Latest news with #Ramlal
IOL News
20 hours ago
- Politics
- IOL News
‘You are misleading the court': Magistrate Ramlal slams State as blue lights fraud trial collapses again
At the heart of the confusion is accused number three, whose role in the case has changed without explanation. He was initially said to have confessed, but no written confession was ever filed. He was then removed from the charge sheet and quietly reclassified as a potential State witness, raising serious concerns about coercion and procedural misconduct. Image: Supplied The long-running tax fraud trial linked to the SAPS 'blue lights' scandal fell into fresh disarray on Thursday at Palm Ridge Magistrate's Court, with Magistrate Ashika Ramlal sharply criticising the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) and accusing the State of misleading the court. At the heart of the confusion is accused number three, whose role in the case has changed without explanation. He was initially said to have confessed, but no written confession was ever filed. He was then removed from the charge sheet and quietly reclassified as a potential State witness, raising serious concerns about coercion and procedural misconduct. Things worsened on Thursday when accused number nine, Thomas Marima, arrived in court late and without proper legal representation. Marima only met his lawyer for the first time during the court break. Magistrate Ramlal was visibly frustrated, accusing the State of using Marima's lack of counsel as a tactic to delay the trial again. 'You are misleading the court if you say you are ready for trial,' Ramlal told lead prosecutor Richard Chabalala. 'This is why South Africans are losing trust in the NPA.' The magistrate concluded that the State may not be ready to proceed and issued a firm directive: by 1 July 2025, the State must ensure all accused persons are provided with a complete and accurate charge sheet and that they fully understand the charges against them. 'You were hoping to use number nine's lack of representation as a way to secure another postponement,' she added. Defence lawyer Piet du Plessis, representing former acting police commissioner Kgomotso Phahlane, was equally critical earlier in the week. 'It's 2025, and the State still doesn't have a valid charge sheet for a case that began in 2018,' he said. 'After 40 minutes, the prosecutor couldn't produce a single legally sound version.' The original charge sheet — dating back to 2021 — was signed by Herman Cronje, who left the NPA the same year. That version listed James Ramanjolam as accused number three. In the latest version, Ramanjolam is no longer included — yet his signature remains on some documentation. Du Plessis and other attorneys argue that altering a charge sheet prepared by a former official without submitting it to IDAC (Investigating Directorate Against Corruption) head Andrea Johnson for re-approval is procedurally improper and potentially fraudulent. These discrepancies have triggered calls for a formal investigation into the NPA's handling of the matter. When questioned in court, Prosecutor Chabalala admitted the errors were his responsibility, blaming 'oversights' in formatting and printing. Legal experts say such explanations fall short for a corruption case of this magnitude. Some accused individuals claim they were harassed or pressured to testify against others, raising additional concerns over fairness. Several have seen charges dropped and later reinstated, including Major General Ravi Pillay, former SAPS Head of Procurement. Businessman Vimpie Manthata and his company — listed as accused one and eight — have experienced the same back-and-forth. At the centre of the case is an alleged R19 million VAT fraud connected to Instrumentation for Traffic Law Enforcement, a company owned by Manthata. Bookkeeper Judy Rose is accused of facilitating the fraudulent claims, which form part of a broader R191 million SAPS procurement scandal involving emergency 'blue lights' equipment. The trial was expected to proceed this week, with SARS officials scheduled to testify. But the continued confusion over documents and legal representation brought proceedings to a halt once again.'This is just another example of a high-profile corruption case falling apart due to poor planning, weak prosecution, and basic legal missteps,' one legal observer commented. Magistrate Ramlal has now set 1 July as a non-negotiable deadline. 'All the accused must receive a complete charge sheet, and all must understand what they are being charged with—no more excuses,' she said. The matter is due back in court on 15 July 2025. But unless the State resolves its ongoing procedural failures, this already seven-year-old trial risks collapsing entirely.
The Hindu
12-06-2025
- The Hindu
Bus rams lorry on NH, 18 injured
At least 18 passengers were injured when a Hyderabad-bound private sleeper bus from Karnataka rammed into a stationary lorry on NH 167 in Narayanpet district in the early hours of Thursday. The bus, carrying 29 passengers from Shivamogga to Hyderabad, met with the accident around 4.30 a.m. The lorry had come to a halt in the middle of the highway due to a mechanical breakdown, and heavy overnight rain had further reduced visibility, explained Inspector Ramlal from Makthal police. 'Although highway patrol teams had placed reflective cones to alert oncoming traffic, the speeding bus failed to stop in time and ploughed straight into the vehicle,' he said. The impact left the front portion of the bus completely mangled. Four passengers suffered fractures, while five others, including three children, sustained spinal injuries. The bus driver's leg was also fractured and the co-driver was injured too. All the injured were given first aid at the government hospital in Makthal. Police have registered a case and an investigation is on.
Time of India
27-05-2025
- Time of India
2 tie guard up, flee with cash and jewellery from factory
Ghaziabad: Two masked men allegedly robbed a factory in Modinagar late Monday night after assaulting and tying up the security guard. The accused fled with Rs 8 lakh in cash and jewellery worth over Rs 15 lakh, cops said. The factory is owned by Vinod Kumar Vaishali, chairman of the Modinagar municipal council, he runs a large advertising and promotion business. According to police, the incident took place at around 11.30pm. Ramlal, the factory's watchman and a resident of Modinagar, said the duo attacked him from behind with an iron rod, leaving him unconscious. "When I regained consciousness, my hands were tied. One of the men was sitting next to me, while the other came out of the office with a bag," he said. Ramlal said both accused had their faces covered. After they fled, he managed to free himself and informed the factory owner, who then contacted police. Vaishali told police that a female employee, had stored jewellery worth around Rs 15 lakh in a locker inside the factory office. "The accused took the jewellery and also stole Rs 8 lakh in cash kept in three different cabinets," he said. ACP (Modinagar) Gyan Prakash Rai said an FIR has been registered and efforts are on to identify and nab the accused.
