27-05-2025
Home educators fight to keep advisory council
Home educators defend survival of advisory council
Jennifer Wright, center inset and a home educator, spoke Tuesday against the idea of getting rid of the Home Education Advisory Council.
Many home education advocates turned out Tuesday to oppose what one called an 'ambush' amendment to eliminate the 14-member Home Education Advisory Council (HEAC).
'You want home educators to get on board, sit down and shut up,' said Katherine Abbott of Portsmouth in defending the council's work.
Rep. Glenn Cordelli, R-Tuftonboro, argued that after 35 years of advocacy, leaders have gotten sidetracked, and the group has become dysfunctional.
Several HEAC members have become critical of Education Freedom Accounts (EFAs), taxpayer-subsidized scholarships for parents to send their children to private, religious, alternative public or home school programs, he said.
'HEAC has lost its way and deviated from its role per law and rule and is not adhering to its responsibility to provide support to home educators,' Cordelli said.
Cordelli proposed his amendment to an unrelated bill (HB 57) to study whether the state should reduce the number of supervisory administrative units (SAUs) in New Hampshire.
Several members of the HEAC said the creation of EFAs in 2021 has threatened to dilute the independent nature of home education by having families accept public funding.
Many home educators believe accepting EFA money gives the state more control over their instruction.
Amanda Weeden with Granite State Home Educators said the council since September has raised issues with Education Commissioner Frank Edelblut about the freedom of their movement.
'The optics of this non-germane amendment being snuck in, it is an ambush,' said Weeden. 'The (EFA) school choice movement is late to the party. We are the original school choicers.'
Group began as a way to advise DOE on the topic
The Legislature created HEAC in 1990 as a forum to give advice to the education commissioner on home education.
'Without this council, this valuable line of communication would be lost,' said Jennifer Pereira, who served on the council for eight years.
Dianne Nolin, a member of HEAC, noted Gov. Kelly Ayotte has already announced that she will name a new education commissioner at the end of this school year when Edelblut will move on after eight years on the job.
'Through periods of change we need the experience of those who do the work every day,' Nolin said.
Several opponents of Cordelli's idea called on the Legislature to get rid of agency rules that along with state law govern home education practices.
'This is an important liaison for us,' said Jennifer Wright, a home educating mom. 'Are there things that could be fixed? Absolutely. This has been going on since I was born. I think eliminating it would be really short-sighted.'
Cordelli had said other advocacy groups such as the New Hampshire Home Educators Association founded in 1983 could take the place of HEAC and be more focused on the mission.
But after nearly every speaker opposed Cordelli's idea, Cordelli told the House Education Policy and Administration Committee he chairs that he would drop the idea, meet with advocates and perhaps pursue cooperative legislation in the future.
'We can give HEAC a little more time,' Cordelli summed up. 'I am hopeful that the tone of discussion between traditional home educators and EFA families who are primarily home schooling will improve, that the rhetoric calms down.'
What's Next: The full House early next month will vote on the SAU study bill without the home education issue in it.
Prospects: Lawmakers never run short of ideas for study committees and this one too is likely to make it to the finish line.
klandrigan@
