4 days ago
Ogdensburg City Council tables charter changes
Aug. 11—OGDENSBURG — Action on proposed changes to the City Charter have been tabled until the entire City Council is present.
Two members of City Council ― Michael Powers and Donna Trimm ― were absent from Monday night's meeting that mainly consisted of a public hearing and then a resolution to adopt a number of recommendations from the Charter Review Commission to the City Charter, a wide-ranging document that lays the framework for how Ogdensburg's municipal government is operated.
Proposed changes included allowing non-residency of the city manager and department heads at the discretion of City Council, small salary raises for council members, and other changes such as allowing for the city manager to have discretionary power to spend up to $10,000 without council approval.
Following a public hearing, Mayor Michael Tooley said that it was decided that no action would be taken on the resolution until the entire council was present to vote on the City Charter changes.
Council heard from two city residents during the public hearing, Macreena Doyle and Kit Smith, who both opposed changing the residency requirement, which dominated the discussion. That proposal from the Charter Commission moved forward with a 7-2 vote and was the "most in-depth" discussion of the commission's previous meetings.
Doyle said that she agrees that those making the decisions about the city should live in the community because "they are going to be affected by the same policies that they are making."
She added that council needs to look at ways to improve housing stock, improve neighborhoods and make it so any prospective city manager candidate would want to live in Ogdensburg.
Smith, who retired as the director of the city Department of Public Works after nearly 17 years, moved to Ogdensburg to take the position.
"I came from Morristown. When I was hired by the city of Ogdensburg, it was an opportunity that I felt was worth selling my house in Morristown for and moving to the city of Ogdensburg," Smith said. " It gave me an opportunity to know the people, be part of the people, join a number of clubs ― the Lions, the Boys and Girls Club and other civic organizations. I really feel the residency law should stay. I don't feel you can be a good department head without being a part of the community."
Councilor Daniel Skamperle said that he understood the arguments presented by the public and that he would be thinking about how he will vote in the near future. He did say that it would be a shame to lose a good candidate for a position, just because he or she wouldn't move into the city.
"It's something that is going to be on our mind, thanks for bringing it up," Skamperle said.
It appears that the residency proposal may not have support from all members of City Council.
One of those was Councilor Jennifer Stevenson.
"I have heard from many citizens over time and I have thought about it extensively," Stevenson said. "I have spoken to numerous past city managers and one of them said to me 'I wanted to live within the city because I wanted to be the neighbor of the people that I was working with. The people that I was affecting by the budget being presented by my staff, the rules and regulations and the departments that work for me. I wanted people to be able to stop by my porch and talk to me.'"
She did say that perhaps the council vote on residency could be a super majority vote, requiring five votes instead of the normal four.
Councilor R. Storm Cilley said that he is generally in favor of maintaining a residency requirement but agreed with Stevenson's proposal for a super majority vote, if it came to that.
Councilor John Tebo felt that the manager and department heads should have a "vested interest."
"I just think that if you want to work for the city of Ogdensburg you should have to live in the city limits," Tebo said.
Tooley said that council had asked the commission to review the residency requirement because of an issue with a failure of the city to fill vacant positions within city government.
He added that council could amend the recommendation to make it so the department head or city manager would have to live in St. Lawrence County, which would align the policy with others across the state.
"If residency requirement is waived, the employee must still reside in the county. Ogdensburg for a few years has experienced vacancies in important administrative and public official positions. I would say it was one of the reasons that a request for flexibility was made to the commission," Tooley said.
Another recommendation called for an increase in compensation for the mayor and councilors. The commission proposed an increase of $3,000 for the mayor's salary, bringing it up to $10,000, and $1,500 increases for councilors to a total of $5,000 for each. That change, if adopted, would take effect Jan. 1, 2026.
Stevenson proposed that the raises, if approved, would not go into effect until after the next election.
The entirety of the proposed changes to the charter can be found on the July 28 City Council agenda on the city's website,
The charter was last reviewed in 2017. The lone change that was adopted by council on Nov. 27, 2017, was changing the length of time in between the convening of the commission from 10 years to 6. In 2023, City Council changed the length of time back to 10 years before the current governing body convened the commission last fall.
In other City Council action:
The city directed City Manager Fonda Chronis to accept a Wastewater Infrastructure Engineering Planning Grant (EPG) from the Environmental Facilities Corporation of New York State for $100,000. The city would have to provide a local share of 20%, or $20,000, to perform an inflow and infiltration study on a "portion of city sewer infrastructure to determine areas where wastewater and stormwater are combined and sent to the wastewater treatment plant for processing."
Solve the daily Crossword
