Latest news with #BrigidODonnell
Irish Times
23-05-2025
- Irish Times
Garda settles High Court case against State over submachine gun discharge
A garda who was shot in the leg when his submachine gun discharged after it allegedly snagged on his bulletproof vest has settled his High Court action against the State. The garda brought an action against the Garda Commissioner, the Minister for Justice and the Attorney General. Ms Justice Denise Brett ruled that the media cannot identify the garda or any Garda witness in the case. The garda's ankle was allegedly shattered after he manoeuvred himself within the confined space of a patrol vehicle, causing the safety selector switch and the trigger of his firearm to snag on his bulletproof vest. He claimed the gun discharged one round during the incident in July 2019. READ MORE In evidence, he told the court he had never experienced pain like it and nearly passed out. On the third day of the hearing, the garda's senior counsel, Richard Kean, instructed by solicitor Brigid O'Donnell, told the court the case has settled and could be struck out. In his case, the garda claimed there was a failure to provide him with a safe place of work and he had been caused to carry his firearm in a confined space while wearing allegedly inappropriate personal protective equipment. At the opening of the case this week, the court heard liability was admitted by the defence. In his evidence, the garda, who had been in the force for more than 15 years at the time of the incident, said he was wearing a bulletproof vest, had a pistol in a holster and a submachine gun in a sling around his neck pointing down. He said he was in the driver seat and turned around to check the back seat when his submachine gun discharged. 'I felt immediate excruciating pain, and I saw smoke from the weapon and blood squirting up to the seat,' he said. He said his colleague made his weapons safe and he was brought to hospital. 'The ankle was shattered. I remember the doctor saying my leg was a mush before I went into surgery,' he told the judge. The bullet went through the back of his left leg and ankle joint and his left ankle had shattered. He had to have surgery and physiotherapy and was out of work for 18 months. The garda told the court he did everything he could to build up his leg afterwards 'but the pain never really left'.
BreakingNews.ie
21-05-2025
- BreakingNews.ie
Garda who was shot in leg by his own gun sues State
A garda who was shot in the leg when his sub-machine gun discharged after it allegedly snagged on his bulletproof vest has sued the State in the High Court. He has brought an action against the Garda Commissioner, the Minister for Justice and the Attorney General. Advertisement The garda's ankle was shattered after he claimed he was required to manoeuvre himself within the confined space of a patrol vehicle, leading to the safety selector switch and the trigger of his firearm allegedly snagging on his bulletproof vest and the gun discharging one round. In evidence, the garda told the court he had never experienced pain like it and nearly passed out. In the proceedings, it is claimed that there was a failure to provide the garda with a safe place of work, and he had been caused to carry his firearm in close proximity in a confined space while wearing allegedly inappropriate personal protective equipment. Ms Justice Denise Brett ruled that the garda or any garda witness in the case cannot be identified. Advertisement His counsel, Liam Reidy SC, instructed by solicitor Brigid O'Donnell, told the court that liability was admitted in the case but initially there was a full denial of liability and allegations of contributory negligence were made against the garda that he had been the author of his own misfortune. This was distressing for the garda and he could not believe it, Ms O'Donnell said. In his evidence, the garda, who was in the force for over 15 years at the time of the incident, said he had been on patrol in July 2019 with colleagues in an area where there had been serious incidents, including shootings. He said he was the driver of the jeep and he was wearing a bulletproof vest and had a pistol in a holster and a sub-machine gun in a sling around his neck, pointing down. Advertisement He said he turned around to check the back seat when his sub machine gun discharged. 'I felt immediate excruciating pain, and I saw smoke from the weapon and blood squirting up to the seat,' he said. He added: 'The pain really kicked in; it was so bad, I nearly passed out. I never experienced that type of pain,' he said. He said his colleague made his weapons safe, and he was brought to hospital. Advertisement 'The ankle was shattered. I remember the doctor saying my leg was a mush before I went into surgery,' he told the judge. The bullet had gone through the back of his left leg and ankle joint, and his left ankle had shattered. He had to have surgery and later physiotherapy. He was out of work for 18 months after the incident. Ireland Annual Garda memorial day made 'more poignant' by... Read More The garda told the court he did everything he could to build up his leg afterwards ' but the pain never really left.' He had further surgery to the ankle in January this year, and he told the court he is still in pain, and he lost a lot of muscle mass in his leg, and he will have to build his leg back up again. The Garda told the judge he did everything in accordance with procedures in relation to the handling of his firearm. He said he prided himself in relation to safety with firearms. He said he was devastated when the claims of contributory negligence were initially made by the State parties. The case before Ms Justice Denise Brett continues on Thursday.
