06-05-2025
Thrifter Checks Out Free Pile, Then Finds the 'Grail' of Hermès Silk Scarfs
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources.
Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content.
A lucky thrifter may have stumbled upon a luxury fashion jackpot—a suspected Hermès scarf—while browsing the free pile.
The Reddit user, u/ImAHoe4Glossier, shared their discovery in the popular subreddit Thrift Store Hauls, where it quickly gained traction with 2,900 upvotes.
"A (possibly real?) Hermès scarf from a free pile! I'm just going to tell myself it's real because it's so cute!" they wrote.
The photo included in the post reveals a silk scarf in soft pink tones, adorned with intricate Parisian architectural motifs, and labelled Hermès — Paris in the right corner.
Though unverified, the design also bears the text 'Les Toits De Paris'—a style of Hermès scarf that has fetched high resale prices online. One pre-owned version is currently listed for $2,068 USD on eBay, while another previously sold on TheRealReal for $345.
Expert Insight
Jennifer Johnson, owner of True Fashionistas, the largest lifestyle resale store in Florida, weighed in on the find to Newsweek.
"From what I can see in the pictures that she sent yes I do think it's authentic however, the disclaimer is I would have to see it in person to be 100% certain. It would probably be priced around the $300 mark," Johnson said.
At True Fashionistas, Johnson and her team authenticate luxury items daily using both experience and advanced technology.
"With regard to the Hermès scarf the very first thing we look for is the stitching on the edge of the Hermès scarf. The stitching should never be sewn by a machine it should always be hand stitched and the hem should be rolled. They should always be 100% silk and the pattern should not look blurred or off," she said.
Johnson explained it is common to find authentic garments in resale stores since people want the "latest and greatest".
A stock image of a woman thrifting.
A stock image of a woman thrifting.
triocean/iStock / Getty Images Plus
Reddit Reacts
Reddit users were quick to voice their excitement and admiration for the stylish score.
"This particular design from Hermès, Les Toits de Paris, is considered a 'grail' by many scarf collectors, myself included! Great find op, wear in good health," shared one user.
"Wow, looks like it was produced in 2006. Comp that sold on eBay for $1,500. I had no idea scarves could be worth that much or that pretty. Guess I will start looking at them," another commenter added.
"Wow. OP, I am no expert, but I am someone who has coveted an Hermès scarf ever since reading about them in a novel as a child in the 1980s. I am pretty convinced this is authentic. I am so happy for OP! (And even if it is a dupe, it is lovely!) I am saving up for one for my 50th but til then will continue to thrift in hopes of finding one for a bargain price!" shared another.
Newsweek reached out to u/ImAHoe4Glossier, for comment via Reddit. We could not verify the details of the case.
Do you have any amazing thrifting finds that you want to share? We want to see the best ones! Send them in to life@ and they could appear on our site.
