4 days ago
Why Chasing Bonuses Is A Risky Gamble For Health Insurance Agents
Angela Palo is COO of Pinnacle Financial Services, a leading National Medicare Brokerage, and member of the NABIP Medicare FMO Council.
A bonus can catch your attention, but it doesn't guarantee a better future. In this business, the temptation of higher commissions, upfront incentives and marketing perks feels impossible to resist. I've seen too many licensed health insurance agents and agencies leap at these agent compensation traps only to discover the true cost down the line.
Sustainable success doesn't come from chasing the next big deal. It comes from thoughtful partnerships built on trust and long-term value. The best agents focus on meaningful career growth and building and protecting their book of business.
When agents move contracts for financial incentives alone, they risk more than they realize. The glow of a bonus fades quickly, leaving many stuck with restrictive contracts, reduced autonomy and uneven support.
The Hook
Larger organizations—including some FMOs and private equity-backed groups—know how to grab attention. They dangle enticing bonuses, better commission splits, marketing perks and back-office support—financial incentives that seem too good to pass up.
For agents and agencies facing rising competition and shrinking margins, these deals can seem like the answer.
The Risks Behind The Rewards
Once the initial excitement wears off and the bonus fades, so do the benefits. Some contracts restrict agents' flexibility, cut their overrides or tether them to systems that don't support their style of working. We've even seen contracts where the agent/agency recontracts as a licensed-only agent and no longer owns their business. That's scary.
We try to guide agents to build their renewals to ensure their long-term stability. Think of that as a pension or 401(k). Once you don't own the business, that means you don't own the renewals.
When an agent or agency tells us, "Well, I'll try it for a year," they often have no idea how problematic exiting these contracts can be—if it's even possible. And the transition often comes with financial and reputational costs.
Regulatory Scrutiny
Regulatory scrutiny is also increasing. CMS and other regulators are paying close attention to compensation structures and marketing practices.
What starts as support can, under closer inspection, appear to be an inducement. The potential for compliance risk is real and should not be underestimated. Expecting the enticer to warn you of the dangers isn't realistic.
Time To Take A Smarter Approach To Growth
Real, lasting success stems from thoughtful partnerships. The agents and agencies that thrive aren't the ones who chase bonuses; they're the ones who align with organizations that prioritize their growth, client service and autonomy.
My conversations with agents have always revealed a simple truth: The most successful agents value support systems that help them grow sustainably. They recognize that long-term gains outweigh short-term rewards. They're asking different questions, focusing on relationships over revenue spikes and looking for partners who understand the bigger picture.
At Pinnacle Financial Services, for example, we focus on providing the kind of support that helps agents build strong books of business and trusted client relationships. This includes training, mentorship, marketing assistance and compliance support tailored to how agents actually work. These resources aren't designed to flash and then fade. They're meant to fuel careers over the long haul. The best FMOs for agents follow the same game plan.
Lessons From The Field
Here's what I counsel agents to do before making a decision:
• Ask the hard questions. Before moving contracts, look closely at the fine print. What kind of long-term support will you receive? What happens after the bonus period ends? How flexible is the relationship?
• Look beyond the bonus. An upfront payout might sound appealing, but what happens next matters more. Consider how the partnership will impact client service, operational efficiency and compliance.
• Value independence. Control over your book of business, carrier relationships and marketing strategy is key. Protect your autonomy.
• Trust your instincts. If a deal feels too good to be true, it probably is. Take the time to evaluate the offer from every angle.
• Talk to your current upline. They may be able to explain why they can't offer you that deal and may be able to put something else in place that is sustainable and better for your future growth.
Building A Culture That Lasts
I come from a company culture where we believe that strong partnerships are built on integrity, service and a commitment to long-term success. Our approach is simple: Invest in people, focus on shared values and provide meaningful support with current technology and resources.
That approach has helped us—and those we partner with—build businesses that last. And we adhere to that principle with our staff. We're committed to the philosophy "The best tech, powered by the best people!"
When agents and agencies prioritize quick payouts, they risk sacrificing autonomy, flexibility and stability. The question becomes: Is a short-term gain worth long-term uncertainty?
So, choose wisely. When you decide to work with organizations that don't invest in your long-term growth and support your independence, you make a decision that shapes the future of your business and the confidence you bring to your clients.
Forbes Business Council is the foremost growth and networking organization for business owners and leaders. Do I qualify?
