logo
#

Latest news with #EVU

Fish joins meat in fray over veggie food
Fish joins meat in fray over veggie food

Euractiv

time22-07-2025

  • Politics
  • Euractiv

Fish joins meat in fray over veggie food

The fish industry is accusing plant-based lookalikes of taking the imitation game too far, with packaging that makes tofu sound like tuna. In 1929, Belgian surrealist artist René Magritte painted 'This is not as pipe' to argue that a label does not constitute the object itself. Almost a hundred years later, Brussels is caught in a dilemma over representations and the defense of what is 'real'. First came the meat. The livestock sector recently stepped up pressure to ban the use of traditional meat names for plant-based products, to which the Commission yielded last week. For the meat producers, selling a chickpea preparation as 'no-beef' is crossing a line. The same goes for the fish industry, which has joined the fray. The EU fishing lobby is accusing vegetarian companies of giving their no-fish products a disguise that's a little too convincing. 'It's important to call a spade a spade,' said Daniel Voces, managing director of Europêche, in a press release. 'Too many products use fish species names, seafood-related terms, and even pictures of genuine fish, all without actually containing any'. 'What's on the label, and is it telling the full story?' asked Voces. Members of the European Parliament (MEPs) are ready to support the fish industry in its fight. "The sector (...) will have to compete with fish that is not fish," said centre-right MEP Isabelle Le Callennec (EPP, France), adding that fish lovers should be "worried". This week, the Parliament's committee on fisheries discussed a report saying that EU rules fall short of protecting seafood products from name appropriation by their veggie counterparts. It argues that labels such as 'salmon vegetarian alternative' raise concerns and points to a mosaic of invented names and wordplays: 'Solmon', 'Sal-nom', 'Salmonderful', 'Toona', 'Tu-nah', 'Tunalicious'... The list is as long as the market is creative. While the report warned that these labels can easily confuse the shopper, others say this is only – or still – an assumption. 'A factor is missing here, and it is actual consumer behaviour,' said Fien Minnens, researcher in agri-food marketing and consumer behaviour at Ghent University, in an interview with Euractiv, pointing to data gaps in the study. 'The report is very much assuming that this is clearly misleading, even implying that market growth could be due to these practices,' Minnens added. The beauty in a name Unsurprisingly, the EU vegetarian lobby (EVU) weighted in and sent MEPs a letter to win them over. The EVU said the plant-based industry knows very well who its clientele is, and has no need – or interest – to fool them. 'The reason producers implement this practice is to ensure plant-based consumers, their target audience, buy the products. It would be opposed to the interest of the producers to mislead their target audience.' Minnens said there must be a way for the veggie industry to give attractive cues to the consumer looking for fish lookalikes without running the risk of tricking shoppers into thinking they're buying the real catch. The PECH committee's report suggests restricting aquatic species names for plant-based foods altogether, but Minnens wonders if there's room for compromise 'If you say soy-based product inspired by tuna , is that enough to avoid confusion, or do we really need to ban those names?' she asked herself, insisting on the need of evidence-based studies. A matter of principle For Minnens, at the core of the spat is the raison d'être of veggie products. 'There is a group of consumers that is consciously choosing not to eat seafood, but is still looking for that culinary experience, and that feels threatening for the fishing industry'. Europêche argues that it has 'no issue' with new food products and that this is not about 'plant-based vs seafood'. Still, it wants to assert the dominance of the 'real kind' of healthy food. In a press release, the organisation denounced the idea that 'the health halo around plant-based' masks a reality. 'Many of these products are ultra-processed, high in salt or fat, and contain allergens or imported ingredients'. Meanwhile, it said fish contains 'real Omega-3, not just added supplements'. Beyond the debates over the healthiness and sustainability of faux fish, the increasing market for veggie products is there – and a part of the EU fish industry is tapping into its economic potential. The Parliament's report itself found that several giant seafood processors have chosen to diversify their supply and are behind the same plant-based alternatives at stake. Some might say it's a classic case of 'if you can't beat them, join them.' As Brussels debates whether 'Toona' is witty branding or bending the rules, one thing is clear: from Magritte's pipe to the supermarket fridge, the question still lingers — is a name ever just a name?

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store