06-03-2025
Governor prevails in dispute over penalties for supervisors who stay silent on misdeeds
South Dakota Republican Gov. Larry Rhoden speaks during a press conference Feb. 6, 2025, at the Capitol in Pierre with Lt. Gov. Tony Venhuizen. (Seth Tupper/South Dakota Searchlight)
South Dakota Gov. Larry Rhoden's preferred version of a bill to punish supervisors who hide misbehavior by state employees is headed to his desk.
Senate Bill 62 is part of a legislative package from Attorney General Marty Jackley as a response to a host of state employee malfeasance cases since last summer.
On Wednesday at the state Capitol, the Senate voted 20-14 to agree with Rhoden-supported changes applied to the bill earlier by the state House of Representatives.
Jackley wanted supervisors who fail to report employee misdeeds to face felony charges – even if the misdeeds in question amounted to misdemeanor crimes.
Lawmakers target government supervisors who stay silent on misconduct, but not with a felony
The bill's basic outlines were broadly popular in both chambers, but the clause on felonies for supervisors proved divisive. Rhoden's lobbyists unsuccessfully pushed to reduce the penalty for supervisors to a misdemeanor in both the House and Senate judiciary committees. Senators narrowly rejected an effort to do the same during SB 62's first appearance on the floor in that chamber.
Earlier this week, the House voted 38-31 to go Rhoden's way.
The Senate was asked Wednesday to concur. Senators could've appointed a conference committee in hopes of hammering out the differences between the House and Senate versions of the bill.
A handful of senators, including Pierre Republican Jim Mehlhaff, wanted to restore Jackley's preferences and hoped a conference committee could pull that off.
'This was an unfriendly amendment,' Mehlhaff said of the House's actions.
The majority of his colleagues, however, decided against another volley.
'I'm not sure a conference committee will resolve this, and I'd like to be done with this today,' said Sen. Amber Hulse, R-Hot Springs.
Jackley filed at least five criminal cases against former state employees last year, for allegations ranging from faked food-service health inspections to $1.8 million of embezzlement from a state department.
His package of anti-corruption legislation includes other bills that would expand the investigatory authority of the state auditor, strengthen the Board of Internal Controls, and establish protections for whistleblowers. Each bill has passed both chambers, with some pending amendments made by one chamber or the other.
Jackley issued a statement Wednesday praising the Legislature for approving the package.
'I remain convinced that there must be significant consequences when a government supervisor does not report a crime or government misbehavior,' Jackley said. 'The number of cases in the last year demonstrates that such crimes should be charged as a felony, not a misdemeanor. The Legislature thought differently, and I respect its decision.'
SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX
