Latest news with #ChancellorElection
Russia Today
11-05-2025
- Politics
- Russia Today
Why is Germany such a mess?
It seems long ago already, but politically speaking, it was really only yesterday that the last, deeply unpopular German government collapsed on November 6 of last year. Based on a fractious coalition and led by the hapless Olaf Scholz, it was a flop from almost the beginning to the bitter end. But what finally imploded Scholz's cabinet was its finance minister's refusal to hollow out Germany's – back then – severe restrictions on public debt, specifically to throw even more money at Ukraine. Exactly half a year after this fiasco, the next and current German government produced another one, even before it had really started: On 6 May, its designated leader Friedrich Merz from the mainstream conservatives (CDU) failed to get parliament to elect him as chancellor. This may look like a formality because, after complicated and humiliating maneuvering, Merz managed to find enough votes on a second try. Yet rest assured, no one in Germany thinks this was a minor glitch. For one thing, unlike a coalition breakdown, this was an entirely unprecedented failure: no post-World War II German chancellor has ever failed to be confirmed in the first round. That's why, on the day of the disaster, some parliamentarians even spoke of a fundamental 'crisis of the state.' No wonder really, because would-be-chancellors only ask parliament for this vote when they believe they have a majority of deputies securely on their side. So did Merz, too. And that is why his initial dud was so much worse than just a sad historic first: The only way he could fail was by quiet but deliberate mutiny from below and, clearly, arrogant negligence on his side. His coalition is made up of his own conservatives and the Social Democrats (SPD). If every member of parliament from these two parties had supported him in the first round, a second one would not have been needed. Clearly, then, it was deputies from his own party or its coalition allies who refused to comply. We will never know who exactly because the vote was anonymous, but we do know that there were at least 18 rebels. A major conservative commentator was right: This blow below the belt from Merz's own ranks will hurt for a long time. This is an awful way to begin a chancellorship. And not only because from now on, right from the get-go, the 'partners' – yes, those are scare quotes – now divvying up power and positions in Berlin will always have to wonder which one of them – SPD or CDU (or even both)? – is harboring snakes in the grass. And when might they strike again? Welcome to the all-new coalition: as backstabbing as the last one but faster off the mark. More fundamentally, if you can't keep your troops together on confirming you as the boss, how do you expect to get your budgets and laws through? But things are even more foreboding in this case. For Merz could only even have a shot at high office because Germany is in such a comprehensive mess: demography, the economy, infrastructure, the party system, foreign policy, technology, and, last but not least, the public mood. You name it – nothing, really nothing, is okay. It is against this dark background that a major German economist serving on the government's own council of experts is already asking the inevitable question: How can this new coalition government fulfill Merz's key promise to finally address this national misery, if it is so obviously bereft of unity? And, we may add, of discipline and foresight, too, because it takes astonishing sloppiness to prepare a chancellor vote so badly. Another economist notes that the debacle has also sent a 'devastating signal' to the rest of the world. Indeed. And good luck for Merz when trying to tell Trump off for his team's meddling in German politics: Whether Trump will say it or not, it is certain that he has already slotted Merz as a 'loser.' And the American bruiser-in-chief has a point. Not only because of the embarrassing lack of professionalism that came to light in mismanaging this crucial vote, but also because Merz's CDU and their SPD coalition partners under Lars Klingbeil richly deserved their come-uppance. Between the last elections and cobbling together their coalition, they engineered a crassly foul maneuver: Clearly against the spirit if not the letter of the constitution, they used the old parliament – de facto already voted out by Germany's citizens – for perhaps the single greatest flipflop in German postwar history. Remember those strict limits for public debt over which the preceding coalition collapsed? Merz ran his electoral campaign promising that he would not abandon this so-called 'debt brake.' As a dyed-in-the-wool conservative, he was in an excellent position to make that claim and get voters to believe it. And yet, it was his first action – even before entering office – to break that promise. And not in a small, corner-cutting way. Merz did not cut corners but razed the edifice to the ground. Having run and won (barely) as a fiscal hawk, he rapidly made a screeching U-turn to – in CNN's words – 'massively expand borrowing and super-charge military spending.' To the tune of a cool trillion or so over the next decade. Many voters and members of his own party were not only bewildered but aghast. We cannot know for sure, but I and many other Germans are probably right guessing that this massive breach of faith motivated at least some of the rebels during the chancellor vote. What we do know for sure is that Merz's personal ratings have crashed even before he almost failed to become chancellor. Never popular to begin with, he has reached a nadir: On the eve of the parliamentary vote, 56% of Germans were against Merz becoming chancellor, only 38% welcomed that prospect. And Merz is not the only one who has emerged dented from this affair: For complicated procedural reasons, Merz needed the cooperation of the Die Linke party under its shooting star Heidi Reichinnek to get his second chance. For Die Linke, providing this help was probably a very bad move. Reichinnek is to Germany what Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez is to the US: a social-media savvy lifestyle leftist with hubristic rhetoric (anyone for abolishing capitalism, all of it, right now and with tattoos, please?) and deeply tactical behavior in the real world. By helping out the unpopular arch-capitalist Merz, she may have overdone it even for some of her most devoted TikTok fans. But it's not all bad news. At least not for everyone. The AfD – under pressure from Germany's domestic intelligence service and the possible threat of a complete ban – is likely to profit. It may have missed a superb chance of embarrassing Merz by actually voting for him. But there is another effect: The collaboration of the oh-so-terribly radical Reichinnek and her party, has already made some German observers ask a simple, plausible question: If both Die Linke and the AfD used to be treated as beyond the pale – or, in German parlance, 'firewalled' – and yet Merz had no problem relying on Die Linke to get into office (no less!), then, clearly, that whole 'firewall' thing is not all it's cracked up to be. And if that is so, then the firewall against the AfD may well also crumble one day. In fact, as a matter of consistency and fairness, it should, whether you like the AfD or not. What an odd way of becoming the new leader of Germany's political mainstream: Limping through the entry gate, badly bruised and humiliated as no chancellor before, while once again de facto strengthening the country's largest and most threatening insurgent party. Merz's predecessor Scholz started with much undeserved advance praise and ended abysmally. Merz has managed to start abysmally already.
Yahoo
06-05-2025
- Politics
- Yahoo
German parliament left dumbfounded as Merz fails in chancellor bid
German lawmakers were left dumbfounded on Tuesday as conservative leader Friedrich Merz failed to secure an absolute majority in the first round to be elected the country's new chancellor. Merz's incoming coalition - made up of his Christian Democrats (CDU), the Bavaria-only Christian Social Union (CSU) and the centre-left Social Democrats (SPD) - holds 328 seats in the 630-seat Bundestag, Germany's lower house of parliament, but he received only 310 votes, six short of the necessary majority. Leading politicians were visibly shocked by the result as it was announced in the Bundestag, with many filing out of the chamber without comment. However, Merz's critics were quick to celebrate, with Jan van Aken from The Left saying the CDU leader "does not succeed in connecting, but only in dividing." According to the Basic Law, Germany's de facto constitution, lawmakers have 14 days to elect a chancellor with an absolute majority. Amid the uncertainty following the result, it was initially unclear whether a second vote would be held on Tuesday. Speculation was rife as to why Merz was unable to secure the majority in the secret ballot, with SPD sources telling dpa that its lawmakers unanimously backed him. Chancellor-designate Friedrich Merz (C) leaves the CDU/CSU parliamentary group office in the Bundestag after failing the first round of voting in the election for Chancellor. Michael Kappeler/dpa Chancellor-designate Friedrich Merz (F) leaves the plenary chamber after losing the first round of voting, accompanied by Jens Spahn (2nd R), Chairman of the CDU/CSU parliamentary group, Steffen Bilger, and Thorsten Frei (R), Federal Minister-designate for Special Tasks and Head of the Federal Chancellery. The election and swearing-in of the Federal Chancellor and the new Federal Government takes place in the Bundestag. Sebastian Gollnow/dpa Chancellor-designate Friedrich Merz (R) reacts in the Bundestag during the election of the Chancellor. In the background, Bernd Baumann (L), first parliamentary director of the AfD parliamentary group, and Alice Weidel, federal and parliamentary group leader of the AfD, talk. Merz failed the first round of voting in the Bundestag election for Chancellor. Michael Kappeler/dpa Chancellor-designate Friedrich Merz (C) reacts in the Bundestag after failing the first round of voting in the election for Chancellor. Michael Kappeler/dpa
Yahoo
06-05-2025
- Politics
- Yahoo
Shock in Germany as Merz falls short in initial chancellor vote
German conservative leader Friedrich Merz on Tuesday failed to be elected the country's next chancellor in a first round of voting in parliament, falling six votes short of an absolute majority in a shock result. Merz received 310 votes in the 630-seat Bundestag, short of the 316 needed to secure his long-awaited election to succeed Olaf Scholz. The vote is a major embarrassment for Merz, whose incoming coalition - made up of the Christian Democrats (CDU), the Bavaria-only Christian Social Union (CSU) and the centre-left Social Democrats (SPD) - holds 328 seats in Germany's lower house of parliament. The result takes Germany into unprecedented waters, with no candidate for chancellor ever having failed to secure an absolute majority in the first round of voting. According to the Basic Law, Germany's de facto constitution, lawmakers have 14 days to elect a chancellor with an absolute majority. Subsequently, only a simple majority would be needed to elect a chancellor. German President Frank-Walter Steinmeier would then have seven days to formally appoint the elected candidate as chancellor, or instead choose to dissolve the Bundestag and hold new elections. Merz received 310 votes in favour, with 307 lawmakers voting against. Three abstained, one was invalid, and nine votes were missing. The unexpected result comes two and a half months after Merz's CDU/CSU bloc won February's parliamentary elections. The 69-year-old forged a coalition agreement with the SPD which was signed on Monday in Berlin. Outgoing Chancellor Olaf Scholz, who received an official farewell ceremony on Monday evening, is now to remain in office until a new chancellor is sworn in. Chancellor-designate Friedrich Merz waves in the Bundestag before the election of the Chancellor. The election and swearing-in of the German Chancellor and the new German Government takes place in the Bundestag. Kay Nietfeld/dpa Chancellor-designate Friedrich Merz (L) speaks with acting German Chancellor Olaf Scholz in the Bundestag during the election of the Chancellor. The election and swearing-in of the German Chancellor and the new German Government takes place in the Bundestag. Sebastian Gollnow/dpa
