Latest news with #CriticalSpectator
Independent Singapore
07-07-2025
- Politics
- Independent Singapore
Where is Michael Petraeus? Some Singaporeans wonder if pro-PAP blogger's Facebook account is gone
SINGAPORE: The Polish blogger Michael Petraeus appears to be missing from some social media spaces recently, and some in Singapore are wondering if his Facebook page has been taken down. However, the Critical Spectator Facebook account is still live, as is Mr Petraeus' blog, which carries the same name. Its most recent post, which took aim at Leader of the Opposition Pritam Singh, was posted on Jul 1. On Instagram, it says that Mr Petraeus' account is unavailable, and on X (formerly Twitter), it says that an account for @michaelpetraeus has been suspended, although the Critical Spectator account on X still seems to be active. Mr Petraeus' account's absence has not gone unnoticed. One Singaporean Facebook user asked if he was 'finally' gone, adding that if the account had indeed been taken down, it would have been 'such a win for internet policing and anti-cyberbullying.' Mr Petraeus has long been a champion for the ruling party and its policies, and his posts have at times been shared by the wife of former Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong, Ms Ho Ching. In early May, she shared his post commenting on the argument between US President Donald Trump and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy . See also Can Facebook solve the fake news crisis? Later that month, however, acting Minister-in-charge of Muslim Affairs Muhammad Faishal Ibrahim took to Facebook to call Mr Petraeus out concerning a post he had made that was critical of former President Halimah Yacob. 'I'm gravely concerned about the recent remarks made by Critical Spectator,' he wrote, adding, 'In times like these, we need more understanding, not division. We must never allow dismissive or divisive rhetoric—local or foreign—to erode the mutual respect and unity we have worked so hard to build in our multicultural society.' Other Singaporeans have also taken to social media to express their unhappiness with the content of Mr Petraeus' posts, including one from Adrian Ang that went viral . In May, a petition was even circulated asking for the Polish blogger's residential status to be revoked. 'Mr Petraeus has consistently engaged in activities that many Singaporeans perceive as intrusive and disrespectful to our nation's sovereignty and social harmony. 'While we value freedom of expression… Mr Petraeus's actions have consistently crossed the line from commentary to interference and insult,' the petition states. If he had been banned from Facebook, this would not be the first time. The Critical Spectator page was removed in July 2020 for three weeks around the time the General Election was held that year. /TISG Read also: Ex-SG PM's wife shares pro-PAP blogger's post calling out 'abuse' Zelenskyy suffered at Oval Office
Yahoo
26-05-2025
- Politics
- Yahoo
Never allow divisive rhetoric to erode mutual respect and unity, says Faishal Ibrahim: Singapore live news
Acting Minister-in-charge of Muslim Affairs Faishal Ibrahim has expressed grave concern about remarks made by a Facebook page that former president Halimah Yacob is "complicit" in a few humanitarian disasters. According to the Straits Times, he warned against allowing such divisive rhetoric to erode Singapore's hard-earned spirit of mutual respect and unity. Read more in our live blog below, including the latest local and international news and updates. Acting Minister-in-charge of Muslim Affairs Faishal Ibrahim has expressed grave concern about remarks made by a Facebook page that former president Halimah Yacob is "complicit" in a few humanitarian disasters. According to the Straits Times, he warned against allowing such divisive rhetoric to erode Singapore's hard-earned spirit of mutual respect and unity. In a Facebook post on Friday (23 May), Halimah said that being silent on the humanitarian catastrophe in Gaza "makes us complicit" in the violation of humanitarian laws. "Keeping quiet makes us complicit in the violations of international humanitarian laws and encourages similar aggressions elsewhere. Our world is all the poorer for it. Uphold humanity," she said. In response, Facebook page Critical Spectator, run by Polish national Michael Petraeus, said Halimah is complicit in "quite a few humanitarian disasters". "If 'keeping quiet' about Gaza 'makes us complicit' in the violations there, it stands to reason that remaining silent about every other such crisis makes us complicit in it as well," the post, put out on Friday, said. It cited situations in places such as Sudan, Libya, Yemen and Myanmar. "And yet I've tried searching if Madam Halimah expressed her horror and grief about the torment of millions of people in these and other countries – and I, sadly, found nothing." Read more about the incident and comments here. Acting Minister-in-charge of Muslim Affairs Faishal Ibrahim has expressed grave concern about remarks made by a Facebook page that former president Halimah Yacob is "complicit" in a few humanitarian disasters. According to the Straits Times, he warned against allowing such divisive rhetoric to erode Singapore's hard-earned spirit of mutual respect and unity. In a Facebook post on Friday (23 May), Halimah said that being silent on the humanitarian catastrophe in Gaza "makes us complicit" in the violation of humanitarian laws. "Keeping quiet makes us complicit in the violations of international humanitarian laws and encourages similar aggressions elsewhere. Our world is all the poorer for it. Uphold humanity," she said. In response, Facebook page Critical Spectator, run by Polish national Michael Petraeus, said Halimah is complicit in "quite a few humanitarian disasters". "If 'keeping quiet' about Gaza 'makes us complicit' in the violations there, it stands to reason that remaining silent about every other such crisis makes us complicit in it as well," the post, put out on Friday, said. It cited situations in places such as Sudan, Libya, Yemen and Myanmar. "And yet I've tried searching if Madam Halimah expressed her horror and grief about the torment of millions of people in these and other countries – and I, sadly, found nothing." Read more about the incident and comments here.
Online Citizen
24-05-2025
- Politics
- Online Citizen
Faishal Ibrahim condemns Critical Spectator post for downplaying Palestinian suffering
Acting Minister-in-charge of Muslim Affairs Faishal Ibrahim has sharply criticised comments made by the Facebook page Critical Spectator, saying they 'minimise the suffering of Palestinians' and risk fuelling division in Singapore's multicultural society. The senior minister of state issued his statement on 23 May, the same day he was sworn in as a Cabinet member. He expressed deep concern over the remarks made by Critical Spectator, which is run by Polish national Michael Petraeus. The post, published on 23 May, was a response to a Facebook statement by former president Halimah Yacob. In it, Halimah had described Israel's blockade of Gaza as a 'humanitarian catastrophe' and warned that silence in the face of such actions amounted to complicity. Petraeus, commenting via Critical Spectator, responded by accusing Halimah of selective outrage, claiming she had failed to comment on crises in Sudan, Yemen, Libya, or Myanmar. He went as far as to say Halimah was 'complicit in the starvation of 3 million children in Sudan' due to her silence on those matters. Associate Professor Faishal strongly defended Halimah's position and character, calling her 'a deeply respected national figure' whose concerns reflected the compassion and moral courage of many Singaporeans. 'While it is valid to draw attention to suffering in other parts of the world, we should reject any statement that minimises the suffering of Palestinians,' he stated. He also stressed the importance of maintaining unity in Singapore, warning that divisive rhetoric, whether from local or foreign sources, must not be allowed to undermine the mutual respect in society. 'In times like these, we need more understanding, not division,' he wrote. 'We must never allow dismissive or divisive rhetoric to erode the mutual respect and unity we have worked so hard to build.' Prof Faishal reiterated that the Singapore government has consistently advocated for a humanitarian ceasefire, protection of civilian lives, and support for the Palestinian people's right to a homeland. He further noted that many in Singapore's Muslim community and across other communities feel deeply about the ongoing crisis in Gaza and continue to express solidarity with those affected. In the original post by Halimah, she had said: 'Keeping quiet makes us complicit in the violations of international humanitarian laws and encourages similar aggressions elsewhere. Our world is all the poorer for it.' Petraeus took issue with the idea of complicity by silence, arguing that Halimah had not made similar statements about other humanitarian crises. He accused her and global media outlets of prioritising Palestinian suffering over other global tragedies, claiming, 'Out of all of the victims of wars and disasters in this world, they deserve the least of our attention, support or even talk.' Petraeus also contended that the suffering in Gaza was self-inflicted, blaming Palestinian support for Hamas as the root of the crisis. He contrasted this with crises in countries like Sudan and Yemen, where he argued the victims were more clearly innocent. Strong support for Prof Faishal's comments on Critical Spectator In the aftermath of his statement, many Facebook users voiced strong support for Prof Faishal, praising his clarity and calling for action. One commenter wrote, 'Thank you… for your heartfelt and principled stance. We must stand together in humanity, not apart in hostility.' Another added, 'Finally, a voice we've been waiting for. Your voice brings hope and dignity to those suffering.' Several users called for Critical Spectator to be investigated or removed from Singapore's digital sphere, accusing it of foreign interference. Comments such as 'Time for people to report Critical Spectator to the police' and 'Ban Critical Spectator. It is foreign interference' were widely echoed. One user remarked that Petraeus 'should not be allowed to attack a former president in this manner', while others questioned why authorities had yet to take action against the page despite what they viewed as repeated provocations. A considerable number of comments suggested invoking Singapore's Foreign Interference (Countermeasures) Act (FICA), asking the government to classify Critical Spectator as a foreign entity. While some commenters expressed broader geopolitical concerns, many focused on the perceived imbalance in Petraeus' statements. One individual stated, 'Whataboutism is a logical fallacy. Expressing concern for Gaza does not mean ignoring Sudan, Yemen or Myanmar.' The reaction also included calls for the Singapore government to examine its economic and diplomatic links with Israel, questioning whether neutrality in policy aligned with moral responsibility. One commenter asked, 'How much have we invested in Israel's war economy while offering humanitarian aid to Palestinians?' Other users applauded Prof Faishal's leadership. 'You are truly a great leader for our Muslim community… Your firm stand is very much welcomed,' read one post. Another said, 'Thank you for taking a stand. I'm proud to have you as my MP.' Some, however, urged the government to match words with action. 'Speaking without action is nothing,' one commenter noted, while another asked for parliamentary scrutiny of the matter.
Yahoo
24-05-2025
- Politics
- Yahoo
Singapore Muslim affairs minister condemns Gaza remarks by expat commentator Critical Spectator, warns of threat to social harmony
SINGAPORE, May 24 – Singapore minister Muhammad Faishal Ibrahim has condemned recent anti-Gaza remarks made by social media commentator Critical Spectator, warning that such rhetoric risks undermining social cohesion in Singapore. The minister in charge of Muslim affairs said while it is legitimate to highlight suffering in other parts of the world, it is unacceptable to make statements that diminish the pain endured by Palestinians in Gaza. 'I'm gravely concerned about the recent remarks made by Critical Spectator,' Faishal said in a Facebook post yesterday. 'While it is valid to draw attention to suffering in other parts of the world, we should reject any statement that minimises the suffering of Palestinians'. Critical Spectator was reported to be the online pseudonym of Michael Petraeus, a Polish pro-establishment blogger and commentator based in Singapore known for his controversial and often provocative views usually directed at the Opposition. The Facebook account had mocked former Singapore president Halimah Yaacob who warned that any silence on Israel's atrocities in Gaza mean that the republic is complicit in the violations of international humanitarian laws and encourages similar aggressions elsewhere. Faishal stressed that such comments, whether from local or foreign voices, are harmful and could erode the mutual respect Singaporeans have worked hard to maintain in a multicultural society. 'In times like these, we need more understanding, not division. We must never allow dismissive or divisive rhetoric — local or foreign — to erode the mutual respect and unity we have worked so hard to build in our multicultural society,' he said. Faishal noted that many Singaporeans, including members of the Muslim community and Halimah, are deeply affected by the humanitarian crisis in Gaza. He praised Halimah's recent Facebook post on the issue, saying her concern reflects the compassion and moral courage shared by many across Singapore. Faishal also reaffirmed the Singapore government's position, stating it has consistently called for a humanitarian ceasefire and supported the rights of Palestinians to a homeland. He highlighted that Singapore and its citizens have contributed over S$19 million (RM64.5 million) in aid to Gaza and continue to support Palestinian state-building efforts through the Enhanced Technical Assistance Package. The minister previously described Israel's actions in Gaza as 'oppressive and unacceptable', remarks he said he has made publicly on various platforms, including a recent podcast.
Malay Mail
24-05-2025
- Politics
- Malay Mail
Singapore Muslim affairs minister condemns Gaza remarks by expat commentator Critical Spectator, warns of threat to social harmony
SINGAPORE, May 24 – Singapore minister Muhammad Faishal Ibrahim has condemned recent anti-Gaza remarks made by social media commentator Critical Spectator, warning that such rhetoric risks undermining social cohesion in Singapore. The minister in charge of Muslim affairs said while it is legitimate to highlight suffering in other parts of the world, it is unacceptable to make statements that diminish the pain endured by Palestinians in Gaza. 'I'm gravely concerned about the recent remarks made by Critical Spectator,' Faishal said in a Facebook post yesterday. 'While it is valid to draw attention to suffering in other parts of the world, we should reject any statement that minimises the suffering of Palestinians'. Critical Spectator was reported to be the online pseudonym of Michael Petraeus, a Polish pro-establishment blogger and commentator based in Singapore known for his controversial and often provocative views usually directed at the Opposition. The Facebook account had mocked former Singapore president Halimah Yaacob who warned that any silence on Israel's atrocities in Gaza mean that the republic is complicit in the violations of international humanitarian laws and encourages similar aggressions elsewhere. Faishal stressed that such comments, whether from local or foreign voices, are harmful and could erode the mutual respect Singaporeans have worked hard to maintain in a multicultural society. 'In times like these, we need more understanding, not division. We must never allow dismissive or divisive rhetoric — local or foreign — to erode the mutual respect and unity we have worked so hard to build in our multicultural society,' he said. Faishal noted that many Singaporeans, including members of the Muslim community and Halimah, are deeply affected by the humanitarian crisis in Gaza. He praised Halimah's recent Facebook post on the issue, saying her concern reflects the compassion and moral courage shared by many across Singapore. Faishal also reaffirmed the Singapore government's position, stating it has consistently called for a humanitarian ceasefire and supported the rights of Palestinians to a homeland. He highlighted that Singapore and its citizens have contributed over S$19 million (RM64.5 million) in aid to Gaza and continue to support Palestinian state-building efforts through the Enhanced Technical Assistance Package. The minister previously described Israel's actions in Gaza as 'oppressive and unacceptable', remarks he said he has made publicly on various platforms, including a recent podcast.
