Latest news with #CommonLaw
Irish Independent
3 days ago
- Irish Independent
‘We finally have justice' – Family of Tina Satchwell speak out as husband Richard convicted of her brutal murder
Key updates Watch: Family of Tina Satchwell speak after guilty verdict In Profile: Tina Satchwell - 'she was loved, happy' In Profile: Richard Satchwell - a bundle of contradictions The six brazen lies that sealed Richard Satchwell's fate – and how holes were poked in his stories Richard Satchwell to be sentenced for his wife's murder on June 4 LATEST: Richard Satchwell convicted of wife's murder and now faces life in prison Richard Satchwell (58) has been found guilty by a Central Criminal Court jury of the murder of his wife Tina (45) whose body was discovered buried under the stairwell of their Youghal, Co Cork home. The jury returned a unanimous verdict after nine hours and 28 minutes of deliberations following a five week trial. Satchwell now faces mandatory life in prison. The English truck driver kept his head bowed as the Central Criminal Court jury returned a guilty verdict on the 23rd day of the Central Criminal Court murder trial. Mr Justice Paul McDermott was told that the jury of seven women and five men had reached a unanimous guilty verdict. The jury had commenced their deliberations at 3.05pm on Tuesday and returned with their verdict on Friday afternoon. He pleaded not guilty to the murder of his wife at a time unknown on March 19/20, 2017, at his home at No 3 Grattan Street in Youghal, Co Cork, contrary to Common Law. Satchwell has been in custody since he was first charged on October 14, 2023, with his wife Tina's murder. However, sentencing will be adjourned to allow for the preparation of expert reports – and for the Fermoy woman's family to consider the delivery of victim-impact statements at the sentencing hearing. For six-and-a-half years the truck driver had told 'lie upon lie upon lie' as he maintained his wife had gone missing from their Youghal home on March 20, 2017, with two suitcases and €26,000 in their life savings. He informed gardaí in Fermoy four days later that she had disappeared from the family home – at the very time her body was in a chest freezer awaiting burial. His insistence his wife had disappeared prompted a six-and-a-half-year missing-person investigation which included major offshore searches and a week-long trawl of an east Cork woodland in 2018. The murder trial opened at the Criminal Courts of Justice in Dublin on April 28. It sat for five weeks and the jury heard from a total of 57 witnesses as well as watching multiple video and audio interviews Satchwell had conducted with gardaí and Irish media organisations including the Irish Independent. The jury were told Satchwell had drawn in 'anyone who would listen to him' to promote his false narrative that his wife was missing, possibly running off with another man. He conducted lengthy interviews with the Irish Independent, RTÉ, TV3/Virgin Media, Today FM, Red FM, 96FM and CRY FM. Prosecutor Gerardine Small SC said his account was full of 'guile', clever lies and 'conniving' behaviour. She described him to the jury as 'an arch-manipulator'. Leicester-born truck driver Satchwell also spoke from March 2017 about how his wife had regularly beat him – telling a man at a car-boot sale six days after his wife's death that she was 'a street angel and a house devil'. He also floated stories that she was depressed, had possible mental health issues and may have had an affair with a Polish man. Satchwell gave multiple interviews to television and radio stations, but visibly disliked newspaper journalists – once commenting that they were 'mentally incapable of reporting what I say'. Two members of Ms Satchwell's family gave evidence to the trial including her cousin, Sarah Howard, and her half-sibling, Lorraine Howard. Sarah Howard sobbed during her evidence when asked about Satchwell offering her for free the chest freezer in which he had temporarily stored his wife's body before later burying her under the stairs. Prosecutors said this offer was 'cynical' – while even Mr Satchwell's own counsel, Brendan Grehan SC, described his actions after his wife's death as 'reprehensible and disreputable'. The trial heard that Satchwell later placed an advert on Done Deal for a chest freezer weeks after his wife's death which he said was free if collected and that it 'just needs a clean'. Sarah Howard said she was very suspicious of the claim Ms Satchwell had left home with the €26,000 – insisting she would never go anywhere without her beloved dogs, Heidi and Ruby, who were left behind in the Youghal property. Jurors also heard that the Satchwell's pets – including the dogs and a parrot – were like their children. Ms Satchwell had wanted to adopt two marmoset monkeys, Terry and Thelma, but the trial heard her husband had sent a significant amount of money for the animals to an international monkey organisation which was probably a scam. Lorraine Howard said she did not like the way Mr Satchwell referred to her half-sibling initially as his 'trophy girlfriend' and latterly as his 'trophy wife'. She said Tina Satchwell also confided to her that she could not get away from her husband. 'She knew she could not get away from him. She would confide in me that he would follow her to the ends of the Earth – she could not get away from him,' she said. 'He [Satchwell] knew she was above his league – his words not mine. He would tell everyone that. He would never go off with anyone else. Even if she came back in the door after all she had put him through, he would take her back.' The truck driver told gardaí his wife regularly assaulted him and that, just days before she went missing, had told him: 'I wasted 28 years of my life with you.' He said he was 'besotted' with his wife and catered to her every need – including bathing her each evening and rubbing oil on her body while she lay naked on the bed. Further, he claimed he was twice arrested for shoplifting clothing he thought his wife wanted. Satchwell maintained his wife had gone missing for six-and-a-half years, but sobbed as he changed his story to gardaí on October 12, 2023, as an intensive search of his home finally revealed his wife's secret grave under the stairs. That search was ordered by Garda Superintendent Ann Marie Twomey who assumed responsibility for the case in 2021. With Detective Garda David Kelleher, she conducted a full review of the case file and consulted with forensic archaeologist Dr Niamh McCullagh who focused her doctoral studies on domestic homicides in Ireland and where bodies were stored in cases where the assailant tried to evade detection. The trial heard Dr McCullagh recommended an invasive search of the three-storey Youghal property with particular attention being paid to an area under the stairwell. Satchwell's house was previously searched on June 7, 2017, by a 10-strong team of gardaí. One detective photographed the area under the stairs – including the shoddily built brick wall which Satchwell had erected to conceal his wife's burial site. However, gardaí did not conduct an invasive search of the property and Ms Satchwell's body would not be found for a further six years. Gardaí did seize a number of laptops and mobile phones at the property and these would prove crucial in the subsequent investigation. Detectives learned Satchwell had conducted an internet search about quicklime on March 20, 2017, and later watched a YouTube video of the effects of combining quicklime with water. He also sent emails – after his wife was already dead – claiming she was about to leave him over the failure to secure the two pet monkeys she wanted. Gardaí also noted six key lies which Mr Satchwell had told about his relationship with his wife and the circumstances of her disappearance. Supt Twomey's four-day search from October 10, 2023, involved contracted builders, ground-mapping radar, forensic archaeologists, the Garda Technical Bureau and, crucially, a Northern Ireland-trained cadaver dog, Fern. The dog immediately focused on the area under the stairwell and, when gardaí broke through a concrete slab, discovered Tina Satchwell's skeletonised and mummified body which had been buried in an old blanket and heavy-grade plastic. She had been buried face-down along with her purse, containing several identity cards. When confronted with the discovery, Satchwell sobbed to gardaí that he had acted in self-defence after his wife attacked him with a chisel. He claimed he fell to the ground and held his wife away from him with his outstretched hands – and she went limp after the belt of her dressing gown went up around her neck with the full weight of her body bearing down upon it. However, he insisted to gardaí he could not remember details of how his wife died – and refused to re-enact the manner of her death to detectives. He maintained he acted entirely in self-defence and was 'fearful' he would be stabbed in the head. Mr Small SC dismissed the account as 'self-serving' and 'farcical' – and claimed Satchwell was once again lying to protect himself. Assistant state pathologist Dr Margaret Bolster, who has performed over 30,000 post-mortem examinations, could not determine a cause of death for Ms Satchwell such was the skeletonised, badly decomposed and partly mummified condition of her remains. Forensic anthropologist Dr Laureen Buckley confirmed that no fractures were detected on the remains – and no bones showed any sign of old fractures having healed. Satchwell explained to detectives that, when he buried his wife with fresh tulips under the stairwell of their home, it was like 'a genuine funeral'. 'When I was burying Tina… it was the final goodbye… I wanted to make her comfortable,' he told gardaí. 'I spent the night [March 20] on the floor, with Tina laying across me. I spent the night sitting on the ground, holding Tina's dead body. I didn't have food, nothing. I just held Tina all night. 'I have a conscience… I still dream of Tina. I have not lost the desire to be with her.' He maintained he had been subjected to a campaign of domestic violence by his wife over the course of their marriage and was left with cuts, bruises, swellings, scratches and even bite marks. Satchwell claimed he had teeth broken from blows by his wife – and said she had knocked him unconscious on two occasions. He replied to gardaí when first charged with the murder of his wife at Cobh garda station on October 13, 2023: 'Guilty or not guilty – guilty.' Ms Small, in her closing argument, noted that Satchwell had given a more respectful funeral to their dog Heidi than he had to the wife he claimed he had loved from first sight. Ralph Riegel Today 08:35 AM Today 08:21 AM Today 08:21 AM Tina Satchwell, pictured in younger years, with one of her beloved pets Today 08:20 AM In Profile: Tina Satchwell - 'she was loved, happy' 'She was loved, happy, a lovely young girl' – Tina Satchwell remembered as an outgoing person known for her sense of style, Catherine Fegan writes Read the full article here: 'She was loved, happy, a lovely young girl' – Tina Satchwell remembered as an outgoing person known for her sense of style With her flamboyant sense of fashion and peroxide-blonde hair, Tina Satchwell cut a striking figure as she walked around the coastal town of Youghal in Co Cork. Today 08:18 AM In Profile: Richard Satchwell - a bundle of contradictions A bundle of contradictions – how Richard Satchwell promoted himself as devoted, while others saw a controlling husband, Ralph Riegel writes A bundle of contradictions – how Richard Satchwell promoted himself as devoted, while others saw a controlling husband Manipulative, obsessive, cunning, devoted, thoughtful, cynical and a skilled liar – Richard Satchell (58) emerged from his Central Criminal Court murder trial as a mass of contradictions. Today 08:17 AM Today 08:16 AM Today 08:15 AM The six brazen lies that sealed Richard Satchwell's fate – and how holes were poked in his stories Six lies ultimately helped gardaí rip apart Richard Satchwell's intricate web of deceit, Ralph Riegel writes. The six brazen lies that sealed Richard Satchwell's fate – and how GPs and car-boot sale enthusiasts poked holes in his stories Six lies ultimately helped gardaí rip apart the intricate web of deceit that Richard Satchwell (58) had woven over the true fate of his wife Tina (45). Today 08:14 AM Richard Satchwell to be sentenced for his wife's murder on June 4 Mr Satchwell has been in custody since he was first charged with his wife's murder on October 14 2023. Sentencing was adjourned to June 4 to allow for the preparation of expert reports - and for the Fermoy woman's family to prepare the delivery of victim impact statements for the sentencing hearing. Several members of Ms Satchwell's family broke down and wept in court as the guilty verdict was confirmed. Ralph Riegel
Irish Independent
3 days ago
- Irish Independent
Richard Satchwell convicted of murdering his wife Tina; sentencing to take place next week
LATEST: Richard Satchwell convicted of wife's murder and now faces life in prison Richard Satchwell (58) has been found guilty by a Central Criminal Court jury of the murder of his wife Tina (45) whose body was discovered buried under the stairwell of their Youghal, Co Cork home. The jury returned a unanimous verdict after nine hours and 28 minutes of deliberations following a five week trial. Satchwell now faces mandatory life in prison. The English truck driver kept his head bowed as the Central Criminal Court jury returned a guilty verdict on the 23rd day of the Central Criminal Court murder trial. Mr Justice Paul McDermott was told that the jury of seven women and five men had reached a unanimous guilty verdict. The jury had commenced their deliberations at 3.05pm on Tuesday and returned with their verdict on Friday afternoon. He pleaded not guilty to the murder of his wife at a time unknown on March 19/20, 2017, at his home at No 3 Grattan Street in Youghal, Co Cork, contrary to Common Law. Satchwell has been in custody since he was first charged on October 14, 2023, with his wife Tina's murder. However, sentencing will be adjourned to allow for the preparation of expert reports – and for the Fermoy woman's family to consider the delivery of victim-impact statements at the sentencing hearing. For six-and-a-half years the truck driver had told 'lie upon lie upon lie' as he maintained his wife had gone missing from their Youghal home on March 20, 2017, with two suitcases and €26,000 in their life savings. He informed gardaí in Fermoy four days later that she had disappeared from the family home – at the very time her body was in a chest freezer awaiting burial. His insistence his wife had disappeared prompted a six-and-a-half-year missing-person investigation which included major offshore searches and a week-long trawl of an east Cork woodland in 2018. The murder trial opened at the Criminal Courts of Justice in Dublin on April 28. It sat for five weeks and the jury heard from a total of 57 witnesses as well as watching multiple video and audio interviews Satchwell had conducted with gardaí and Irish media organisations including the Irish Independent. The jury were told Satchwell had drawn in 'anyone who would listen to him' to promote his false narrative that his wife was missing, possibly running off with another man. He conducted lengthy interviews with the Irish Independent, RTÉ, TV3/Virgin Media, Today FM, Red FM, 96FM and CRY FM. Prosecutor Gerardine Small SC said his account was full of 'guile', clever lies and 'conniving' behaviour. She described him to the jury as 'an arch-manipulator'. Leicester-born truck driver Satchwell also spoke from March 2017 about how his wife had regularly beat him – telling a man at a car-boot sale six days after his wife's death that she was 'a street angel and a house devil'. He also floated stories that she was depressed, had possible mental health issues and may have had an affair with a Polish man. Satchwell gave multiple interviews to television and radio stations, but visibly disliked newspaper journalists – once commenting that they were 'mentally incapable of reporting what I say'. Two members of Ms Satchwell's family gave evidence to the trial including her cousin, Sarah Howard, and her half-sibling, Lorraine Howard. Sarah Howard sobbed during her evidence when asked about Satchwell offering her for free the chest freezer in which he had temporarily stored his wife's body before later burying her under the stairs. Prosecutors said this offer was 'cynical' – while even Mr Satchwell's own counsel, Brendan Grehan SC, described his actions after his wife's death as 'reprehensible and disreputable'. The trial heard that Satchwell later placed an advert on Done Deal for a chest freezer weeks after his wife's death which he said was free if collected and that it 'just needs a clean'. Sarah Howard said she was very suspicious of the claim Ms Satchwell had left home with the €26,000 – insisting she would never go anywhere without her beloved dogs, Heidi and Ruby, who were left behind in the Youghal property. Jurors also heard that the Satchwell's pets – including the dogs and a parrot – were like their children. Ms Satchwell had wanted to adopt two marmoset monkeys, Terry and Thelma, but the trial heard her husband had sent a significant amount of money for the animals to an international monkey organisation which was probably a scam. Lorraine Howard said she did not like the way Mr Satchwell referred to her half-sibling initially as his 'trophy girlfriend' and latterly as his 'trophy wife'. She said Tina Satchwell also confided to her that she could not get away from her husband. 'She knew she could not get away from him. She would confide in me that he would follow her to the ends of the Earth – she could not get away from him,' she said. 'He [Satchwell] knew she was above his league – his words not mine. He would tell everyone that. He would never go off with anyone else. Even if she came back in the door after all she had put him through, he would take her back.' The truck driver told gardaí his wife regularly assaulted him and that, just days before she went missing, had told him: 'I wasted 28 years of my life with you.' He said he was 'besotted' with his wife and catered to her every need – including bathing her each evening and rubbing oil on her body while she lay naked on the bed. Further, he claimed he was twice arrested for shoplifting clothing he thought his wife wanted. Satchwell maintained his wife had gone missing for six-and-a-half years, but sobbed as he changed his story to gardaí on October 12, 2023, as an intensive search of his home finally revealed his wife's secret grave under the stairs. That search was ordered by Garda Superintendent Ann Marie Twomey who assumed responsibility for the case in 2021. With Detective Garda David Kelleher, she conducted a full review of the case file and consulted with forensic archaeologist Dr Niamh McCullagh who focused her doctoral studies on domestic homicides in Ireland and where bodies were stored in cases where the assailant tried to evade detection. The trial heard Dr McCullagh recommended an invasive search of the three-storey Youghal property with particular attention being paid to an area under the stairwell. Satchwell's house was previously searched on June 7, 2017, by a 10-strong team of gardaí. One detective photographed the area under the stairs – including the shoddily built brick wall which Satchwell had erected to conceal his wife's burial site. However, gardaí did not conduct an invasive search of the property and Ms Satchwell's body would not be found for a further six years. Gardaí did seize a number of laptops and mobile phones at the property and these would prove crucial in the subsequent investigation. Detectives learned Satchwell had conducted an internet search about quicklime on March 20, 2017, and later watched a YouTube video of the effects of combining quicklime with water. He also sent emails – after his wife was already dead – claiming she was about to leave him over the failure to secure the two pet monkeys she wanted. Gardaí also noted six key lies which Mr Satchwell had told about his relationship with his wife and the circumstances of her disappearance. Supt Twomey's four-day search from October 10, 2023, involved contracted builders, ground-mapping radar, forensic archaeologists, the Garda Technical Bureau and, crucially, a Northern Ireland-trained cadaver dog, Fern. The dog immediately focused on the area under the stairwell and, when gardaí broke through a concrete slab, discovered Tina Satchwell's skeletonised and mummified body which had been buried in an old blanket and heavy-grade plastic. She had been buried face-down along with her purse, containing several identity cards. When confronted with the discovery, Satchwell sobbed to gardaí that he had acted in self-defence after his wife attacked him with a chisel. He claimed he fell to the ground and held his wife away from him with his outstretched hands – and she went limp after the belt of her dressing gown went up around her neck with the full weight of her body bearing down upon it. However, he insisted to gardaí he could not remember details of how his wife died – and refused to re-enact the manner of her death to detectives. He maintained he acted entirely in self-defence and was 'fearful' he would be stabbed in the head. Mr Small SC dismissed the account as 'self-serving' and 'farcical' – and claimed Satchwell was once again lying to protect himself. Assistant state pathologist Dr Margaret Bolster, who has performed over 30,000 post-mortem examinations, could not determine a cause of death for Ms Satchwell such was the skeletonised, badly decomposed and partly mummified condition of her remains. Forensic anthropologist Dr Laureen Buckley confirmed that no fractures were detected on the remains – and no bones showed any sign of old fractures having healed. Satchwell explained to detectives that, when he buried his wife with fresh tulips under the stairwell of their home, it was like 'a genuine funeral'. 'When I was burying Tina… it was the final goodbye… I wanted to make her comfortable,' he told gardaí. 'I spent the night [March 20] on the floor, with Tina laying across me. I spent the night sitting on the ground, holding Tina's dead body. I didn't have food, nothing. I just held Tina all night. 'I have a conscience… I still dream of Tina. I have not lost the desire to be with her.' He maintained he had been subjected to a campaign of domestic violence by his wife over the course of their marriage and was left with cuts, bruises, swellings, scratches and even bite marks. Satchwell claimed he had teeth broken from blows by his wife – and said she had knocked him unconscious on two occasions. He replied to gardaí when first charged with the murder of his wife at Cobh garda station on October 13, 2023: 'Guilty or not guilty – guilty.' Ms Small, in her closing argument, noted that Satchwell had given a more respectful funeral to their dog Heidi than he had to the wife he claimed he had loved from first sight. Ralph Riegel
The Journal
3 days ago
- The Journal
Man who threatened ex-partner from prison to change her statement given additional three years
A DONEGAL MAN jailed for stabbing his girlfriend has been given another three years behind bars after phoning her from jail and threatening to kill. Jason McDonagh phoned ex-partner Shauna Greene 18 times from Castlerea Prison in Co Roscommon warning her to change her statement about the vicious attack. The 34-year-old, who has 134 previous convictions, also sent her cards and letters from prison warning her to lie. McDonagh, of Lawne Park, Ballyshannon, appeared before Letterkenny Circuit Court after pleading guilty to intent to pervert the course of justice, contrary to Common Law. He was charged that between 25 May, 2023 and 13 July, 2023, he made phone calls to Shauna Greene from Castlerea Prison in Co Roscommon. These calls had a tendency to pervert the course of justice in that he continuously telephoned Ms Greene and asked for her to withdraw a complaint in relation to a section 3 Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act which was before the court. He asked her to withdraw, change her statement, to state that it was not true, and go to court and tell the judge likewise. In March, 2024, McDonagh was given a four-year prison sentence for assaulting Ms Greene and causing her harm. It followed an incident in May, 2023 when he stabbed the victim five times. He grabbed a knife and began stabbing her and she said all she could feel were sharp pains through her puffer jacket and in her neck. As paramedics attended her, the terrified victim asked them if she was going to die. When interviewed by Gardai, McDonagh initially said he did not stab Ms Greene and said a glass had simply been broken in their flat. However, he later pleaded guilty and was jailed for five years with the last 12 months suspended by Judge John Aylmer in March, 2024. McDonagh appeared at Letterkenny Circuit Court after pleading guilty to the single charge of intent to pervert the course of justice. His former partner Ms Greene was present in court along with her new partner to hear the case. Garda Paul Corcoran from Ballyshannon Garda Station said Ms Greene had attended the station and told how McDonagh had contacted her from prison on a number of occasions asking her to drop the charges and say he was not involved. Ms Greene said he warned her that if she did not do as he said he would beat her again and she said she believed McDonagh would kill her if he got out of prison. Advertisement McDonagh also sent Ms Greene three letters and a card while transcripts of 18 phonecalls made by McDonagh were recorded and downloaded by the Governor of Castlerea Prison. In her victim impact statement, Ms Greene, 27, said she was terrified of McDonagh, saying he told her to go to the Garda station and tell them she made up her story. Ms Greene said he pretended to contact other people so he could get in touch with her and told her she was dead when he got out and that she now feared for her life. She added that she now changes her appearance when she is out as she fears meeting McDonagh's family and they tell him where she is. 'I know he will come and find me. He does not like women…he has promised me he will come and kill me,' she added. The court was told McDonagh has 143 previous convictions for a range of offences including assault, public order, theft, breach of barring orders, trespassing, criminal damage and obstruction. Barrister for the accused, Mr Peter Nolan, BL, instructed by solicitor Rory O'Brien , said his client made an early plea even though it would have been proven due to the recordings of the telephone calls from prison. He said his client understands the relationship with Ms Greene is now finished and has said he will have nothing to do with her on his release and that he apologised to her for any stress he caused to her or her mother. Judge John Aylmer said the threat against Ms Greene had to be viewed in the context of the offence he had just committed at the time. He stressed that he was in no sense sentencing him again for the stabbing of Ms Greene but he was considering the charge of intent to pervert the course of justice which led the victim to believe she would be murdered. He added that has to be considered in the context of the stabbing event for which she was trying to recover and he had also to consider where on the scale to place it. He said he placed it in the mid-range and said he was constraining himself by not putting it higher than the headline sentence in the previous assault case. He said due to the intimidating and frightening nature of the threats, it could be argued that the incident could be placed in the higher bracket but added that he would constrain himself. He told McDonagh he took the appropriate action by entering a guilty plea but noted that it was an 'open and shut case' because the phone calls were recorded. He saved Ms Greene the trauma of another trial, as well as saving the state time and effort, and for this he reduced the sentence to one of four years in prison to run consecutive with the current sentence of four years. However, Judge Aylmer said he had to look at the totality principle and although he was not sure if there was room for optimism, he had to try and encourage it. In the interest of rehabilitation, he said he was suspending the last 12 months of that four years sentence in return for signing a bond to keep the peace. He also made an order that McDonagh is not to come within one kilometre of Ms Greene's place of work or residence upon release. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
Sunday World
3 days ago
- Sunday World
Man jailed for three years for phoning girlfriend from prison and threatening to kill her
"I know he will come and find me. He does not like women… he has promised me he will come and kill me," Shauna Greene added. A Donegal man jailed for stabbing his girlfriend has been given another three years behind bars after phoning her from jail and threatening to kill. Jason McDonagh phoned ex-partner Shauna Greene 18 times from Castlerea Prison in Co Roscommon warning her to change her statement about the vicious attack. The 34-year-old, who has 134 previous convictions, also sent her cards and letters from prison warning her to lie. McDonagh, of Lawne Park, Ballyshannon, appeared before Letterkenny Circuit Court after pleading guilty to intent to pervert the course of justice, contrary to Common Law. He was charged that between May 25, 2023 and July 13, 2023, he did make from Castlerea Prison in County Roscommon, phone calls to Shauna Greene which had a tendency to pervert the course of justice in that he continuously telephoned Ms Greene and asked for her to withdraw a complaint in relation to a section 3 Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act, 1997, which was before the court, asked her to withdraw, change her statement, to state that it was not true, and go to court and tell the judge likewise. Castlerea Prison News in 90 Seconds - May 30th In March, 2024, McDonagh was given a four-year prison sentence for assaulting Ms Greene and causing her harm. It followed an incident in May, 2023 when he stabbed the victim five times. He grabbed a knife and began stabbing her and she said all she could feel were sharp pains through her puffer jacket and in her neck. As paramedics attended her, the terrified victim asked them if she was going to die. When interviewed by Gardai, McDonagh initially said he did not stab Ms Greene and said a glass had simply been broken in their flat. However, he later pleaded guilty and was jailed for five years with the last 12 months suspended by Judge John Aylmer in March, 2024. McDonagh appeared at Letterkenny Circuit Court after pleading guilty to the single charge of intent to pervert the course of justice. His former partner Ms Greene was present in court along with her new partner to hear the case. Garda Paul Corcoran from Ballyshannon Garda Station said Ms Greene had attended the station and told how McDonagh had contacted her from prison on a number of occasions asking her to drop the charges and say he was not involved. Ms Greene said he warned her that if she did not do as he said he would beat her again and she said she believed McDonagh would kill her if he got out of prison. McDonagh also sent Ms Greene three letters and a card while transcripts of 18 phonecalls made by McDonagh were recorded and downloaded by the Governor of Castlerea Prison. In her victim impact statement, Ms Greene, 27, said she was terrified of McDonagh saying he told her to go to the Garda station and tell them she made up her story. Ms Greene said he pretended to contact other people so he could get in touch with her and told her she was dead when he got out and that she now feared for her life. She added that she now changes her appearance when she is out as she fears meeting McDonagh's family and they tell him where she is. "I know he will come and find me. He does not like has promised me he will come and kill me," she added. The court was told McDonagh has 143 previous convictions for a range of offences including assault, public order, theft, breach of barring orders, trespassing, criminal damage and obstruction. Barrister for the accused, Mr Peter Nolan, BL, instructed by solicitor Rory O'Brien , said his client made an early plea even though it would have been proven due to the recordings of the telephone calls from prison. He said his client understands the relationship with Ms Greene is now finished and has said he will have nothing to do with her on his release and that he apologised to her for any stress he caused to her or her mother. Judge John Aylmer said the threat against Ms Greene had to be viewed in the context of the offence (the assault during which he stabbed Ms Greene) he had just committed at the time. He stressed that he was in no sense sentencing him again for the stabbing of Ms Greene but he was considering the charge of intent to pervert the course of justice which led the victim to believe she would be murdered. He added that has to be considered in the context of the stabbing event for which she was trying to recover and he had also to consider where on the scale to place it. He said he placed it in the mid range and said he was constraining himself by not putting it higher than the headline sentence in the previous assault case. He said due to the intimidating and frightening nature of the threats, it could be argued that the incident could be placed in the higher bracket but added that he would constrain himself. He told McDonagh he took the appropriate action by entering a guilty plea but adding it was an "open and shut case" because the phonecalls were recorded. He saved Ms Greene the trauma of another trial as well as saving the state time and effort and for this he reduced the sentence to one of four years in prison to run consecutive with the current sentence of four years. However, Judge Aylmer said he had to look at the totality principle and although he was not sure if there was room for optimism, he had to try and encourage it. In the interest of rehabilitation, he said he was suspending the last 12 months of that four years sentence in return for signing a bond to keep the peace. He also made an order that McDonagh is not to come within one kilometre of Ms Greene's place of work or residence upon release.
Irish Daily Mirror
3 days ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
More jail time for man who called ex from prison to ask her to change statement
A Donegal man jailed for stabbing his girlfriend has been given another three years behind bars after phoning her from jail and threatening to kill. Jason McDonagh phoned ex-partner Shauna Greene 18 times from Castlerea Prison in Co Roscommon warning her to change her statement about the vicious attack. The 34-year-old, who has 134 previous convictions, also sent her cards and letters from prison warning her to lie. McDonagh, of Lawne Park, Ballyshannon, appeared before Letterkenny Circuit Court after pleading guilty of intent to pervert the course of justice, contrary to Common Law. He was charged that between May 25, 2023 and July 13, 2023, he did make from Castlerea Prison in Co Roscommon, phone calls to Shauna Greene which had a tendency to pervert the course of justice in that he continuously telephoned Ms Greene and asked for her to withdraw a complaint in relation to a section 3 Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act, 1997, which was before the court, asked her to withdraw, change her statement, to state that it was not true, and go to court and tell the judge likewise. In March, 2024, McDonagh was given a four-year prison sentence for assaulting Ms Greene and causing her harm. It followed an incident in May, 2023 when he stabbed the victim five times. He grabbed a knife and began stabbing her and she said all she could feel were sharp pains through her puffer jacket and in her neck. As paramedics attended her, the terrified victim asked them if she was going to die. When interviewed by Gardai, McDonagh initially said he did not stab Ms Greene and said a glass had simply been broken in their flat. However, he later pleaded guilty and was jailed for five years with the last 12 months suspended by Judge John Aylmer in March, 2024. McDonagh appeared at Letterkenny Circuit Court after pleading guilty to the single charge of intent to pervert the course of justice. His former partner Ms Greene was present in court along with her new partner to hear the case. Garda Paul Corcoran from Ballyshannon Garda Station said Ms Greene had attended the station and told how McDonagh had contacted her from prison on a number of occasions asking her to drop the charges and say he was not involved. Ms Greene said he warned her that if she did not do as he said he would beat her again and she said she believed McDonagh would kill her if he got out of prison. McDonagh also sent Ms Greene three letters and a card while transcripts of 18 phonecalls made by McDonagh were recorded and downloaded by the Governor of Castlerea Prison. In her victim impact statement, Ms Greene, 27, said she was terrified of McDonagh saying he told her to go to the Garda station and tell them she made up her story. Ms Greene said he pretended to contact other people so he could get in touch with her and told her she was dead when he got out and that she now feared for her life. She added that she now changes her appearance when she is out as she fears meeting McDonagh's family and they tell him where she is. "I know he will come and find me. He does not like women... he has promised me he will come and kill me," she added. The court was told McDonagh has 143 previous convictions for a range of offences including assault, public order, theft, breach of barring orders, trespassing, criminal damage and obstruction. Barrister for the accused, Mr Peter Nolan, BL, instructed by solicitor Rory O'Brien, said his client made an early plea even though it would have been proven due to the recordings of the telephone calls from prison. He said his client understands the relationship with Ms Greene is now finished and has said he will have nothing to do with her on his release and that he apologised to her for any stress he caused to her or her mother. Judge John Aylmer said the threat against Ms Greene had to be viewed in the context of the offence (the assault during which he stabbed Ms Greene) he had just committed at the time. He stressed that he was in no sense sentencing him again for the stabbing of Ms Greene but he was considering the charge of intent to pervert the course of justice which led the victim to believe she would be murdered. He added that has to be considered in the context of the stabbing event for which she was trying to recover and he had also to consider where on the scale to place it. He said he placed it in the mid range and said he was constraining himself by not putting it higher than the headline sentence in the previous assault case. He said due to the intimidating and frightening nature of the threats, it could be argued that the incident could be placed in the higher bracket but added that he would constrain himself. He told McDonagh he took the appropriate action by entering a guilty plea but added it was an "open and shut case" because the phonecalls were recorded. He saved Ms Greene the trauma of another trial as well as saving the state time and effort and for this he reduced the sentence to one of four years in prison to run consecutive with the current sentence of four years. However, Judge Aylmer said he had to look at the totality principle and although he was not sure if there was room for optimism, he had to try and encourage it. In the interest of rehabilitation, he said he was suspending the last 12 months of that four years sentence in return for signing a bond to keep the peace. He also made an order that McDonagh is not to come within one kilometre of Ms Greene's place of work or residence upon release.
