Latest news with #SharavathiPumpedStorageProject
The Hindu
5 days ago
- Politics
- The Hindu
Sharavathi PSP: Villagers resist $1.2 billion project in Wildlife Sanctuary
Published : Aug 01, 2025 18:25 IST - 14 MINS READ Begodi, a small dispersed hamlet of around 15 families, is located in the Nagarabastikeri panchayat of Honnavara taluk of Uttara Kannada district in north-west Karnataka. A potholed road extends from the highway to Chaturmukha Basadi, a grand 16th century Jain temple, but beyond this, it is a stony, 10 kilometre pathway leading to the hamlet, which turns into mush in the monsoons. The relentless rain causes jets of impromptu streams to gush downhill from the thickly forested hills of the Western Ghats, furrowing channels to the tributaries of the Sharavathi river, turning hamlets such as Begodi, located on the periphery of the Sharavathi Lion-Tailed Macaque (LTM) Wildlife Sanctuary, into veritable islands that can only be reached by perilous and ingenious means and networks of hand-hewn wooden bridges. Mahesh Naik, a 39-year-old farmer in Begodi, crossed the stubby wooden bridge he himself built a few years ago across the raging stream that encircled his land and casually walked past a kere haavu (rat snake) as he led us to his house set in a 5 acre areca and coconut plantation. After vigorously rubbing himself down with a towel, Mahesh gingerly fished out an official letter from the Uttara Kannada district administration. According to the document, Mahesh and other landholders of Begodi were asked to participate in a meeting on July 31 to discuss the terms under which their land would be acquired for the proposed Sharavathi Pumped Storage Project (PSP), a gargantuan electricity generation project on the Sharavathi. Pointing to several 2-feet-high concrete pillars planted along the village tracks marking the proposed extent of the widening of the road for the PSP, Mahesh said the residents of Nagarabastikeri had taken a unanimous decision in April to 'not part with the 54 acres of land sought for the PSP in Begodi'. Mahesh and his neighbour Gajanana Lingappa Naik pointed to the silhouettes of tall green hills shrouded in the pouring sheets of rain behind their village in the wildlife sanctuary, where they said the enormous tunnels of the Sharavathi PSP would emerge. Also Read | Karnataka farmers refuse to give up fertile land for Aerospace Park When one looked at the opaque green jungle wall beyond the limits of Begodi, it was hard to imagine how these underground tunnels would bore their way through the forested hills from the upstream reservoir of Talakalale without completely destroying the verdant landscape. Gajanana, who was part of a group of labourers that went with a survey team into the wildlife sanctuary, said: 'The tunnels would pass Begodi and the river water would flow down into the Gerusoppa reservoir.' One could, theoretically, trek up the forested hill for around 8 kilometres from Begodi to reach the two small hamlets of Marathi Keri and Henni in the neighbouring Sagara taluk of Shivamogga district, which will constitute the upper site of the Sharavathi PSP. But since this was physically impossible in the monsoons because of the leech-infested terrain, the alternative was to take a two-hour detour by road passing the majestic Jog Falls along the way. In Marathi Keri, named thus because the residents of the 56 houses in this village are all Marathi speakers, H. Gururaj, a 32-year-old farmer who grows areca, pepper, cashew, and coconuts on his 2 acres of land, walked up to the highest point in the village. Pointing to the picture postcard vista on the horizon where the hills kissed the Sharavati river, he said: 'According to the survey team, 8.5 acres of land will be required in Marathi Keri for the Sharavathi PSP and the tunnels will start boring through from our village.' Akhilesh Chippali, an environmental activist who has rejuvenated several lakes in Sagara—a small town in Shivamogga district enveloped by the Western Ghats—is convinced the Sharavathi PSP is an impending environmental disaster. To demonstrate how the project would work, he lifted a cup of tea with his left hand, holding it high to represent the upper reservoir, while his right hand rested on a saucer placed on the table—the lower reservoir. He said: 'Imagine my cup is the Talakalale reservoir where Marathi Keri and Henni are located and my saucer is the Gerusoppa reservoir where water will flow into after passing through Begodi. The concept of a PSP is simple. The Sharavathi will flow down from my cup [Talakalale] to the saucer [Gerusoppa] through tunnels, generating hydroelectricity, and will then be pumped back during off-peak hours and flow down again during peak hours to generate hydroelectricity again.' (The Talakalale reservoir is 528 metres above sea level while the Gerusoppa reservoir is merely 84 m above sea level.) The pre-feasibility report prepared in 2017 for the Karnataka Power Corporation Ltd (KPCL) said: 'The proposed Sharavathy Pumped Storage Project on Sharavathy river would perhaps be one of the biggest pumped storage schemes in the range of 2,000 MW in India. The proposed project is planned as an additional installation utilising the existing Sharavathy system consisting of Liganamakhi [sic], Talakalale Dam and Gerusoppa Dam.' (Bengaluru requires approximately 2,300 MW daily on average, which puts the scale of the project in perspective.) 'The proposal was pushed through because of political pressure even though the Karnataka Forest Department was reluctant to give clearance for the project.'Joseph HooverWildlife activist and former member of the SBW This PSP, if built, will be a significant addition to the cumulative energy output of Karnataka considering that the State's largest hydroelectric project to date is the Sharavathi Hydroelectric Generating Station with an installed capacity of 1,035 MW a day, but this is not the only hydroelectric project on the Sharavathi, which originates in Thirthahalli taluk of Shivamogga district in the Western Ghats and flows westwards for 128 km. Power is also generated along its course at Linganamakki Dam, Mahatma Gandhi Hydroelectric Station, and Gerusoppa Dam before the river's tail water flows into the Arabian Sea. As per the 219-page pre-feasibility report, the Sharavathi PSP 'envisages to utilise the existing Talakalale dam as upper dam and Gerusoppa as lower dam without any modification in these structures'. Thus, while no new dams will be constructed, the PSP does plan the construction of 14 km of concrete-lined underground tunnels and an underground pump house containing eight generating units and turbines of 250 MW each. (As per a power sector analyst, each generating unit is as large as an independent house.) The project was estimated to cost Rs.4,862.69 crore in 2017, but in the Karnataka Budget of March 2025, the outlay was increased to Rs.10,240 crore. Back in 2017 when the plan was first mooted, the site of the proposed project was a reserve forest; the zone's protection has since been enhanced after it became a part of the Sharavathi LTM Wildlife Sanctuary whose expansion was notified in 2019. Despite this, the project was approved by the Karnataka State Board of Wildlife (SBW) and the Central Electric Authority (CEA) in 2024. Joseph Hoover, a wildlife activist and former member of the SBW, said the proposal was 'pushed through because of political pressure even though the Karnataka Forest Department was reluctant to give clearance for the project'. Crucially, the Sharavathi PSP also received an 'in-principle' nod from the Standing Committee of the National Board of Wildlife (SC-NBWL) on June 26 this year although it was subject to the fulfilment of 28 conditions, including pivotal forest, wildlife, and environmental clearances from the Union Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change. Strangely, the in-principle approval was granted despite a negative site inspection report by Praneetha Paul, a senior Indian Forest Services officer. In her report submitted in May, Paul did not recommend the project because the Sharavathi PSP would have a massive impact on the unique forest habitat of the Western Ghats and lead to the destruction of rare, endangered, and endemic species. According to the minutes of the critical SC-NBWL meeting, the Sharavathi PSP proposal was recommended by the Chief Wildlife Warden of Karnataka, the SWB, and the Karnataka government for the 'use of 42.51 hectares of forest land and 60.534 hectares of non-forest land from the Sharavathi Valley LTM Wildlife Sanctuary and 11.645 hectares forest land and 28.074 hectares from the eco-sensitive zone around the sanctuary…'. It added that 'about 15,000 trees are going to be cut for construction of road'. Justifying the proposal in the meeting, Subhash K. Malkhede, the Chief Wildlife Warden of Karnataka (retired since then), stated that '…it is a green project which will not have much ecological impact on the area'. (Interestingly, Malkhede stated that 'solar power' would be used to pump water, but Paul mentioned in her report that both 'thermal/renewable energy resources' would be used.) Striking a note of caution during the proceedings, Raman Sukumar, a member of the SC-NBWL and a noted elephant ecologist, mentioned that the wildlife sanctuary was a 'densely forested area... housing the maximum population of lion-tailed macaques in the entire Western Ghats…. The proposal should be carefully examined in detail [along with] a thorough environmental impact assessment…' Chippali flagged the concerns the environmentalists had with the Sharavathi PSP: 'A population of around 730 lion-tailed macaques, an endangered species, resides in the wildlife sanctuary. The Western Ghats are a UNESCO World Heritage Site with dense natural tropical forests. How can this project be approved in a wildlife sanctuary destroying 350 acres when Section 29 of the Wild Life (Protection) Act [of 1972] clearly prohibits this?' Hoover, who visited the proposed construction site inside the Sharavathi LTM Sanctuary in 2024, said: 'The area beyond Begodi where the KPCL team has done preliminary drilling is in the pristine old growth Western Ghats forests which can never be replaced. The destruction of this forest will lead to ecological imbalance.' Nirmala Gowda, an ecological activist and researcher, objected to the SC-NBWL's approval on several grounds. In a note that she shared with Frontline, she listed these in detail: The 'in-principle' approval was beyond the legal authority of the SC-NBWL; it violated Supreme Court rulings and clearance procedures in assessing project alternatives; ignored landslide risks and geological instability of the area as the proposed project site falls within moderate to high landslide susceptibility zones as identified by the Karnataka State Natural Disaster Monitoring Centre; the PSP would lead to a loss of significant and irreplaceable natural carbon stocks and sequestration capacity; it undermined the escalating loss of biodiversity; and the land identified for compensatory afforestation violates the Compensatory Afforestation Rules as it lies in the buffer zone of the Bhadra Tiger Reserve, which is already a forest. Shankar Sharma, an electrical engineer who has been closely associated with the power sector for more than 44 years, including a 9-year stint with the CEA, was visibly angry with the idea of the PSP. Around 20 years ago, Sharma had walked along the entire length of the Sharavathi river from its source in Ambuthirtha to Honnavara, where the river spills into the Arabian Sea, studying the riverine ecosystem and engaging with the communities that live alongside. It is this deep sense of connection he developed with the Sharavathi river and the Western Ghats that has compelled Sharma to consistently campaign against the project since 2019. Sharing a tranche of emails that he has written to various authorities over the years, Sharma said: 'It is a tragedy that the SC-NBWL has not cared to question the true relevance of the project proposal before giving the 'in-principle' approval. The amount of electricity required to pump a certain quantity of water from a lower reservoir to the higher reservoir in a PSP will be approximately 24 to 25 per cent more than the electricity that can be generated from the same quantity of water stored in the upper reservoir. The cost-to-benefit ratio of this project is less than one.' This fact is borne out in the 2017 pre-feasibility report that stated that 12,000 MWh (megawatt-hour) of energy will be generated by the Sharavathi PSP, while 14,833 MWh of energy will be required to pump the water upstream. Sharma also made a shocking accusation against the Karnataka government, which has demonstrated great eagerness to implement this PSP despite the dire ecological problems. 'The tender for this project was bagged by a company in 2024 without all the clearances,' he said. 'Even now forest, wildlife, and environmental clearances are pending. Why this great hurry? How can the construction contract be awarded without the availability of a Detailed Project Report [DPR] to assess the cost? Something was seriously wrong with the tender allocation procedure and there must have been extraneous considerations. Check the electoral bonds bought by the company and you can connect the dots.' Sharma's insinuation of corruption stemmed from the controversy surrounding the allotment of the construction tender to Megha Engineering and Infrastructure Ltd (MEIL) by KPCL. In 2024, Larsen and Toubro, another bidder, approached the Karnataka High Court and the Supreme Court citing irregularities in the award of the tender to MEIL, but the plea was dismissed. Notably, MEIL was the second biggest purchaser of electoral bonds, worth Rs.966 crore as per data released by the Election Commission of India in 2024. Chippali alleged that the project is just an avenue to mint money. Hoover said: 'The lure of big money has blinded Karnataka Energy Minister K.J. George, who has ironically been promoting renewable energy alternatives.' In a press conference on June 28, George stated that the DPR 'for the Sharavathi project has already been approved by the Central Electricity Authority' although Chippali said that his RTI application for this document was unsuccessful. Also Read | Karnataka: The southern outlier Sharma asked: 'Let us assume that the DPR was ready last year [2024] and has been hidden from the public. Why should the DPR be hidden from the public if it is a public sector undertaking? What does the government want to hide?' In an earlier statement, also in June, George dismissed the protests of the environmentalists: 'Only a few environmentalists are raising objections. If the project is executed, it will generate 2,000 MW of power along with a proper storage facility. All pipes and cables will be laid underground.' At a function to mark the 56th anniversary of KPCL on July 23, George said: 'Even though a satisfactory amount of power is being generated in Karnataka, there is no facility to store this. Therefore, the government has decided to go ahead with the Sharavathi PSP and the Varahi PSP (of 1,500 MW). Through this, power can be stored and can be used whenever there is a surge in demand.' Responding to the push for PSPs in the Western Ghats, Nirmala Gowda organised a two-day knowledge summit in June in Shivamogga, which was attended by environmental researchers, lawyers, campaigners, local community representatives, and civil society organisations. The participants decided that while PSPs in the Western Ghats may be necessary for transition to renewable energy, they must be located outside wildlife sanctuaries and ecologically sensitive areas. Assessing the contribution of these power generation projects, Gowda said that the 'Western Ghats must not be treated as a power plant' and that there were numerous preferable alternatives. 'There are location alternatives, energy storage technology alternatives such as battery energy storage systems, and strategies to flatten peak electricity demand through a combination of regulatory measures and enabling technologies. All these options are outlined in the National Electricity Plan 2023 and represent viable, less ecologically damaging alternatives to large-scale PSPs in sensitive forest and wildlife areas.' For Gowda, the issue is a deeply emotional one. She spent several weeks last year travelling through the Western Ghats speaking to a wide range of stakeholders. She told Frontline: 'Undermining the sanctity of the last frontier of biodiversity is a profound failure to recognise multispecies justice. Earth is not ours alone; it is a shared home, where every species holds an intrinsic right to exist.' Back in Marathi Keri, Gururaj walked up to a flaring red ribbon tied to a branch, which marks the area required for the Sharavathi PSP in his village. His aunt Nagarathna, an elderly woman in her 70s, looked on forlornly at the bewitching Sharavathi river valley spread out before her and said that if she was forced to relocate, it would be the second time in her life; the first time was in 1964 when Linganamakki Dam was constructed upstream on the Sharavathi. Her words highlighted the historical price that humans, forests, and wildlife have paid for energy projects that seek to harness the rivers of the Western Ghats. So far, this paltry piece of red fabric is the only indicator of the looming gigantic engineering project that has been envisaged in the virginal terrain of the Sharavathi LTM Sanctuary but if one were to read the blowing cloth as a semaphore, the signs were ominous. (Frontline reached out to Karnataka Minister of Energy K.J. George for his response to the concerns raised by environmental activists. A detailed questionnaire was mailed at the request of his office, but no response had been received at the time of going to press.)
Hans India
17-07-2025
- Politics
- Hans India
Cong Mysuru convention, show of strength amid internal conflict: Bommai
Haveri: The Congress party is holding a convention in Mysuru on July 19 to showcase its internal power struggles rather than achievements, said former Chief Minister and Member of Parliament Basavaraj Bommai. Speaking to the media in Haveri on Wednesday, he said Congress has not achieved enough to warrant a convention. They had earlier planned a show of strength in Hassan under the pretext of a convention of achievements. Now, that is being done in Mysuru. The fact that the party in-charge has already held meetings with ministers shows that things are not right within the party. The internal conflict continues without a full stop. Unless the Congress High Command gives clear direction, this unrest will persist. It even seems like the High Command itself wants this confusion to continue. On the Sharavathi Pumped Storage Project, Bommai said, it is a project that can generate around 2,000 megawatts of electricity at a relatively low cost. About 38 hectares of forest land will be affected. Forests should be grown in alternative areas and the surrounding forest must be protected. The project has already received conditional approval, and it should proceed in adherence to those conditions. When asked about the Congress allegation that protocol was violated during the inauguration of the Sigandur bridge, the former CM said there was no violation of protocol in any manner.
Time of India
15-07-2025
- Politics
- Time of India
Belur criticises MP over Sigandur bridge inauguration row
Shivamogga: A day after the launch of India's second-longest cable-stayed bridge at Sagar in Shivamogga, Sagar MLA Belur Gopal Krishna criticised Shivamogga MP BY Raghavendra. He accused him of having a "fox mentality" and deliberately scheduling the event hastily to exclude state govt representatives. He urged CM Siddaramaiah to take disciplinary action against govt officials who attended the Sigandur bridge inauguration on Monday, despite the CM's instructions. The 2.44 km-long cable bridge, built at a cost of Rs 473 crore, was opened to traffic by the Union road transport and highways minister Nitin Gadkari on Monday amidst political rumblings over protocol lapse. Speaking to reporters on Tuesday, the Congress MLA attacked Raghavendra, who is a MP and son of former CM BS Yeddiyurappa and brother of BY Vijayendra, state BJP chief. Velur noted that the BJP's late invitation to the CM, merely five days before the event, suggested a deliberate attempt to prevent the CM's attendance. He clarified that while Congress supports regional development, they questioned the breach of the CM's protocol, explaining their absence from the event. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Unsold 2021 Cars Now Almost Free - Prices May Surprise You Unsold Cars | Search Ads Learn More Undo However, Raghavendra expressed his discontent with Congress functionaries. Speaking to reporters here, he said: "I must express my disappointment and frustration over the petty behaviour displayed by some politicians from our district. Their desperation was palpable." He noted that rising water levels would affect barge operations, and his request for an earlier inauguration was disregarded. He expressed satisfaction at ministers and MLAs visiting the bridge, but criticised attempts to diminish the event's importance. Employment opportunities Belur discussed the Sharavathi Pumped Storage Project, which aims to generate 2000 MW of electricity to address state power shortages. The project promises employment opportunities and compensation for affected families, with assured implementation, he said.
New Indian Express
10-06-2025
- Politics
- New Indian Express
Eco-panel hearing on Sharavathi project today: Karnataka Energy Min George
BENGALURU: The environment committee is having a look at the execution of the Sharavathi Pumped Storage Project in Shivamogga. Energy Minister KJ George said here on Monday that the committee will hold a meeting on the project on Tuesday. George said he was not aware of the details of the report prepared by the Ministry of Environment, Forests and Climate Change (MoEFCC) team that visited the site recently. 'The project will be executed. Issues that have been raised pertaining to lion-tailed macaque and other wildlife are being examined,' he said. The energy department has sought 54 hectares of land for the project, while offering alternative land to the forest department. 'Only a few environmentalists are raising objections. We had obtained permission to conduct a study in the area, and it was done. If the project is executed, it will generate 2,000 MW of power along with a proper storage facility. All pipes and cables will be laid underground,' he added.
The Hindu
27-05-2025
- General
- The Hindu
Site inspection report disfavours Sharavathi project
A site inspection report of the controversial Sharavathi Pumped Storage Project has not recommended the proposal of the Karnataka Power Corporation Limited (KPCL) which seeks diversion of 54.155 hectares of forestland for the project. A detailed site inspection, conducted by Praneetha Paul, Deputy Inspector-General of Forest (DIGF) from the Regional Office, Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change of India (MoEF&CC), Bengaluru, has not recommended the proposal for the project citing 15 reasons including presence of Lion Tailed Macaque Wildlife Sanctuary. However, S. Senthil Kumar, Deputy Director-General of Forests, (Central) Regional Office, MoEF&CC, has recommended the proposal, while suggesting that 'revision in the design to minimise tree-felling and protect the ecological integrity of the area may be considered'. Concern about damages Ms. Paul, who was the inspecting officer, in her report, stated that the reason for not recommending the proposal include felling of more than 15,000 trees, many of which are endemic to the Western Ghats. 'Construction of new roads, widening of roads, construction of the surge shaft, adits, pot head yards, power evacuation etc would result in complete destruction of the wet evergreen forests of canopy density ranging from 0.7 to 1,' the report states as one of the reasons. It further states that the felling of 15,000 trees would result in further fragmentation and creation of isolated populations of the Lion Tailed Macaque (LTM) and other endemic species which may eventually lead to its extinction. 'Alternate CA land proposed, being a shola grassland, will not be able to compensate for the loss of habitat of the LTM,' it said. It also said that as the ecological fallout far outweighs the economic benefits that may be accrued by commissioning this project, 'it is recommended that the project should not be approved.' The inspection was conducted between May 1 and May 9, 2025. Damage acknowledged Meanwhile Mr. Kumar acknowledged that the area is home to significant endemic species, including LTM and the Malabar Pied Hornbill, both of which rely on tall, undisturbed canopy trees. 'There is no alternative alignment as the project depends on utilising reservoirs and gravity for hydroelectricity production,' he states in his recommendation. It further says the proposed project lies within the Sharavathi Valley Lion Tailed Wildlife Sanctuary which harbours the largest known population (730 individuals) of LTM and a separate proposal has been submitted for wildlife clearance which is pending. It added that the Chief Wildlife Warden had recommended modifications to design, including adopting underground structures and minimising surface openings to avoid felling approximately 518 trees in the Surge Tank area and by constructing an underground road from Nagar Basti Kere to Bagodi to preserve approximately 12,000 out of the 13,756 trees marked for removal. 'Building an overground road would disrupt the free movement of canopy dependent species such as the LTM. Revision in the design to minimise tree felling and protect the ecological integrity of the area may be considered. The proposal is recommended,' stated the DDGF .
