03-03-2025
Candidates to replace McGloin say they can work with Gaughan, including one dismissed last year
A former Lackawanna County economic development director who Commissioners Bill Gaughan and Matt McGloin dismissed early last year said she expects she'd work well with Gaughan if chosen to replace McGloin as commissioner.
Brenda Sacco, who led the county's Department of Planning and Economic Development for about five years before Gaughan and McGloin fired her shortly after taking office as Democratic majority commissioners in January 2024, is one of three potential appointees the Lackawanna County Democratic Party's executive committee advanced last week as possible McGloin successors. The others are Olyphant Borough Council President James Baldan and Scranton School Director Robert J. Casey.
Baldan and Casey, who is not related to the former senator, each said they could work well with Gaughan, too.
McGloin recently announced his resignation as commissioner effective Feb. 24, prompting a process under the county's Home Rule Charter that saw the party submit the names of three potential Democratic replacements — Sacco, Baldan and Casey — for consideration by the judges of the county Court of Common Pleas. Gaughan, who earlier last week announced Dunmore Mayor Mark 'Max' Conway Jr. as his preferred choice to succeed McGloin, continues to sharply criticize the process by which the party advanced those three candidates from a field of 18 applicants.
While the charter tasks the judges with choosing one of the three to fill the remainder of McGloin's term expiring Jan. 3, 2028, the court said Friday it will take no action on the vacancy until commissioners officially accept McGloin's resignation at a formal meeting.
It came a day after county solicitor Donald Frederickson noted in a memo to the court that, 'as a matter of law,' no vacancy exists until McGloin's resignation is accepted at such a meeting. And with commissioners meeting Wednesday, Frederickson said in a phone interview that McGloin could conceivably come back and rescind his resignation, though he hasn't publicly expressed any desire to return.
'Until the resignation is accepted, there is no vacancy to fill and any effort toward naming a successor is premature,' Frederickson wrote in the memo to the court.
A former Penn State and NFL quarterback, McGloin resigned as commissioner for a job with Boston College's football program. He then left that job, citing family reasons.
Frederickson also advised the court of an apparent conflict between the Home Rule Charter and a procedure set forth in Rule 1908 of the Pennsylvania Rules of Judicial Administration that the state Supreme Court adopted in 2019. That procedure for filling a vacancy involves the county court alone, not any political party.
How the court proceeds remains to be seen.
But, given her position atop the short list the county Democratic Party submitted to the judges, the newspaper asked Sacco on Friday if she had any concerns that her having been fired by Gaughan would create an awkward dynamic should she ultimately replace McGloin.
'Reasonable minds can disagree about how to regard my prior separation from Lackawanna County, but I certainly don't regard it as Commissioner Gaughan having fired me,' she said in a statement. 'The truth is I have great respect for Commissioner Gaughan and I supported him when he ran. If I am chosen I hope and expect to work very well with him given our combined experience and dedication to the county.'
Sacco joined the county economic development office in August 2013 as deputy director of operations and finance under Director George Kelly, who left in January 2019. Kelly ran for commissioner that year as incumbent Democratic Commissioner Jerry Notarianni's running mate, but didn't advance beyond the primary.
Commissioners elevated Sacco in early 2019 to replace Kelly as director, initially in an acting capacity. She served through the next administration of Notarianni, fellow Democratic Commissioner Debi Domenick and Republican Commissioner Chris Chermak, often earning praise for her performance.
Gaughan and McGloin dismissed Sacco in late January 2024 but gave no specific reasons at the time for letting her go. A contemporaneous news release noted the county had 'parted ways' with Sacco. It's not unusual for new majority administrations to replace department heads.
Longtime planning manager Mary Liz Donato served as Sacco's interim replacement until Gaughan and McGloin appointed Kristin Magnotta to the planning and economic development director position in February 2024.
Gaughan declined to comment Monday on Sacco's dismissal, calling it a personnel issue. He also declined to comment on Baldan or Casey, both of whom, like Sacco, expressed confidence in their ability to work with Gaughan should they fill McGloin's seat.
'I can work with anybody,' said Casey, now in his second stint as a Scranton school director after previously serving as a director from 1979-91. 'I spent over 14 years on the Scranton School Board, and, when you're dealing with nine people, in order to get anything done you need to be able to develop a consensus and work with people and understand … what their point of view (is).'
Baldan made a similar case for himself, citing his more than four decades working for Burlington stores.
'I worked for over 40 years in the same company,' he said. 'To make that happen you have to be able to conform and be able to work with anyone or work for anyone. … Yes, I would be able to work with anyone in the county, anyone in government or anyone in the private sector.'
At this point the appointment process is in the hands of the county judges, Gaughan said.
'They have to go through their process and I respect that, so I'm refraining from commenting on any of the individuals who had their names submitted,' he said.
But Gaughan did reiterate his objections to the process county Democratic Party Chairman Chris Patrick used to determine which three candidates should advance to the judges, calling it 'pretty pathetic.'
He criticized Patrick last week for not interviewing potential candidates before the full executive committee and for lacking transparency more broadly. Patrick has not released the names of everyone who applied to fill the vacancy or details about a scoring rubric used to grade the candidates.
In a Friday statement defending the process, Patrick said that the three highest-scoring applicants were put before the executive committee, which advanced them to the judges. He also noted the relatively short window of time the party had to conduct the process as part of his broader defense.
'(Patrick) wants to be the kingmaker instead of being transparent and honest,' Gaughan said Monday. 'And it's my opinion that he has absolutely no interest in good government.'
Patrick rejected the charge.
'My response still stands from last week and my only goal as chairman is to make sure we elect Democrats in every election,' he said. 'I totally support good and responsible government on all levels.'
