured. He told the inquiry: 'It is important that we always keep in focus that it was republican terrorists under the name Real IRA who planned and planted the Omagh bomb. They alone are responsible for the loss and hurt caused by it. 'On hearing the accounts of so many at the commemorative hearings, it beggars all belief as to what else was intended other than murderous carnage by leaving a bomb in a peaceful town's main street on a busy sunny Saturday afternoon where so many innocent women, children and men were likely to be. 'The preventability of the murders and injuries was at all times within the absolute control of the Real IRA.' Advertisement He added: 'Our clients are of the clear belief that whatever aspects of preventability may lie at the door of the UK state authorities, blame, to a greater or lesser extent, rests with the state authorities in the Republic of Ireland. 'Our clients again renew their call for a parallel inquiry to be immediately established by the Government of the Republic of Ireland, a call that they should not be required to repeat. 'Our clients remain greatly disappointed at the lack of any commitment of the authorities in the Republic of Ireland to meaningfully assist this inquiry. 'They regard the memorandum of understanding, agreed with the Minister of Justice of the Republic of Ireland as wholly unsatisfactory. Advertisement 'Our clients wish to use this inquiry to heap shame on the Government of the Republic of Ireland for their failures.' Mr Kane said there was a 'moral, human and legal imperative' on the Dublin Government to set up its own inquiry. He said: 'As a country with a professed European inclination, it is extremely regrettable that the Republic of Ireland continues to be in breach of Article 2 of the European Convention on Human Rights in failing to ensure there has ever been any effective investigation into the death of the people to whom they owe that duty. 'There are preventability issues which clearly arise from the territorial origin of the Omagh bomb, and the cowardly refuge which its perpetrators enjoyed within the boundaries of the Republic of Ireland.' Advertisement The barrister said his clients had likened the work of the public inquiry to an MOT vehicle test. Solicitor John McBurney, arrives at the Silverbirch Hotel in Omagh for the Omagh Bombing Inquiry (Liam McBurney/PA) He said: 'To their disbelief, they are told only the engine can be inspected, all that exists beyond the engine, including the body, the suspension, the brakes, the contents of the boot, cannot be examined. 'Such an MOT would clearly be unfit for purpose. 'This inquiry can only examine the parts of the car made in the UK as it were, the preventability, it cannot examine the rest of the car where the terrorists sat, or the boot area where the deadly bomb was hidden. 'If this inquiry could examine the whole car then it would also be able to examine any preventability issues which fall on the Republic of Ireland state authorities and all the faults and defects in the vehicle could be identified.' The barrister referred to comments from former Taoiseach Bertie Ahern that no stone would be left unturned to bring those responsible for the 1998 atrocity to justice. He said: 'That is a promise which has significance only for the ignoring and disregarding of it which has taken place over the almost 27 years which has passed since the Omagh bombing.' Mr Kane added: 'I have the authority of those I represent to say they are sick and tired of platitudes, false assurances, broken promises and grand but empty words from the state authorities of the Republic of Ireland. 'Their resolute refusal to institute a parallel inquiry and their ongoing failure to provide real and meaningful cooperation with this inquiry speaks far louder than their words.' The Omagh bombing devastated the centre of Omagh in 1998 (Paul McErlane/PA) The barrister referred to a memorandum of understanding (MOU) agreed between the inquiry and the Irish Government to allow access to material held in Dublin. Mr Kane said the MOU is 'redundant' due to the terms of how it was drafted. He said: 'First because the assessment of relevance is in the power of the Republic of Ireland, secondly because it only relates to relevance concerning preventability by the UK state authorities. 'This is an unacceptable yet significant escape clause for the Republic of Ireland. 'Under the memorandum the Republic of Ireland state authorities, and therefore any information which reflects badly on them, could be determined by them to be irrelevant.' He added: 'This voluntary statement of participation by the Government of the Republic of Ireland lacks any degree of real commitment and does nothing to give our clients any degree of confidence in it.'
Irish Times
19 hours ago
- Politics
- Irish Times
Omagh bombing bereaved wish to use inquiry to ‘heap shame' on Irish Government over ‘failures'
Those bereaved and injured in the 1998 Omagh bombing wish to use the inquiry 'to heap shame on the Government of the Republic of Ireland for their failures,' their legal representative has said. Delivering an opening statement to the inquiry on Tuesday, Alan Kane KC said those he represented were 'sick and tired of platitudes, false assurances, broken promises and empty words from the State authorities of the Republic of Ireland. 'Their resolute refusal to institute a parallel inquiry, and their ongoing failure to provide real and meaningful co-operation with this inquiry speaks far louder than their words,' he said. 'One of our clients' main areas of significant concern … is the responsibility of the Government of the Republic of Ireland and their State authorities to have prevented the Omagh bomb.' READ MORE Speaking on behalf of the families of seven victims of the bombing: Debra Ann Cartwright; Olive Hawkes; Julia Hughes; Mena Skelton; Samantha McFarland; Alan Radford; Lorraine Wilson; and a number of the injured, Mr Kane said they were 'of the clear belief that whatever aspects of preventability may lie at the door of the UK state authorities, blame to a greater or lesser extent rests with the State authorities in the Republic of Ireland.' He renewed their call for a parallel inquiry 'to be immediately established by the Government of the Republic of Ireland, a call that they should not be required to repeat'. The barrister was also strongly critical of the memorandum of understanding agreed between the State and the inquiry in April, which sets out working arrangements to cover the disclosure of materials. Alan Kane arriving at the Omagh bombing inquiry on Tuesday. Photograph: Liam McBurney/PA Wire Mr Kane said his clients 'remain greatly disappointed at the lack of any commitment on the part of the authorities in the Republic of Ireland to meaningfully assist this inquiry'. He said they regard the memorandum of understanding agreed with the Republic's Minister of Justice as wholly unsatisfactory. It was, he said, a 'cynical effort to appear to be assisting and co-operating and to alleviate the pressure of the commencement of this inquiry on themselves,' adding, 'they grasped this opportunity of a fig leaf'. A total of 31 people, including unborn twins, died and hundreds were injured when a car bomb planted by the dissident republican group the Real IRA exploded in the centre of Omagh on August 15th, 1998. The inquiry into the bombing, which opened in the Co Tyrone town in 2024, was ordered by the UK government to examine whether the atrocity could reasonably have been prevented by British state authorities. It followed a high court judgement in 2021 which found it was potentially plausible the bombing could have been prevented and recommended the UK government should carry out a human rights-compliant investigation into alleged security failures in the lead-up to the attack. The judge said he did not have the power to compel a similar inquiry in the Republic of Ireland, but urged the State to establish its own investigation. Ireland has not done so, but has repeatedly stressed its commitment to assisting and supporting the inquiry. Mr Kane said his clients consider 'there is a moral, human and legal imperative on the Government of the Republic of Ireland to establish a parallel inquiry into the deaths of people who were their own citizens, visitors to their country, and those who would have been entitled to Irish citizenship under their laws. [ The stories of the Omagh bomb victims: from unborn twins to community stalwarts Opens in new window ] 'As a country with a professed European inclination, it is extremely regrettable that the Republic of Ireland continues to be in breach of Article Two of the European Convention on Human Rights … failing to ensure that there has ever been any effective investigation into the death of the people to whom they owe that duty. 'There are preventability issues which clearly arise from the territorial origin of the Omagh bomb and the cowardly refuge which its perpetrators enjoyed within the boundaries of the Republic of Ireland,' he said. Earlier this year, the inquiry heard four weeks of emotional testimony from bereaved relatives who delivered pen portraits of their loved ones, as well as from the injured and first responders. It resumed on Monday for two days to hear opening statements from core participants to the inquiry. Core participants include the bereaved and injured and state authorities such as Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI) and the Northern Secretary, representing the UK government.
