02-06-2025
Berks man pleads guilty in fake artwork sales
A Berks County man has pleaded guilty in federal court to charges he sold about $186,000 in counterfeit artwork that he claimed had been created by prominent artists, including the late Keith Haring.
Carter Reese, 77, pleaded guilty Thursday before U.S. District Court Judge Jeffrey L. Schmehl in Philadelphia to one count each of wire fraud and mail fraud, according to an announcement by U.S. Attorney David Metcalf of the Eastern District.
Prosecutors are seeking the forfeiture of $186,125, the total amount Reese received in selling the fake artwork, officials said.
According to court documents:
Reese, claiming to have more than 40 years of experience in art and antiquities, operated Carter P. Reese American Antiques and Fine Art. Online records indicate the business lists a Wyomissing address.
An unnamed person — referred to as Associate 1 in court documents — pleaded guilty in federal court in Illinois in September 2010 to six counts of mail fraud and wire fraud in the sale of counterfeit artwork, some of which he had purchased on eBay.
He admitted he and co-conspirators schemed to sell limited edition fine art prints and that he forged the signatures of certain artists on those prints.
Prosecutors note Associate 1 died in November 2021.
From February 2019 to March 2021, Reese sold and tried to sell art that he represented as genuine pieces created by artists, including Francis Bacon, Jean-Michel Basquiat, Jean Cocteau, Fernand Léger, Roy Lichtenstein, Joan Miró, Pablo Picasso, Andy Warhol and Haring, a Kutztown native.
Reese purchased and acquired pieces from Associate 1 at low prices. Many of the pieces Reese sold appeared identical to images of artwork reproductions Associate 1 bought on eBay.
Reese told potential buyers that he purchased more than 100 pieces of art from a collector — identified in court papers as Individual 1 — including work by Bacon, Basquiat, Cocteau, Haring, Léger, Lichtenstein, Miró, Picasso and Warhol.
Individual 1 never owned or sold such a collection to Reese. At the time Reese offered this art for sale, Individual 1 was dead and thus unavailable to verify Reese's claims for potential buyers.
Reese told potential buyers that he acquired an additional set of art from an individual named 'Ken James' who was friends with various renowned artists.
'Ken James' was an alias used by Associate 1 so potential buyers would not know he had been convicted of selling fake artwork. Associate 1 did not have the purported connections to such artists.
To support his claims that the artwork was authentic, Reese concealed Associate 1's involvement with the fraudulent artwork; provided prospective buyers with false provenance information such as affidavits signed by himself and an attorney stating that he had acquired the artwork from Individual 1 and sold prospective buyers art on which forged inscriptions and signatures had been added.
Reese continued to claim the artwork was authentic even after some potential buyers told him the work was fake.
A potential buyer also informed Reese of Associate 1's conviction, but Reese continued to offer artwork he had obtained from Associate 1 as authentic.
During a telephone call on July 16, 2020, Reese told a person in Florida that he had acquired various works of art from Individual 1 and offered to sell them.
On July 30, 2020, Reese sent a package to the person in Florida containing an affidavit notarized in Berks County falsely certifying that he had acquired artwork by Miró, Lichtenstein, Haring, Picasso, Basquiat, Bacon, Warhol and others from Individual 1.
Reese is scheduled to be sentenced in September and faces a maximum possible prison term of 40 years.
